Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy
charlie belden in san jose
>We spend a lot of time learning to use both power and hand tools, about wood, the myriad of possible ways to stick two pieces of wood together, scraping and or sanding methods, proportions, scale and so on. There's a LOT of stuff to learn, or at least become somewhat familiar with.
No matter how nice the wood is, how nice the design, how well the joinery was done, how well the surfaces were prepped - it's the finish that often can make or break a piece. Get that wrong and there's either a nightmare period trying to recover - or the piece becomes "shop furniture", scraps to reuse - someday - or - worse case - firewood.
It's not like there aren't a boatload of finishes available, most swearing that they're easy and "nearly fool proof". You've got sanding sealers, "wood preps", pre-coats, oils, stains, dyes, shellac, varnishes, lacquers (catalyzed, pre-catalyzed, acrylic, . . .), polys - there's waterbased, oil based, toluene based, alcohol based - with and without driers. And there are "retarders" , "extenders" and "accelerators". Hell, do you know the difference between just the solvents - naptha, anhyrdous alcohol, turnepntine, paint thinner, lacquer thinner - the list goes on and on. And some finishes have UV protection and some don't. I've heard that TransTint dyes are very susceptable to fading on exposure to light. If that's true, that's an important piece of information - that ain't on the label or in the brochures.
Can't leave out the Home Brews - tar dissolved in one of several solvents, rust and vinegar, secret blends of boiled linseed oil, bees wax and varnish. Then there's Fuming.
I'm sure production shops find a couple of finishes and finishing schedules and then stick to them for just about everything. But those who make things for fun aren't prone to repeating much - different woods, different designs, different finishes. And being semi-frugal sorts, we probably won't use 5 or 6 board feet of a project's wood to experiment on for the project finish. A 5x5 sample really doesn't give you much of an idea of what an 18x30 panel - with some lighter sapwood on one side, dark heartwood on the other and grain reversing direction and coming out of the face of the door at all angles - a little test piece is going to tell you very little.
So, after the trial end error approach, have you settled on two or three finishes and finishing schedules and stick with them or is each project a crap shoot when it comes time to finish it?
Do you shoot your finish on, wipe it on or brush it on?
Have you used a finish - following the instructions exaclty and still wished you had an "UNDO" feature for it? If so, which one?
charlie belden



