Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

Posts

Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

#1

Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

charlie belden in san jose

>We spend a lot of time learning to use both power and hand tools, about wood, the myriad of possible ways to stick two pieces of wood together, scraping and or sanding methods, proportions, scale and so on. There's a LOT of stuff to learn, or at least become somewhat familiar with.

No matter how nice the wood is, how nice the design, how well the joinery was done, how well the surfaces were prepped - it's the finish that often can make or break a piece. Get that wrong and there's either a nightmare period trying to recover - or the piece becomes "shop furniture", scraps to reuse - someday - or - worse case - firewood.

It's not like there aren't a boatload of finishes available, most swearing that they're easy and "nearly fool proof". You've got sanding sealers, "wood preps", pre-coats, oils, stains, dyes, shellac, varnishes, lacquers (catalyzed, pre-catalyzed, acrylic, . . .), polys - there's waterbased, oil based, toluene based, alcohol based - with and without driers. And there are "retarders" , "extenders" and "accelerators". Hell, do you know the difference between just the solvents - naptha, anhyrdous alcohol, turnepntine, paint thinner, lacquer thinner - the list goes on and on. And some finishes have UV protection and some don't. I've heard that TransTint dyes are very susceptable to fading on exposure to light. If that's true, that's an important piece of information - that ain't on the label or in the brochures.

Can't leave out the Home Brews - tar dissolved in one of several solvents, rust and vinegar, secret blends of boiled linseed oil, bees wax and varnish. Then there's Fuming.

I'm sure production shops find a couple of finishes and finishing schedules and then stick to them for just about everything. But those who make things for fun aren't prone to repeating much - different woods, different designs, different finishes. And being semi-frugal sorts, we probably won't use 5 or 6 board feet of a project's wood to experiment on for the project finish. A 5x5 sample really doesn't give you much of an idea of what an 18x30 panel - with some lighter sapwood on one side, dark heartwood on the other and grain reversing direction and coming out of the face of the door at all angles - a little test piece is going to tell you very little.

So, after the trial end error approach, have you settled on two or three finishes and finishing schedules and stick with them or is each project a crap shoot when it comes time to finish it?

Do you shoot your finish on, wipe it on or brush it on?

Have you used a finish - following the instructions exaclty and still wished you had an "UNDO" feature for it? If so, which one?

charlie belden

Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

#2

Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

Fred Davis

>Charlie,

that's a very to the point piece on what can happen to a woodworkers pride and joy if he didn't exercise the same care on the finish that he did on the joinery.

Being able to cut tight fitting dovetails doesn't mean much if the finish looks like it was put on with a broom.

FredD

Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

#3

doesn't need to be Alchemy

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>You are right on one point. The manufacturers of finishing stuff don't tell us what is in it. A MSDS sheet gives clues, if one can read them. As an example of the latter, I was recently selecting some water soluble dyes for a mahogany piece, more on that later. The MSDS sheet for the Lockwood dyes and the Mosher dyes were available on line. A friend who is a dye chemist said the kind of dyes used by Mosher are more light fast.

My pet peeve is that manufacturers change formulates with great regularity, especially Sherwin Williams and then you get to start all over.

I never experiment on the finished product. I recently finished an oak piece and I am working on a mahogany piece. In each case I asked persons that finish these woods what they used. I obtained these products and tested them on wood samples identical (cut offs from the project) to the finished piece. In the case of the mahogany I even veneered a test piece to be sure the test replicated the actual piece.

I recently finished an ash piece that will be used in an environment different from normal furniture and in this case I asked the technical rep. at Target Finishes about what to use. He recommended something and then warned to be sure to spray it on a test piece first.

"Have you settled on two or three finishes and finishing schedules and stick with them" For things I finish more regularly I settle on a schedule and stick to it until the manufacturer reformulates. "is each project a crap shoot when it comes time to finish it?" Never a crap shoot. I test first.

"Do you shoot your finish on", yes when I can. If every one would learn to spray (not difficult) you would like finishing more and be more successful. Lacquer is an excellent finish and easy to learn to spray. "wipe it on or brush it on?" sometimes, especially for something very small.

"Have you used a finish - following the instructions exaclty and still wished you had an "UNDO" feature for it? there is always an UNDO button." Strip it and start over.

Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

#4

Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>So, after the trial end error approach, have you settled on two or three finishes and finishing schedules and stick with them or is each project a crap shoot when it comes time to finish it?

