Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

Posts

OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#1

OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

North of the Border

>and close down this store?

Well, $20,000 US a year is pretty low ... and $13 B profit? I'm not a pro-union guy but that kind of profits is insane (or inhumane) when we take into account the wages of the staff who are the driving force for its operation.

***

News: A Quebec arbitrator has imposed a collective agreement on Wal-Mart for the first time in the world's largest retailer's history.

The arbitrator released the decision Friday on the contract for eight workers at a tire-and-lube garage at a Wal-Mart store on Maloney Boulevard in Gatineau.

Guy Chenier, head of the local representing the workers, said the union is delighted with the deal, which gives the workers raises averaging 35 to 40 per cent effective immediately, as well as more vacation.

A spokesman for Wal-Mart said the company is unhappy with the decision and it is "incompatible" with the company's way of doing business. Wal-Mart is the biggest company in the world, according to the Fortune 500 rankings, and recorded nearly $13 billion US in profits in 2007 � yet its front-line employees make less than $20,000 US a year, on average, and the company has been cited for union-busting tactics by government agencies and independent watchdogs.

Friday's precedent-setting contract is the first ever imposed on the Arkansas-based retailer by an outside agency.

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#2

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon North,

Wal-mart didn't get to be the biggest in the world by inept tactics. Salaries and related human resources are business considerations, and nothing more. It takes external forces such as arbitration to curb corporate greed. So, yes, they will do what made them big.

George

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#3

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

Frank in Forest Hill

>And then those greedy buzzards go and pay out dividends to those high and mighty retired share holders ( like me) and Union pension funds,and school board pension funds..... How dare they!!!

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#4

What is the percentage profit??

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

>Well, what is the Walmart return on sales, on investment? I find that people who complain about big profit numbers have no idea of what is invested to make that profit. People complain about Exxon making absurd profits, but 5% profit is not very high at all. (I don't recall where I read the 5% number.)

If you look at the WalMart 2nd quarter report you will see that it takes money to make money.

For the first 6 months of fiscal year.

Gross Sales, 198 billion

cost of sales 150 billion

admin costs 37 billion

profit before taxes and interest 10 billion

Net profit after all expenses 6.4 billion

THAT IS A PROFIT OF 3.25% ON SALES.

WalMart share holders got a 95 cents per share dividend.

I will bet that there was not a single WalMart manager that held a gun to the emplyee's head to make them work there.

Yes, I would close all the stores in Quebec. Maybe the people who did work at the closed stores can find jobs translating finance and management text books into french.

Please do not consider this a personal attach in any manor or form,

Ken

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#5

Re: What is the percentage profit?? *LINK*

North of the Border

>If every company looks at the % of return in deciding how much they're to pay their staff (of course many do), many stores and businesses would no longer exist and the unemployment rate in the US (or for that matter in Canada) would not be what it's. 'Decent salaries' doesn't mean 'excessive salaries.'

Here's another view on WalMart:

"Conclusion

Wal-Mart does a lot right. It has expanded productivity by being more efficient and leaner than many other companies. Many of the benefits shoppers accrue from Wal-Mart's expansion could be preserved even if the retailer had to meet the expectations of its critics regarding fair worker compensation. Defenders of the company too often set up false dichotomies such as low prices vs. high wages when in reality, better compensation for workers won't negate Wal-Mart's competitive edge."


WalMart

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#6

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>WalMart employs folks who otherwise couldn't expect to make $20K a year. Nobody is holding a gun to anyone's head to either work or shop there.

Clint

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#7

Huh? Staff???

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>".... the staff who are the driving force for its operation..."

Please don't take this as an insult to anyone working at Walmart, but since when was staff really an important part of Walmart, or any other big box retailer?

I thought it was all based on sales volume. Huge sales means huge purchases from their suppliers, which means they can make strong demands of those suppliers. They can dictate how products are manufactured and how much they'll pay. Why pay staff to stock the shelves when you can force the supplier to do that as part of the delivery? I wouldn't be surprised if they say "we'll buy your XYZ floor cleaner, only if you wash our floors at night". Again, less staff to hire.

I think some of the Walmart staff (in the stores) are sweet people, but I can't see how Walmart would see them as a key ingredient to their success.

More people buy because it's cheaper. It's cheaper because more people buy.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#8

Re: What is the percentage profit??

Howard Norman

>WalMart will probable do one of two things:

1) Shut down all stores in Quebec

2) Raise prices to cover the increased salaries

I would bet on number one and if it was my decision that is what I would do.

howard

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#9

Re: Huh? Staff???

Howard Norman

>>but since when was staff really an important part of Walmart,<

The staff was certainly a major part of WalMart during the days of Sam Walton, I knew Mr Walton on a personal basis. He and my late father were close friends in Bentonville. I am of the opinion that the importance of the store clerks is still a prime concern of WalMart top management. I would also imagine that there are individual store managers that couldn't care less.

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#10

Thank you ! . . .

steve mackay

>%98 of pepole look only at these mind blowing numbers and call a company a greedy monster. Before they do that they really should use this here internet thing and do some research including the percentage of the tax burden these "monsters" pay out. Now, THATS obscene !

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#11

Re: Thank you ! . . .

Norman (Ottawa, Ont.)

>Walmart has already closed another store in Quebec after a similar ruling and introduction of a union to the workforce.

So I will not be surprised if this time they're all shut down in Quebec for fear that this is a dangerous precendent to the way they conduct their business ( in this province, at least).

BTW, I am impartial in all this, just voicing my thoughts on what will occur.

Norman

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#12

Interesting to see if this union thing continues

North of the Border

>across Canada and whether WalMart will be withdrawing from Canada completely. Needless to say, Costco and other big box retailers would be quietly hoping that to happen - and the sooner the better. My relative in Quebec where that WalMart store was closed told me life has been usual there and the closure was actually music to the ears for the small shops.

