Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial

Posts

A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial

#1

A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Earlier someone asked about an aide for learning to make dovetails. I am going to offer some additional advice for someone wanting to learn to make this joint. This advice is based on my observation that this joint would be used more if people were less intimidated by the standards that have evolved for it.

Dovetails are the best way to construct many common projects, for example case work and drawers. Hence, it is not helpful for experienced woodworkers to dissuade apprentices form using this joint. Yet, that is exactly what they do with this fixation on flauntable dovetails.

Dovetails used to be a sign of quality construction. Now it seems, a perfect dovetail has become the entry fee for peer acceptance, and/or a parlor trick to impress an audience.

The dovetail joint has great strength and a far less than perfect dovetail will hold a case or drawer together just fine. In most cases the joint is hidden or at least seldom exposed anyway. So here is my advice:

1. Go to antique stores and see what quality of dovetail is adequate to hold something together for 200 years. Let that be your standard, not the Cosman dovetail executed by someone that makes hundreds of these joints each year in promotions for LN ( this statement is not meant to detract from Cosman or his excellent video.)

2. Force yourself to use dovetails every chance you have. If they hold the piece together you have been successful.

3. Show others how you have successfully held something together with a less than flauntable dovetail so that they may be encouraged to try it. Your less than perfect dovetail may have more positive impact on promoting this useful joint than Cosman.

Re: A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial

#2

Re: A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial

Jim Toews - Walla Walla, WA

>Preach it, Brother Tindall, preach it! I couldn't agree more if I was paid to do so. I think one should always strive to do the best one can and to continually improve, but perfection, while an admirable goal, is an unreasonable baseline. Some of my shop cabinets have , shall I say, weird dovetails at best, but they are holding together just fine, thank you very much. They were my first crude efforts, but they work. I am reminded of an old saying I heard many years ago: Good, better, best; never rest until your good is better and your better is best. I also note that "best" does not equal "perfect".

Cheers!

Jim

Re: A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial

#3

Re: A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial

Henry (Raleigh NC)

>"Nothing ventured, nothing failed." I think you just illustrated why I have never tried dovetails on anything but scrap. Dovetails, chair-making, and spray finishing are on my personal 'gotta try that' list. Maybe I'll finish the list once I retire?!

Henry

Re: A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial

#4

Re: A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial

Jesse Cloud

>Great editorial Bill! I know some folks out there can cut a new type of joint perfectly the first time, but not me. One of these days I'll be cutting handsome dovetails, but I'm gonna make a lot of not so handsome ones before then. We all need encouragement from time to time to keep working on our skills, thanks for the good words!

Re: A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial

#5

Re: A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial

Robert W

>To borrow the title, your post should be named "sense and sensibility". From the view of a full time woodworker, I thought your post was a keen observation on all counts. Way to go!

Robert

Re: A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial

#6

Re: A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial

wilbur

>Just to add another element to this discussion: you won't find many exposed dovetails in Asian woodworking. Dovetails are used, but they are more frequently hidden dovetail joints, or mitered dovetail joints so as to hide the actual dovetail itself.

The reason for this is that a through dovetail joint winds up exposing a fair amount of endgrain, and as we all know if you've ever dealt with checking at the end of a board, moisture preferentially enters a board through endgrain as opposed to the face grain. So a lot of effort was made to hide endgrain whenever possible in Asian woodworking.

This is also why most mortise and tenon joints in Asian woodworking are blind, instead of being through mortise and tenon joints.

Re: A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial

#7

So, by your rationale...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>...we should also show hand-planed boards with pockets of tearout?

DC

Re: A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial

#8

Couldn't agree more..

John E in SC

>My office desk is probably at least 75 years old, and the main drawer is constructed from WAY less than perfect dovetails. The glue has completely failed on this drawer (I can pretty much almost disassemble the joint by hand), so at present, it's only a "mechanical" joint. I have used it daily for 10+ years now, with no problems whatsoever. I keep telling myself one day I'll take it appart and reglue, but why bother when it's working fine? My own first attempts at dovetailing weren't much to look at, but I "practiced" on a little catch-all box for my daughter, and she likes it :) so that's all that matters (and it holds together well)

John

Re: A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial

#9

Chet Kloss

On the contrary...

