>As I get closer to finishing my table top (I hope to be starting the breadboard ends this weekend), I have a question about wood movement. It is pretty humid still here in Albany, NY so I think my table top maple (which has stablized to the local humidity) is probably at it's widest dimension.
First off, I found on the web a rule of thumb that a table top will move up to 3/8" seasonally. Is this a relatively accurate figure?
Second, for a breadboard end would I make it even now during construction, so that the table top will be shorter in winter than the end, or do I make the end shorter so that the table is flush with it in the winter. I am thinking it probably doesn't look very good with the table beyond the end. But if the movement is greater than 3/8 I might want to split the difference.
>It really depends on the species of wood and the grain orientation, plain vs quarter. A more acurate amount a shrinkage can be calculated with the wood shrinkage calculater from wood web.
>I would make it even now, matching the wood where it is. As the wood seasons more and dries you may find the ends are "always" too long in whch case they could be trimeed off and refinished. If you make it short and don't like the short look, board streching is nearly impossible.
>Like a clock that needs winding, but is correct twice a day, breadboard ends are out of tune most of the time. Just a guess, but I suppose they were invented mainly to keep a jointed top flat and true, unnecessary with today's milled lumber and glues. Consider eliminating them in favor of a moulded edge. More interesting, IMO.
I agree with Clint. Although I personally like breadboard edges, I'd rather not employ them. A couple years ago I built a secretary desk/bookcase for my #2 daughter. (Shop Shot 810). The plans called for breadboards built into the sloping desk lid. I elected not to use them, believing the cherry was stable. Since the lid is overlayed, it is rabbeted into and rests upon the frame of the writing compartment. Thus far there has been no problems with movement out of flat, and the piece looks better without the breadboards, in my opinion. However, they are traditional in many designs, and many of my woodworking friends believed I was making a mistake.
>As others have mentioned, seasonal dimensional change depends on a lot of variables, species and grain orientation (quartered, rift, flatsawn) being among them, but there are a couple other things that enter the equation.
One is the swing in relative humidity in the locale where the furniture will live. Most areas of the United States have average seasonal humidity that produces MC (moisture content) swings between about 6 and 10 or 12 percent. In wetter coastal areas the swing averages from 8 to 13 percent, while in dry southwestern areas, it might range from 4 to 9 percent. These are significant differences that must be taken into account when you're constructing furniture.
Another consideration I wanted to mention is that the seasonal dimensional change is highest in Year One of a piece's life and tapers off somewhat over another year or two. After that, the seasonal swing becomes smaller, maybe as low as 50% of the initial first-year change, again depending on species and humidity. So, even if you predict the initial shrinkage accurately, it will change again, but less the second time and thereafter.
By way of an example, I built my dining room table about 25 years ago. It is 44" wide and made of three boards of black walnut, which has an annual nominal shrinkage/expansion of about 1.7% between 6 and 12% MC. The first year, the breadboards were sticking out about 3/16" on either end during heating season (we're in PA) and returned to almost flush the next summer. The following winter, the top contracted to about the same dimension as the first year, but now, in the most humid season (right about now) the ends stick out about 1/8" or less at each end. In other words, it doesn't seem to expand so much.
If there is an upshot to this, it is that you can drive yourself crazy trying to predict this with any degree of accuracy, and like Clint says, it's only going to be right once a year whatever you do. I think Greene & Greene came up with an interesting, if somewhat overwrought-looking with its contrasting floating ebony splines, way of dealing with this, by making the breadboard longer than necessary and rounding over the edges where it returns to the table top slab. In other words, they made a detail out of the unpredictability of the wood movement.
>If you don't want to always log onto the web to make this calculation with the online calculator, here is a link to a program you can download from right here at Wood Central that does the calculations, prints tables, and draws graphs. Personally, I think it's a lot handier than the online calculators.
DISCLAIMER -- I'm prejudiced! I wrote this program (and made it available here for free.)