Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

OT - Compact Fluorescents Revisited *LINK*

Posts

OT - Compact Fluorescents Revisited *LINK*

#1

OT - Compact Fluorescents Revisited *LINK*

Bill Hammond, Oregon Coast

>In a recent discussion on compact fluorescents many expressed their dislike for the lamps. I think I know why.

In a recent discussion on shop lighting a post suggested that 6500K was a good color temp for shop fluorescent lighting, making everything look better and brighter, it got me to thinking... 6500K is rather white and bright.

The local power company handed out some CF lamps and I started comparing them to some that I had and found that the color temp of the CF's from the power company was 2700K. If you are used to white and bright (6500K) then going to a 2700K lamp will be a very dark experience for you. To add insult to the dimness, not all are as bright either. I have nominal 60 W in CF that are 14 W - 900 lumens and 13 W - 720 lumens and the nominal 75 W are 1000 and 1200 lumens. Only one listed the color temp (the ones from the power company). I expect that the others may be even worse.

Therefor I think that the dislike for the CF's is based on expectations generated from marketing information. If you use a CF that has a color temp the same as what you are used to and the lumen output is the same or higher then you would find that CF's are a good replacement. If you buy from a source that is meeting a price point you may have a less than illuminating experience.

All this has to do with how things look and not how fast the light comes on. If you want a fast light use and incandescent, if you want a cheap light for long periods of time then use the CFL's

Also posted on another forum because I really could not remember where the discussion started.

Bill, on the Sunny and bright Oregon Coast


Additional info on color temp. available here.

Re: OT - Compact Fluorescents Revisited *LINK*

#2

Re: OT - Compact Fluorescents Revisited

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Evening Bill,

Same experience here. I bought a package and installed one in the kitchen. I was telling my wife all about how great, efficient and cost effective they were as I flipped the switch. She was underwhelmed and said it was as dim as my wit.---made me feel like Rodney Dangerfield, I get no respect. :<) At least I can make light of it.

George

Re: OT - Compact Fluorescents Revisited *LINK*

#3

let them warm up before comparing

John K Jordan

>Don't forget that fluorescents take a while to "warm up" before they reach full brightness. Wait two to five minutes after you flip the switch before comparing, depending on ambient temperature. Those in my cold garage in the winter are plum dim when first switched on.

In my shop I use the high wattage CF bulbs only available from the local electrical supply house, similar to the bulbs used in overhead fixtures in warehouses, etc. They are much brighter than those found at HD or Walmart. Over the lathe I mix the bright CF with 150-200w tungsten bulbs for a more balanced lighting.

Outside the barn I use CF in a floodlight configuration. Far cheaper to operate than floodlights, cooler, and they don't burn out as fast. Not as bright but plenty of light to get around.

JKJ

Re: OT - Compact Fluorescents Revisited *LINK*

#4

Re: OT - Question about the CF bulbs

Winnemucca Lynn

>A blind friend of mine had a brain operation. During the course of the operation she developed epilepsy. If she is in a room with the usual long fluorscent bulb, she has a siezure. Will that continue to happen with the CF bulbs that we are going to be 'mandated' to use? Even without eyes, she can tell if a light in the room has been turned on.

Lynn

Re: OT - Compact Fluorescents Revisited *LINK*

#5

Re: OT - Question about the CF bulbs

Bill in IN

>The problem may not occur with the newer electronic ballasts. They are higher frequency and do not exhibit the strobing that the older units do. Most compacts are high frequency anyway. Do standard incandescents trigger the response also?

Re: OT - Compact Fluorescents Revisited *LINK*

#6

Re: OT - Compact Fluorescents Revisited

Jim Dillon

>Bill

"The local power company handed out some CF lamps..."

Better check your electric bill to see if the CF lights "handed out" were actually free. Last winter, we received several CF lights in the mail with a note from our local power company (Allegheny Power) explaining how great the CF bulbs are and how they hope we will use them. I naively thought this was a wonderful forward-looking gesture on the utilities part. Guess again. Customers were actually charged for the bulbs and at a cost far greater than what one can buy the bulbs for at the local Costco. Customers were naturally outraged and the utility recently sent a letter apologizing for the "error" and committed to "making-it-right". With all the line-item charges in my utility bill, I - so far - don't have a clue if I got a rebate or not.

