Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Now which table saw?

Posts

Now which table saw?

#1

Now which table saw?

Mitch from Canada

>Hi all,

Went to wood show yesturday. Have a chance to buy a General International left tilt cabinet saw for about $1600.00 plus taxes. Old splitter/guard etc...they are getting rid of them due to riving knife model coming out.

Wife likes the idea of the Saw Stop contractors saw though...1.75hp motor...Model they show is $2100.00 plus taxes.

I haven't used a REAL table saw since high school...I'd like to start by making coffee tables and end tables etc. I don't know how thick, or what species of wood I may get into using in the future.

If I had the dollars I'd probably go for the cabinet saw stop...power and safety together.

I think to myself ... love my fingers...anything that could help protect them is good..but $2100 for a contractors saw? I'm very careful with my bandsaw and radial arm...what are the odds I'd get hurt? Will I miss not having a cabinet saw...more power etc... Just some stuff I'm tossing around in my head.

Any advice is appreciated.

Mitch

Re: Now which table saw?

#2

Re: Now which table saw?

steve mackay

>Just a small shop mind you, but I've had two Craftsmans in ten years (I'm on the second). After haveing the Griz combo sander for a year now (also very high use) my next TS will be their cabinet saw. In my mind I just can't justify $1,500 for a saw. Also, in MY mind, my greatest safety factor is ME. Measure twice, think it over five times THEN cut once (or twice). A good, healthy fear of that blade has saved my fingers a thousand times. Still counting ten.

Re: Now which table saw?

#3

If You Like Your Fingers Remember-

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla

>Never put your fingers where you wouldn't put your tongue. Having spent more years then I want to remember working on Delta Unisaws I think 1.75 HP is a bit underpowered. Especially cutting thick hardwoods.

Re: Now which table saw?

#4

Re: Now which table saw?

Barry Irby

>I have a 38 year old Rockwell/Delta cabinet saw. Upgrade the motor from 1 1/2 to 2hp when the 1 1/2 burned up about thirty five years ago. Added dust collection and a Biesemeyer fence. I have cut miles of stuff on it. Including myself twice. Hurt three fingers in a kick back about ten or twelve years ago. Relatively speaking, the injuries were minor and I had forgotten them, until my son recounted the story of me coming out of the shop with a bloody hand. On another occasion I nicked a finger so slightly it did not bleed. (it would have triggered a SawStop though.)

I have been working wood for forty some years. You have to be right every time or wrong only once.

I have only seen a Sawstop sitting on the show room floor. Never used one. It was a cabinet saw. If I were doing it again or for the first time, I would buy the Saw Stop. The cost of firing the mechanism is a couple of hundred or less. Much cheaper than a trip to the doctor, let alone the pain and suffering.

I also understand that SawStop saws are accurate and well made. Again, from reviews by others. No personal experience. I think you will find someone that says they got a bad one or one that needed some work, but that is true of the other saws as well.

There are some draw backs if you can call them that. Turning off the feature to cut sopping wet wood. Changing the cartridge to use a Dado set. Still would be worth it.

I don't have a goldfish in this bowl, but my point is that my saw has been powerful enough for my hobby shop use, cutting everything I have thrown at it. I actually like it. (Don't get me going on my bandsaw) What separates me from a Sawstop is the money.

Re: Now which table saw?

#5

Re: Now which table saw?

Mitch from Canada

>Well..I'm really leaning toward the Saw Stop now...it can be wired for 220 from what I've read as well. A little more juice won't hurt. I may just go for the basic version. Aluminum fence etc...I don't really have room or see a need for a 52inch fence. I may add a bench dog cast iron router table on one side, or just make my own insert table for a router.

Still thinking it over...thanks for the responses.

Mitch

Re: Now which table saw?

#6

JL

Re: Now which table saw?

JL

>I went to IWF in August. I saw the Sawstop contractor's model - even got a hat for listening to their spiel. They weren't really doing a demo on it at that time though. I've seen the General - even contemplated buying one - but I ended up with a Steel City.