Chet Kloss

>I believe Bill is saying plane more boards. Don't hide from hand planes if you are not perfect at it. Many area's one might plane, drawer sides for example, are not in plain sight (no pun intended) most of the time.

Bill is not saying make things poorly, but rather, we may need a reality check for what could be considered good (or good enough).

,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,Chet

Re: A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial

#10

Chet Kloss

Your premise confirmed in reality

Chet Kloss

>I had the good fortune to take a woodworking class with a cabinet master (apprenticed in England and Italy) who had done work with Frank Klausz many years earlier. He commented that in the course of watching Frank make a fair number of hand dovetailed drawers, the "quality" in terms of looks varied significantly. However, the quality in terms of function and stability were unassailable.

His advice to me - cut more dovetails.

,,,,,,,,,,,,,Chet

Re: A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial

#11

Can I get an AMEN!!

Ron Bauman

>In a fine book by Soetsu Yanagi (sp) "The Unknown Craftsman" he talks about how Korean bowl turners worked wood so wet a fine spray came off it when turning. When asked what they did when the bowls checked they said, "oh we repair them." He goes on to say that the repairs were even more impressive than the original turning. As a former restorer I have seen numerous dovetails that were fit slightly off and then a wedge was driven into the tail to tighten them. When my stool seats check from whatever reason I feel that it would be near sacrilegious just to discard $25-$30 worth of Cherry so I splice a patch in. Sure it's more work, but it's kinda fun, too. And given the inflation rate that's my 3 cents.

Re: A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial

#12

Re: YEP -if its a hidden surface :~)

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I have looked at many antiques in my (almost 67 years) - Bill is absolutely correct in his statements. Many of the drawer dovetails (the through dovetails at the back of the drawer where they aren't seen) are pretty rough - often there is only a couple of actual tails. These are drawers that have had the runners wore out, replaced and worn out again - still holding tightly together. I have also observed "planed" boards where the planing was done only to "thickness" the board and there was plenty of tearout - but not visible in the finished piece unless you stood on your head and used a flashlight! His observation is correct in that (at least I do) we don't use hand cut dovetails in many places as we can't make them match the pro's that do it every day. I have the LN dovetail saw and full set of LN chisels - I can cut pretty good dovetails (in my eyes) but nothing like the pros. I will start doing so in some pieces as what Bill said makes good sense. It will save me from setting up my Leigh D4 for one and two pieces.

Re: A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial

#13

Re: Dovetail jig ?

Chuck in ND

>Personally I'd rather use a dovetail jig. I don't get some of the hype of hand cut dovetails. Nowdays I feel speed is just as important as quality. I can cut them faster and get a tighter fit, meaning a better glue joint with a jig.

Re: A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial

#14

You get an AMEN from me.

Eddie Pacheco; San Jose, Ca.

>I heartily agree that the dovetail joint is sometimes used as a "show off' joint.

Re: A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial

#15

Most traditional Japanese tansu...

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>are put together with box joints, occassionally dovetails. Lots of end grain exposed, often covered by iron strap work. Through mortise and tenon joints are also common, also often covered by iron strap work

Clint

Re: A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial

#16

Sure, that's called maker's mark

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>

Re: A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial

#17

How about Martian dovetails???

HC Sakman

>If you haven't seen it, Mr, Shaver will show you how it's done!!!

Chico...

;-)

Re: A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial

#18

Re: Sure, that's called maker's mark

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>I thought Maker's Mark came in a bottle??? :))

Re: A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial

#19

Those are eminently flauntable! :-)

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>

Re: A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial

#20

Re: A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial

Ron In Sterling CT

>I agree wholeheartedly. In my 68+ years of making sawdust, I have tried most everything, but like most of us I steered away from handmade dovetails. I think the last one I cut was probably 25 years ago, until this past winter. I had procrastinated long enough so I prepped up some cherry and made LOML a nice 11"x14"x30" mini blanket chest. The dovetails for all the corners, including the plinths were hand cut. Sure some of them have a little "character", but I am the only one that notices. Everyone else looks at it and says "wow I wish I could do that". I say "quit procrastinating --- go cut dovetails.