I prefer a solvent lacquer: NC, CAB, or Alkyd, either on bare wood or over any stain. Never use a "sealer", and it's done in a day. It's fool proof, of which I'm an example.

Do you shoot your finish on, wipe it on or brush it on?

Spray

Have you used a finish - following the instructions exaclty and still wished you had an "UNDO" feature for it? If so, which one?

Yes, I've stripped and refinished wiping or brush-on finishes more than once. Whether it's product or pilot error doesn't matter; I've never had a problem with lacquer.

Clint

Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

#5

Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

Howard Acheson

>You questions are beyond the purview of a forum like this. What you need is a basic understanding of finishes and then you can get some specific detail from a forum.

I suggest you purchase Tauton's Complete Illustrated Guide to Finishing by Jeff Jewitt or Understanding Finishing by Bob Flexner. Both are excellent. You can get them through Amazon.

When I taught woodworking, I taught two almost foolproof finishes. Using either one could provide an excellent, easily applied finish.

And, you are correct: It's the finish that gets the oohs and aahs, not the joinery.

Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

#6

Re: Finishes - I'm a wimp, really

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I'm not a pro at this. It's a hobby. I've been making furniture and stuff for maybe eight years now, and have a pretty well over equipped shop. Well, it's an over equipped garage. And it's stuffed with tools and wood and some family storage stuff. The car hasn't been in there since 1999, and then it was my son's car, on jack stands.

The first student piece I built from the Adult Ed class that got finished looked a lot better before the Yellow Can crap than afterwords. I managed to get it's follow on hall table not to stink too badly. But after three oor four projects, I dragged all the yellow cans to club meeting, and gave them away to whoever would take them.

Everything is a wipe on now. There is no room for, and really no budget for, spray gear. Waterlox. McCloskey's Spar. Good shellac. Tried & True. Some Watco Danish oil with color. There are some dyes for colorant, too, and these get used sparingly.

But if it doesn't wipe on, I don't use it. There are enough mysteries in life for me to pursue. Let others figure out spraying.

Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

#7

Re: Finishes - the Bibles

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I have those books. The authors are really good.

I still only want to wipe the finish on. The rest, the quest, is for someone else. Spending more thousands to be able to spray once in a while is for someone who does it regularly, defined as 'more often than once every 3 to 6 months'.

Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

#8

Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Morning Charlie,

A few years ago when I worked part time for several antique stores, and did lots of work for individual clients, I had to learn to match the color, shade and type of finish of various pieces of furniture. I liked minwax oil based stains and aniline dyes, and use(d) each depending on the wood and desired look. I got acceptably good at it, although I never sprayed with a compressor and gun. Presently I do very little in lacquer, mostly because of strong objections regarding the smell from my #3 daughter and SWMBO. SWMBO is the operative clause here. I like what shellac does and how it looks. Shellac generally goes under all topcoats as a matter of course, and sanded and dusted before the top coats are applied. Top coats are nearly always a 50/50 mix of poly and naptha, which I hand wipe, and rub out a couple times during build. Otherwise, I like commercial "tung" oil. Every thing I do is paste waxed once the finish is cured, and that wax is applied with 4/0 steel wood to satinize the gloss to a soft glow. I feel I get good results, and a relativelyhard/tough finish. The down side is difficulty matching repairs. Like everyone else, I've done my share of stripping off mistakes.

George

Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

#9

inaccurate premise

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>1. It does not take very much money to be able to spray. If you go the conventional route, the air compressor, which does not have to be very large, is useful for a multitude of other tasks. Set a fan in the shop door, and blast everything with the compressed air and in no time the shop is clean and dust free. For this reason alone buying a compressor is a good idea. I have seen good used professional guns go for less than $50.

2. It is not hard to learn to spray lacquer. My daughter sprays hardly once a year, but she is successful every time she drops by to finish something. Most recently it was painted wains coating boards. With a conventional gun you can spray lacquer, paint, varnish, stain.

Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

#10

what were they

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>It would have been helpful to describe your fool proof finishes.

Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

#11

Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

Fred Davis

>do your wife and #3 daughter use nail polish?

Just wondering mind you ;=))

FredD

Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

#12

Ellis Walentine

Couple ways to look at it

Ellis Walentine

>Finishing can definitely be complicated if you try to include all the available products and techniques in your arsenal. That's why most woodworkers eventually settle on a small repertoire of "go-to" finishes for the majority of their finishing situations. But, as you've seen here, not everyone is agreed on the same short list of finishes.

