Maybe bargains
Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn
>
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Maybe bargains
Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn
>
A sad, sad, sad, sad story
Lee Grindinger
>When we lived in upstate NY, around Woodstock, a high school nearby was doing away with it's wood shop program due to budget issues. They hosted a sealed bid auction to rid themselves of all the equipment. I bid $101.00 on a Delta Milwaukee (does this date it for you?) lathe and won. At first elated that I got this workhorse so cheaply my joy turned to sadness once it was set up in my shop. This lathe, you see, should have been in the service of high school kids beating the crap out of it as they experienced the pleasure woodworking can provide. I used that lathe for years and without exception every time I put it to use I thought that my shop is not where this tool belongs. I passed this lathe onto an aspiring woodworker when I retired from furniture making but I would have gladly donated it to a high school program had any been interested.
Lee
P.S. I hope this sale you brought to light does not mark the end of a similar program.
Sign of the Times
Nat Robison
>I'm not terribly old (38) but I remember, somewhat fondly, spending time in "Industrial Arts" class in middle school.....making can openers, door stops, perpetual calendars, etc. Now, the non-core classes basically focus on web design and CAD.....more engineering-type pursuits (not that carpentry doesn't involve engineering). The middle school near me has a lot of Delta/Rockwell machinery that I don't think gets used at all. While it would be better for those machines to get used in school, I'd love to pick up a 3 hp cabinet saw for a few hundred dollars.
As with most lessons or skills in life, they're not usually learned in school. I think that carpentry (and all those skills that become really useful once you buy your first house) will continue to fade from the schools. Besides, I'm not sure I'd want to oversee some kid who plays 3 hours of video games each day with a 6-second attention span use a table saw, drill press, jointer, etc.
Re: Sign of the Times
Glenn Madsen in the SF Bay Area
>In our area, the challenge is finding teachers for the classes.
Anyone who's good is making 150% of what the districts can pay, without the joy of dealing with middle school kids. And the ones that aren't good are still better off working in the community. To find an excellent craftsperson who has put up with the crap that goes into getting a teaching credential is really unusual.
It takes a pretty special person to teach middle school under any circumstances. Even more if they have to keep things together in a shop program.
Re: Sign of the Times
Lee Brubaker
>What actually started the demise of high school workshop courses ie: woodworking, automotive, & metal working was the insurance liability rates. With the propensity of people to sue these days for rediculous amounts, insurance rates became unaffordable for many school districts hence the shop courses are no more.
Lee
Re: Maybe bargains
Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.
>Maybe they just want to convert to all handtools....
Greening of America.
Save energy
Marv
On the brighter side...
John E in SC
>There are still places where kids who don't grow up in a "mechanically inclined" household can get that type of exposure, and one I recommend whole-heartedly is cub scouts / boy scouts. I recently spent several Monday nights with a bunch of 9 year old cub scouts down in my basement shop using hand tools to make different things, and they had a blast. (Honestly, so did I!) Almost every level of scouting involves some type of craft projects, whether wood, leather, metal, etc. No, you don't get those things in school anymore. Just makes me try harder to make sure my own kids get comfortable with tools. But I just wanted to mention for those who don't know that scouting is another avenue to consider.
John
Re: Sign of the Times
Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn
>The school district in question pays teachers an average of around $89,000 plus benefits for nine month's "work", and my tax bill reflects it.
Clint
Agree - insurance premiums
M. McNamee
>I have the 67 Delta Jointer I used in Jr. High shop class. The school shut down the Jr. High shop for lack of interest and wanted the iron to disappear. It was salvaged by a smart person and given to me. The Sr. High shop was also going to be shut down due to lack of interest. However a football player ran his hand over the jointer head. All disposals came to a halt as the lawyers swooped in.
Since one teacher (he was not a woodworker) was running all the shop type classes, this accident was inevitable. He was not a trained in woodworking his machine maintenance on the safety equipment was poor (as told to me by the a reliable source) and inexperience instructing the students contributed to the accident. The lawyers are drooling over this one.
Before the accident he was quietly taking the woodshop iron for recycling. The description of the disposed of iron for scrap $ would break your heart. And he took all the wood home acknowledging he had no idea what he would use it for.
Re: Maybe bargains
Fred Davis
>The shop program at Abilene High school produces fair projects in furniture and the Carpentry class builds a three bedroom /two bath house every year that is auctioned off in August.
The county high school in Chapman does the identical same thing every year.
When I went through Abilene High, I majored in Industrial Arts, now they don't call out Majors and the discipline in the shop classes is like this.
When I asked the new Shop Teacher (second year out of college) and on his first job how come the kids were being allowed to destroy equipment?
For instance you can't tell a chisel from a screwdriver and all in the same wall cabinet.
He said... when he sent the offenders to the office , they were sent back with a note saying they had no other place for them .
This particular problem is reflected in many schools and has nothing to do with insurance issues.
The teachers and the school board to a man , say it started with the "No Child Left Behind " program started by you know who.
FredD
Re: Sign of the Times
Chuck in ND
>Insurance liability might have something to do with it, or it's a convieniant excuse the boss wants to tell you when you ask for a raise, but, there is also less demand for skilled labor in this country. There isn't much incentive to get into the trades, especially if you have to work for someone else.
Re: Maybe bargains
Chuck in ND
>Alot of those bargains are probably 3 phase and not such a great deal after you buy a single phase motor.