Do you need more than 1 3/4 hp? I cut 2" thick oak, maple and cherry with my old 1 1/2 hp Craftsman (and a sharp blade) - slow but steady. You could make do with 1 3/4 hp.

On the other hand, I can really zip through lumber with more power. A 3 hp saw will make cutting faster. You also have more weight to stabilize everything.

Your call. Fingers are nice.

Re: Now which table saw?

#7

Re: Now which table saw?

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>I have a jet cabinet saw that I purchased new 10 years ago. I'm happy with the saw and it has done everything I have needed it to. I have been making my living in one way or another that involved using a table saw for 20 years and I have never had an accedent. having said that, if I could buy a Saw Stop for the difference in what I paid for my saw and what a Saw Stop costs I would jump at the chance.

Robin

Re: Now which table saw?

#8

Re: Now which table saw?

Barry Irby

>I have added a router table as a wing on my TS also. It's home made out of two sink cutouts from a counter top laminated back to back with plastic laminate on each side. This maybe part of my reluctance to get rid of the saw. (I have a lot of time and money in upgrading this one.) I also find myself forming attachments to my tools as if they were "old friends".

The two saws you are considering are apples and oranges to some extent. The cabinet saw is just that, a cabinet saw and to some extent "Old School". A fine and powerful tool, but by their own admission, they are phasing it out for the newer model with the riving knife. Still very useful and got a lot of life left in it, but .....? The SawStop is perhaps the most significant upgrade in TS safety EVER. But, Its a contractor model and somewhat less powerful. Dust collection may not be as good. But you need to ask yourself what you give up by buying the Sawstop.

I resaw thick stock with a good thin kerf blade and make two passes if I must. This does not come up often and if it takes four times as long to do on my saw as it would on a 3 HP Cabinet saw, it may have cost me 6 or 8 hours in thirty years. A very small PITA

The dust collection I added to my saw is about 98% effective and that is without an over the blade pickup.

As for the fence, I got a Biesemeyer when Lowes had the closeout, (gloat) for $80. Until them I had the original fence but had added bars that allowed me to cut cabinet ends (36") to the right of the blade. The Beis fence will only cut 30". In all the years I had the 36" capacity I only used it once or twice. Again, what are you going to do? In my case, I don't have a clue. I built houses, and cabinets and furniture and Christmas presents, and turn stuff and....

Re: Now which table saw?

#9

Re: Now which table saw?

Chuck in ND

>The problem with your question is, you ask a hundred people, you'll get a hundred different answers. Some people are rich, some are middle income, some are poor, some are running a bussiness, some are running a part time bussiness, and some are hobbyists.

Re: Now which table saw?

#10

Re: Now which table saw?

Mitch from Canada

>Hi Chuck,

Having almost no experience with table saws I want to see what people who have worked with them for years would do in my case. Getting info from a variety of knowlegable sources is what I'm looking for.

The spoke to a guy from General at the wood show and I told him exactly my dilema...buying his General Cabinet saw vs the Saw Stop Contractor Saw...and he said "Well, I don't know about you, but my fingers are more important than my saw."

Thanks for your opinion though.

Mitch

Re: Now which table saw?

#11

Re: Now which table saw?

Fred Davis

>This reply is not meant to influence your choice of saw but rather how you use any power tool that can hurt you if you allow yourself to be distracted in the use of it.

SawStop is a mechanical device to stop a blade before it hurts you , just like a safety on a firearm

Not all or hardly any for that matter, power tool can do that, so you really need a attitude about power tool use rather then depend on a expensive device that may cause you to relax a vigilant approach to using the saw.

Any saw that is underpowered or badly adjusted can cause incidents which would not have happened if the user was more aware.

The people on this thread who have decades of powertool use (myself included) without loss of digits or mutilated hands undoubtely use a approach that prevents these types of incidents.

Notice I use the word incident, for the reason that I don't believe accidents happen, they are caused by inattention on someones' part.

So what ever saw you buy regardless of make, respect the power of it and dwell on how hard it is to grow a new finger.

Fearing a tool while your using it is unhealthy, respecting it and knowing it will cut anything shoved into it will keep you safe.

