Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Did dealer sell me a USED jointer?!?

Posts

Did dealer sell me a USED jointer?!?

#1

Did dealer sell me a USED jointer?!?

Dan Mitchell

>I bought a General 80-100 jointer from an area Woodcraft. When I got it home, I noticed the main box was taped shut only, no staples.

Uh-oh.

Opened the main box, the jointer assembly (top portion with bed & fence) is sitting in the styrofoam with no bag around it, and the area beneath the cutters is full of saw dust. Now, I'm about 99% sure this indicates a USED unit, but I want to check before I go ballistic with these people that General (or anyone else, for that matter) does not "test" jointers at the factory prior to shipment. I had a Delta some time back & don't recall this being the case with it.

Anyone have any comments?

Thanks

Dan

Re: Did dealer sell me a USED jointer?!?

#2

I'd say it's used

Nat Robison

>I haven't purchased a lot of machinery in my life but I would vote that it's used. I can't imagine even if the machine were test run that they would leave sawdust in it.

When I bought a new Ridgid jointer, everything was encased in styrofoam and shrink-wrapped in plastic. All of the cast iron was coated with a petroleum-based coating as well.

Re: Did dealer sell me a USED jointer?!?

#3

Re: Did dealer sell me a USED jointer?!?

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Evening Dan,

I BELIEVE YOU DID GET A USED JOINTER. I would recommend you contact the supplier and apprise them of the sawdust you found. I don't see how your machine couldn't be "used". I would ask them to price adjust for a used machine, or take it back altogether for a full refund. My jointer is now a few years old,m and if I cleaned it up, I'm sure it could pass for new. Good as it may look, its dishonest to represent it as new. If it works perfectly, then a price adjustment is in everybody's best interest. But I would not settle for being duped.

George

Re: Did dealer sell me a USED jointer?!?

#4

Good advice

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>

Re: Did dealer sell me a USED jointer?!?

#5

They do test jointers before they ship them.

Forrest Addy

>Are all the parts present and properly packages in the right places? You say a bag is missing? Is that important? Not to say you can't use this as a club to bludgeon a price reduction but understand that machinery has to be tested before shipment.

Seems to me it would be foolish NOT to test the machine before they ship. If the machine had had enough use to show wear on the parts that's another thing entirely but a little residual sawdust is to me only evidence of a final test. If they don't get all the sawdust out so what? It aint like it was a hamburger or a pair of shoes.

Re: Did dealer sell me a USED jointer?!?

#6

Re: Did dealer sell me a USED jointer?!?

Dick Coers

>According to their webiste, you have 90 days to be satisfied. Shouldn't be any trouble getting satisfaction from them.

Re: Did dealer sell me a USED jointer?!?

#7

Re: Did dealer sell me a USED jointer?!?

Dan Mitchell

>Thanks for the replies. Yup, it's used. Went out & took a closer look, one of the blades is nicked. I don't think this was intentional deception, just bungling. Called them & reported the situation, they offered me the top off the floor model, supposedly the only other one they have. No thanks. For 50 bucks off, maybe. Paid for new in box, expect new in box. I asked how long it would take to get another, 2-3 weeks.

I think I'll just return it.

So now, after I thought I'd finally figured out which jointer/from where, I'm back in the market again.

PITA

Dan

Re: Did dealer sell me a USED jointer?!?

#8

A different used item from General

marc rosen

>Hey, I'm not trying to start a "Pick on General" thread here, but I ordered a ceiling mount blade guard/dust collector through one of my local woodworking shops at a show in January. It arrived in February and when I got it home I noticed that the box had been resealed. The hose manifold/bracket asembly was brand new but the guard unit itself - though not covered with sawdust - show a lot of use, as if it were someone's display model. Paint was chipped, there were wear marks at pivot points, and one part was missing.

I decided to take it back to the dealer (Skarie) to show them and they offered to get a new unit which would take a few weeks. I spied their display unit which was in perfect shape and asked if we could swap pieces, which they agreed.

Anyway, although a blade guard is a small ticket item compared to a jointer I think this is not the way a company should be conducting business.

Marc

Re: Did dealer sell me a USED jointer?!?

#9

Re: Did dealer sell me a USED jointer?!?

