Re: the purpose of patents
Robert W
>Chuck - you have to be more realistic in your expectations. Because it is a good idea to you, it simply may not mean much to them. It may be brilliant, but Penn State in particular is making money hand over fist with their product line as it is.
Product development, protection of ideas, production requirements, marketing times and strategies, manufacturing, and many other things just scratch the logistics of putting a product on the market. To be frank about it, I really think you may be personalizing this as they may just feel like they have better things to do than to interface with you and listen to you pitch your product.
How many requests do you think they get a week for someone that believes they have the key to a successful product? Granted, it would be nice to be treated nicely by everyone you deal with, but as the man says, "it ain't happenin".
As a self employed woodworking/remodeling/repair contractor, I deal with this so much I even have a name for it. I tell my contracting friends that my potential clients that won't respond to my contact efforts as "high school girls". Remember when you were in high school and you called a girl and she never called you back? She was nice to your face, but when you called her again, she still never called you back. You were supposed to understand that if she didn't respond she wasn't interested. It was an unwritten code. So now when one of my amigos asks me about a job he knew I was bidding, I tell him the clients were "hogh school girls" if they hide from me or just don't respond.
For all of my years in business, 97% of my clients that don't do business with me let me know they aren't interested by simply not returning my calls, ignoring my emails and my voice messages. They were happy as could be for me to take a few hours to inspect things, pass on ideas, then draw up a detailed estimate spelling out materials, methods, and costs. Once they have it *poof* I only hear from them with other questions or if they are ready to go.
People are inconsiderate. And for the most part, a hard lesson for me to learn was that they really don't OWE me the time of day. And just because your project is important to you doesn't mean it will be or should be to someone else. Another lesson learned the hard way by me.
My priorities simply aren't important to others.
Good luck, and I sincerely mean it. For the small guy, this has to be a labor of love as you may never see a cent. I have a plumber friend that invented a very clever multi wrench, and from start to finish, it took him about 7 years to get it into production. He is personally out about $350,000 (I believe him, too) and more time than can be counted. To get this this re-engineered to make it manufacturing friendly cost a bundle, to get all the patents filed, then when changed, refiled, cost another bundle. Worse, he had to take Home Depot to court as they started selling a Chinese knockoff (I was the one that found it and took one to him) to get them off the shelves. It was cheap. That only cost about $50,000 or so according to him for the attorneys to take them to the proper courts. Good for HD, when they figured out what was going on, they pulled the product immediately. However, they didn't want his as it didn't match their price point.
He now owns about 5% or so of his own idea, and he is now getting regular checks from it. But $70 for this wrench set, he actually figures he will never make his money back.
He learned a lot about rejection, the legal system, manufacturing, engineering, lying, liars, idea theft, and all manner of other things. In the end, he wishes he had just put the time in his company, which suffered pretty hard while he was on his quest.
Robert