Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Bowed lumber

Posts

Bowed lumber

#1

Bowed lumber

Larry in NW Ohio

>I got some lumber from Frank Miller Lumber a few weeks ago. All QSWO with a lot of beautiful Flacks, can`t wait to put a finish on it.Anyway I had to splitabout 30 pieces to make slate for a baby bed, and every one of them bowed outward. What causes this and is there anything I can do to prevent this? TIA Larry in Ohio

Re: Bowed lumber

#2

Re: Bowed lumber

Barry Irby

>Larry, I'm having a little trouble tracking what you are saying.

Did you resaw pieces to make Slats for a baby bed? I'm guessing these are the slats or pickets in the railings?

Anyway, if you received them and they were not completely dry they would have been prone to warp. The idea is that the surface is dryer than the interior. If this is the case, I suppose you could have let them "rest" in your house or shop for a while to finish drying and acclimate before you resawed them.

Not sure what you can do now that they are warped. Having made them half as thick or less, I doubt there is enough wood left to straighten them with a jointer as you would in "stock prep".

Re: Bowed lumber

#3

Re: Bowed lumber

Dick Coers

>White oak is difficult to dry, quarter-sawn white oak is really difficult. I would return it because it is either wet in the center or has drying stresses.

Re: Bowed lumber

#4

Re: Bowed lumber

Keith Newton, LR, Arkansas------WebKitFormBoundary

>I am afraid that this is one of the traits of QS oak lumber. I wish I knew precisely what is happening to cause it. The best I can offer is to just count on it, and cut oversize, then straighten it afterwards.

Re: Bowed lumber

#5

Dale Lenz

Re: Bowed lumber

Dale Lenz

>Hi Larry,

Sorry to hear of your wood problems. By the wood bowing outwards I presume your saying the lumber sticks are doing this: ). Could be moisture imbalance, or more than likely stress built up in the "mother" board cause from one to several reasons. Bottom line: I'd take your curved piece back to the lumber dealer and see if they will make allowance.

Good luck

Re: Bowed lumber

#6

Steam bend?

Pat Evans

>I have never done this, but perhaps some of the experts out there can tell you. Is it possible to steam bend the slats in the opposite direction of the warp in order to straighten them?

Re: Bowed lumber

#7

stress from drying is likely cause, explanation

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>When lumber deforms promptly upon sawing or planing it is a result of stress in the lumber. Most likely that stress developed during the drying process either because of poor kiln management or bad luck. Even with the best practical management there will be that occasion region of the kiln or maverick board that will develop stress.

There is no practical fix for this first problem once you get the lumber home. It could have been fixed by steaming the kiln charge at the end of the drying cycle. Most large kilns do post drying steaming now days. You may be able to negotiate an exchange of stressed lumber for some that isn't. In my opinion this problem is a drying defect that should be rectified by the seller but they don't always see it my way.

Moisture regain or loss after cutting or planing can also deform a board but this process will not be as quick(hours to days) as that resulting from stress relief. (thats stress relief of the board. the board's owner gains stress in these situations)

Re: Bowed lumber

#8

Re: moisture imbalance also plausible

Dave Mount

>Hey Bill--

I don't disagree that drying stress is a likely cause here, but I believe moisture imbalance is also plausible as I have observed for myself. Your statement that instant distortion is not likely moisture-related assumes the lumber is well equilibrated to its environment. If that's the case, then I agree that instant distortion is a sign of drying-related stress.

However, I store air-dried lumber in unheated buildings and then bring it into the shop to equilibrate before using it. On a couple occasions I have resawn lumber after only a day or two in the shop (in the winter, when the RH/EMC in the shop is low) and have had the resawn parts spring right off the saw. In this case, I believe the cause was the outer part of the lumber being drier than the core because of inadequate equilibration time at the lower RH in the shop. My primary evidence for this explanation is that after 2-3 days additional time in the shop, most of the initial deformation was lost; if the cause had been drying stress, I don't think the situation would have improved with time. The opposite deformation (cupping inward instead of outward) could happen with KD lumber brought into an unheated shop with higher RH/EMC.

The situation I describe results not from improper drying per se, but from inadequate equilibration of properly dried wood. I have no idea whether this could have been the case for the original poster.