Re: A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial

#21

"good enough"

John Veerkamp Western Mo

>Years ago I heard a wise person say that we need to teach the principle of "good enough". The degree of perfection in a given task should be measured by how well a given task or project fits its intended use. A utility workbench made of nailed 2X's can be just as useful as a fine piece of bench "furniture" with beautiful dovetails and mortised joints, thus just as perfect. Demanding "perfection" in every task as Bill aptly stated, only discourages trying in the first place.

My two cents.

John

Re: A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial

#22

We are always learning or we die on the vine

Wayne Carson

>The thing about all trades is that everyone wants people with experience and unfortunitly there are few places to learn. I would rather learn how to do something from someone that does it all the time than to pratice for years just to find out that there was a much easier way. I probably will not make perfect dovetails during the rest of my lifetime but I would like to do one that I can hang on the wall. And I love to watch skilled people do there job no matter what is because they make it look so easy and kind of poetry in motion. I watched a man dig a ditch with a shovel one day about 4' deep and he was so good that he never missed a lick and after about 20' he was finished and wasn't even out of breath. He was about 50 ish and not in that good of condition he just knew his trade and his tools and used them to his advantage. He said he was taught by an old man way back, but didn't have anyone to pass it on to, back hoes and ditchers you know.

my 4 cents worth

Re: A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial

#23

Here is a sample

HC Sakman

>I just finished this night table drawer. Look at under the top 2 pins and the 2nd. pin from the bottom...see the gaps? Doesn't look "perfect" but fit is perfect. I guess I could have filled those but did not bother. Besides, the gaps are visible in the photo, in person it's hard to see beside dark walnut tails.

Chico...


img

Re: A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial

#24

Ellis Walentine

I was waiting for that :-)

Ellis Walentine

>

Re: A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial

#25

Re: A case against flauntable dovetails-editorial *LINK*

charlie belden

>wilbur wrote:

> Just to add another element to this

> discussion: you won't find many exposed

> dovetails in Asian woodworking.

> Dovetails are used, but they are more

> frequently hidden dovetail joints, or mitered

> dovetail joints so as to hide the actual

> dovetail itself.

> The reason for this is that a through

> dovetail joint winds up exposing a fair

> amount of endgrain, and as we all know

> if you've ever dealt with checking at the end

> of a board, moisture preferentially enters a

> board through endgrain as opposed to the

> face grain. So a lot of effort was made to

> hide endgrain whenever possible in Asian

> woodworking.

> This is also why most mortise and tenon

> joints in Asian woodworking are blind, instead

> of being through mortise and tenon joints.

I think it's far deeper than merely the issue

of exposed end grain and practicality. I think

it's a cultural approach to things - Evocative

rather than Provocative - US rather than ME

- Look what I can do! rather than - See, use

and enjoy this thing that I made for YOU.

"Western Culture" is more about the individual

and only then the collective society. "Easter

Culture" is more about the collective society,

the individual a part of the larger whole. We

"westerners" WANT to stand out. "Easterners"

are more proned to wanting to FIT IN.

"Western" wants to be straghtforeward - no

ambiguity - what you see is what you get.

"Eastern" intentionally builds in ambiguity

- what you think you see and what's actually

there - may or may not be the same - by

intent - some wiggle room to leave you with

some space to interpret what's there - or

may be there.

I inherited a LOT of nice Chinese furniture

and since getting into woodworking, have

studied and come to understand and

appreciate more the "eastern" approach to

furniture makings and life in general.

The attached link is to a page I put together

on a Chinese version of a sideboard. Most

of the illustrations I'd already done. This

thread prompted me to put some of it

all together in a web page which I hope some

will find useful at best, or at least interesting.

If you go through the info, keep a Greene

& Greene sideboard in mind and juxtapose

it with this piece.

Interesting this woodworking thing.

charlie belden


Sideboard - a Chinese Approach