Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Unbelievable

Posts

Unbelievable

#1

Unbelievable

Dwain - Lakeland FL

>I took Thursday off last week to be at home to receive my new Powermatic PM 2000 only to be disappointed. I was at the rear of the trailer when the driver started to move the pallet containing the tablesaw and as soon as he turned the pallet I could see the huge tear in the cardboard (yes I said cardboard)that was wrapped around the saw at which point I said it's damaged, so he brought it to the rear of the trailer so we could inspect it and sure enough it was all scratched up at which point I told him I was refusing the delivery.

I then proceeded to email Amazon as well as powermatic. I could not believe the fashion in which the saw was packaged. Considering how much one pays for a PM 2000 to package it with cardboard simply wrapped around the body of the saw does not say much for the quality Powermatic is professing, not to mention that it doesn't do much to make the customer feel confident that they've purchased a quality tool.

I've made purchases from Grizzly as I explained in my email to Powermatic the grizzly package was reinforced as though it was going to be air dropped into a combat zone.

Anyway that's been my experience so far. I told the Amazon rep I was willing to give it another try, so let's see how things go this time.

Dwa

Re: Unbelievable

#2

Re: Unbelievable

allen heath

>wow....I too have ordered from grizzly and you are correct....their merchandise is packed like its goning to be aridropped into a foreign country. however, when i oreder my shaper from grizzly, even with all the packaging, it still had a good sized dent in it...works good after 2 years though

Re: Unbelievable

#3

Re: Unbelievable

charlie belden

>Bummer. All that time waiting in aniticipation, the time spent clearing a new home for your unit, the thrill of hearing the delivering truck coming. To then see The New Baby wrapped in a torn up cardboard box!

Crisis can present opportunities.

If the damage was merely cosmetic - dents, paint scratches and such, there's an opportunity to negotiate a price on the "damaged" goods. The seller, or their insurance company, incurs some expense, both in time and money, returning and "refurbishing" returned damaged goods. Asking for 15-20% off on the price originally paid might be worth trying. And if, when you unpack the whole unit and put things together, there's still a problem - you still have recourse.

Not sure why a cabinet saw - in the $2K price range, didn't come in a crate. Granted my Robland X-31 was shipped - literally by ship - from Belgium - and its crate was 1 1/8" thick dense MDF (which weighed a prheakin' TON).

Still ended up with a dinged joiner fence, some orange peeled paint, scratched/gouged shaper rings and a few missing parts. That took close to three months to resolve - but I was dealing with Laguna Tools. To LT's credit, they did offer me a good deal on their LT 16SEC bandsaw - and through in the shipping cost and state sales tax. Didn't know I needed a bandsaw but the offer was too good to pass up. I've since learned how nice it is to have a bandsaw.

There are advantages to buying locally.

Re: Unbelievable

#4

All of them will be scrimping on packaging soon.

Eddie Pacheco: San Jose, Ca,

>The head of Seagate technology gave a talk and said that shipping was costing more than employees and parts per product. In the disk drive industry the various parts are shipped from all over for pre-assembly then shipped somewhere else for final assembly/testing and shipping. I'm pretty sure this same expense scenario is starting to hit the various tool makers that have offshore fabrication (most). They will play the odds, along with applying pressure to the shippers, and scrimp down to the bare minimum for protective packaging to save some money.

Re: Unbelievable

#5

Re: Unbelievable

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>As a packaging engineer (past life), good packaging will never make up for poor handling - ever.

Packaging design is a compromise between protection, money and the environment. I can design packaging that will absolutely ensure you get your product in pristine condition, regardless of how it got there. But for a table saw, you can probably expect to add at least $250 - $400 for it. Will you pay that for something you just throw away? And then you get to fill up the landfill with waste that will never decompose. Not what anyone wants.

Remember that while the packaging cost you time, it costs the company money. And you can bet that if damage like this is a regular occurrence that the packaging will be changed. But packaging is designed to protect a product from the loads it's most likely to incur. The wound you describe sounds like a careless forklift driver or ?? who perhaps swung another load into your saw. Granted, a full-on foam-filled plywood crate would probably have protected against that - or then again, maybe not?

