Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Ideas brought to companies

Posts

Ideas brought to companies

#1

Ideas brought to companies

Chuck in ND

>I have in the last few months have tried to aproach a couple companies on a idea I have. I'm not a rich guy, probably not even middle class. It seems that some companies want you to have the patent first, and some want you to get legal counsel. Well these are expenses I can't afford, I'm barely keeping my head above water financially the way it is. One other company took the idea, but wanted to change the design so much it didn't even look close to what I had, I suspect so they could call it their design and leave me siting at the roadside. The latest companies VP looked a picture, never got back to me so I sent another e:mail and he said it may be something they would be interested in and asked for dimensons, so I sent them some and never heard back again, not a thankyou, looks good or anything, so I sent him three e:mails, no reply back again, so I called and was told by customer service in a relayed message that he was working on it. Well after a couple weeks I called him again and he told me one of his contacts was working on the prototype and that he would let me know when he knows more. Well after all the run around I feel I'm geting, I don't think it's going to happen, I think I'm geting shafted again. If this is how they deal with customer service I'm not impressed at all. If I have to take this idea to my grave then thats what I'll do, I'm sick and tired of all the BS. Seems like no one apreciates anything anymore and everyones out to screw eachother.

Re: Ideas brought to companies

#2

A suggestion

North of the Border

>Let me first share with you a real recent story: A guy by the name of Paul Kind came up with a product that makes it easy to check for prize statements hidden under the rims of paper coffee cups in various contests (most notably the Tim Hortons roll up the rim contest in Canada). He contacted Tim Hortons about his idea and no interest was expressed whatsoever. Eventually he approached Lee Valley Tools which agreed to promote and sell his product see his product and story here: http://tinyurl.com/35hddz ). Thousands and thousands have been sold since and other chain retailers (Zellers, e.g.) also began selling these key-chains ... Tim Hortons which could be the sole seller simply missed it.

Lee Valley, through its manufacturing arm Veritas, has created products based on outsiders' ideas / designs. It is always looking for fresh ideas, products and tools. You may consider sounding out your idea with them. The owners are people of integrity and you don't need to worry about your idea being stolen or anything.

Re: Ideas brought to companies

#3

Re: Ideas brought to companies

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla

>In 3 months it will be on the market and you won't see a penny from it---Betcha!!!

Re: Ideas brought to companies

#4

Re: A suggestion

Chuck in ND

>Woodguy thanks for the story, I may have to check into it. Ken, you don't need to bet me, I think your right, BUT, I only gave him one piece of the puzzle, so to truely make it all work the best that it can, they need more info. After awhile of doing this I started geting a little wise. The name of the company is Penn State Industries. The VP is Ed Levy, which is who I've had contact with. I'm starting to think that I could trust a snake oil salesman more than this guy and his company.

Re: Ideas brought to companies

#5

Re: Ideas brought to companies

John E in SC

>You didn't mention what kind of product you're working on, but if you truly think it's marketable, you really ought to consider at least checking with a patent attorney to see what you need to do to protect your idea before some company takes your idea and markets it. Don't fool yourself into thinking they can't figure out the rest of it from a few pieces - there are lots of smart people in the world.

John

Re: Ideas brought to companies

#6

Re: A suggestion - One more observation

North of the Border

>Whoever has dealt with Lee Valley knows its reputation. In fact, they worry more about their reputation than whether they'll make a couple hundreds more in sales (by the way, they design their pay system such that salesmen are not on commission so they don't have to sell things that a customer doesn't need!). Each year, through their store sales of CDs, calendars, etc, and seminar activities, they donate over $120,000 to charities. Lee Valley is a rare species in today's competitive business world and too bad, it's a privately owned company and we can't be part of it by owning any shares.

Re: Ideas brought to companies

#7

Re: Ideas brought to companies

Chuck in ND

>John, I've checked with a place intown here that is supose to help inventors. In the brief discusion that we had he wanted to drag in a panel of designers to look at it and offer possible design changes. I don't need to pay a bunch of people that have probably never worked in a woodshop before telling me how to design it. I have a ton of time into all this, after designing it 4 times I finally know what I want. And I don't need to pay his engineer to draw up plans either. These people just want to drag all their buddies in to grab a piece of the pie. And now with China in the big picture of produceing stuff for this country I sometimes wonder how much water a patent holds anymore. It would probably take a international patent and I couldn't even begin to imagine the costs on that. I think alot of it just boils down to who can produce it cheaper and sell it cheaper. A patent isn't a one time cost thing, to keep it going in the course of 20 years I would need to make two more substantial payments.

