OT Heating with Coal?
Sawman
>So anyone out there use a coal furnace? Mabe it is a multifuel-coal,wood,& gas?
Please tell me about it.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
OT Heating with Coal?
Sawman
>So anyone out there use a coal furnace? Mabe it is a multifuel-coal,wood,& gas?
Please tell me about it.
Re: OT Heating with Coal?
Virgil Johnson, Versailles KY
>My parents have heated with coal since 1948. Its a nasty substance...beware...coal soot on the roof and everything else. Maybe there are better stoves now than I remember.Yuck.
You just gave AlGore a stroke !
steve mackay
>
Re: OT Heating with Coal?
Randy Johnson Connersville IN
>I've done a lot of electrical work in houses that were once heated with coal. You are right, the soot goes everywhere. After a few hours in the attic I always looked like I'd been mineing coal.
Re: OT Heating with Coal?
Glenn Madsen in the SF Bay Area
>We had a Franklin stove, some 25 years ago, when we lived in Utah, and we were in graduate school. We burned, as supplemental heat, coal from Carbon County, and pitch pine, from the Uinta National Forest. It was messy, mostly from the fine soot, and smelled funny to a California boy, who had grown up burning Valley Oak in the fireplace.
I doubt it was efficient, and that stove only really warmed the living room and kitchen, and I got more value out of splitting wood than burning it. But it was a nice thing to have going.
Now, we live back in California, have a fireplace with a gas log, and light it maybe every other year... The house is much better insulated, better windows, etc., and here, we have no snow, and very little coal.
And when the air smells funny, it's because there's a wild fire somewhere out of control.
AAH! Peace at last!!!
Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla
>
I may rush out and buy a coal stove....
Virgil Johnson, Versailles KY
>
Gag!
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>My neighbor that lives a 1/2 mile away has a coal stove. He burns local soft coal and the smell gags me even at this distance when I am down wind. If he was closer I would consider plugging his chimney.
I was thinking the same thing(-;
Dustmaker Mike
>
Re: OT Heating with Coal?
Dave Paine
>I may be out on a limb, but I have been using coal to heat my house for a long time. My latest furnace is a "stoker stove" which burns rice coal. I am in Eastern PA and so we have local anthracite coal available.
I use 2.5 - 3 tons of coal for the entire season.
We have some dust in the house, but rarely smell the stove burning outside. Exceptions are no wind and damp weather.
The stove is rated as 60,000 BTU. So far even in , 0 deg F days, this stove is able to keep the house warm.
We also have a heat pump for summer air conditioning and heat in the early spring and late fall months.
Compared to the heat pump, we really like the warm air from the stoker stove.
Re: OT Heating with Coal?
mdclor
>Dave, I agree with you that anthracite is virtually odorless. We burned coal for 18 years and I really liked the fact that the house was always warm, even when the blower wasn't running. There is a lot of fly ash however. I have seen wood burning furnaces that are like a small shed outside the house with the air lines to and from the house buried under the lawn. I don't know if they have this for coal or not. I definitely prefer coal to oil. We now have propane with in floor radiant heat and that is the best from a comfort perspective, not sure about cost yet.
Re: OT Heating with Coal?
Galen Vetterick
>http://www.vermontcastings.com/content/products/productdetails.cfm?id=238
I had a Vermont stove that burned wood in my family room and used as supplimental heat, since rural power was not real consistant in my Iowa location. My neighbor had this little stove that burns coal. Think my wood stove was more work and dirtier than his coal unit.
Re: OT Heating with Coal?
Robin Corell in Atascadero CA
>The nastiest byproduct of burning coal is that it releases a fair amount of radiation.
Re: Outdoor furnace
Kneale Brownson dreaming of snow in N. MI
>Those usually are hydronic systems. The wood/coal or other combustable heats water which goes to either an air heat exchanger in the house or a radiator/radiant floor heating system. So the lines under ground carry fluid, not air.
Ask Bill Grumbine
Dan Donaldson
>He has been using one for a couple of years now.
Re: Gag!
Lee Schierer - McKean, PA
>I have the same concern from the local wood burner outdoor furnaces near us when we get still cold temperatures in the winter. I'm at the bottom of the hill and the smoke can be choking strong outside on cold mornings when the wind isn't blowing. If the dog goes out, you can smell the wood smoke in his fur when he comes back in.
Lee
P.S. I heat with well water!
He's Got To Take His Lumps
George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA
>like everybody else, Steve!
George
Re: OT Heating with Coal?
Charley
>Back in the 70's when oil and gasoline was a bit hard to get and becoming more and more expensive I was heating with oil, but bought a Belgian coal stove after watching neighbors messing with wood stoves, chopping wood, and having chimney fires. The Belgian stove was made by Surdiac and I connected it in the living room fireplace. It was hopper fed from an internal hopper above the fire, thermostatically controlled, and very clean. It was even relatively pretty, for a stove, with a painted sheet metal cover, a cast iron grate on the top, and a window in the front. It supplied 90% of our heating needs (1800 sq ft house)from about 2 1/2 tons of "pea" size anthracite coal per year and I would still be heating with it if I still lived in New York state. In the early 80's I moved to North Carolina and couldn't find a source of anthracite here, so I left it with the buyer of my New York home. He has been using it most winters ever since. It was very clean (relative to wood stoves) and like another poster said, you can only smell it outside on damp wet days when the wind is right. Fly ash was almost non existant. I had to dump 2 ash tins once every 2 days and add 2 buckets of coal through a trap door in the top and shake down the ashes every morning and evening during the coldest weather (less during warmer days) and it did a beautiful job of keeping my house warm.
Re: OT Heating with Coal?
Louie Lovas
>I live in New Hampshire - winters are long and cold. The latest rage is wood pellet stoves - http://www.woodpelletstoves.net. They are like regular wood burning stoves except they burn these small tiny compressed pellets. The pellets are made from sawdust and other by-products and scrap materials. These stoves are in such demand all over the Northeast they are back-ordered at most places even now - in the heat of the August sun.
Why not, that's what they use in China and
Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI
>nobody complains do they? Oh, right, the Olympic athletes are whining about bad air or something. Maybe that Gore guy is right.
Re: Gag!
Charlie Self
>Bill,
When I was a kid, we burned coal for heat. I remember having to bank the fires in the furnace every night before loosely scattering a small shovel of pea coal on the glowing embers already there. Shake it down in the a.m., toss on a small shovelful again, and within minutes it was throwing good amounts of heat.
But that was a furnace, not a stove, and had thick cast iron and asbestos construction. We also used Pennsylvania pea coal, a hard coal that doesn't stink anything like the soft coal found in most regions.
Of course, we probably wouldn't have noticed any smell, as probably 95% of our neighbors still used coal heat. Buy it a ton at a time, have it poured from 100 pound canvas and leather bags toted up the stairs by the driver, or down a chute, into the coal bin.
Long time ago. Propane and a heat pump are a lot easier, if a lot more costly. IIRC, hard coal at that time (circa 1949-50) was about nine bucks a ton. It had recently risen from about $8.50, and I recall Mom bitching about it. She was almost as upset as I was when I moved to Wisconsin in Fall of '72 and discovered fuel had was up to 16.2 cents per gallon.