FredD

Re: Now which table saw?

#12

Re: Now which table saw?

Jim Dillon

>Mitch,

I purchased the General 350(?) cabinet saw (the one made in Canada) about 10 years ago and it has been wonderful - except for the dust collection which is worthless. The newer model is better I understand. At the time, there was no General International line of products, nor was there any Saw Stop. And IIRC correctly, the Grizzly brand was just starting to be well-known. If I were shopping now, I would seriously consider the 10-inch Saw Stop (not the hybrid). While I consider myself a safe and cautious woodworker, stuff happens. If the Saw Stop were a piece of junk, I would not consider it and would look at the Grizzly brand (for good value), and then the usual suspects like Jet, Delta, Powermatic, Steel City. The US dollar is so low now (compared to 10 years ago) that buying from Canada would not be worth it - even if the quality is better. But, from what I have read, the Saw Stop is well made with a good fence.

Regarding the 52 inch table extension, I have found it to be extremely useful and have put my router in the extension which has worked out very well. I also like having the extra flat surface for glue-ups etc.

Regarding HP, others are right that one can do everything with a 1 3/4 HP vs a 3 HP - just maybe a little slower is all. But I would vote for the 3 HP (but not 5 HP) as something that will make you happy as you eventually slice through that thick piece of extremely hard wood, like jatoba.

Any discussion of the Saw Stop seems to generate strong feelings pro and con. Nonetheless, this is what I would think about if I were shopping today. Good luck, and have fun shopping - and be sure to discuss your options with your wife.

Jim

Re: Now which table saw?

#13

Re: About saw horsepower and costs...

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>Five years ago, I bought a spanking new Delta 3hp Unisaw from the local Woodcraft, with a mobile base and a 52" table, and spent $1700 USD including our local taxes. I thought it was a pretty good deal.

It cost me almost $1200 for the electrical upgrades to the garage, by the time I was done. Subpanel, separate shutoffs, extra 110V plugs, and a 30A 220v circuit for the saw.

Was it a good choice? I love the saw, and use most of the other outlets regularly. Just wrap everything you'll need into the discussions you have with yourself. There's a reason we talk about slippery slopes...

Re: Now which table saw?

#14

Re: Now which table saw?

wooden leg

>I have Powermatic contractors saw. If I had to do it again, I would go with a cabinet saw mainly for the dust control and I would look very hard at a Saw Stop. My thoughts are its piece of equipment you will only buy once. I like a left tilt saw and I wanted cast iron tables. My sons use the saw and my son's wife is starting to use my shop. Hopefully my grandson will use shop. I try to buy the best out there at the time and within my budget. Have fun and think what you will be doing with it. Dave

Re: Now which table saw?

#15

Different Opinion

John M in mid Mich

>5-6 years ago I upgraded from a craftsman 1.5 hp contractor saw to a total zoot Jet 3hp cabinet saw. I'm NOT convinced about the need for the hp. There was NEVER a cut I couldn't do on the lower-powered saw! More importantly, when I do something stupid now, the results are impressive (scary), like when the kickback hit me in the chest, knocking the wind out of me (I know, don't lecture me), so I laid on the shop floor for 5 minutes wondering what the damage was... No problem, the bruise was gone in a few weeks, and it was at least 10 days before my wife noticed it. With the smaller motor, I'd more likely just stall it, turn it off, think about the problem, solve it, do it right. No damage. I think power/speed are HIGHLY overrated (though I'll readily yield the point to the pro's among us).

What I'd do right now: Steel City granite. That stone is such a GREAT idea. Makes so much sense - no rust, no warp. Get the 1-3/4 (?) hybrid. Excellent. Upgrade with the Incra fence. Total about the same as your $1600, but with a WAY better fence, and safer.

YMMV>

John

Re: Now which table saw?

#16

Re: Different Opinion

Mitch from Canada

>Hey all,

So I went back to wood shop today...talked to a bunch of different people. I decided to ask the Kreg Jig guy what he used for a table saw. I had bought the Kreg Pocket hole jig from him last year.

