>I've always been puzzled by this kind of question, too, though I changed Unisaw bearings more than once and somehow muddled through without heating anything. My take is that what you really want to do is eliminate the interference fit between bearing and shaft at room temperature. If you heat the bearing, it seems to me you have a couple possible snakes in the grass to watch out for:
If the bearing has seals or lube that can be damaged by heat, you could ruin them.
If you heat just the inner race of the bearings, you will expand the metal. I don't know where that expansion occurs. It seems as though it would first take up any slop in the ball bearing race first and then have to deform inward. Metal doesn't like to be compressed.
So, my take would be to try shrinking the shaft first, using some source of cold air (dry ice?). That way, the ID of the bearing doesn't have to change.
>I've always found that finding/using a tube or bushing of some sort that just fits the over the shaft and touches the INNER part (not the middle or outer edge) of the bearing, and then a mallet or hammer, works well. When I can't find a tube of proper size I can make something with a scrap of maple and a fostner bit.
>Rather than heating the bearing which will probably damage it. Try cooling the shaft. Most areas have dry ice available for a modest cost. Pack the dry ice around the shaft to shrink it. Then quickly install the bearing. Be ready with a proper sized piece of pipe in case the bearing needs tapped into place. I can not stress too much to have everything ready before you try and install the bearing.
>Keep in mind that most of these parts are engineered to be replaced by a mechanic whose tool assortment does not include a tempering oven or similar temperature-controlled environments, just a hammer. Unless the shop manual calls for heating the bearing or housing, you can probably drive it on and off with a hammer. As Mark has mentioned, when driving ball and roller bearings, your driving force should ALWAYS be against the part of the bearing that's rubbing against the part you're driving it into/over. Otherwise, you can wreck the bearing. Brass or maple is best (if the bearing is not sealed - unlikely - wood's not a real good idea). Tap around the race - that is, not all the driving on one side. Check out the shaft first, make sure there's no burrs left from the removal of the old one, no rust, etc. You can get emery cloth and crocus cloth (really, really fine emery cloth) at decent hardware stores and auto parts stores; use this to get the shaft as shiny as you can before you start installing the bearing. Hammer weight matters; a relatively heavy hammer, used judiciously, will drive a bearing where a lighter one, used heavily, makes no movement.
The kind of interference fit you're describing, where one part is at a radically different temp than the other, is very, very rare in my experience with consumer-grade equipment. If you do find that's the case (maybe snowblowers differ because they're used at low temperatures), then I agree with Ellis: cool the shaft, don't heat the bearing. Dry ice isn't too hard to come by in most areas, and a few hours in that will make the shaft a lot smaller; watch your hands - it'll be COLD, kind of like a warm February day in Duluth.
Bill, 40 years of repairing cars and machines with limited tools...thinking of the January day I spent replacing the fuel pump in a 1962 VW bus on top of a freeway overpass in Michigan...I was a shrink fit for the wrenches...took me an hour to defrost...so glad I'm no longer running clapped-out cars...
>Where I used to work, we built precision indexing machinery. It was routine to heat the bearings so they would fit tightly on shafts. We used an oven that heated them to about 250-300 degrees. That much heat will not damage an open bearing like a tapered roller bearing. If the bearing has plastic shields or rubber seals it is generally not advisable to heat them. Slight burrs, bumps and even slight misalignment will prevent a new bearing from slipping on a shaft or into an opening.
If you heat the bearing to get it on it will also be hard to get it off in the future. Bearing cups can be removed easily if you have an arc welder by welding beads a inch or so long on the bearing surface at several points around the inner surface of the bearing. I've seen bearings that defied pressing and pounding to get them out drop out of the housing after this procedure.
Note: It is nearly impossible to heat the bearing and keep the shaft cool enough at the same time to get a bearing to slip off.
>In the old days of Fixed grip chairlifts we routinely (ok every couple of years) installed gearbox bearings by heating them in oil. A five gallon bucket, a rosebud torch and a candy thermometor. Heat the oil to 325, pull the bearing out and very quickly slip it on the shaft. You only get one chance. The temp my vary for differnt sizes, the expert told us how hot to get the oil, I just the flunky with the torch. I have heard of heating small bearings with a lightbulb but don't know the details. It might be tougher with small bearing, not much mass to hold heat, if the bearing cools off half way on you are.... in a world of hurt
>You shouldn't need to do any heating at all. Small bearings in a snow blower should be easily pressed on/off with a bench vice or small press. Heat is used with larger bearings. If you don't have them, use a hammer and piece of pipe or socket to press directly 1) on the inner race while pressing on to a shaft, or 2) press on the outer race when pressing into a hole.
Just remember to:
1) Make sure hole or shaft is smooth & clean, and lightly oiled.
2) Make sure to drive the bearing squarely, and not start to drive at an angle. This mucks up the shaft/hole, and may not allow you to get the bearing properly alligned.
3) Insure the new bearing is exactly like the old bearing (thus, if the old one came off, the new one will go on without any danger to the bearing).
4) Never press/drive on the wrong race or seal. You will damage the balls/race/seal. Damage will be immediate, or may result in a shorter life of the bearing.
>As others have mentioned, it is unlikely that you HAVE to heat the bearing to get it onto the shaft. Heating the bearing opens you up to some potential problems. Most likely you will get the bearing partialy set and then it will get stuck.
While a college student I worked summers at an electric motor repair shop. Mucho HP down to small drill motors. Ball bearings were almost always removed and replaced without heat, a hydraulic press was used for all but the smallest bearings. Pressing the bearing on is the best way to go in my opinion. Most of us don't have a hydraulic press so options are to take the parts to an automotive/machine shop or an electric motor repair shop and see if they will press the bearing on the shaft or, If you are totaly independent (as I am :), you can sometimes "press" the bearing on a shaft using a pipe clamp (or two) and a hollow pipe. This does require the hollow tube/pipe of some sort to rest on the inner race of the bearing and extend past the end of the shaft receiving he bearing. If nothing interferes with positioning the pipe clamp and the bearing fit is not too, too, tight, you can place the pipe clamp over the shaft with tube in place, square up the bearing and start to squeeze with the clamp. You are sort of making a small "mechanical press". I have had to "back up" the stationary jaw of the pipe clamp with vise-grips on the pipe to keep it from sliding backwards. The pressing action gives you a bit better control for getting the bearing started square and minimizes the chance of damage to the bearing. Last option is to use the tube and pound the bearing home as was mentioned. Sounds a bit kludgey (sp) I know but the pipe clamp can work rather well.
>Did you find that a snow chaser lodged between the bottom of the dash and the throttle made a good "cruise control"?
In the winter I used to drive my '67 all over southern Michigan with the "cruise control" on and a blanket wrapped around my shoulders while hunched over the steering wheel peeking through the 6x6 inch spot that the defroster could clear. Oh them were the good old days...
>Regarding suitable sized pipes, I have been taking bearings off of shafts for some time now using a hammer (sometimes a press) and deep sockets of the appropriate size. Sure beats looking all over the place for the correct sized piece of pipe. If I beat up a socket to bad I just pitch it and make a note to self to find a replacement at the pawn shop in the area.