Re: Ideas brought to companies

#8

Found this on our contest page - LV contact

North of the Border

>Woodcentral competition

http://tinyurl.com/3beu4y

Judges:

# Brian Ebbinghaus is a veteran industrial designer with many international design projects to his credit. He is an educational advisor to the Industrial Designers Society of America (IDSA) and Director of Design and R&D at Lee Valley and Veritas Tools.

Re: Ideas brought to companies

#9

the purpose of patents

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I have some experience in patenting and licensing. The process is of necessity complicated to keep you from getting screwed. Most law is complicated. Lawlessness is the alternative. If you are unwilling or unable to pay for the help that is essential to effectively obtain a patent and market the patent then you should have entered into a partnership with someone with the expertise and money to do so. It is not society's fault that you chose not to do so.

The not well understood purpose of patents is to spur innovation which benefits society, not to reward the patent holder. A patent gives one exclusive right to practice an invention. If the invention is useful, others will try to improve upon the idea 1. to avoid your patent and 2. to get their own patent. In the process society benefits from the innovation.

As it is, you have likely disclosed your invention in a way that renders it unpatentable and free to anyone to practice. The places that advised you to obtain legal help were offering sound advice to protect both you and them. That was the only reputable response they could have offered. Any other response was from someone unknowledgable or disreputable.

BTW, an idea might be worth something like 1% of product selling price.

Re: Ideas brought to companies

#10

Re: Ideas brought to companies

Howard Norman

>It is very difficult for the individual inventor not to get screwed by large companies on inventions. If you do not have patent protection when you approach them, watch out. For every company that will deal with you honestly without patent protection there are probable ten that will screw you one way or another.

Document all correspondence with anyone concerning your invention. Build a prototype and document the prototype also.

It is a very difficult situation for the individual.

Howard

Re: Ideas brought to companies

#11

Re: the purpose of patents

North of the Border

>Makes good sense to me. Thanks for sharing your inside knowledge of the subject with us. I have over a dozen of woodworking tips published in various woodworking magazines and as good ideas as they are, I don't think I would want to spend the time or money in trying to turn them into any commercial products. Your suggestion that one should find a credible partner is the most viable alternative to anyone who has a great idea but lacks the resources to pursue it further .... (and that also is why I suggested LV to Chuck).

Re: Ideas brought to companies

#12

Re: the purpose of patents

Chuck in ND

>Bill, I apreciate all of the information everyone has provided in here. But to clear up any misunderstanding, Ed Levi at Penn State Industries never advised me of anything, and I realize I have probably been foolish in my hopes. It just really bugs me that he shows no apreciation for my efforts at all with even as much as a simple reply whenever I e:mailed him. By far the worst company I've dealt with in this whole ordeal.

Re: Ideas brought to companies

#13

Re: Ideas brought to companies

Chuck in ND

>I agree Howard, I have saved every e:mail that I've ever sent or recieved. I never expected to get filthy rich from any of it, just a little apreciation for my efforts if they use it would be nice.

Re: Ideas brought to companies

#14

YUP ! Count on it !

steve mackay

>E-mailed Jack In The Box once and told 'em they needed a " G.I.Jack " antenna ball. " No un-solicited suggestions taken ". I just know, deep in my heart, I'll see them one day !

Re: Ideas brought to companies

#15

Re: Ideas brought to companies

Joseph Mulherin, Sr.

>One does NOT necessarily HAVE to deal with a patent attorney. I have a idea and contacted an attorney...he said his fee for researching the USPTO was going to be $7,200. Well, I went online to the USPTO.com and did my own research on the products previous use before I came up with the idea. NOTHING like it has ever been done....but I cannot get the funds to manufacture it, ergo, it stays with me forever.

If one does own research at the USPTO and can get his patent, one can get it for as low a $385, and pay the maintenance fees (three of them) up till 14yrs....the run of the patent use for your saftey. Then the idea is open to all from then on. Over the 14yrs it would have only cost me just under $5,000 total. Lawyers are handy at timews, but in my humble opinion, they are almost like criminals too....considering the fees that they charge.