Best,

Dave

Re: Bowed lumber

#9

interesting data, more discussion

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>You describe a situation I never considered. In the situation you describe, indeed the lumber would be under temporary stress in that the outside would be compressing the wetter core. However, unlike the case where this situation is set up on initial drying of the lumber and leads to tensile stress in the end, in this case the temporary compression stress is relaxed as the core dries.

Never-the-less, instant (seconds) bowing is still a result of stress within the lumber however it got there- drying issues, or in rare cases stress in the original tree.

The other case that people question is cupping and bowing that occurs in hours or days. This deformation is most likely a result of moisture regain or loss not being equal. It could be caused by "wet" lumber drying more on one side than the other or "dry" lumber gaining more moisture on one side or another.

Re: Bowed lumber

#10

Re: Bowed lumber,more info

Larry in NW Ohio

>I`m going to try and post THIS post again, I tried to post it a couple hours ago, but I got lost somewhere. If anyone finds me floating out in siberspace somewhere just grab ahold of me and put me where I belong. As i tried to say in that post, whenI got the lumber I put it in my basement and took a reading of MC and it was somewhere below 6%, as my meter dosen`t go below 6%. I guess I`ll need to invest in another meter. Also it was in the basement for over two weeks waiting ing line to be used, being very pataint. I must say thatQSWO behaves very well. I think tomorrow I`ll try a different piece of wood and see what it does. THANKS TO EVERYONE WHO TRYING TO FIGURE THIS OUT for me. Thanks again. Larry in Ohio

Re: Bowed lumber

#11

spend your money on lumber not a meter

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Moisture meters are one of the least useful thing a woodworker can spend money on. Meters are not very accurate at low moisture levels, as you recently found out with your meter. Lumber would have left a reputable mill at 7% MC or maybe a bit more. The typical basement would not have removed moisture. A different meter would not have done much better. If for some unique reason you need to determine Moisture content at low levels then buy a scale so that you can do the determination gravimetrically. The scale will be multitasking and useful for postage calculation, baking and mixing sheep deworming medicine.

Re: Bowed lumber

#12

Man I wish there was an edit button

Keith Newton, LR, Arkansas------WebKitFormBoundary

>While it clearly says BOW above, my mind was thinking crook. It would be pretty hard for a QS board to bow away from the heart since the heart would be off of one edge. My bad.

What I was referring to, and see pretty often when I am sawing out on the mill, is that a lot of the QS boards take a crook away from the heart. They stay flat, but the edges take a curve.

Maybe I better check my saw if nobody else sees this happening.

Re: Bowed lumber

#13

I see the same

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>While we seldom purposely bought QS lumber but occasionally a piece would show up in a pack and it was not uncommon for this piece, especially in oak, to be crooked away from the pith (center). I always assumed this deflection occurred during drying, but you are saying it happens right off the saw. And you are right, these boards stay flat, but the crook can be a couple of inches on a 12' piece.

Re: Bowed lumber

#14

Re: spend your money on lumber not a meter

Larry in NW Ohio

>Thanks Bill I`ll do that. Lumber is pretter than a meter anyway. Thanks to all. Larry in Ohio

Re: Bowed lumber

#15

IMO, get lumber and a meter

John K Jordan

>The relative value of owning a meter is not a constant for all circumstances and persons.

I certainly would not have bought a (pinless) meter if it dented my hobby budget or took food off the table, but it didn't and I did and I use it quite often. I check wood air drying outside by the sawmill, air drying in the barn, and pieces turning wood in bins and shelves in the shop. Once when buying a bunch of lumber both the "yeah, it's kiln dried" claim and the price changed when I pulled the meter out of my pocket.

I usually don't care about the exact moisture reading, but it sure is nice to pick up two pieces suitable for a project and in 10 seconds be able to choose the one with lower moisture.

JKJ

Re: Bowed lumber

#16

Dale Lenz

Re: IMO, get lumber and a meter

Dale Lenz

>Agree with you John. I purchase my lumber from mills, hopefully off the saw. Dry outdoor, when it gets to 12-15%, move inside and dry to < 10%, move it to the lumber loft. Really don't like to guess. If I purchased all of my lumber from kiln dried lumber yards, my meter might collect a lot of dust. Use the meter 1-3 times/year. Good investment for me. To say a wood moisture meter is not worth having is nuts! Depends on who you are and what you do.