Whether or not you consider the packaging to be inferior, it's a pretty safe bet that the vast majority of their cardboard wrapped saws get to where they need to go with no damage - else they'd simply not package them that way.

You, unfortunately, were the exception.

The saw itself has had good reviews as you yourself can attest to - after all, you bought one! I think it wise to bring the issue to the company's attention, but I don't think it's fair to slam Powermatic or the saw based on this experience. While I can fully understand your disappointment, to judge a product such as a PM2000 based strictly on it's packaging is a bit premature. I'm thinking that once you get an undamaged saw set-up in your shop and have the chance to use it for a while, the entire packaging episode will be pretty far behind you.

Now - if they'd packaged the saw in one of those stupid da$@$ed bubble packages that cut me every time I open one, I'd be beating a different drum!

Rob

Re: Unbelievable

#6

Very well thought out reply

Dan Mitchell

>Rob - I think you're absolutely correct. I also have a PM2000, which I got from the local Woodcraft, and which they delivered. As I recall, it was also packed in cardboard, on a pallet, with vertical wooden framing. I've had other troubles with this dealer, and they may not have the lowest price on everything, but one advantage of buying locally is they take the risk for the majority of the shipping.

I also have an 8" PM jointer, the top portion of which was packed in a thin wood crate. Given how thin the wood was, I don't know how much real addition protection it might have afforded vs. a lunging pallet fork or similar threat.

On a related note, I ordered some replacement knives for the jointer from Tool King. When I saw the box sitting by the door, clearly marked 6 x 6 x 6, I though "Crap, they sent the wrong size". Nope. The 8" knives were inside, wrapped in one layer of paper, placed diagonally across the box, their sharp, brittle edges separated from oblivion at the 2 corners by maybe 1/8" of cardboard. Only dumb luck prevented the box from being dropped just the right way to chip one or more blades. In this case it wasn't the design of the packaging, but the stupidity of the shipping clerk that was the issue. But I guess there again, the business in question was likely attempting to get by with the least expense possible when the employee was hired, and they got what they paid for ;-/

Dan

Re: Unbelievable

#7

Re: Unbelievable

Ralph Turney

>"And then you get to fill up the landfill with waste that will never decompose. Not what anyone wants."

Really?

Re: Unbelievable

#8

Re: Unbelievable

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>"really?"

Sorry Ralph - not sure what you're getting at here....

Rob

Re: Unbelievable

#9

Re: Unbelievable

Ralph Turney

>"And then you get to fill up the landfill with waste that will never decompose. Not what anyone wants."

Really?

Just that you think you're speaking for everyone in the statement above. Just my not so subtle way of saying that you're not. Since you added, what is in my opinion, a political statement, I'll add mine.

I could care less about the land fills, and never say never.

Ralph

Re: Unbelievable

#10

Re: Unbelievable

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>All righty then.

Rob

Re: Unbelievable

#11

Jesper, Denmark

Re: This could be a case for less is more....

Jesper, Denmark

>I ship very large and very expensive machinery from japan to EU and USA by contaqiner. We used to pack in wooden crates, which are costly - and need special certificates for heat or chemical treatment.

Now we just wrap in plastic sheets and tie the machinery down in the container.

We actually have less damage, as the handlers in the ports and in trucking can see what is inside, and that it can be damaged. As a result, they are more careful and the goods arrive with no damage as a rule. With the solid woooden crates, everybody assumed that they could take rough handling - likr getting tipped over on the side etc.

Re: Unbelievable

#12

Pssssstt, Rob

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Ralph might just be a landfill operator, and you would be threatening his rice bowl with your posit.

