Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

OT/Long - When to replace heating/cooling system?

Posts

OT/Long - When to replace heating/cooling system?

#1

OT/Long - When to replace heating/cooling system?

Joe Pack

>We have a natural gas Armstrong furnace with a single speed blower rated at 91% efficiency combined with a Trane XE 900 heat pump rated at SEER 9. Both were installed in 1991, making them 17 years old. Neither has any known major problems, although the heat pump did require recharging about 8 years ago because of a leak in a line fitting.

The heat pump is set to provide home heating when the temperature is 40 degrees and above. The furnace takes over when the temperature falls below 40 degrees. The heat pump also provides cooling in the summer. We are located in north-central Ohio.

Our electricity cost is now 8 cents/kwh, but, based on our typical usage, will go to about 10 cents/kwh in September. I don't have the ccf price on natural gas at hand right now, but is "typical" for our part of Ohio.

Most things I read suggest that a system of this age is expensive to run compared to today's more efficient models. Our rural electric cooperative suggests that a SEER 16 heat pump unit would save 60% on cooling costs compared to a SEER 10 model and that a new heat pump would also save considerably on heating costs at 40 degrees and above (no specific heating cost savings numbers were estimated). A hvac contractor told me that even though my furnace was rated at 91% efficiency, the newer furnaces rated at 95% would actually save more than the obvious 4% because of their 2 stage design. The design supposedly saves fuel by heating more slowly, but more often, than having the full 80,000 BTU kick in at one time. (My words, not theirs, similar to saving gas going 0-60mph slowly instead of 'pedal to the metal' acceleration.) The full 80,000 BTU force kicks in only with extreme weather. The variable speed system also takes advantage of digital thermostats that may help save energy.

I can replace the SEER 9 heat pump with a SEER 15 without replacing my furnace. At least with Trane, I am told that to get the SEER 19 heat pump I would have to also replace my furnace with the complimentary 2 stage unit. Many pages I have read seem to back this up; the higher SEER ratings depend on installing a complete, paired system.

Do any of you have specific experience with this, either as a consumer or HVAC professional? I am not ready to run out and spend money this instant, but, with rising electricity and natural gas costs all but a certainty, I am looking down the road.

Thanks for any input.

Joe

Re: OT/Long - When to replace heating/cooling system?

#2

Re: OT/Long - When to replace heating/cooling syst

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

>HI Joe. I remember those Ohio winters, and I am glad that you are there to enjoy them. :-)

When we built back in 2002 I had a Water Furnace geo thermal system installed. It does both heating and cooling. With out looking it up, I think the SEER is around 22. On the heating side, the COP is in the area of 4.5. If you are thinking of replacing the HVAC system, I recommend the geo thermal route. The Water Furnace brand is the 1000 pound gorilla in that marketplace. As I recall, they are made in South Bend In.

Good Luck,

Ken

Re: OT/Long - When to replace heating/cooling system?

#3

Re: OT/Long - When to replace heating/cooling syst *LINK*

Jim Dillon

>Joe,

Having gone through this about four years ago, from what I remember, unless your electrical rates are REALLY high, a middle-of-the-road system gives the best payback, i.e. one within the normal life-expectancy of the equipment. IIRC, the Trane middle-of-the-line unit actually had a better COP value than the higher end units - which might be important in your climate. FWIW, in reading your post, I found nothing misleading in the info the vender provided you. There really has been significant changes in the efficiency of the equipment and how everything is designed to work together to give you more efficient cooling/heating and to save you money. I found the forum below to be a great source of info. Hope this helps.

Jim


HVAC Forum

Re: OT/Long - When to replace heating/cooling system?

#4

Re: OT/Long - When to replace heating/cooling syst

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>Since you don't have any problems, what is the payback time of the cost of new system vs the savings of the added efficiency?

Re: OT/Long - When to replace heating/cooling system?

#5

JL

Re: OT/Long - When to replace heating/cooling syst

JL

>We went through this about 2.5 years ago.

We replaced old (heat pump and air handling unit) with a new dual fuel heat pump and propane gas furnace.

It doesn't have as high of a SEER as the one you are thinking about (ours is ~15 SEER). The energy costs between the old system (heat pump only, supplemented by propane gas fireplace) and the new system are very different. We are warmer (and cooler) and heating more space (basement included) at a net savings of about ~$750 or so a year.

Re: OT/Long - When to replace heating/cooling system?

#6

Re: OT/Long - When to replace heating/cooling syst

Jim Dillon

>Bill,

IIRC, given our electric prices, I calculated a payback of around 13-15 years if I purchased a middle-grade Trane. It was considerably longer for the high-end Trane. Inasmuch as this was a completely new install, i.e. new ductwork etc., I really had nothing to strictly compare it to except the winter baseboard heating bill. Turns out our average monthly electric bill went down a bit, even with the addition of the AC component. Oh yes, my calculation was done based on just the equipment, not the charge for installing the ductwork. If I had included that, the payback would have been a thousand years give-or-take 8-). Hope this helps.

