Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Ideas brought to companies

Posts

Re: Ideas brought to companies

#26

Re: Ideas brought to companies

Chuck in ND

>Well if anything has come out of all this maybe some other people in here got educated also. To tell you the truth, I'm exhausted with woodworking and I'm exhausted with what I thought might of been a good product for others. I think I really need to take a break from all this and not worry about what others want or like. I need some me time. See if I can ever get back to enjoying time in the shop again.

Re: Ideas brought to companies

#27

Personal experience (long)

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>I have an idea of mine that's distributed by a well-known company. When I was considering my options I figured that getting a patent for my product was way beyond my means (in the line of $10k if I did it myself). Then there would be the manufacturing, distribution and all ancillary costs, despite your faith in the product you have no way to determine if it is viable enough to recoup your costs (many lost their shirts for not paying attention to that fact).

Add to this the fact that if the product does indeed sell well, there will be other companies out there looking at producing a competing product, either by circumventing your patent by changing a few features, or even blatantly copying your product. As a "small manufacturer", what do you do if this happens? Legal fees incurred in protecting your patent can bring you down on your knees financially real fast (and if you don't protect your patent you lose it). For each inventor that made it to riches with their invention there are hundreds who went bankrupt. Keep that in mind. It does suck, but in our society there is no way for someone with a great idea to get it to the market and make money out of it unless you have the financial means to develop, manufacture, distribute and market your product, and then be able to protect your product from copycats.

One thing that helps US citizens is that patent protection is awarded to the person who can demonstrate he/she was first to come up with the idea. Elsewhere in the world the patent is awarded to "first to market", i.e. if you show your idea to someone and they take off and market it then you're up s... creek without a paddle... My uneducated understanding is that there is international pressure to get the USA to switch to the "international process", for the sake of all small inventors please resist this...

In the end, I went to a trusted company with my idea, they took on the risk of spending resources to get the product to the market because they felt they could make some money at it. In exchange I get a small royalty, nothing that could allow me to retire at age 45, but I get a reward for my idea, without any of the risks associated in bringing it to market myself. I'm not ecstatic about the whole thing, but I'm happy I went the way I did, it gives me the best possible risk-free return I could possibly expect. And I have my name on a patent, something that will still be there long after the product stops selling...

Hope this helps,

DC

Re: Ideas brought to companies

#28

Re: Personal experience (long)

Chuck in ND

>Denis, thats the way I feel and would like to see it go in the direction as yours has. As far as someone seeing it, I think the inventor has one year to get it patented after it has been seen. But I think you still have to prove it was your idea first by haveing it documented as in Notorized before showing to anyone, includeing showing it to patent lawyers.

Re: Ideas brought to companies

#29

Re: Personal experience (long)

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>I don't think you have to go to that extent, provided you can clearly demonstrate that your idea was out first. But don't take my word for it, IANAL :-)

DC

Re: Ideas brought to companies

#30

Re: Ideas brought to companies

Stuart Hough

>Chuck, A friend of mine had an idea years ago about a tool he dreamed up for his refinishing business. What a mutual friend told us was for my buddy to draw up a set of plans with a description of the purpose and function of the tool, and then mail it to himself by Registered Mail, so he would have to sign for it. The purpose of this was to give a sort of "time-stamp" on the idea, so he could prove the idea was his. This was to be used in court if anyone tried to patent the idea before he could get it rolling along. Never heard if he did it, or if he got his invention patented and into production, but at least from an "intellectual property" standpoint it seemed to make sense.

Re: Ideas brought to companies

#31

Re: Ideas brought to companies

rarebear

>There is no honor in the US any more execpt for the small guys like us..

I had a friends with a small production company..

He wrote a pilot and produced it and showed it to someone at FOX

Never heard any thing..

Fox released a show with an actress he had used and called it Tribes

A Teenage soap opera and the set was a high school just like my friends

Year later they came out with 90210

He tried to sue but lawers cost big money and big companies will bury you in costs

Re: Ideas brought to companies

#32

Re: Personal experience (long)

Rob Lee

>Chuck -

First and foremost - if in doubt - contact your lawyer for advice (doesn't have to be a patent lawyer)... there both good and bad information in this thread.