I spend time checking our marked plastics and binding up several kinds of paper which I then spend a gallon of gasoline to take to the recycling center each week, but there are people I've met who live near me who refuse any sort of recycling, put out 2 or 3 cans of garbage every Friday, and will go to some length to maintain that to do otherwise is Anti-American and also encourages gay marriage.

|;-}}}

Re: Unbelievable

#13

Ha! *LINK*

Tony - Memphis

>I just received a PM2000 week before last. I ordered it from Woodcraft, buth they are all shipped out of PM over in East Tn I think? Anyway, mine was got here without a scratch. So far, everything looks good. I checked everything pretty close with dial indicators and all that stuff. Haven't found anything significant. I'm not picky about the paint job and such. I was dissapointed with the insert, but I'll probably not use it much anyway. One thing I did think was odd was that the pallet that the saw was on was too small for a standard pallet jack (27" wide forks?). So, the driver and I had to tilt it over and slide a regular pallet under it.

Here are some pics of how I got it to the shop from the garage. It was quite a day....HOT too...

AS for packaging, I work for a very large shipping company. It always amazes me to see the extremes that go through our system. I was out at the hub testing one night and we had a box of something that looked like Karo syrup open up on a slide - talk about a mess! Then, we had a box of semi truck lug nuts open on an overhead belt, so every few minutes one or more of those big suckers came raining down. Another night it was raining beer bottle caps. We have a whole team of folks that do nothing but develop packaging for our customers. I've been to their lab. They have some pretty cool toys.

Tony


Moving a PM2000

Re: Unbelievable

#14

Well, that's 'cause you bought the wrong..... *LINK*

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Well, that's 'cause you bought the wrong thing.

Ever purchase a small electronic accessory or something like a USB cable in those plastic clamshell packages? The ones that are IMPOSSIBLE to open without some sort of heavy duty metal cutters to cut the plastic.

Or how about a toy doll which has every limb tightly tied down to the back of the package box in three places with titanium twist ties. And the hair taped down in 6 places to keep it in place.

Upset that you spend $2000 and they use less than $20 worth of packaging? Try spending $20 and having to spend 20 minutes disassembling $18 worth of packaging.

Powermatic might not, but Mattel sure knows how to package an item ;)

:)

http://www.bloggingstocks.com/2006/12/04/wrap-rage-indestructible-packaging-endless-twisties-turn-nurse/

http://www.plasticsurgeonopener.com

http://plasticsurgeonopener.com/files/azrepub.pdf

Happy Woodworking!


http://plasticsurgeonopener.com/

Re: Unbelievable

#15

Re: All of them will be scrimping on packaging soo

Lee Brubaker

>Classic case of the effects of increasing shipping costs incurred by the price of oil/diesel fuel. I wonder how long Governments' are going to continue to allow irresponsible speculation on the commodity markets to threaten the country's economy ?

Lee

Re: Unbelievable

#16

Re: Unbelievable

Dwain - Lakeland FL

>Rob,

I agree with a lot of the points you made, and I myself am an industrial engineer for one of the largest freight companies in the world and resolving such issues have been one of my primary tasks in the past.

Also, like you I deduced that the damage was probably due to a reckless forlift driver. However, the quality point I made to Powermatic was more from a marking perspective.

As a packaging engineer you should be well aware of the point I was making: That presentation has everything to do with perception, and the perception one would get when they receive a tablesaw packaged in the manner I did is less than I'm willing to bet the CEO of Powermatic would want for it's customers, and aside from all this look at what has happened. Due to my experience I've ended up spreading the word on a woodworking blog site.

I'm willing to bet that the CEO of Powermatic would agree that the cost of proper packaging is not worth bad word of mouth testimonials.

Dwain

Re: Unbelievable

#17

Mark how do you know about opening a toy Doll?

Dustmaker Mike

>are you sure you are just a tool junky(-;

Father of three girls and 6 Grandkids I have opened many a doll box myself.

Re: Unbelievable

#18

Re: Pssssstt, Rob

Ralph Turney

>No Mark,

I just bothers me when environmentalists assume that everyone thinks like they do. You're welcome to believe any nonsense that you want, but just don't make blanket statements that assume that what you believe is universal and oh so correct. And just what is all this about gay marriage and Anti-Americanism? Hopefully, you're being tongue and cheek, but if not, you really need to be more open minded.

