Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Saw something on (OT)

Posts

Saw something on (OT)

#1

Saw something on (OT)

Larry in NW Ohio

>QVC the other night called a Magic Jack. It`s plugs into your computer via the usb port, then you are suppose to be able use the computer as your land line telephone. You can look it up on the web at magicjack.com or on QVC. Of course they had all kinds of testimoinals. It really sounds good for $40 and after the first year it costs something like $20 a YEAR. I was wandering if anyone here has one and how they liked it. Of course all comments wecome. Thank You Larry in Ohio

Re: Saw something on (OT)

#2

Steven Antonucci

Is it an IP phone?

steve antonucci

>Is it anything like a Skype phone? Or can you call any number with it?

Steven

Re: Saw something on (OT)

#3

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Is it an IP phone?

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>Sort of. I guess the tech is a little different than Skype, probably more like Vonage or the other VOIP phones. The biggest downside (I looked into getting one) is that Magic Jack is only able to provide you with a phone number in some of the larger markets. That means that if you got one, your next door neighbor would have to dial long distance to call you. But if I were in one of the larger markets, I would probably have one--at $40, that's a pretty cheap experiment with large potential savings.

Jason

Re: Saw something on (OT)

#4

MagicJack? Garbage!

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>That's all I'll say, for now.

Okay, you've twisted my arm.

The theory is great! Fantastic idea! $39 for a device the size of a.... hmmm, what is it like?..... a small MP3 player, I guess. Plug a regular $9 phone into the device, then plug the device into the USB port of your PC, or any PC, and it uploads and installs software to your PC.

A minute later you have a screen on your PC and you can enter a phone number. Any phone number in the world. It dials and then you're talking to the other person on their normal phone. Then another $16 each year to keep it active.

All this and 30 day money back guarentee. Absolutely marvelous.

Except that.....

- They over charged me on my credit card. No big deal, this is going to save tons of money, even over my VoIP Vonage line I've used for 23 years.

- Read the instructions. Easy. It's so simple there isn't much to read. Just plug it in and wait for it to load the software.

- Wait

- Wait

- Wait

- Wait

- Try to turn off computer

- Unplug computer

- Turn on computer again

- Wait for Windows to load

- Plug in device again

- Wait

- Wait

- Wait

- Reboot again

- try it on another computer

- Wait, wait, reboot

- Try it on another computer... good thing I have 12 computers here.

- Wait, wait, give up......

- Go back to first computer

- Reboot

- Plug in

- Wait, wait.... software loads

- Dial number

- Horribly noisy line

- Try again

- Noisy line

- try again

- less noisy line

- turn off all computers in the house (I know from my Vonage VoIP line that if there are other computers accessing the internet... even unattended computers doign an auto send/receive in Outlook, and it aftects the long distance callse.

- try again

- still noisy line

- try it on another computer....

Well you get the idea. It took me 31 days of trial and error with this stupid thing before I decided it was junk. I know. I should have sent it back earlier.

But I had such HIGH HOPES for this device.

In theory it's fantastic. In practice? Well, it sucks!

But then again, I'm very hard and critical on technology.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Saw something on (OT)

#5

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Well, you just saved me...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>...$40 if they ever decided to use Lafayette, IN exchanges (strong potential college market here...) If it's noisy, no way. To me clarity of call is a baseline standard, one reason I have tried one Bluetooth ear cockroach. I don't care if I have to jump through a few hoops to get something working the first time, but not every time...

Jason

Re: Saw something on (OT)

#6

funny thing

Dan Donaldson

>One of my sons lives out where cell phone reception is very dicy and they do not have a land line. He got one just to try it out and for him it works fine. I call him on it all the time and it seems to be a clear signal. I haven't tried it because they don't have a linux version yet. Just to confuse the issue.

One thing to be aware of is that they are not totally sure about the business model and how it is going to work out, so there is some reasonable risk that it could go belly up without warning. (My son is one that researches EVERYTHING he buys ;-) and he figured that if it worked at all (which it has for him so far) and he gets at least 6 months usage, he is money ahead considering the alternatives where he lives. If not, he has not lost too much.

Re: Saw something on (OT)

#7

Re: MagicJack? Garbage!

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

>Another thing to consider....if the electricity goes off you do not have any phone capability....yet with the regular phone connection it is always on. In an emergency I would like to have that phone available always.

Re: Saw something on (OT)

#8

Re: MagicJack? Garbage!

Art Liebeskind

>I beg to differ. I got Magic Jack last March before a business trip to Rome. I wanted it mainly to call back to the US and Canada from overseas and it was fine in Rome ($0.00) and later in May from Australia($0.00). I use iot here at home to call Canada and it is just fine. I like it and it has paid for itself many times over.

Art Liebeskind

Re: Saw something on (OT)

#9

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Not necessarily...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>A UPS is a good thing to have. With my desktop shutdown, my laptop running on battery and wirelessly connected to my router and cable modem, both of which were plugged in to the UPS, I was able to surf the internet for almost an hour during our last power outage--I could have gone longer, but was limited by the laptop battery.

Cell towers usually have backup generators, so cellphones are an option during power outages.

Jason

Re: Saw something on (OT)

#10

Re: Saw something on (OT)

Garrett in Victoria

>There's been a lot of discussion about Magic Jack on boating discussion boards, and almost all comments from users have been positive.

Cheers, Garrett

Re: Saw something on (OT)

#11

Re: Not necessarily...

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

>That's fine...if you have a laptop and a cell phone....BUT I was stating that computers run on electricity and the Magic-Jack would not work if the desktop shut down....laptops probably will, like you said until the battery runs down....and then it has to be recharged with electricity.

The regular phone lines will work because the phone companies figured this out decades ago so that there would be communication in emergencies.