OT Home Inspector ethics question? long
Barry Irby
>I have been drawn into a controversy surrounding another Home Inspector. I would appreciate your detached opinion.
The home buyer's story is that the inspector did not get under the kitchen because it was very low and a duct was in the way and that he did not tell them he could not get under the floor of the kitchen. In the eight months intervening, the husband has found a way to get under the floor and found that someone has made a really half A$$ repair. He went to look because there is a soft spot in front of the kitchen sink. It appears the dishwasher leaked and at some time in the past someone made this terrible repair. There is a piece of particle board shelving with the white melamine on it pressed up under the floor and other bits and pieces propped up on shims and sticks. They have gotten bids of $9K and $11K to terolut the cabinets, fix the floor and replace the vinyl (at least 12 by 30 feet.
No one actually knows when the repair was made. Certainly years or years ago. Who knows, maybe five years or even ten. There is clearly no new damage since the repair was made.
The Home Inspector's version of the story is that he did not get under that part of the house and put it into his report that there was 15% of the floor he could not see. He had checked the crawl and realized he could not get into the far corner, so he went back out and got has million candlepower light and while he was doing that he explained there was part of the crawl he could not get into but that he was going to take the best look he could. He reported that the band board was stained and that there had clearly been some sort of leak, but that it appeared sound now and he could see no evidence of an active leak. He also explained that some sort of repair had been made because he could see the crud left from it in the form of rotted crap left in the crawl, but that from that angle he could not see the repair at all.
He did find rot under the master bath tub and the buyers got a concession from the seller for a repair. The buyer now claims there is rot under the other bath tub and that he missed it. He claims that he checked both tubs and the rot was not there. They buyer has tow teenagers taking lots of showers and the Home Inspection points out that he told them to seal the grout and they have not. They also have not made the repair under the tub they were compensated for. Also, they showed the report the inspecotr did, but conveniently "forgot" to show me the page that noted that there was 15% he could not see.
I was recently at the house and there is a slight puffy place in front of the kitchen sink. Not bad, it may move a 1/16". The subfloor is stained slightly under it, but not rotted. At least there is no visible rot below the puffy place.
So, what is your take on this?



