>I`m looking at an electric garage space heater for the winter here in Northwest Ohio and would like to seek the advise of the WC collective. The place has a Dayton L5600 that puts out 19100 BTUs and is 5600 watts and costs $130, and another Dayton G73 for $270 that puts out 17100BTUs. I called them and asked why the apparently bigger unit costs so much more and put out 2000 less BTUs, they said that the smaller BTU unit will actually heat the room faster because, now see if this flys over your head the way it did mine, "because the seemingly smaller unit is actually bigger". Can someone explain this to me. This really has an old man CONFUSSED. I think I`ll buy the $130 units, what would you do? Larry in Ohio
>Yes they both have the same assesories on them, as far as I can see from the pics and the discription the only difference is the amps and the BTU`s. Larry
>Larry a BTU is a British Thermal Unit, the amount of heat it takes to raise the temperature of 1 pound of water 1 Degree Fahrenheit. (There is some more Attached to it such as the water must be distilled and at sea level and between certain temps, but essentially, that's it.) Each watt produces 3.4 BTU's when passed through a heating element. Apparently this is a pretty hard rule of physics. No one has found any magic heating element that produces more than 3.4 BTU's per watt.
If these heaters have a fan in them the more expensive unit might SEEM more effective if the fan is matched better. That would be hard to second guess. If the fan moved less air the air would come out hotter and might feel more "toasty", at least at first until it felt like it was cooking you. If the fan were more powerful it might have a better "throw" and distribute the air around the shop better making it more even, unless you were standing in the blast of air and felt like you were in a hurricane.
I have an ancient Barn Heater someone gave me and use it in my small shop. It is About the number of BTU's you are speaking of and does a good job in mild weather. I would think the features you want would be About that many BTU's, a fan, a thermostat, and an anti-tip device so that if it gets knocked over it stops running. I think you can buy one like that for about $40 at the big box stores. For that price, you could buy two.
>The price difference is the case. If you're going to run it unattended then the G73 is a much better choice. Almost every "space heater fire" will involve a unit similar to the L5600. The pictures at the links illustrate the difference:
>I got snookered into purchasing a L5600-type 240-volt heater made by Marley, thinking it would take the curse off cold hands and feet while I worked on a car in my otherwise unheated barn during the winter. Went to a lot of trouble to make up an extension cord for the unusual plug (so I wouldn't have to change out my 240-volt wall plugs), found out it only blows tepid air when it's cold in the barn. I'd run it about 20 hours before wanting to work in the barn, and, if I placed it near my feet, it would keep them from freezing. All my tools/the car, etc., remained a lot closer to the ambient (below freezing) temperature. I noticed the coil in the front of the heater wouldn't get even close to red like the little 110-volt milkhouse heaters I've used previously, so I asked the manufacturer whether I needed a replacement coil or some way to slow down the fan. Their response was the heater waw operating normally. It wasn't intended to raise the temperature significantly from below freezing, they said, just increase it a bit if it was above freezing. POS by my standards. I wouldn't buy another unless there was a fan speed control.
>Thanks everyone, it`s going to be the G73. The 5600 just looks like junk, and from the price probably made in China and just waiting for a place to start a fire, Larry