Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

"puckered" rail and stile doors

Posts

"puckered" rail and stile doors

#1

"puckered" rail and stile doors

Bill- Evansville, IN

>Thanks to those that responded to my "non-flush" doors questions...they straightened out when I mounted the face-fram. I have a new question about making rail and stile doors w/ a rail and stile bit set. Everything looks good when I dry-fit the doors, but when I glue them up they come out "puckered". If I'm looking at the door end-on. The stiles are bowed up. I'm using the cabinet-master clamps, I know these toe-in a bit. So I made a "caul" with a point on it to try to mitigate this. Still no success. Does anybody have any advice? Am I making some common rookie mistake?

Thanks in advance,

Bill


img

Re: "puckered" rail and stile doors

#2

Re: "puckered" rail and stile doors

Pete in Holland, MI

>1) Do your parts dry fit together (clamped) proper?

2) Are your cutters cutting to full depth, not leaving one one part of the grooved piece with a slightly shorter leg? Have done this before.

3) If the parts dry fit together well, claps with non-parallel jaws, either loose, or under load, will flex the parts into the arc that you describe, thus dry that way.

When gluing up my doors, I lay a staight edge on them to insure they are flat. If now, I also clamp them to the pipes on my pipe clamps to keep this heaving from happening.

Good luck !

Re: "puckered" rail and stile doors

#3

Re: "puckered" rail and stile doors

Dick Coers

>It might be as simple as you over tightening the clamps. It should only take a snug up on the clamps to draw the joint tight. I've never had any cutters that fit up too tight.

Are you taking the proper cut with the router bits? You set the fence by putting a straight edge against the bearing, and then bringing up the fence so the face of the fence is flush with the bearing.

Re: "puckered" rail and stile doors

#4

Re: "puckered" rail and stile doors

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>It sounds as if you are laying your parts on the bars of the clamps and then tightening them. Try laying the parts on some scraps and then clamping with the bars in the same plane as the panel.

Robin

Re: "puckered" rail and stile doors

#5

Ellis Walentine

Flat glue-ups

Ellis Walentine

>If all the shoulders close up nicely without glue, they should do so again when you glue and clamp the doors. I don't know what kind of cauls you used, but it sounds like your clamps or clamping technique might be at fault here. If your clamps "toe in" as you suggest, that could be part of the problem, as the clamping pressure exerts what amounts to a twisting force when it pulls the edges of your stiles or cauls flush to the clamp jaws. This shouldn't be much of a problem unless the pads are really out of square to the bars.

One way to center the clamping force on the edges is to use dowels as cauls. They need to be the same diameter as the thickness of the stiles. Another way is to set the glued-up door on waxed sticks and clamp the joints with the clamps laid flat on the bench or assembly table, coming in from the ends of the door instead of from one side or the other.

Let us know if any of these suggestions works.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: "puckered" rail and stile doors

#6

It's your clamping

Rick Christopherson

>Way back when I was with AW magazine I had a photo shoot at my workshop and specifically had our photographer snap an off-task photo of exactly what you are seeing. The photo never did make it into a shop-tip, but it was a topic that I had planned on covering at some point. It is a common problem that many woodworkers associate with bowing clamp bars/pipes, but is actually the opposite direction, and is the result of the clamp heads torquing when tightened.

After tightening your clamps, you MUST drive the stile down tight to the bar of the clamp, even if the bar is bowed due to clamping pressure. You will see daylight between the bar and the stile, just like your drawing shows. This is caused by the clamp heads lifting the stile as they are tightened.

I want to reiterate that it does not matter if the clamp bars are bowed upward. Your frame will come out of the clamps with an opposite bow if you do not drive them down to the bars. My rule of thumb was to inspect every door in the clamps to ensure that there was no daylight between the bar/pipe and the rail.

Re: "puckered" rail and stile doors

#7

Re: "puckered" rail and stile doors

Dale Warder

>I agree, its the clamping. In the good old days the conventional wisdom when using bar clamps or pipe clamps was to balance the clamping force by applying equal clamping, number of clamps, to both sides of a panel or frame during glue up. This prevents the clamps from distorting the glue up by applying pressure to only one edge. This practice has been disregarded since the introduction of the new parallel jaw clamps, but if the clamps are bent slightly or not truely parallel under pressure the problem peresists. My solution, apply clamps from both sides.

Dale in SC

Re: "puckered" rail and stile doors

#8

Re: "puckered" rail and stile doors

Jim Dillon

>Bill,

Not a "rookie" question at all, since sometimes there is a lot going on during a complex glue-up and it is easy to simply forget to check for flatness of the work piece against the clamps. After making your same mistake on a small cabinet door, I now try to remember to do the following:

1. Work on a flat reasonably flat surface;

2. Apply enough clamp pressure to bring the corner joints together, then maybe back off a little; judgement will be needed here - and most importantly;

3. Check under the workpiece to make sure that the it is still flat against the clamps.

If you need to release a clamp to wipe excess glue away, be sure to reclamp the workpiece flat to the clamps.

Hope this helps.

Jim

Re: "puckered" rail and stile doors

#9

Re: "puckered" rail and stile doors

Bill H - Evansville, IN

>Wow, thanks for all the great advice. Sounds like it is definitely the clamping. I think I set the fence correctly, I did use a straight edge and got everything lined up nicely. Also, the doors fit well when I dry-fit them. I do have a tendency to "take full advantage" of all the clamping pressure of the clamps. I'll take greater care in clamping up the next set and post my results.

Thanks for all the help!!!

Bill