Shop air filters
Dan MItchell
>Anyone have any thoughts/opinions/recommendations concerning shop air filters?
TIA
Dan
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Shop air filters
Dan MItchell
>Anyone have any thoughts/opinions/recommendations concerning shop air filters?
TIA
Dan
Re: Shop air filters
teflon_jones
>How big is your shop? How many tools do you want to be able to vacuum at once?
In general, any of the Delta, Jet, or similar filters that you can get off eBay for $150-200 will do a great job in most home shops.
Re: Shop air filters
Dan MItchell
>Thanks for the reply. To be clear, I'm thinking of air cleaners, not a dust collector (have a 2hp 1 micron bag Penn State DC right now).
Shop is a 2.5 car garage, about 600 sq' in total w/~9' ceiling, though a car is there also. Currently have a TS, jointer, planer, CSMS, drill press, assorted power tools.
Door open Box Fan
Dustmaker Mike
>Dan when I had a garage shop I ran with the door open and a box fan to suck the saw dust out. If it is unheated space this works great and the cost is pretty cheap. I hung the fan from the bottom of the door when it was open to keep it up high enough. If you have a window in the shop you could also use that with the box fan and then just a simple furnace filter taped to the back to catch the big pieces of dust. I now have the Delta Triangle looking one in my basement shop and it does a good job of keeping the dust down. I got it at the Blue Borg on clearance about a year ago.
Re: Shop air filters
Jim Dillon
>Dan,
I don't have any experience with the standard brands as I built my own and placed it over where I do my sanding. The standard brands seem much alike, but there was a thread in the past six months or so that said IIRC the newer Powermatic unit had several speeds, which I would find useful. I would shop based on price, shipping costs, availability etc. etc. It is amazing how much fine dust they pick up. The ideal solution for sanding (especially hand sanding) would be to have a down-draft unit, but I didn't have the room for such a beast. Good luck.
Jim
Re: Shop air filters
Tony - Memphis
>I've been using a JDS 750 for several years and have been very happy with it. My shop is 16'x20' with 10' ceilings. It seems to get rid of a lot of the airborn dust. I use a DC too. I still wear a mask though.
I was cleaning and resuing the pleated first stage filters, but got tired of buying them, so I bought a washable filter (took advantage of a Woodcraft sale) last fall. So far, it seems to work well. It gets real dirty anyway!
Tony
Re: Shop air filters
Robin Corell in Atascadero CA
>I too built my own. I built mine over 10 years ago, before they were in all the catalogs. I probably didn't save more than $50 by the time I bought time I bought all the materials.
One of the biggest advantages is that in the winter the filter pushes the warm air around and keeps the shop warmer. This is a disadvantage in the summer and for this reason alone a unit with multiple speeds would be plus.
Robin
Great For The Long Haul
George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA
>Good Afternoon Dan,
The most effective way to get rid of dust is the Dustmaker Mike solution. I have a JDS Air Filter, as well as a 2hp DC in a small shop. When I am milling, I generate lots of dust in a short time, easily overwhelming filtration and collectors. An exhaust fan evacuates dust-laden air. I also use a mask when I mill. The beauty of the air filter is that it removes most of the smaller particles which would precipitate onto shop surfaces/floor/tools once the day is done and lights are out. Most times, I am not milling and the in-shop equipment works well. But I like and use a exhaust fan.
George
Re: Shop air filters
JL
>An area your size might take two air cleaners. Put them both on the perimeter of the shop (say ~3' out from the wall) and have them on opposite sides of the garage with one facing the garage doors and the other facing the opposite way. That way you get lots of air circulation and don't have too much dust everywhere.
Just a thought...
Re: Shop air filters
Chuck in ND
>I have a Delta 50-875 3-Speed Air Filtration System with Remote in a shop thats 20' X 22'. Seems to work pretty good. In the winter up here I don't have the option of opening doors and windows, it gets too cold. I also had a Grizzly G1029, 2hp dust collector but am in the process of geting a Penn State Industries Tempest 142, 2 hp cyclone. I allways try to use a dust mask also, it's next to impossible to get every particle of dust with a DC and air unit.
Re: Shop air filters
Jim Dillon
>Robin,
I agree. In the end I probably didn't save much (if anything) but at the time (10 years ago) I think only the JDS unit was available. I also made the mistake of getting a 4-speed blower motor which cost a LOT more. In actual use, I only run it on high or low. I took the two filter approach: the normal blue furnace for gross stuff and a 3M Filtrete filter for the fine stuff. Boy, that Filtrete filter really catches stuff. It was a fun project even if I didn't save money.
Jim
Re: Shop air filters *LINK*
Dan MItchell
>Thanks for the replies. I'm leaning towards the Grizzly G9956. 5 speeds, timer, 1/3hp, 1 micron, said to move 1400 CFM. $299. The brute weighs 79#'s. Seems like a lot of machine for the $$$. Wish I could find a comparison review, I'm on FWW online, these machines seem like something they'd test, but I can't find them on there.