Personal experience (long)
Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.
>I have an idea of mine that's distributed by a well-known company. When I was considering my options I figured that getting a patent for my product was way beyond my means (in the line of $10k if I did it myself). Then there would be the manufacturing, distribution and all ancillary costs, despite your faith in the product you have no way to determine if it is viable enough to recoup your costs (many lost their shirts for not paying attention to that fact).
Add to this the fact that if the product does indeed sell well, there will be other companies out there looking at producing a competing product, either by circumventing your patent by changing a few features, or even blatantly copying your product. As a "small manufacturer", what do you do if this happens? Legal fees incurred in protecting your patent can bring you down on your knees financially real fast (and if you don't protect your patent you lose it). For each inventor that made it to riches with their invention there are hundreds who went bankrupt. Keep that in mind. It does suck, but in our society there is no way for someone with a great idea to get it to the market and make money out of it unless you have the financial means to develop, manufacture, distribute and market your product, and then be able to protect your product from copycats.
One thing that helps US citizens is that patent protection is awarded to the person who can demonstrate he/she was first to come up with the idea. Elsewhere in the world the patent is awarded to "first to market", i.e. if you show your idea to someone and they take off and market it then you're up s... creek without a paddle... My uneducated understanding is that there is international pressure to get the USA to switch to the "international process", for the sake of all small inventors please resist this...
In the end, I went to a trusted company with my idea, they took on the risk of spending resources to get the product to the market because they felt they could make some money at it. In exchange I get a small royalty, nothing that could allow me to retire at age 45, but I get a reward for my idea, without any of the risks associated in bringing it to market myself. I'm not ecstatic about the whole thing, but I'm happy I went the way I did, it gives me the best possible risk-free return I could possibly expect. And I have my name on a patent, something that will still be there long after the product stops selling...
Hope this helps,
DC