Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

My New Oneida 3hp Gorilla

Posts

My New Oneida 3hp Gorilla

#1

My New Oneida 3hp Gorilla

howard

>Could you answer two questions for me -

1)I heard that starting and stopping the motor too often will wear it out. But, to me this is the norm since we all move around to different machines at different times. What do you think.

2)I installed the cyclone myself and I have the bruises to show. Afterwards, I did not have the opening to the cyclone pointing where I originally wanted it. To solve this, my Oneida rep sent me 8" elbows and pipe to solve this. Does having approx. 7' of 8" duct starting from the cyclone enhance or hurt CFM?

Thanks for your thoughts, Howard

Re: My New Oneida 3hp Gorilla

#2

Re: My New Oneida 3hp Gorilla

Joanne in Pt. Pleasant, PA

>Congratulations, Howard! I finally installed mine this summer. I had some great help setting up the main unit, but did most of the ductwork myself (yes, yes, the post on this whole shebang is coming, folks). Oneida recommends coming off the unit's 8" port with at least 5 ft. of 8" pipe, so I don't suppose 7 ft. would be so bad. In fact, my 8" run is not quite 5 ft., then elbows down to the floor (my motor and filter are up in the loft; shop below) and has another 2 ft. run to the Y adapter that splits it off to 7". So I have almost 7 ft. of 8" on my system and it still SUCKS!

Oneida's note says not to start/stop the motor more than 6 times an hour. I've tried to be better organized about my work habits and then just open and close blastgates to the different machines I need to use, leaving the unit running. I LOVE not crawling around, moving the 4" hose on the Jet DC from machine to machine.

Re: My New Oneida 3hp Gorilla

#3

JL

Re: My New Oneida 3hp Gorilla

JL

>Oneida's recommendation is to not keep starting it and stopping it - who am I to argue. I do know that some motors are wound for continuous duty as opposed to intermittent duty. It would make sense that a dust collector would have a continuous duty motor.

As far as the ducting - couldn't you rotate the impeller housing? Or was it really too different? Bill Pentz has a static pressure calculator on his site (http://billpentz.com/woodworking/cyclone/ducting.cfm#DuctingIntroduction). Cincinnati Fan has a nice file you can download and work things out with a calculator (http://www.cincinnatifan.com/catalogs/EngData-203-internet.pdf).

My $0.02.

Re: My New Oneida 3hp Gorilla

#4

Speaking from little experience.....

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Speaking from no experience with cyclones (I only have a regular 1.5HP DC) I personally always found/figured that the less ductwork and bends the better.

If I understood correctly, you added an extra elbow bend and ductwork because the input didn't point or end up in the right spot.

Again if I understand correctly (and I might not 'cause I'm trying to visualize this) if you installed the cyclone and the input pointed the wrong way, I would think your options would be.

- Move all your tools to the other side of your workshop (kidding)

- Move into a house that is the exact same as your's but is a mirror image (really kidding, but I've seen a few and and it's cool to see an identical but flipped house when you're used to it the other way)

- Rotate or install the cyclone differently (perhaps too much work)

- Add extra elbow bends and ducting and live with the possible (and possibly insignificant) inefficiency it causes.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: My New Oneida 3hp Gorilla

#5

Re: My New Oneida 3hp Gorilla

GalenV

>Oneida has a very good web site that has a ductwork tutorial to help you duct the unit and figure the air flow. The owners manual gives some very good warnings on improper operation. They seem to skirt around the duty cycle but you could ask them direct. Starts per hour but also time between starts is important. I know people who said they started 6 times in an hour but all within the first ten minutes!

I assume Rep that gave you elbows suggested you not put right on intake of cyclone as it would degrade performance. I know four to six pipe diameters is a good number in most cases for straight pipe run to intake before an elbow.

Re: My New Oneida 3hp Gorilla

#6

Re: My New Oneida 3hp Gorilla

Joanne in Pt. Pleasant, PA

>About the intake not being where you need it--you CAN rotate the barrel and point it in a different direction. I did that.

Re: My New Oneida 3hp Gorilla

#7

Re: My New Oneida 3hp Gorilla

Barry Irby

>Howard, I don't have a cyclone, but I do have a dust collector.

The straight pipe leading into the DC is a good thing. Allows the airflow to smooth out and become more laminar. Or some such thing.

The elbows are not a good thing and as others have mentioned, are the equivalent to adding about eight diameters of pipe, in your case, about five feet each or more. You could improve this by rearranging the DC if you can and elimanating the elbows, but I assume you thought of that and would have done it, if it were easy. Another option would be to use the gentlest most "swept" elbows you can get.

OTOH, does any of this matter? A 3HP cyclone is a powerful machine. How BIG is you shop? How much pipe and elbows do you have? How many machines do you run at one time? I can't imagine that you are so close to the limits of performance on this system that a couple of elbows push you over the limit. Are you straining gnats when you have a machine that would swallow camels?

