>The battery in my 12V Dewalt drill motor has died, and the cost of a replacement battery is high enough that I am considering replacing the whole tool.
I use this for screwing and light drilling. I have a corded drill for things like pocket screws.
What brands do you recommend? What brands should I avoid? What about voltage? Mine is (or was) 12V, but the newer ones are generally higher voltage.
At my business where we rely on these tools daily and expect them to get a good share of abuse, we uses 18 volt Milwaukee's. In my woodshop I perfer the much lighter weight and smaller size of the Panasonic 12 volt drill/drivers. And from what I can tell, the durability is equally as good, just a bit less power.
>I have a half dozen drills and a dozen batteries. Makita, Panasonic, DeWalt. I'm tied of the batteries dying. I've deep-freezed them, shocked them, pampered them, kicked them, they're a waste of time and money.
My next tool with be Lithium powered. If we look at the improvements that Lithium batteries provided to laptops and cell phones (I remember when my cell phone wouldn't last more than 12 hours without recharging, now it can go for days) I think we'll see improvements in tools too.
The added benefit to the new Lithium batteries, is that they may be so good, that the prices of the old style batteries and tools will drop to pennies on the dollar as stores try to get rid of them. Maybe then I'll be able to afford new batteris for those old tools. That is if I don't throw them in the trash before that :)
>I have had good luck with Crapsman battery drills. I don't use them professionally, but they are good for all I need. I started witht he 12v but when the batteries died, it cost less to buy a new one, with extra batteries than to replace the 12v. Using a 18.8v (I thinks) now.
>I have an 18V Milwaukee. Lithium battery pack. I like it. Smal, Light-weight, yet plenty of power. the battery pack is one-half the size of the 12V NiCd packs of my DeWalt. The Milwaukee and Makita were the lightest weight drills that I found in that voltage.
>Warren, I bought a 18v.drill at the local ACE hardware store for $29.00 + sales tax. Just finished putting up a sheet metal fence arrangement and the battery ran for a long time before having to be recharged. Drill case has drill 4 drill bits, double headed screwdriver bit, one battery, and a recharge transformer.....all for only $29 + tax. Might still have such a deal going on now...check them out. Joe
>Does anyone make a good corded drill that also has a clutch? Cords aren't a bother for me in the shop and the fact that there's no battery to wear out would be a big plus.
My #3 son uses a DeWalt impact driver which he demonstrated for me. Very impressive, and I decided right then to get one of my own. The DeWalts are still a bit too pricy for me. I do have a Milwaukee Service Center nearby, so maybe I'll swing by there this afternoon and look at some of the recons there. I have two surviving battery driven drills at present: a old and very tired Porter+Cable, and a Ryobi with short lived batteries. A very comfortable tool to hold and use---until there is no more juice.
>Post what you finally buy please. My 15 year old Sears Craftsman's last battery went dead. Brought one intermediate priced unit home and gears sounded like they were trashed and took it back. Too many brands and models out there so I gave up. Back to my corded drills for now. I do know the drill/drivers may be nice for some but they are so long they will be of no value in a tight corner. Some chucks I found would never take small drill bits. Not sure why they are puttig such big 1/2 chucks on some as if you read the liturature very few will recommend drilling with 1/2" bit. Good luck I got burnt out looking.
>I have a 13 year old DeWalt 12V. When the batteries went belly up I purchased another DeWalt 12V drill w/ batteries. It's always nice, at least for me to have two drills on the bench, one for drilling pilot holes and one for driving screws, on occasions, wish I had a third drill. Will pay attention to the lithium batteries in the future, sounds like something for future batteries in power tools.
>Here's what I have and I would recommend it to anyone for woodworking and general use. If you haven't used an impact driver, you are really missing out!
>Hi Warren. I have the DeWalt 12v nicad drill. When the batteries went south, I had both of them rebuilt by the folks at MTO batteries. I got both batteries rebuilt for the price of ONE new battery from DeWalt. The replacement batteries have a higher current rating than the originals and have served me well in the past year. I would definitely use them again.
>warren I have a bosch 14.4 v compact toughf that i have used for 3 years killed 1 potter cable aftr 5 years of hard use I would recomend a a bosch so far it has held up to dailey use from hanging sheet rock to finish work on cabinets check out there 10.8 voil litheon stuff I have all of those just starting to use them
>Like many here, I started with a Makita 12 volt about 12 years ago. Batteries died and I bought a combo kit to get a second set of batteries and the impact driver. Then those batteries died and I had all four rebuilt at Primecell. Better power and about 2/3's the cost of new ones.
A couple of things. I have no complaint with the power of the 12 volt drills. The smaller size and lighter weight is a serious plus. Bigger is not better. They will do 99% of what I do building furniture and when I need more power I pull out one with a tail.
The Impact Driver is an amazing thing driving screws. I screwed down a subfloor and drove 2" screws all day. In fact, the impact driver will ring off screws if you are not careful. The only drawback I know how to an impact driver is that they don't have a clutch. You have to watch what you are doing or you will break the screws or drive them out the other side.
I saw a Makita kit at Home Depot with a drill and impact driver with 10.8 volt batteries. Lithium batteries. I bet you would be happy with that. Don't know the price.
Cordless tools are both great and terrible. Wonderful not to have to drag a cord around. BUT, the batteries are crap. The older ones were good for about 500 cycles. Sounds great, but after two or three years, they could be shot. Maybe the Lion batteries will be better.
Having said that, my Makita drills would be one of the last tools I would give up if I had to seriously downsize.
A dealer told me Bosch has a three year guarantee. At two years and 11 months just turn in the batteries for new ones. ????
>Warren I have mostly DeWalt tools, that way things interchange with the same voltage. I tried three different battery rebuilders and liked MTO the best. They cost me $80 to rebuild each battery, BUT they were 3300Mam cells, the biggest at the time. They almost twist your arm when stuck, it takes quite a bit to stall it. I really like them. Of course they have other sizes. I think the web site is MTObattery.com, if not just go to ebay and shearch for battery rebuild. Another thing about ebay, I have bought quite a few toold from there. The latest were 3 12v impacts for me and my sons. For $100 I got the whole 12v kit. An impact, watch so you don`t get the impact WRENCH, two batteries and charger, and they wer brand new. May be worth to look at, Larry in Ohio
Yeah, I know, bigger is better for some things 8-), but I've always been happy with my Bosch 9.6 volter. Call me an underachiever, but it served my WOODWORKING needs for 8 years then died. I bought another from Amazon, but there is not much selection in 9 volters. I also got a 12 volt Panasonic at a super deal (couldn't resist) and it is very nice as well. Try to visit a place that has a good selection and handle the different brands. Might help you decide. My own feeling is that for basic woodworking, I don't need something bigger. My 2 cents.
>A HUGE "thank you" to all who responded. I really appreciate the time each of you took to share your experiences and views.
I am not sure which direction I will go, but I have a much better idea of what to look for. I have looked into getting the battery rebuilt, but I am not sure that I want to go that way yet.
I think the idea will be to head out to a tool supply store, heft the different models (at least those that aren't tie-strapped to the wall) and decide which feels best, then decide based upon that, and options, battery style, and warranty.
Again, thank you. I have been reading and re-reading each response. I am much more confident than I was when I began this process.