Re: Ideas brought to companies

#16

you are right...more on patents

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Companies frequently get "unsolicited ideas". A company should have a process for dealing with this kind of communication. A reputable company will have a process that protects both parties....both parties??? Yes.

The deep pockets company doesn't want a person to claim 5 years from now that this person provided the idea for something that the company is selling for $10 million a year. And the person with the idea doesn't want a company to steal it. To avoid legal battles over good ideas - two classics are the idea for intermittent windshield wipers and another for quick release socket wrenches- a well managed company will have in place a process for dealing with these unsolicited ideas. It may involve suggesting the idea holder get legal aid and a patent or copyright. Lawyers that know what they are doing then deal with one another to sell the idea so nobody gets screwed.

Once by strange circumstances I was involved in the sale of a company. Several million was subtracted from the price because the ideas of the company had not been properly protected. I was boggled by the complexity of the business-legal details. It was a good lesson of when it involves money a good lawyer is a good investment.

Not nice companies would blow you off or steal your idea.

Re: Ideas brought to companies

#17

Re: Ideas brought to companies

Chuck in ND

>Joseph, manufacturing anything is a whole nother ball game. Among all the other costs of manufacturing you have product liability insurance.

Re: Ideas brought to companies

#18

Re: the purpose of patents

Robert W

>Chuck - you have to be more realistic in your expectations. Because it is a good idea to you, it simply may not mean much to them. It may be brilliant, but Penn State in particular is making money hand over fist with their product line as it is.

Product development, protection of ideas, production requirements, marketing times and strategies, manufacturing, and many other things just scratch the logistics of putting a product on the market. To be frank about it, I really think you may be personalizing this as they may just feel like they have better things to do than to interface with you and listen to you pitch your product.

How many requests do you think they get a week for someone that believes they have the key to a successful product? Granted, it would be nice to be treated nicely by everyone you deal with, but as the man says, "it ain't happenin".

As a self employed woodworking/remodeling/repair contractor, I deal with this so much I even have a name for it. I tell my contracting friends that my potential clients that won't respond to my contact efforts as "high school girls". Remember when you were in high school and you called a girl and she never called you back? She was nice to your face, but when you called her again, she still never called you back. You were supposed to understand that if she didn't respond she wasn't interested. It was an unwritten code. So now when one of my amigos asks me about a job he knew I was bidding, I tell him the clients were "hogh school girls" if they hide from me or just don't respond.

For all of my years in business, 97% of my clients that don't do business with me let me know they aren't interested by simply not returning my calls, ignoring my emails and my voice messages. They were happy as could be for me to take a few hours to inspect things, pass on ideas, then draw up a detailed estimate spelling out materials, methods, and costs. Once they have it *poof* I only hear from them with other questions or if they are ready to go.

People are inconsiderate. And for the most part, a hard lesson for me to learn was that they really don't OWE me the time of day. And just because your project is important to you doesn't mean it will be or should be to someone else. Another lesson learned the hard way by me.

My priorities simply aren't important to others.

Good luck, and I sincerely mean it. For the small guy, this has to be a labor of love as you may never see a cent. I have a plumber friend that invented a very clever multi wrench, and from start to finish, it took him about 7 years to get it into production. He is personally out about $350,000 (I believe him, too) and more time than can be counted. To get this this re-engineered to make it manufacturing friendly cost a bundle, to get all the patents filed, then when changed, refiled, cost another bundle. Worse, he had to take Home Depot to court as they started selling a Chinese knockoff (I was the one that found it and took one to him) to get them off the shelves. It was cheap. That only cost about $50,000 or so according to him for the attorneys to take them to the proper courts. Good for HD, when they figured out what was going on, they pulled the product immediately. However, they didn't want his as it didn't match their price point.

He now owns about 5% or so of his own idea, and he is now getting regular checks from it. But $70 for this wrench set, he actually figures he will never make his money back.

He learned a lot about rejection, the legal system, manufacturing, engineering, lying, liars, idea theft, and all manner of other things. In the end, he wishes he had just put the time in his company, which suffered pretty hard while he was on his quest.

