Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

Posts

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#26

Re: Pros and Cons of Walmart

Howard Norman

>>Question: Do the folks displaced at small business actually get paid less (I don't know) at Walmart than they did at the mom and pop shop?<

From my limited knowledge, less than a dozen people, they are not paid less at WalMart. None of them had any medical insurance working at the Mom and Pop stores.

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#27

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

Dick Coers

>I wasn't going to touch this subject, but have to raise a couple of questions. Is there anyone in this group that works at Walmart? Don't think so. Our demographic seems to be aging white guys, white haired, slightly overweight, retired or close........ You get the picture. I wonder how we would respond to this posting if we were working two jobs, our wife was working two jobs, we had $20,000 in credit card debt, the car we drove was a gas guzzler with the service engine light on, and the wife was pregnant? We have paid our dues, but it's a tough world out there for the generation or two younger than us. I don't like to debate other peoples lives since I don't dwell there. Have you watched any of Morgan Spurlock's work on TV with his "30 Days" programs? Might be easier for us to discuss the merits of this type of subject if we worked at Walmart for a month, without checking on our stocks, 401k's, etc.........

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#28

A Canadian Issue - for the most part

Hank Knight

>In the U.S. it's unlawful for a company to close part of it's business - a single store or a factory for example - to avoid unionization. The Supreme Court decided that in The Darlington Manufacturing Company case where Roger Milliken pledged to close his plant in Darlington S.C. if the employees voted in a union. They did and he did. The union brought unfair labor practice charges and the National Labor Relations Board ordered Milliken to reopen the plant and bargain with the union. Milliken refused and the case wound up in federal court. It took 25 years for the Supremes to rule, but the ruling said that an employer can shut it's entire business down to avoid dealing with a union, but it can't close just part of it. The theory is that a partial closing sends a killer message that if employees vote in a union they will lose their jobs while the employer continues to operate elsewhere. Today, even a threat to shut down if employees vote in a union is unlawful. Canadian labor law is different in this respect. It apparently allows employers to selectively shut down it's operations to avoid dealing with a union.

Of course, there can be lots of reasons to shut down that don't have anything to do with employees voting in a union. Wal Mart obviously had very convincing economic reasons for shutting down the Texas stores after the meat cutters voted in a union. Otherwise, shutting down the store to avoid dealing with the union would have been a violation of the law.

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#29

Re: Thank you ! . . .

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>Being one of your 98%ers, I took your advise to check "this here internet thing and do some research"; found that these "monsters" pay little, if any, tax. You're right, it's obsecene.

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#30

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

Kneale Brownson dreaming of snow in N. MI

>My wife's twin sister worked at WalMart for several years. She made wages similar to what she'd made at similar wage-earner jobs and she had better benefits than before or since. She left because of the parade of managers-in-training that influenced her daily working conditions more than any thing else. She only recently (like eight years later) sold off her WalMart stock that had been part of her benefits. It was then the highest it had been in the interim and she just decided it was time. She rejected offers to join the parade of managers-in-training.

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#31

My last word on this

North of the Border

>When I brought up this news item, I knew there'd be views from both sides ... but didn't expect the strong negative sentiments about the front-line workers. It seems to suggest a lot of people on this forum aren't happy with the workers at WalMart (or elsewhere, too). Someone pointed out the background of the people on this forum might be a factor. Before I semi-retired, I worked on the Executive Floor. Now in my 50s, I have my own professional business but also work a few hours each week as a front-line worker (of course, not for money). I must say some front-line workers I observe DO NOT deserve the pay they receive while to some others we should be thankful for their dedication and service, despite their $10 - $12 an hour pay. The difference is in the QUALITY of Management / supervision, not always due to the workers. Then of course, like buying woodworking tools, we get what we pay for, even when we're talking about employees.

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#32

Re: No surprise

Wood Grip

>I don't get it, why bother posting this highly political topic on a woodworking forum, if you don't want to stir it up? Worst thing about this forum, people post stuff like this and then Ellis and others get bent out of shape about the responses. How could it not go this way?

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#33

Re: A Canadian Issue - for the most part

Charlie Self

>Unfortunately (or fortunately, depending on your POV), it is not necessary to actually shut down a business to bust a union. If a company has other plants, it can simply move production to them for "efficiency" reasons, and eliminate jobs at the unionized plant until they are down to a caretaker crew.

That's basically what happened here when the union "won." No threats. No promises. No plant. No recourse, and I have seen a number of those people working as greeters at the local WalMart where I am willing to bet they make less than half what the plant paid.

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#34

Re: No surprise

Charlie Self

>It's germane, or seems to be, because WalMart and the big box stores are ubiquitous, influencing every area of our lives, including woodworking (do I buy my Titebond at a local woodworking store...not a chance, as it would be a 40 mile drive to a store with which I try not to do business, but WalMart is 12 miles away [Lowes is now also 12 miles away, though and is preferable, though we have one small hardware store and two farm supply stores, plus Tractor Supply, too]).