Don't spend (alot) of money before finding someone interested your idea... you get people to sign a Non-Disclosure-Agreement (NDA) that will protect your rights.

Another useful step is a Provisional Patent Application.... get's you "in line" at the patent office, and is really an undertaking to finalize your patent application within 1 year .... Only a few hundred dollars to go this route, while you find someone interested.

Few people realize how difficult (or expensive) it is to bring a product to market. Typical royalties on a patent may run 2-10% of manufacturing cost (or wholsale cost)... thats's it. Most of the "sale" price of a product is marketing cost and overheads.... it's not like the music industry - where artists may get much higher percentages.

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Ideas brought to companies

#33

Eli Whitney....

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>single handedly invented the cotton gin, probably the most socially and industrially transformative products in history. He got it patented, but that didn't stop worldwide copying, for which he didn't receive a cent.

Clint

Re: Ideas brought to companies

#34

Re: Ideas brought to companies

Joseph Mulherin, Sr.

>I agree, Chuck. I, too, am getting back into my shop starting tomorrow morning....am going to remove all equipments, benches and many various tools and am going to decide which shall keep and sell or give away the rest. There are so many things that I do not need or want anymore.

Shop gets to looking like a grandma's house saving things for others, so am clearing things out.

Re: Ideas brought to companies

#35

Re: Ideas brought to companies

Chuck in ND

>Yeah, I think I'm better off just forgeting about the whole idea. Other than it bennefiting my shop and learning about what it takes to get something into the market place nowdays, I feel like I've wasted too much time trying to go anywhere with it. Too many sharks in the water, and I'm just a defenseless seal.

Re: Ideas brought to companies

#36

Chuck, Read the post by Rob Lee on March 31

North of the Border

>if you haven't done so. As you may or may not have known, he's the owner of Lee Valley / Veritas. If you could only listen one advice given in this thread, take his.

Re: Ideas brought to companies

#37

Sorry his post is on March 30

North of the Border

>http://tinyurl.com/6hnmq2

Re: Ideas brought to companies

#38

Re: Chuck, Read the post by Rob Lee on March 31

Chuck in ND

>Thanks North, this is a fairly complex idea I have come up with and really kind of limits the companies that I can aproach. I have contacted these companies without leting the cat out of the bag and it is proveing to be quite a struggle. I need to take a break from it all for awhile if not forever, it's really takein the wind out of my sails. Maybe someday I'll come back to it. Thanks again though for the advice.

Re: Ideas brought to companies

#39

Re: Personal experience (long)

William H. Falberg

>As one who has pursued several patents, some pro se, and attempted every avenue to produce and market them, my only success has been the portable band saws with my name on them. I have found, in the end, that patents are not needed at all if you can make and sell your product at a competitive price. No big company wants to jump into competition with an established brand unless they can clearly see big profits. By that time you've got your own big money to fight back with. Marketing: if it (your invention) makes money for you when used, you're friends and associates will want to buy one too. Starting small: water-jetting, sand casting, Grainger parts, and some basic hand tools (along with the steady proliferation proprietary fabrication techniques and jigs) are cheap and get you into profit-mode from day one. Never get in over your head and don't go into debt over any idea. If it's a good idea it will generate its own sales momentum and finance you onto a web site internet presence. Keep putting profits back into jigs and tooling and before you know it (five-ten years) you're in a business that's your own and branded to the point where you have no competition. By then you will have expanded into other product lines that share the same market. The first thing you have to find out is if there's a market. If you can't make a profit from selling your prototypes, the market isn't there; and you're better off dropping it until a better idea comes along or until you iron the bugs out and make it profitable. There are many micro manufacturers in the specialty tool niche, doing nicely. "Suits" do indeed suck. Woodworkers are the BEST! And they return calls; as proper gents do..