We have a number of CF bulbs around the house, in outdoor flood lights but not in the shop. They really do seem to vary between brands in the speed with which they "warm up". So far, I don't have any real problems with them and wish the price on the CF bulbs that can be dimmed would drop.

As an aside, there was an interesting study done on the impact of nighttime illumination on incidence of breast cancer in women. The hypothesis is that too much light at night can raise the risk of breast cancer by interfering with the brain's production of a tumor-suppressing hormone. Many scientists believe that melatonin production is the key. The body produces melatonin at night and levels drop in the presence of light. This hypothesis is supported by other studies on rats, shift workers (nurses, flight attendants etc) and blind women who have very low incidences of breast cancer. Now, what does this have to do with CF bulbs? Well, the researchers found that the energy-efficient CF bulbs suppress melatonin production more than incandescent bulbs. The reason given is that light sources heavy in the blue region of the light spectrum (CF bulbs, flourescent bulbs, computer screens) suppress melatonin the most. The World Health Organization announced in December that "shift work" is a "probable carcinogen". Food for thought, and keep those CF bulbs turned off at night 8-).

Jim

Re: OT - Compact Fluorescents Revisited *LINK*

#7

Re: OT - Compact Fluorescents Revisited

Tony - Memphis

>I've gradually filled almost every socket in our house with them. But I didn't get the big box bulbs. I ordered from an online source that lists all the values of their bulbs. So, its really hard to tell the difference. The first bulbs I tried were from HD and they were awful. I decided that cf's weren't for me at that point. But, later, I learned that they had come a long way and decided to order some quality bulbs to try. We have three ways, minis, the a-shape bulbs, floods, etc. There is a warm up period as somebody mentioned. Some of my bulbs are faster than others. Its funny that folks think they are dimmer as our experience has been the opposite. I matched equivalent wattages best I could and we have been amazed at how much more light we have. My wife is an artist, so we bought the real expensive bulbs and tubes for her work room. She wanted as close to sunlight as we could get. I can't see the difference in our bill (too many variables), but I'm hoping we are makign some difference. I like that they don't produce much heat. Especially the floods in the ceiling. I'd like to replace the cheapo bulbs in my shop (very blue), but I just haven't made the investment yet. It always amazes me how much different the color is between the shop and the house. I bring all my color samples into the house to check them. I think Mr. Dresdner tells a story about a light source vs color issue he had with a customer once.

I can't recall who I ordered from at the moment but there are tons of good suppliers online.

Tony

Re: OT - Compact Fluorescents Revisited *LINK*

#8

JL

Re: OT - Compact Fluorescents Revisited

JL

>When I installed the track lighting above my lathe, I put the compact fluorescent PAR 30 lamps in the fixture. I am happy with them. When the PAR 30s above my workbench go out, I will replace them with CFL PAR 30s. I obviously have a reasonable means of comparison :). The CFL PAR 30s take a few minutes to come up to full brightness, but the color is similar.

My only "beef" is in the disposal - not every locality has drop off points for fluorescent lamps (long tubes as well as compact fluorescents) - I'd rather not contribute any mercury to the environment.

Re: OT - Compact Fluorescents Revisited *LINK*

#9

Re: OT - No

Winnemucca Lynn

>

Re: OT - Compact Fluorescents Revisited *LINK*

#10

Re: OT - Compact Fluorescents Revisited

Larry in NW Ohio

>Tony If you think of the supplier, I hope you post it. Thanks. Larry in Ohio

Re: OT - Compact Fluorescents Revisited *LINK*

#11

Another medical thing

Bill Howatt

>Item on news few weeks ago where some people seem to get sick when they are "exposed" to CF lamps. They suspected cause is not the light itself but high-frequency electromagnetic fields which I imagine comes from the ballast circuit.

Bill

Re: OT - Compact Fluorescents Revisited *LINK*

#12

This is the place...

Tony - Memphis

>I have had real good luck with these folks. I got one bulb that quit working after a few days and they immediately shipped out a replacement and seemed very concerned and asked me to hang to the bad one in case they needed to send it back.

http://www.lightbulbsdirect.com/page/001/CTGY/CompactFluorescent

This is the company we got the bulbs for my wife's work room...

http://www.naturallighting.com/web/shop.php

Tony

Re: OT - Compact Fluorescents Revisited *LINK*

#13

2700K bulbs

wilbur

>A typical incandescent light bulb has a color temperature of 2870K. The 2700K CFL bulbs are the ones that match an incandescent bulb most closely, which is probably why those bulbs were offered to you.

