Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

OT Question for Tree guys

Posts

OT Question for Tree guys

#1

OT Question for Tree guys

Barry Irby

>There are several tree guys here and I need some help. I have a Redbud "Forest Pansy", the one with the burgundy leaves. I got it back when they were "collector" trees and have grown it to the point it is huge by Redbud standards. Probably twenty five feet tall and wide with about an eight inch trunk. Yesterday I was removing dead limbs and found a significant split up in the middle of the tree. A major upright leader spit about eight inches vertically and four inches wide. Apparently it has been spilt a while and I have not noticed. The tree is brittle and prone to split and It has lost a couple of limbs to ice storms and heavy rain in the past.

The question is, is there a good repair? If I put a cable or chain around it, that will girdle the limbs. I was thinking a rope or something above the fork and replace it and move it maybe once a year. But what about a bolt or rod through the limbs above the fork to take the strain and not allow it to split further? If so, what metal would you make the rod out of? Any suggestions would be appreciated. Would you fill the split? With what?

Re: OT Question for Tree guys

#2

Re: OT Question for Tree guys

Kneale Brownson Dreaming of the Snow in N. MI

>Sounds like there's a reason those "trees" usually don't grow beyond bush size.

Anyway, I've seen several trees survive the kind of injury you describe by having the rod-with-large-washers type of repair. There's one that was in my parents' back yard fixed like that in the 1950s that stood past the time they sold the house in the 1970s. It had about 12-inch stems above the split and was held together with a rod that must have been at least an inch thick. The plates on each side probably had a five-inch diameter. I've seen similar fixes using one-inch ID water pipe.

They usually fill/cover the split with one of those tar-like substances, I believe.

Re: OT Question for Tree guys

#3

Re: OT Question for Tree guys

Pete in Holland, MI

>Threaded rods do work. Large washers on the outer sides to spread the force. Tighten up the nuts to put some tension on the forks of the tree so they will sway as a unit, and not independantly, else the rod will wear into the tree. Make sure to peen the rod, or double nut the rod to keep the nuts in place. Skip using lock washers.

Have also been told that tree tars do more damage than good. Let the tree heal naturally.

Re: OT Question for Tree guys

#4

Re: OT Question for Tree guys

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>metal rods in a tree are never a good idea. A rod and bolts may fix the problem. it may even recover compleately and grow for many decades. and this is where the problem with bolts lies. No one ever removes a bolt so what happens is that eventualy the tree grows around the bolt and it is forgoten. Eventualy the tree will come down and the bolt is going to become a hazzard. at best it will dull a chain on a saw, but it also has the potential to cause a kick back and cause an injury.

The split will always be a weak point if you try to fix it. The tree will heal itself and that will be stronger than any fix you would do. if the way it heals is to shed the limb than that is the strongest way for it to heal. If it ultimatyely causes the tree to die then that to is the best way for the tree to heal as it will make room for another tree.

If you chose to cut off the limb it is best to leave a couple of inches rather than cut it flush.

Robin

Re: OT Question for Tree guys

#5

Dale Lenz

Re: As a forester...

Dale Lenz

>and some urban tree adviser; listen to Pete, he gives good advice.

Re: OT Question for Tree guys

#6

Re: OT Question for Tree guys

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Barry,

We had a shady maple tree outside my boyhood home. One of the lower, larger branches split close to the trunk following a lightning strike. The branch drooped significantly, and my mother wanted me to saw it off, which would have spoiled the eye appeal. I used threaded stock and fender washers along the length of the split and drew the split together. That was over 50 years ago. The tree survived and flourished. I saw it last week and my repair is doing fine somewhere underneath a big burl.

George

Re: OT Question for Tree guys

#7

Dale Lenz

Re: Col...

Dale Lenz

>that's interesting that a burl formed at the spot of the tree's injury. Wonder if you cut the burl open you would find metal-flake grain, : ' >. You could call it Col.-fleck as the discoverer, : ' >. Seriously, maybe someday WE will learn how to grow burls, thanks for adding to the post.

Re: OT Question for Tree guys

#8

Re: Col...

John K Jordan

>It might not be a true burl with the figure we expect, but just a rounded over growth that looks like a burl. Some trees cover broken off stubs of limbs that way.

JKJ

Re: OT Question for Tree guys

#9

Re: OT Question for Tree guys

John Veerkamp, Western Mo.

>Pete's advice is good. Use stainless steel washers if you don't want the rust to stain the trunk below the fix. I've seen similar fixes using cable if the limbs need bracing higher up than a threaded rod is practical. On the wound , do not use tar or other such compounds as this will harbor insects and decay. For the first few years use a general purpose insecticide to discourage opportunistic insects. After the wound heals over this won't be needed.

John