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#36

Re: Political????? Absolutely!

Ralph Turney

>

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#37

Re: Political?????

Howard Norman

>It depends on what your defination of political is.

I don't consider it political myself. It is relevant to all of us in where we decide to spend out money. I make those decisions on where I can get the best bang for my dollar. Using that criteria WalMart comes out on top in many, but not all, categorizes. As an example, I have to go into town today for shampoo, for me that is something that is either purchased at WalMart or Costco. Costco is too busy on a Sunday so it will be a WalMart purchase today.

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#38

Re: Political adj - defined....

north of the border

>merriam-webster dictionary:

Main Entry:

po�lit�i�cal

Pronunciation:

\pə-ˈli-ti-kəl\

Function:

adjective

Etymology:

Latin politicus

Date:

1551

1 a: of or relating to government, a government, or the conduct of government b: of, relating to, or concerned with the making as distinguished from the administration of governmental policy2: of, relating to, involving, or involved in politics and especially party politics3: organized in governmental terms 4: involving or charged or concerned with acts against a government or a political system

Free online dictionary:

po�lit�i�cal (p-lt-kl)

adj.

1. Of, relating to, or dealing with the structure or affairs of government, politics, or the state.

2. Relating to, involving, or characteristic of politics or politicians: "Calling a meeting is a political act in itself" Daniel Goleman.

3. Relating to or involving acts regarded as damaging to a government or state: political crimes.

4. Interested or active in politics: I'm not a very political person.

5. Having or influenced by partisan interests: The court should never become a political institution.

6. Based on or motivated by partisan or self-serving objectives: a purely political decision.

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#39

Not sure I agree

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>"Anyone who thinks staff isn't part of a business's success knows little about business."

Admittedly they are people who know much more about business than I do.

But that being said, all I'm saying is that compared to other industries, I didn't think that the staff the big box retail industry influenced their business success as much as in other retailers or other industries.

If you ranked the top 500 companies in order where general staff, as opposed to other aspects, is their key to success, I wouldn't expect Walmart to be anywhere near at the top of that list.

There are some industries where the sales staff have a bigger impact on the company's success. Even other, smaller, retail companies. I'm thinking sales staff in particular since I'm assuming that was the largest part of Walmart's staff.

"... someone, somewhere, in each store has to be capable enough to keep track of what is and isn't sold, and keep the backroom storage and shelves filled...."

I didn't think that in big box retail companies there was a large percentage of their staff that did that. Certainly if you took every single person out of a company, it wouldn't be able to function. But, the percentage of staff at a company like Walmart that makes the biggest impact on their success is small. Again, based on my assumption that Walmart's success is determined by sales volume, low prices and profit.

If staff was so important to Walmart, why do they force their suppliers to stock the shelves rather than using their own staff? Why do they outsource so much of their work? Why did they replace friendly cashiers with self-checkout machines?

For me at least, I choose to shop at Redmond Machinery because of the people and products. When I shop at Walmart, it's because of the price and convenience/availability. When we go out to eat at the local Pizza place here, it's because of the people and the pizza. When I eat at McDonalds it's because of the price and convenience.

Walmart wouldn't exist without staff, but compared to other retailers, or other industries, I can't see how anyone can say that Walmart's success is due to their staff more than the other factors of their success (volume and prices).

I certainly didn't want to offend anyone, but I guess it was unrealistic to think no one would be insulted. Sorry.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#40

Re: Not sure I agree

Howard Norman

>At my local WalMart SuperCenter there are eight self checkout bays. I don't think that I have ever been in the store when there weren't more cashier operated check outs than eight. Of course I am not there at three am either so I can't say what happens during the middle of the night. At my local store it is a mixture of vendor and employees stocking the shelves. Like most retail outlets the staff at WalMart varies greatly as far as helpfulness is concerned. I have had an employee spend several minutes with me looking for an item. I have also had an employee say "I have no idea". WalMart is certainly interested in low prices more than any other thing in my opinion.

Whatever one thinks of WalMart you have to admit that there practices have allowed them to dominate the low cost retail arena. I don't think that I would have predicted them to overshadow places like Sears and Kmart when they started out.

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#41

Ellis - - how bout we kill this thread.

Pete LaBelle

>

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#42

People at Walmart

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>The people at the Walmart here in Peachtree City are great. They tend to be older (over 40) and while they might not always be there right when you need them, or know where everything is, they sure try to be helpful and friendly. Just about all of them are here.

However, I've found the opposite to be true at other Walmarts all around Atlanta. Seems the younger they are the more attitude (bad) they have.

I don't shop at Walmart based on the people. But it's almost always a pleasant experience (except at the checkout lines) here near home, and almost always miserable elsewhere.

This phenomenom is not limited to Walmart. The other stores here in Peachtree City and neighboring cities tend to have much more pleasant staff than elsewhere in Altanta. I guess the neighborhoods make a difference.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#43

What If

iew

>Rockler employees decided to unionize?? What would happen to service and pricing?? That ain't poltical, thats my pocketbook.