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#13

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

Norman (Ottawa, Ont.)

>What bothers me about the union's response ( joy and glee) to this deal is the fact that Walmart can decide to close this store at the drop of a hat. Don't these courts and unions take this into account. It is purely Walmart's perogative if they want to continue to do business at this location. Incredible short-sightdedness and a risky gamble on the union's part I'm afraid.

These court imposed collective agreements might work within the government and the public service in general, but in private industry I'm afraid it doesn't quite work this way. It is way to easy for a company to shut its doors and relocate to a more "business-friendly" location. If the economics of doing business aren't right or favorable, businees moves elsewhere.

I'm curious at the outcome of this decision and how Walmart reacts.

Norman

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#14

Re: OT I think earlier on the Union has already

North of the Border

>assured all the auto workers there that alternative unionized auto jobs will be arranged for them if WalMart chooses to close down the operation there. Unions have a 'war chest' to fight this kind of games. Without such 'protection,' I don't think those auto workers would risk their jobs in such a way, knowing that WalMart is likely to shut down the shop once and for all.

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#15

Re: OT I think earlier on the Union has already

Howard Norman

>I think that you are giving the unions much too much credit. From my limited experience back in the '60s the unions here did not have other union jobs for such people. Can't say what happens for sure these days however.

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#16

Re: The job offer assurance was reported in the

North of the Border

>same news item earlier on that covered this union fight between the autoworkers and WalMart. I'm just the messenger ....

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#17

Re: The job offer assurance was reported in the

Howard Norman

>OK, that is different than what I saw around years ago. From the workers standpoint it would appear to be a no brainer then.

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#18

Short history

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Okay, I didn't think of that. I was introduced to the Walmart Superstore a little over 12 years ago, so that's all I've seen.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#19

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

Brent in Montreal

>It's my birthday and I've been drinking. so I won't respond to this post except to say that nothing has hurt the Quebec economy more than unions, except the threat of seperation.

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#20

Re: Huh? Staff???

Charlie Self

>Anyone who thinks staff isn't part of a business's success knows little about business.

While the clerks and stockers may not be the world's best and brightest, someone, somewhere, in each store has to be capable enough to keep track of what is and isn't sold, and keep the backroom storage and shelves filled. That's not an ad hoc job, and requires certain skills. I've got a friend who works nights at the local WalMart who is a retired Sgt. Major, USMC, who is a stock manager. I don't know what he makes, nor would I ask, but probably more than 20K, while the average clerk at this particular store appears to make $8.00 an hour, give or take (from conversations with a dozen or two), or less than 17K. In essence, WalMart's getting what they pay for, of course, but staff is ALWAYS important, even those some of us look down on as incapable of making 20K elsewhere.

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#21

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

Charlie Self

>It's not always easy to predict a union's sensitivity to real life. Here, we had a union about a decade or 15 years ago in a rubber product mfg. plant. It struck, even though the plant was already shrinking badly, and had been bought by a company with other plants in lower wage areas. The whole deal was over a raise in benefits for people who had retired earlier. After several months, the union declared victory (they somehow got an agreement that management personnel wouldn't work the line jobs), as the plant shut down and moved all production elsewhere.

The clown who was president of the union local got on TV and declaimed loudly that the union was the victor, while the last 200 or so people go laid off (the plant employed more than 1,100 in its best days).

If we'd been able to foresee some things, we might have been able to get him a "Mission Accomplished" banner for his TV appearance.

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#22

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

iew

>One administrative judge will bring the house down. Wallmart will shut it down. They did it in Texas when the butchers voted to go union, no more butchers at Wallmart. Funny, never missed them. If Obambi is elected there will be a push to unionize all Wallmarts. Just read a story that WM is gearing up for that possibility. What happens to WM when they have a 3.5 billion loss? Most of the people that work for WM are overpaid anyway. My philosophy is that you don't like the pay, move on.

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#23

Re: OT I think earlier on the Union has already

Charlie Self

>They still don't have jobs. Any union war chest is built up of overall funds, and can pay partial salaries for a period of time, but after that, zip. I'm not at all sure how a WalMart closing affects auto workers, anyway. Does a guy working the line making maybe $50 an hour gross seem likely to be grateful for a 9 or 10 buck an hour dock wallopers' job at WalMart?

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#24

Steven Antonucci

Pros and Cons of Walmart

steve antonucci

>Pros- they create lots of jobs wherever they are.

Cons- Small business suffers, as they swallow everything in their wake

Question: Do the folks displaced at small business actually get paid less (I don't know) at Walmart than they did at the mom and pop shop?

Pros- Walmart has driven innovation in supply chain management, which has a downstream effect of lower prices

Cons- The work in volume, which ususally means lower margins.

Question: If you look at margin as a business metric vs gross $$$ as a measure of stability and management capability, would you want to erode that number if you owned Walmart stock? (I am not a shareholder, but I would not want higher wages for commodity employees if I were...)

Pros- Walmart's approach to sourcing products has driven lower prices

Cons- Manufacturing in the US is on the decline(not because of Walmart, tho)

Question: Are most people willing to raise wages across the board (manufacturing, at Burger King, Walmart) only to have the gains eaten up by the higher costs of everything?

Question: Do you care about the standard of living in China? I know that I don't, and I also know that they don't care about the standard of living here. If keeping jobs in the US meant someone had to work for $1/hr, would it be you?

Not a Walmart basher, nor a Walmart shopper. Just a regular guy with a slightly broader perspective...

Steve

Re: OT Will WalMart do again what it did before

#25

Well put.

steve mackay

>