I did not know it was unwise to stop and start a DC other than in some vague general sense. I have the blast gates on my machines that start the DC when I open them. I try to make myself open the gate on the next machine before I close it on the last machine. That way the DC continues to run. Sometimes I crack a gate and leave it to leave the machine on. Most of the time I just open the gate on which ever machine and close it when I am finished. Then go to the next one. I am sure I have started my Delta machine many many times more than six and hour and have been using it off and on in a hobby shop for about four or five years. No problems.

Re: My New Oneida 3hp Gorilla

#8

Re: My New Oneida 3hp Gorilla

Stuart Hough

>Howard, I say forgeddaboudit! Hook it up and make some sawdust. That thing is a monster! If you see it isn't getting everything, then go through the hassle of repositioning it, but I think you'll be just fine.

Re: My New Oneida 3hp Gorilla

#9

Re: My New Oneida 3hp Gorilla

Jim Dillon

>Howard,

I have a 10-year old Oneida 1-1/2 HP cyclone that I sure wouldn't want any wondering gerbills or small cats around when that sucker starts up. I can't imagine what a 3 HP cyclone is like. I think you could put just use about any length of reasonable diameter pipe on that unit and it would work just fine. FWIW, at-the-time, the Oneida design engineers assured me that my 10-foot long 3-inch diameter dust pick-up hose on the end of a a 25-foot run would NEVER work and would pick up nothing. Well, it works just fine and picks up plenty of shop floor dust, dead (hopefully) mice etc. You should be fine.

Regarding the motor turn-off/turn-on duty cycle. What gives!! What kind of motor are they selling? I turn mine on and off easily 6 times an hour on busy days and never thought about a limit on the number of times I had to turn it on and off. Puzzeling?

Jim

Re: My New Oneida 3hp Gorilla

#10

Re: My New Oneida 3hp Gorilla

Fred Davis

>Like you I have a nearly ten year old Onieda industrial cyclone with a Marathon continuous duty 3 HP motor and six bag house and wondered about the post saying not to cycle on and off more then six times in a hour.

I read the manual twice , it never mentioned on and off cycles.

So it must be a new development, I have DC on a off a bunch more times then six in a hour.

It did say Onieda used Marathon and Leeson motors, both good US brands.

FredD

Re: My New Oneida 3hp Gorilla

#11

Re: My New Oneida 3hp Gorilla

mdclor

>Howard,

I'm jealous! My cyclone prefers a straight run of 5 feet going into the unit so the air flow gets laminar as was previously mentioned. I think the starting and stopping issue is that the motor might overheat due to the current draw when starting, so I tend to let mine run if I will only be a few minutes until I will need it again. I agree with others that a 3hp motor will be very adequate if you only run 1 machine at a time. In fact, you might need to leave an extra blast gate open so that the DC isn't starved for air when using anything with a 4" opening.

HTH,

Merle

Re: My New Oneida 3hp Gorilla

#12

Thanks Everyone for the great........

howard

>feedback. My issue is that it was not easy putting this thing together myself, so I don't look forward to taking it all apart. I will try to work out the ducting so that I avoid too many elbows and I'll see how the performance goes. Thanks again!!!!!

Re: My New Oneida 3hp Gorilla

#13

Re: My New Oneida 3hp Gorilla

Larry in NW Ohio

>Howard I have had a Onieda 3HP industrial cyclone for over 6 years now and it was the best thing I ever did. I came off the cyclone with 8" S&D PVC and about 4ft, and then I had to put an elbow on, that is as far as I could go, I would have like to go farther but the wall was in the way. But I was able to come off of that 4ft and went down to 6" and went to the table saw and router table. It works very well. How ever you do it you should not have any trouble, in my opinion you have the best on the market. If you have an American made motor and you take care of it, don`t stsrt and stop 10-20 times an hour, it should last a life time. Good luck Larry in Ohio

Re: My New Oneida 3hp Gorilla

#14

Re: My New Oneida 3hp Gorilla

John in Calgary

>To address the start/stop question - the killer of any motor is degradation of the insulation on the windings. The insulation self destructs with heat, but its not just a maximum temperature relationship, usually its a time/temperature thing that is cumulative over the life of the motor. The more you run the motor overloaded, or the more times you start the motor, the more heat damage you get. The only thing you can qualitatively say is that the higher the current flowing through the motor, the greater the damage, the shorter the motor's life. So what does that mean to your average hobbiest? Well, maybe your motor will only last 10 years instead of 20, or maybe its 15, or, well, its hard to predict.

During start-up, the motor will usually draw 6-8 times its normal operating amperage, which means a large heat load. Every time you start the motor, it goes through this cycle. If you start & stop the motor many times in a row (i.e. 6 times per hour as mentioned by Joanna above), you don't give the windings enough time to cool down from the high starting temperatures, so your next start begins at an even higher temperature, resulting in greater damage to the insulation.

So can you predict the longevity of your motor based on how you use it? No, its kind of like smoking, the long term cumulative effects are too hard to pin back to any one operating scenario (in other words, there is no way you are going to be able to say that it was that day in September 2008 that really sent your motor to its early grave).

John

Re: My New Oneida 3hp Gorilla

#15

Very interesting. Thanks.

Jim Dillon

>