He currently uses a 20 yr old 3 hp Unisaw with a Excalibur sliding table.

He had been making cabinets for 25 plus years and used that saw forever with no missing digits. 2 weeks ago, he was doing blind dado? cuts...a bunch of them...anyway...he somehow managed to have his finger contact the dado blade. It took off part of the tip and damaged the rest of his finger up to the middle knuckle. He can still use it ok,,,but he said he was very lucky.

He recommended the Saw Stop Contractor version to me...my first table saw...1.75 hp on 220 would have lots of power. Enough for a novice like me anyway. His next saw will be a Saw Stop as well.

I didn't pick one up today...they had no discount for the show...just 5% off accessories. Figure I'll let it all sink in first. Yeh, it's still about $2000.00 plus no matter how you slice it. I pay alot for car insurance every year as well...like a Saw Stop, I hope never to have to use it.

I think it boils down to ... if I did manage to somehow lop off a finger on a terrific 3 hp cabinet saw... no amount of "why didn't I just get the Saw Stop when I could have?" will put the finger back on.

Thanks again for the input.

Mitch

Re: Now which table saw?

#17

Re: Different Opinion

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Mitch - 1.75hp is the same regardless of the voltage you wire it to. The only thing that changes is the current (it will be halfed if you use 220). You won't recognize any more power and unless the 110 circuit you plan on using is weak, you won't notice any diference in the way the saw runs.

BTW - I went from a 1.5HP (Taiwanese) contractors saw to a 1.5hp cabinet saw (old American saw, new Baldor motor) and there was a difference. Then I went to a 3hp (Taiwanese) cabinet saw and for me, there's no going back. I could make cuts with the others, but it's night and day with the new (to me) saw.

Oh - the price of the 3hp cabinet saw? $750 - and I had to take the cosmoline off it. I bought it "used", and I'll bet it had 10 cuts on it, all associated to cedar siding.

Deals are out there.

Last thing, I took the tip of my finger off with my contractors saw, but I did so after I'd turned the power off but before the blade had stopped spinning (no brake on that saw's motor - I have one now). A Sawstop would not have helped me. It's probably the best thing that happened to my woodworking ability...I take things much more seriously in the shop now.

Rob

Re: Now which table saw?

#18

SawStop probably would have still worked

wilbur

>From the SawStop FAQ:

Is the safety system still on after power is turned off and while the blade is coasting down?

Yes. The safety system remains active while the blade is coasting down after the start/stop paddle is pressed to the off position. When the main power switch is turned to the off position, however, the safety system is no longer active.

Re: Now which table saw?

#19

Re: Hammers and kitchen knives...

pecker

>...have done far more damage to my fingers than any power tool.

I think the noise from the motor scares me into thinking thoroughly about the task at hand, so that I don't do anything foolish.

Re: Now which table saw?

#20

Re: Now which table saw?

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Evening Mitch,

I just upgraded from a Jet Contractor's saw. It had an 18 amp motor, rated at 1.5 hp. I literally built a house full of good hardwood furniture with it. Always plenty of power. I currently have a Jet hybrid which has 1.75 hp. Plenty of power, and I can't honestly tell the difference in performance. So, a lesser powered saw has been more than adequate for my needs to make furniture. I think power is a non-issue in most cases. Trying to cut hot dogs isn't in my wish list. Attention to safe operation always has been. I think riving knives are the way to go for every new saw from now on. However, that General is as safe as your are willing to make it. Given the choice of the two, I'd go for the General. It will never fail, and will be cutting wood after you and I are long gone.

George

Re: Now which table saw?

#21

Re: Now which table saw?

Mitch from Canada

>I still haven't purchased a saw. I do like the idea of the riving knife as well. From what I've read, General will probably offer an update kit to add a riving knife to existing saws...cost is around $800 from what I hear.

I'm at the point now where I'm kind of sick of thinking this stuff over and want ANY saw that'll work.

I actually did buy a Delta Air Cleaner at the show...did I need one...no idea...I think I bought it just because I was dissappointed at not having bought a table saw...lol.

Mitch