Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial

Posts

Re: A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial

#26

Re: Dovetail jig ? *LINK*

charlie belden

>Woodchuck29 wrote:

> Personally I'd rather use a dovetail jig. I don't

> get some of the hype of hand cut dovetails.

> Nowdays I feel speed is just as important as

> quality. I can cut them faster and get a

> tighter fit, meaning a better glue joint with a

> jig.

Depends on how many you've got to cut,

how uniform your stock prep is and how

familiar you are with your dovetail jig.

I don't care what the brochures and ads

say, NO router based dovetail jig on the

market that I'm aware of, "requires NO

test cuts". If the "depth of cut" isn't

REALLY close to your stock thickness

the joint won't fit right. And getting

that just right IS a trial and error tuning

process - no matter what THEY say -

and I have, and use, probably the simplest

to set up and use dovetail jig out there

- the AKEDA. (and if you want to know why

I say that - see the attached link - and be

forewarned - there are SEVERAL pages of

WHY)

Now if it's speed and efficiency you want

why use dovetails at all - a Lok-Miter router

bit makes pretty strong corner joints

a LOT faster than cutting dovetails - even

with a router and a decent dovetail jig - along

with some experience with both.

I guess it comes down to whether wood-

working is a journey, or a means to an end.

If you want to get there FAST - take a plane.

If you want a possible adventure, which might

include meeting some interesting people

along the way, and seeing some interesting

things you didn't even know existed - drive

and stop if there might be some roses

to smell, if it's over a mile or so, walk if it

isn't.

And re: the original message - I totally

agree with adding, and using dovetails

when they'll do the job - even if not

"perfect" - great joint.

charlie belden


AKEDA Dovetail Jig

Re: A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial

#27

Re: Dovetail jig ?

Chuck in ND

>Charlie, I'm not feeling well tonight and I'm not in the mood for a long drug out feud or reading a infomercial about someones expensive dovetail jig that I can't afford or need. I have my opinions and you have yours, just leave it at that.

Re: A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial

#28

Re: Dovetail jig ?

charlie belden

>Just to be clear

1. hopefully there wasINFORMATION at the link

which might be useful for someone looking

into dovetail jigs - rather than learning to

cut them by hand. There is no

"COMMERCIAL" at all. I buy tools that I

think will do a job I want to do - and pay the

going price for them - no discounts, no

nothing - my money - my opinion - hopefully

adequately supported by presented facts.

How the info is used is up to the reader.

If it's ignored - that's ok too.

2. This dovetail jig is about the same price as

the other jigs that will do variable spacing

so if it seems expensive to you - well

they're all getting pretty close in price.

3. yes have, and enjoy using, handtools as

well as power tools, and yes I can handcut

through dovetails and just haven't gotten

around to half blinds - yet. And for

anyone who wants to give handcutting

through dovetails a try, I put together

some stuff based primarily on a Frank

Klausz video, with a little Tage Frid

and Ian Kirby thrown in. Put it together

for myself and posted it for others to

use - or not. Print it - do what you see

and you end up with a dovetailed drawer.

When someone finds a hole in the info

or suggests an addition I update things.

Use it- don't use it - either is fine by me.

Hope your tomorrow is better than today.

charlie belden

Re: A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial

#29

Re: YEP -if its a hidden surface :~)

Dan Donaldson

>I have the big Leigh and I think that I looked at it in the cabinet a couple of years ago to make sure it was still there. I like to cut DT's by hand and for one or two drawers or a simple chest carcass, I can cut them out by hand faster than I can get out the jig, router, and bits and get then set up. Of course part of that is because, since I use then so seldom, I have to first find them ;-) I can also cut ones that I cannot make with the jig, especially since the entry point for the bit has to be at least 1/4" to clear the shank.

That said, if I were going to make a kitchen, I would definitely use the jig. I like to cut them by hand, but am not a masochist, and for that application I would be using them for strength and would not care if they looked machine made or any other way as long as they were strong. ;-)