Ralph (wishing I was a landfill operator)

"Ralph might just be a landfill operator, and you would be threatening his rice bowl with your posit.

I spend time checking our marked plastics and binding up several kinds of paper which I then spend a gallon of gasoline to take to the recycling center each week, but there are people I've met who live near me who refuse any sort of recycling, put out 2 or 3 cans of garbage every Friday, and will go to some length to maintain that to do otherwise is Anti-American and also encourages gay marriage.

|;-}}}"

Re: Unbelievable

#19

Re: Pssssstt, Rob

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Ralph - I'm not an environmentalist. In fact, in my neighbourhood I'm considered the redneck. I've got a pair of SUV's, I usually have a nice (power) boat in the driveway, I use a gas weedeater and lawnmower, I burn wood for heat and I play with chainsaws in my front yard.

But I also participate in study/work/test groups to reduce electrical energy usage, I design building control systems every day for commercial and industrial facilities, designed to reduce energy consumption, and I'm active in LEED work towards the same goal. At home we make purchasing decisions partially based on the packaging of the product we're interested in, we work extremely hard to recycle as much as we can, we run a full-blown compost system for kitchen and yard waste, we collect rainwater for use in the gardens and take pride in producing 2 garbage can loads of waste every three weeks - not bad for an urban family of four. I even recycle my planer chips - every single one of them. You slot me wherever you want to..

My statement to the effect of not wanting to fill landfills is a pretty safe one. Regardless of your obtusely stated position, I highly doubt that you spend your life creating as much waste as you possible can. I think you were trying to make a point, and I get it.

As I said in my original post, packaging is a compromise and one of the three considerations in packaging design is the environment. I didn't make this up - it's a requirement set forth by the customers that I used to deal with. And I assume they didn't make it up as they're driven by profit, and environmental concern costs money. So I can only assume that they in turn were being driven by their customer base. This is not to say that environmental stewardship is paramount in the eyes of every customer. But it's obviously paramount in the majority of their customers else they'd not bother to bring it forward.

So while my "political" comment was taken as an afront by you and you chose to leapfrog from it into a polarized conversation where you're attempting to abdicate yourself from environmental responsibility with an argument conveniently predicated on political bent, I think it's fair to state that as a rule, western society wants to reduce solid waste. I don't think that qualifies as a political statement and it's a position I'm not going to retract nor apologize for.

Rob out.

Re: Unbelievable

#20

Re: Unbelievable

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Dwain - I do get it. I remember doing a packaging design that used a foam-in-place system (molded) for an industrial operators interface panel. In addition to providing better protection, the design saved approx $25/unit and at 4000 units/year, the total savings was impressive. The product manager refused the cost savings for the exact reasons you state. The look and feel of the packaging did not increase the perception of quality - and in fact decreased it.

I ended up doing a re-design that used a foam plank system that did an origami thing, and each flat plank was cut/shaped to unfold into an end cap (two needed per panel). It looked a LOT better, but only provided minimal protection and saved about $5/unit instead of the $25.

But the product manager was happy - and she was my customer. And yes - we had returns due to packaging mishaps and the company was willing to eat those costs.

....lesson learned.

Rob

Re: Unbelievable

#21

Oh, Ralph

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>My "pssssst" to Rob was, of course, semi-humorous on the issue of landfill operators and rice bowls.

However,

I have "neighbors" who are dead serious that "all this recycling crap is part of the liberal conspiracy of tree hugging spotted owl kissers who also support gay marriage." The couple I'm thinking of have Two [count'em](2) American flags waving on the front of their house, and one on their GM monster SUV along with an uncounted number of "I Support The Troops" ribbon stickers in a rainbow of colors coupled with a "I Only Buy American" bumper sticker.

So yes, that part of my post is quite straight up, even if a bit of a sideline. While these people may seem to some to be either out of place in both space and time or fugitives from some Central Casting department, they are N-S serious. And, I will point out, They're Not Alone.