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>Let me make sure I understand this clearly. A) You have a top of the line, gorgeous General jointer setting in your shop B) You are returning it because it has a nick on the blade and some sawdust in it and is missing a plastic bag and you think perhaps you are not the first owner. C) Now you are going to return it and settle for something that's probably not as good as this General.

This is just my opinion, but my opinion is that if I was fortunate enough to actually buy a GENERAL jointer I would be thrilled to death with it. Words simply could not describe the feeling I would have. Apparently you have always had plenty and do not know how to apreciate something like this when you have it.

Re: Did dealer sell me a USED jointer?!?

#10

Nothing to do with General

Bri in Mtl

>I don't see what this has to do with General. Both yours and Dan's problem appear due to your dealer's screwup.

Re: Did dealer sell me a USED jointer?!?

#11

Re: Nothing to do with General

Chuck W

>I agree. Likely a don't care attitude on the dealer's part. What they should have done is mark down the price on the jointer and let you decide if you wish to buy it or not. The customer will weigh the hassle needed to return the item and probably just decide to keep it.

Re: Did dealer sell me a USED jointer?!?

#12

Re: Another Perspective on "used"

albertabob

>Recently we have been opening, inspecting and often running equipment before we package and ship it.

The reasons are two fold:

First the packaging and QC at many of our suppliers seems to be getting less thorough than it used to be 5 years ago.

Secondly, we seem to be dealing with a new consumer that has no stomach for reading the instructions or following them.

This results often in unreasonalble phone calls and demands resulting directly from not undertanding what they purchased or how to properly use it.

So we test before shipping.

The customer gets a "used" machine " that we know is working properly an has no defects.

We do put a note in the package to explain why we do this.

You will have to take my word for it but it happens more than most of you think.

You would be surprised at how many returns we get that are improperly repackaged by the cusomer demanding a full refund and then having a scenario like this one to deal with subquently.

It's tough to go all the way over to China for a new "plastic bag" because the customer didn't bother to replace it when he changed his mind about the purchase.

Or he ran a board through it with a nail in it and said nothing!

Cheers

Bob

Re: Did dealer sell me a USED jointer?!?

#13

chech the bed and knives

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>If the machine has been used more than a test pass or two, either at the factory or perhaps a demo in the store, then there will be obvious wear on some portion of the knives and the bed will have scratches or burnish marks. If you can not tell that there is any difference in the sharpness of the knives across their length then I would judge the jointer new for any practical purpose.

Monday I would call General and ask them about the shavings. I suspect that they have an excellent customer service line.

My Powermatic Planer came with someone's lunch bag and remains packed in it. Stuff happens.

Re: Did dealer sell me a USED jointer?!?

#14

Re: Nothing to do with General

Joseph Mulherin, Sr.

>Dan, I would at least have the dealer give you a new set of blades. As albertabob states, they do test their machines before sending off to customers to try to eliminate problems, but as others have said it is probably a dealer's mistake and just trying to make a sale....get new blades from them or General.

Re: Did dealer sell me a USED jointer?!?

#15

The Bigger Fear ?

Mark McC

>Sounds like you are done with this Used Item...which I think is wise. If you did keep it, even at a discount,I think the bigger fear is never knowing what the real reason was for the return

If the dealer knew it was only a knicked knife...$20 bucks makes it new for him again to hold its value. But the fact that the dealer tried to hide it or at least didn't mention that it was returned, brings his credibility into question.

Why put up with that?...we all spend allot of time considering major tool purchases..dont need that kinda BS.

My General was not pre tested, not opened or taped, full of sawdust,and not missing anything....looked like I was the first person to open it up since it was packaged and shipped.

Re: Did dealer sell me a USED jointer?!?

#16

Re: Nothing to do with General

marc rosen

>Hello Brian,

I can not agree with you as the box I got from my dealer was opened and resealed before it arrived at my dealer. My mention of the double taping was to explain that it had been opened sometime between leaving a warehouse and arriving locally. My dealer did not open it to inspect it and should not have to.

Marc (who wants to reiterate that I am not picking on General, just stating my own anecdote)

Re: Did dealer sell me a USED jointer?!?

#17

Re: Yep, it's used.