I have 5000 K fluorescents in my workshop, but the CFLs in the rest of the house are 2700K because they looked most like the incandescent bulbs that we were used to. The wattage equivalent bulbs do seem to be dimmer, but I took care of that by buying higher wattage bulbs. Our 60W incandescents were replaced with 23W CFLs which put out the lumens of a 100 watt bulb, but use 37 less watts.

As a matter of fact, if we are taking pictures in our living room, which is lit with the 2700K CFLs, the white balance on our digital camera has to be set at "incandescent" instead of "fluorescent" for the photos to come out well.

Re: OT - Compact Fluorescents Revisited *LINK*

#14

Re: OT - Compact Fluorescents Revisited

Bill Hammond, Oregon Coast

>>Better check your electric bill to see if the CF lights

>"handed out" were actually free.

To the extent that anything the power company does is payed for out of revenue garnered through the sale of electricity, yes I payed for them. However not as an itemized item. The first were handed out at a home show. Ask and intelligent question and get a lamp. I made several passes at that booth. The second batch came with a new electric meter. The new ones can be read from the office over the power line. For the inconvenience of having to reset all those #$&&* clocks in appliances that don't bridge a 30 sec power outage the meter reader/exchanger left a box of 4 lamps. So they were free to the extent that I would have to pay my share for all of them even if I received none. Our power company is a COOP so I may have received an additional fraction of a cent at the end of the year had I not taken any lamps.

You're right though, it's a real pain when you get charged for handouts that you didn't ask for.

Bill on the Sunny Oregon Coast

Re: OT - Compact Fluorescents Revisited *LINK*

#15

Re: OT - The mercury may be a big issue.

Barry Irby

>The local news ran a story on the proper disposal of these bulbs. They contain mercury and should not be just thrown away. With more and more people switching to them and the current crop aging and failing it is becoming a bigger and bigger issue.

I have had them in about every socket in my house for about five years, and I like them.

Re: OT - Compact Fluorescents Revisited *LINK*

#16

Re: OT - The mercury may be a big issue.

Lawrence See

>To a significant degree, the lifetime of fluorescent lamps is proportional to the amount of mercury (a controlled arc through mercury vapor in the lamp is the basis of its function) because a reserve is needed.

So we have lots of voices clamoring to eliminate mercury, other loud voices exhorting us to "save energy, use CFL's", all of them using the worst sort of scare tactics. So, the manufacturers reduce the mercury in the CFL's to where the content of mercury in a small truckload is about equivalent to one broken fever thermometer, the lamp life goes way down and the bit about "they cost less in the long run" sounds rather hollow.

I live where the 49'ers used literately tons of mercury to extract gold before the cyanide process replaced the amalgamation process (gee, I wonder how safe cyanide is?) - we are still alive.

/> rant off.

Re: OT - Compact Fluorescents Revisited *LINK*

#17

Re: OT - My issue with CFL's

Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon

>The varieties of lamps sold for home screw in used have a built in ballast. The ballast should have 5 to 10 times the life of the lamp. Why is no one out there(at least that I can find) making a screw in ballast with plug in lamps. It seems cray to throw away a ballast every time the lamp goes bad. I can find retro fit kits for all kinds of commercial fixture, albeit somewhat expensive, but not a simple screw in ballast that uses plug in lamps.

glc

Re: OT - Compact Fluorescents Revisited *LINK*

#18

Re: OT - My issue with CFL's *LINK*

John K Jordan

>From http://www1.eere.energy.gov/femp/procurement/eep_compact_fluor_lamp.html: "CFLs are sold either as integral bulb/ballast combinations or "modular" systems, which have one or more pin-based bulbs that may be replaced separately while re-using the ballast. ... Modular CFLs allow a separate pin-based bulb to be replaced when one burns out. The ballast and base can generally be re-used for about five bulb replacements. (Most ballasts are rated at 50,000 hours.)"

The modular bases in the link below claims "Use anywhere a standard incandescent is used. Perfect for Table lamps, Floor lamps, Ceiling fixtures, Closet lights" so it must use a standard base.

JKJ


http://www.goodmart.com/pdfs/tcp/2pc-spring-160.pd