Personally, I prefer to figure out the best possible finish for each piece, selecting for function first, then for appearance, and then for other considerations like ease of application and cost. I like having a choice of options, e.g., varnish vs. lacquer, and I'm prepared to make that decision apropos of an individual piece. Sometimes, I see the need for different finishes on different parts of the same project. For example, I made a dining room suite a while back and I used polyurethane for the tabletops and serving tops, but I used multiple coats of Waterlox for the uprights and non-functional areas of the woodwork.

My two cents on this issue is that you would do well to understand just a few things:

  • Shellac in all its dilutions and uses

  • Wiping varnish and how to build it to your needs.

  • Sprayed finishes, including the entry-level equipment necessary to do them respectably.

    Beyond that, especially when it comes to stains and such, it really is about alchemy. You have to experiment and finish firewood first.

    Ellis Walentine, Host

  • Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

    #13

    Moses Yoder

    Re: inaccurate premise

    Moses Yoder

    >I would agree that anyone who spends $1000 or $2000 on a table saw and won't spend $100 for a spray gun might be missing the boat. I spray conversion varnish, which is a very durable and good looking finish. I don't usually use my cup gun more than 2 or 3 times each year. But it is possible to get good looking finishes without spraying; it just takes longer. I always figure the federal reserve can just print more money, but the time machine has not yet been invented.

    Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

    #14

    or hair spray

    Bill Tindall, E.TN

    >which historically has been nitrocellulose lacquer dissolved in solvent which is why it is such good potato gun propellant. There are some modern water based formulations now days.

    Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

    #15

    question

    Bill Tindall, E.TN

    >Form the perspective that you can finish a piece with all the techniques you elaborated, under what circumstances would you use a wiping varnish. This is a technique I never considered, believing(apparently incorrectly) that it was an inferior finish that only inexperienced finishers would use. Broaden my horizons.......

    Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

    #16

    Re: what were they

    Howard Acheson

    >One is an oil/varnish mixture that works particularly well for darker woods where you want an in-the-wood finish. The second is a thinned wipe-on varnish finish.

    BTW, there is nothing inherently inferior about a thinned wipe-on varnish. The only difference between it and a brushed on finish is that it takes twice as many applications to build a comparable film thickness. It is, after all, just varnish once the thinner evaporates. Nothing in the finish changes. However, Big box off-the-shelf "wiping varnishes" are inferior as product to making your own wiping varnish.

    Wipe-on is an application technique that is easier to learn and control for many folks. I've found that many just do not have patience to learn and use good brushing technique. Therefore, using a wipe-on is the best option for getting a smooth finish.

    Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

    #17

    Re: question - not Ellis

    Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

    >but I'm convinced that wiping varnish has a place.

    It dries quickly.

    It seldom drips.

    It's portable. I can take it to the piece.

    It's flexible, in that I can mix it at various consistencies. And I can, if I'm brave, add dyes.

    It sets up to use quickly, and tears down quickly. I don't have to clean the whole shop, or kill everything that's going on there for a finishing cycle.

    And it's cheap. A can of varnish is almost always less than $20, and a quart of VMP Naptha usually less than $10. I haven't bought any lately, so I don't know. The Critter spray gun, one of the least expensive and least sophisticated sprayers around, was $50+ when I bought one, to spray shellac.

    The results are as good as almost everything else I've seen for the projects I do. Now, when I do a breakfront, or a set of dining room chairs, or something ornate, I'll wander over across the street, where Brad has a $$$ Apollo HVLP he uses once every 18 to 24 months, and we'll make a deal. ;-)

    Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

    #18

    Re: question - not Ellis

    Fred Davis

    >Glenn,

    If your that attached to wiping varnish (silly term there) and that impressed with the results , how come you don't use it on "Breakfronts, chairs, Ornate stuff" ?

    Just wondering here ;-))

    FredD

    Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

    #19

    Re: question

    Steve Schoene

    >Wiping varnish differs from brushing varnish only by the addition of thinner, and the thinner doesn't participate in the final finish, merely evaporating away. But it does take more coats to achieve the same total film finish--about three wiped on coats to 1 brushed on coats. The thin films allow them to dry faster so they accumulate less dust, and even to a small degree, again because they are so thin, cure faster.

    The downside is, that applied according to directions, the thin coats are very difficult to rub out if needed. They are so thin that cutting through the top coat is very easy to do, and the witness lines could be a problem. However, you can apply the coats in "sets" of about three in a day, spaced just far enough apart for them to be dry to the touch. They won't be sandable after that short a time. That way, with them still not much cured, there should be enough crosslinking between coats to not show witness lines. After a set has been applied, it must be allowed to cure at least overnight, and scuff sanded as usual before applying another set. This gives a thick enough final coat that as long as the surface has been well leveled before the final set, you should be able to do a full rub out without cutting through. Of, course, you want to give as long as possible before the final rub out. A month would be ideal.

    Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

    #20

    Adult onset ADD

    Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

    >

    Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

    #21

    Ellis Walentine

    Wiping varnish

    Ellis Walentine

    >Sorry I missed your reply, Bill. All I can say is that of the many jobs my shop did over many years, we used wiping varnish for a lot of them. As Steve mentions further down, the only distinction between a wiping varnish and a regular varnish is additional thinner. You end up with the same finish but it takes more coats. The upside is that you have more control over the results. There are many studio furnituremakers who use it almost exclusively. I wouldn't equate inexperienced with dust-challenged.

    A varnish finish can be a lot of trouble if there is a lot of airborne dust. It settles into the thick, brushed varnish film and creates nibs galore. So, dust problems are the downside of laying down a thicker millage of slow-drying finishes. A wiping varnish on the other hand, which can also be brushed on but is usually wiped on, opens up a lot of new possibilities if you're willing to experiment to get the feel for this finish.

    Your preference for the visual and tactual experience of your final finish will ultimately determine your choice(s). I find polyurethane varnishes, lacquers and conversion varnishes to be rather plastic looking and feeling, although they are easy to apply (if you have your spraying act together) and demonstrably bulletproof for most finishing objectives. Wiping varnish is a bit more down-home, softer to the touch, more resilient and less brittle, usually deeper in tone, and very easy to apply if you're willing to get the hang of it. It makes great sense in small shops without spray booths. And it is a durable and tactually pleasing finish.

    I like the fact that I can lay on anywhere from one to a dozen or more coats to get exactly the depth and protection I want. I can rub it out with fine steel wool to alter the sheen, and it comes out very smooth to the touch, with excellent specular highlights. There's also a touchy-feely aspect of hand-rubbing a finish and watching it develop and build under your touch and before your eyes.

    I think wiping varnish offers an excellent alternative to shellac and sprayed films for small shop furnituremakers. I don't use it on large casework, production items, or most architectural projects, but for one-off furniture I love it.

    Not sure if any of this is very enlightening...

    Ellis

    Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

    #22

    ENLIGHTENING! It should Be Required Reading.

    George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

    >

    Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

    #23

    Re: ENLIGHTENING! It should Be Required Reading.

    Fred Davis

    >not the part about Lacquer looking plastic.

    Lacquer has been the benchmark finish for fine furniture for longer then any of us can remember.

    FredD

    Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

    #24

    There's some misinformation in this thread

    Michael Dresdner

    >A lot, in fact, but let me address two egregious statements that jumped out at me about wiping finishes.

    The first is that wiping varnish is simply thinned varnish. This is not necessarily true. In fact, two of the companies I consult for make several wiping varnishes that have the same solids content (and the same solvent content) as their brushable varnishes. In fact, even you can easily make a wiping varnish with a higher solids content than the original varnish you started with by merely adding drying oil (boiled linseed oil, for example) to oil based varnish or polyurethane. That adds no solvent and in fact increases the percentage of solids and decreases the percentage of solvent. Many formulators use both oils and lower molecular weight resins to make high solids wiping varnishes. Unlike you, they can't add extra solvent because the VOC laws forbid them to sell it if they do.

    Second, the statement that what is sold premixed is inferior to what you can make yourself is complete hogwash. Good formulators create good products, great ones create great products, and poor ones sell crap. I can assure you that I know several top notch formulators working today (I am excluding myself out of modesty) who can and do make some amazing formulations that the average woodworker could never even approach, much less surpass. Don't paint everyone with that brush of dismissal. Both good and poor quality exists in the marketplace whether it is finishing, woodworking, tool making, and so on.

    Now for a free third; it is entirely possible and quite easy to apply any oil based varnish or polyurethane without reducing it at all. The trick is to scrub it on with Scotchbrite instead of a rag. It builds much quicker and is cheaper and less odorous than buying and adding solvents. That way, you don't even have to raise the question of whether wipe on is better or worse; it is the same.

    Re: Finishes - Woodworking's Alchemy

    #25

    Ellis Walentine

    Excellent info

    Ellis Walentine

    >Michael, can you be specific about some of these high-solids wiping varnishes? I think there is a lot more mileage in this thread.

    Ellis