Robert

Re: Ideas brought to companies

#19

you are right...more on patents

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Companies frequently get "unsolicited ideas". A company should have a process for dealing with this kind of communication. A reputable company will have a process that protects both parties....both parties??? Yes.

The deep pockets company doesn't want a person to claim 5 years from now that this person provided the idea for something that the company is selling for $10 million a year. And the person with the idea doesn't want a company to steal it. To avoid legal battles over good ideas - two classics are the idea for intermittent windshield wipers and another for quick release socket wrenches- a well managed company will have in place a process for dealing with these unsolicited ideas. It may involve suggesting the idea holder get legal aid and a patent or copyright. Lawyers that know what they are doing then deal with one another to sell the idea so nobody gets screwed.

Once by strange circumstances I was involved in the sale of a company. Several million was subtracted from the price because the ideas of the company had not been properly protected. I was boggled by the complexity of the business-legal details. It was a good lesson of when it involves money a good lawyer is a good investment.

Not nice companies would blow you off or steal your idea.

Re: Ideas brought to companies

#20

Re: the purpose of patents

Chuck in ND

>Thanks Robert, although maybe a little harsh, you definatly drove the point home, sometimes thats what it takes. I guess what really got to me is after Mr Levi seen a picture, then wants measurements, and then takes off like a theft in the night instead of saying he wasn't interested is what really got to me. I'm glad I decided not to expose all of it. But thats ok, if thats the way he wants to run his bussiness, I say good luck. I certainly won't be one to promote it for him or buy anything from him.

Re: Ideas brought to companies

#21

Re: the purpose of patents

Howard Norman

>Chuck, back in my working years I was employed by a large electronics firm in Phoenix, AZ. We had a very rigid policy of not looking at any unsolicited ideas that were presented to us unless they were patented. All unsolicited items were returned. I know that this was not unique to my former employer but it was not universally followed by others in the industry. I spent several years on the internal patent review board which reviewed all internal patent applications and got to know some of the patent lawyers very well.

In your case it may well be that the gentleman at Penn State just has been to busy to get back to you. Unless it is sole responsibility to review outside product ideas I would think that is a good possibility.

Re: Ideas brought to companies

#22

Re: the purpose of patents

Bob S

>You are right on the money Robert, I have done product design in the past as a consultant and more than once the people I was working for lost large sums of money trying to get their great ideas manufactured. Some even lost their companies to other more business savvy investors that came in to save the day. I tell people that come to me with brilliant tool ideas wanting me to do the design work in exchange for a piece of the pie that I will happily do the design work for money but have no interest in ownership. Unfortunately most do not have enough money to really cover all of the costs involved with product development: protection, design, prototyping, tooling, etc.

As was stated earlier, just because one person thinks a new tool design is wonderful doesn't make it wonderful.

Bob

Re: Ideas brought to companies

#23

Re: the purpose of patents

Chuck in ND

>Howard, I thought of that too, but really, if I sent you an e:mail how long would it take you to send a simple reply stateing that you atleast got it after you opened it ? I waited for almost a week before I called. I wasn't rude, I fiqured maybe by some freak coincedence the guy was on vacation, or had family bussiness going on. But after that the same thing happened, no replies back. I'd allways have to call. I expected a little more consideration for other people. Maybe I'm wrong, but thats not the way I was brought up.

Re: Ideas brought to companies

#24

Re: the purpose of patents

Chuck in ND

>Thats true Bob, I believe in what I have done, I worked very hard on it for a long time, even going the extra mile of listening to what others wanted and adding to it. I'll admit that it's been a tough sell, some people just plain don't get it, or don't want to spend the money, or as many woodworkers are, would rather make it themselves even if it takes them 40 hours to make a $40 product. I'm guilty of it myself. But I think there are people out there with money too, who's keeping SawStop, Festool, etc alive ?

Re: Ideas brought to companies

#25

Re: Ideas brought to companies

Joseph Mulherin, Sr.

>Chuck, I know that. I have a degree in BusMgmt and Acctng. and was in const. for 35yrs too. My gripe was, and is, that this nation has funds to spend to help other countries and people but nothing for its own citizens when they ask for help. I was not intending on getting and not returning the funds....had it all planned to return the funds when the operation got going good so others could have them to start their own businesses. I had all the items listed for opening a business including Insurances....you see, my son is in Insurance so I was well covered that way with his knowledge.