Jim

Re: OT/Long - When to replace heating/cooling system?

#7

Re: OT/Long - When to replace heating/cooling syst

Curly Smith

>As a general rule of foresight, an augury beats an oracle and an oracle beats a seer.

SEER is the acronym for Seasonal Energy Efficiency Rating and roughly translates to BTU's of cooling per watt of electricity, so the higher the SEER the lower the operating cost. Quite naturally one must consider whether a better SEER really justifies the sacrifice of more goats.

The annual operating cost of an AC unit is estimated by:

(BTU's * hours operated) / (SEER) * ($/kwhr) / (1000)

An AC Ton is equivalent to 12,000 BTU's per hour

So, if we assume a 3 Ton unit operating 2200 hours during the year (roughly 25% of the time), and an electrical cost of $0.08 per kwhr we can estimate cost savings between a SEER 9 and a SEER 15 unit as:

SEER 9 Op Cost: (3*12000 * 2200) / 9 * 0.08 / 1000 = $704

SEER 15 Op Cost: (3*12000 * 2200) / 15 * 0.08 / 1000 = $422

Cost Saving SEER 15 vs SEER 9 is then $704 - $422 = $282 per year (saving for a 4 Ton unit would be $375/yr)

Another way to estimate the savings is to take a mid-spring or mid-fall bill, when you use minimal heating and cooling, and multiply it by 12 to get a baseline electrical load (Note: use Kilowatts, not $). Then average your annual electrical usage over the past 2-3 years and subtract the baseline load to get the average heating/cooling load. Then factor in the %savings your HVAC rep mentioned and multiply the "saved" kilowatts by your rate to see how much money you're saving.

Since your unit is currently operational then my guess is that changing to a more energy efficient unit is probably not cost effective. However, replacement should be strongly considered if major repairs are ever needed.

FYI - A/C costs in the summer months can run 50-70% of your electrical bill. Each degree increase on your thermostat can save 5% - 8% with similar saving reflected by lowering the thermostat in winter.

Re: OT/Long - When to replace heating/cooling system?

#8

Re: OT/Long - When to replace heating/cooling syst

Larry in NW Ohio

>Do you have a web site for your Water furnace. Thank You Larry in Ohio

Re: OT/Long - When to replace heating/cooling system?

#9

We just replaced our heating system

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>We had a ground source heat pump that was about 25years old and working fine. We wanted to add A/C to the house. We bought a new Bryant 50K btu geothermal with 4 ton A/C heat pump. It was installed the end of June. We ran the A/C all the time since installation. We just received our first electric bill. Our useage for this period was exactly the same as the same period a year ago even though the average temperature was a little higher and we were running the A/C for 24/7 during most of the period. I attribute this to the fact that we weren't running all the ceiling and box fans we normally would and the dehumidifier in the basement was turned off because the A/C unit also handles that area.

Ours is a variable speed fan with two stage heating and two stage cooling. The fan runs on low all the time to keep the temperature more even through out the house, it shifts to a higher speed when the compressor runs. It has an EER rating of 22.5 and a COP of 4.7 at full load and EER of 28.7 and COP 5.1 at the first stage level.

Lee

Re: OT/Long - When to replace heating/cooling system?

#10

Heat pump payback calculator *LINK*

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>Here is a link to a heat pump payback calculator that I used to determine if the two stage unit would pay back the additional cost. Note if the link doesn't work do a google search for: energy useage and payback calculator - heat pump

The first entry should be an Excel spreadsheet with the calculator.


Pay Back Caclulator

Re: OT/Long - When to replace heating/cooling system?

#11

Re: OT/Long - When to replace heating/cooling syst *LINK*

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

>Sure do, Larry.

Glad to help,

Ken


Water Furnace Geo Thermal

Re: OT/Long - When to replace heating/cooling system?

#12

This is Great......

Barry Irby

>Curly has really nailed this. All the responses you have gotten are good, but you should read this one tow or three times.

What ever the increase in efficiency is, it can only save you a percentage of the heating and AC costs, nothing from the base usage.

As a Home Inspector, I have seen lots of people replace their equipment and get very little decrease on their bills.

Be skeptical and careful.

Also, give some thought to improving the efficiency of your house. Work on the demand side rather than the supply side. You might find you can install a few hundred dollars worth of insulation in your attic and a similar amount in your crawl space and help your bills about as much as new equipment. Even if you feel you must replace the equipment, you should really give the house a going over first, reducing the thermal demand and then buy new equipment that matches the new size. Its hard to convince Americans that bigger is not better, but in this case, bigger costs more to operate than correctly sized equipment. Buy properly sized stuff. If given a choice, buy it slightly under sized rather than way over sized.

After a house is fairly well insulated, the biggest heat loss is usually air leakage. Look at tightening up every air leak you can find. Put gaskets under cover plates, caulk around the Inside of your windows, improve weather stripping, and on and on.