Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

OT Home Inspector ethics question? long

Posts

Re: OT Home Inspector ethics question? long

#26

Home inspectors in NJ

wilbur

>I could be way off on this, but when we bought our old house here in NJ 4 years ago, our home inspector told us up front that he was limited to things that he could see. He was not allowed to remove panels, or cut holes in floors, walls, or ceilings to see what was going on behind the sheetrock. So if our house had had a shoddy repair like this, but was covered from the top by the floor and from the bottom by a finished ceiling in the basement, there would have been no way for the home inspector to identify such a flaw. He would have put into his report that he was not able to inspect that part of the floor.

At the time, being first time home buyers, my wife and I were attracted to the fact that the seller worked for Lowes, and that they had made a lot of cosmetic improvements to the house, so it was in "move in" condition. Since then I've learned more about what really makes a good house. It's all the infrastructure that doesn't necessarily show: electricals, plumbing, heating, framework, insulation. It's easy to paint a room. It's much harder to get the electricals into shape if the wiring job wasn't the best to start with.

Or, as our electrician put it, "I don't see why they fixed all the superficial things if they weren't going to fix the stuff that could burn the house down."

It sounds like the home inspector you are talking about did the right thing, since he did point out circumstantial evidence of a bad repair, unless these days home inspectors are expected to carry around those fancy fiber optic camera systems that let you look around corners. But then again, if plumbers have them.... :@)

Re: OT Home Inspector ethics question? long

#27

Re: OT Home Inspector ethics question? long

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>When my daughter bought their house in Pittsburgh and my son bought his in Cazenovia, NY I advised both of them to get a home inspection done. Basically it was another set of skilled eyeballs looking for potential problems. In my daughters case he didn't find anything that was really serious. In my son's case on the first house he looked at there were some serious structural issues in the garage roof trusses that would have cost many thousnads to fix. The home owner was totally unaware of the problem as they had only lived there for a short time and hadn't gotten a home inspection when they bought the house.

In order to do a home inspection the buyer has to sign a contract to buy the house. Once you've signed you are on the hook for at least the realtors fee should you change your mind, unless there is a serious problem with the house found during the inspection. I think with a home inspector you are in a far better position to get out of a committment on a house with a professional opinion that there is a problem than you would be if dear old Dad or the FIL said there was the same problem.

Lee

Re: OT Home Inspector ethics question? long

#28

Buy some track shoes

Curly Smith

>Because you need to run away from this mess as fast as you can.

If I read your post correctly, the inspector:

- ID'd past water damage in the kitchen

- ID'd an old repair

- Stated his inability to visually inspect the old repair

In other words, he fully disclosed what he did and didn't do.

His mistake, that you mention in a subsequent post, was the offer to make a repair. His report had the usual disclaimers and he appears to have made the proper disclosures. However, he admitted culpability with his offer "to make things right" and that offer will likely supercede the original contract. You have no reason to "make things right" unless you've done something wrong. He's going to get sued and unless you run away you're going to get dragged in and have your own attorney's fees to pay. He needs to find a lawyer ASAP and you need to find one, sooner rather than later, to protect yourself.

The inspector is in financial jeopardy - not because of how he inspected the house but because of how he handled the complaint.

Re: OT Home Inspector ethics question? long

#29

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

It's all about curb appeal...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>It's just like a couple brothers for whom I've worked in the past. They own a used-car lot (with the requisite buy here/pay here biz). They would rather have a car that looks good and runs poorly on their lot than one that has a new engine and tranny and otherwise is in excellent mechanical condition but has a bunch of rust and holes in it.

Funny thing, though. Builders I know who are building a house for a customer (not on spec) spend all their time on the structural, plumbing and wiring, but then when it gets to the finish items of sheetrock, painting and carpentry that can really make a house look good, they really start to cut the schedule short. I've done better paint jobs in new-construction apartments than some I've seen in some $500k homes.

Jason

Re: OT Home Inspector ethics question? long

#30

Re: OT Home Inspector ethics question? long

Rick Christopherson

>In my past life, I used to be a certified AHERA building inspector, which is the most rigorous level of building inspections for asbestos, and is required for schools and government buildings. Even though this is not the same type of inspection as a home inspection, what that inspector did was exactly what he was supposed to do.

He performed his inspection and noted that he was not able to physically inspect a specific area. If he had not noted in his report that he could not observe 15% of the crawl space, then he would be at fault, but that is not the case. He specifically stated this in his report.

An AHERA inspection requires physical damage to the building to complete the inspection, but even then it is still permitted to note that some areas are not accessible. A home inspector is not expected to cause damage in the process of the inspection, and is in no way as rigorous.

What you have is a homeowner that is trying to get something from someone else, and it sounds as though they want you to help. I get the impression from your posting that you do not agree with the tactics of the home owner. If your inspection report has any type of summary or conclusion section, I would specifically note that a piece of information was withheld from you by the homeowner. You don't need to draw any conclusions about it, just simply state that you were not given the complete report until a later date, which revealed this 15% omission as a legitimate notation.

It is not your job to either support or condemn a previous report, just state facts. Consider that everything that you write could be used in a court of law. It is the court that is responsible for drawing conclusions regarding negligence, not yours. Don't play into the hands of the homeowner for a buck, just do what you do.

Re: OT Home Inspector ethics question? long

#31

Thanks, guys......

Barry Irby

>I have made the same mistake the Inspector made. In a effort to calm the situation and keep the agent happy I offered to make a repair that to me seemed simple. I thought it was a nice gesture. They thought it was an admission of guilt.

I have had another conversation with the inspector. The more I talk to him, the more convinced I am that he did a reasonably good job, or actually a very good job.

I am going to with draw from this. I am sure the buyers don't want me to explain to them that they did not read their report carefully. I think they have an obligation to extract as much information as they can from the report and the inspector and to do it in a timely fashion. It makes no sense to me that you would hire someone to help you in a matter that was time sensitive and then ignore or not explore what they are able to tell you.

Re: OT Home Inspector ethics question? long

#32

Re: Stuart, were you the seller?

Stuart Hough

>Barry, Yes I was the seller. My first two homes were my "book-learning" phase. I got took on both, because I listened to people who said things I hoped to hear. Both realtors, (training salesmen, really) told me that the buyers wanted a home inspection, and that it was a gesture of sinceretu to provide that. "You won't even have to pay for it up front, because it'll come out of the proceeds of the sale" I was told. Damn! was I ever naive! By the time the third house was to be sold, I had talked with several realtors ( part of the relocation office from work) and they told me that I had been given BAD instructions. The Buyer pays for the inspection, and the then counteroffer based on what the inspector finds. That is when I decided that I will do my due dilligence when I need another inspector, and did a lot of background work on more than 15 people before the buyer officially made an offer contingent on the findings of the inspection. I was satisfied with their choice, as i had already spoken with him, and had a good feel for his talents. He came VERY highly reccomended by friends and neighbors. I should make note, that the first two incidents were in the Tampa bay area of Florida, and the third was in Easley, SC. Florida has a bunch of hooligans masquerading as professionals.