I really don't think Rob was making a political statement, but rather echoing the general sentiment in his industry for companies to reduce their solid waste generation as much as possible, for both environmental" and economic reasons. Beyond things like The Golden Cocoon Award, manufacturers are getting increasing pressure from governmental enties, who have to deal with serious solid waste issues, to reduce unnecessary tonnage and use readily degradable materials.

Peace

Re: Unbelievable

#22

Lee Grindinger

Another view of landfills,

Lee Grindinger

>First, the Addy protocol..., I was on the board of directors of a solid waste refuse district, chairman of a countywide recycling program and sat on the executive board of a recycling co-op that served many counties in Montana and Idaho.

I came to learn a great deal about waste and recycling. Recycling is not always a great option but burdening the public with options is never a good idea because they are slow to respond and learn about this stuff. Hence recycling programs generally err on the side of dealing with too many commodities rather than too few. An example would be glass which is a nearly worthless commodity but very expensive to collect, handle and process because of it's weight. Glass's most practical use unless you live with 100 miles of a bottle manufacturing facility is to be pulverized for sand or crushed and used as landfill cover. Either option is expensive.

Some plastics are worth a great deal but they have to be sorted out at sorting facilities and contamination percentages kept below acceptable rates. Because plastics are so light, yet so bulky, the processes used prior to sorting are expensive. Still, it's worth it to recycle some plastics, but not all.

One incredibly encouraging thing I've come to realize is that landfills are chock full of latent energy. One day we'll figure out how to cleanly extract this latent energy and when that day comes all these materials we can't reasonably recycle now (like that plastic beer cup) will make landfills rich sources of materials we are storing there for a decade or more.

If you think of landfills as storage facilities rather than bury-it-forever-never-see-it-again facilities it drastically changes your view of things. Soon we will mine landfills much the way mining companies are reworking tailings because advancements in technology make it possible to extract useful commodities economically.

Lee

Re: Unbelievable

#23

Re: Another view of landfills,

Stuart Johnson

>Methane is already being harvested from landfills and used by some companies and utilities for generating power.

Re: Unbelievable

#24

That's the problem.....

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>We had our son first, and all the Tonka trucks and Lego boxes were easy. Then came our two daughters and baby dolls are everywhere.

And Barbies.... I thought they were expensive until "we" discovered American Girl Dolls� Yikes! ;)

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Unbelievable

#25

Interestimg thread..but...

John Cotten

>Being a full time cabinet maker I would have called Amazon, worked a compensated price break and repair paint for the saw. While I have ordered from Grizzly also, I have recieved damaged goods from them also (over zealous fork lift driver) Grizzly compensated the priced and send the repair parts for free. Took about 15 minuts of time to do it. I got the driver a cup of coffee and told him to relax for a few minutes.

Most packaging for industrial machinery is fairly light weight other than the fork lift skid blocks. The companies look at the size and weight of the products and critical parts as the primary issue. Cardboard is not really used to protect the machine from scratches, but more so from dirt, grime and other gunt from trucking. It also helps protect the protective coating from being rubbed off from the raw metal parts like the table top to help keep it from rusting.

If the cast iron was cracked or some other damage, I agree send it back. Bur for some paint scratches?

The thread is talking about the amount of waste generated by packaging to landfills and the enviroment; lets follow the rest of the stream of the return. Numerous clerks generated invoices, credit statements and memos, printouts, lots of electric use, lots of paper, lots of ink, etc... The driver filled out extra paperwork, wasted fuel not to mention the fuel expended by the dock workers and the fork lift drivers. the trucks sending the saw back to the warehouse...etc.etc.etc.

While I am the first to agree you deserve to get what you pay for. In my world what ever new comes into my shop will get scratched at some point. Repair paint isn't expensive and only takes a few minutes to apply. I probably would have made a phone call first to see how much off they are willing to give me.

Good luck on the new saw. Hope all works out well.