Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Byrd Shelix heads - worth it?

Posts

Byrd Shelix heads - worth it?

#1

JL

Byrd Shelix heads - worth it?

JL

>Finally got the literature from Byrd. They are offering a Shelix head for my DW 735 planer as well as a head for my 8" jointer.

So - if you could only buy one (and the prices are quite similar for some odd reason) - which would you buy and why?

I mostly joint and plane relatively straight grained lumber - occasionally I'll do something that is more figured - but not as a matter of course. So the question is, do I really need one? I've been happy with the performance of my straight knives so far.

TIA

Re: Byrd Shelix heads - worth it?

#2

You Bet!!

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>I have one in my 8" jointer and one in my 14" planer.... Love them to death!

Take it easy,

Jim

Re: Byrd Shelix heads - worth it?

#3

Re: You Bet!!

Larry in NW Ohio

>Do they make spiral heads for lunch box planers? Do you have the web address? Thank you Larry in Ohio

Re: Byrd Shelix heads - worth it?

#4

Worth it? Maybe not in your case

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I have pushed thousands of linear feet of domestic lumber across a jointer and tens of thousands of feet of lumber through a planer. There haven't been a half dozen times that I could not control chip out on the jointer and on those rare occasions I simply sawed the edge. The planer, on the other hand, depends on what you are working. Maple, birch and black gum can more often be a problem surfacing than jointing. If I was planing a lot of these species I would at least look into something besides straight knives. My decision would also consider a surfacing sanders.

Re: Byrd Shelix heads - worth it?

#5

Re: Byrd Shelix heads - worth it?

David Yoho

>If you're mostly working straight grained woods and you like the results you're getting with the original cutters, I'd say no need to switch. However, if you work figured woods much, they will make a difference in the results and can be worth the cost.

David

Re: Byrd Shelix heads - worth it?

#6

Mine

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>I use mostly figured woods, so the Shelix is a great addition on my planer

Not sure a lunch box option is available...

Photobucket

You should see this slice through curly qs white oak...amazing!

Take it easy

Jim

Re: Byrd Shelix heads - worth it?

#7

JL

Mostly oak (red and white), maple, poplar...

JL

>and the occasional piece of cherry and walnut. I'll also do whatever wood happens to come my way.

Re: Byrd Shelix heads - worth it?

#8

Re: Mine

Brent in Montreal

>Here's a link to lunch box heads

http://www.popularwoodworking.com/techniquearticle?id=17751

Re: Byrd Shelix heads - worth it?

#9

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Depends on price

Jim in Burlington On

>I have a 15" delta planer and 4 sets of blades. If the price was right personally I'd just buy a unit that came with a shelix head before upgrading a lunch box planer. Chances are something in the planer may break long before you get your money's worth.

Re: Byrd Shelix heads - worth it?

#10

Re: Byrd Shelix heads - worth it?

Ken Platt (Granby, CT)

>You didn't mention the price, but in choosing between jointer and planer helix heads for the same $$, I'd go with the planer. You get a larger capacity for the same price, and the planer is the last step in surfacing anyway, so that's the one you'd want to be chipout free.

Having recently had a real bear of a time with tear out on some white oak, I went with a drum sander to solve the problem. I got the small Jet/performax, and that seems to work for me for those occasional problem figured boards that I love, but that don't love me...

Ken

Re: Byrd Shelix heads - worth it?

#11

JL

Not sure if they make yours.

JL

>It is in the new Byrd Tool catalog (2008 A, effective 20 August 2008). The price for the Dewalt DW-735 is $439. I don't really see any other lunchbox planer heads. The Delta 22-660 isn't a lunchbox, neither is the Powermatic P100.

As I said, it is weird because the price for a head for my 8" jointer is about the same as a 13" head for the DW-735.

Re: Byrd Shelix heads - worth it?

#12

Re: Mine

NickB in Eastern Mass.

>Jim,

How was the installation on your General 130? I did a bad thing to the journal head on mine (never, ever let a 4 yr. old distract you when you are changing planer knives), so I need a new one. I checked sometime back and there wasn't much of a price difference between a replacement head from General vs. a Shelix head, but I'm a bit of a scaredy cat when it comes to the idea of installing the new head.

Nick