Brian in Brighton

>Probably returned from another purchaser, but who knows why. When I got my jointer it was covered in cosmoline and needed a LOT of cleaning. If this is not the case and you have wood chips in the machine I would argue that it is used. I would also argue that no manufacturer tests their jointers before shipping. I say this as I have never seen a machine come out of the box ready to go.

Brian in Brighton

Re: Did dealer sell me a USED jointer?!?

#18

Re: new knives and a discount!

Chuck W

>I would ask the reason why it was returned. The dealer should have the answer. If they provide new knives and a discount(at least $100 for your trouble) and there machine is otherwise in perfect condition then keep it. But the fundamental thing is you paid for a NEW machine not a RETURNED and USED machine. This is where the dealer messed up and he should make it all right for you, the most important piece of the equation.

Re: Did dealer sell me a USED jointer?!?

#19

Re: Another Perspective on "used"

Dan Mitchell

>"It's tough to go all the way over to China for a new "plastic bag" because the customer didn't bother to replace it when he changed his mind about the purchase. Or he ran a board through it with a nail in it and said nothing!"

I can see that happening, and shame on the customer who pulls such a thing. I think though it is incumbent upon the dealer to inspect every return both to protect himself and any later buyers.

Dan

Re: Did dealer sell me a USED jointer?!?

#20

Re: The Bigger Fear ?

Dan Mitchell

>"Sounds like you are done with this Used Item...which I think is wise. If you did keep it, even at a discount,I think the bigger fear is never knowing what the real reason was for the return

If the dealer knew it was only a knicked knife...$20 bucks makes it new for him again to hold its value. But the fact that the dealer tried to hide it or at least didn't mention that it was returned, brings his credibility into question.

Why put up with that?...we all spend allot of time considering major tool purchases..dont need that kinda BS.

My General was not pre tested, not opened or taped, full of sawdust,and not missing anything....looked like I was the first person to open it up since it was packaged and shipped. "

Mark-You have exactly summed up my feelings. Who knows why the machine was returned. Could be a new set of knives is all it needs, could be the tables are irrepairably out of alignment, or something else more serious. This is an item I will have for a long time. Seems like these days there is enough difficulty getting a NEW machine where all the castings are true, etc. Why risk the further unknowns of something like this, subjected to who knows what, and for full price to boot?

Dan

Re: Did dealer sell me a USED jointer?!?

#21

Re: Yep, it's used.

Dan Mitchell

>"When I got my jointer it was covered in cosmoline and needed a LOT of cleaning."

A very good point, I was actually thinking about this task on the way home, since it's something I always hate doing.

I agree, it would be too cumbersome for the factory to test each jointer, then measure the results, do adjustment if needed, etc. Imagine what the bloody things would cost then! They take a far easier route - leave the testing to US! ;-)

Dan

Re: Did dealer sell me a USED jointer?!?

#22

Re: Did dealer sell me a USED jointer?!?

Dan Mitchell

>You're kidding, right? I PAID for a NEW jointer. It's not like I got a discount, or knowingly bought used. You actually mean to tell me you'd have NO PROBLEM with paying FULL PRICE and getting something which is used and damaged?

This is probably someone's return. The saw dust & knives are just the conditions I can see without pulling the top out, setting it up, etc. Who knows WHY it was returned, or exactly WHAT had been done to it beforehand.

Suppose it was a new car that arrived with a dented fender & 5,000 miles on the odometer, or a washing machine that was supposed to be new and was delivered with someone's last load still inside. You're saying you'd just keep the item, and feel privileged to do so?!?

As to whether or not I've "always had plenty and do not know how to apreciate something like this when you have it", you don't know what you're talking about.

Like I said, you've got to be kidding.

Dan

Re: Did dealer sell me a USED jointer?!?

#23

Re: Did dealer sell me a USED jointer?!?

Barry Irby

>Dan, I have to agree with you on this.

Times are tough for me, again, and if I paid the money for a new General Jointer, I would want a new one. OTOH, if I got a slightly used one at a decent discount and with a new set of knives, I might be pretty happy with it. I have bought several tools that were not virgins, but I knew what I was getting.

I talked to them at the local Borg about a tool that had been returned and his advice I should shun it. They explained that they have a lot of tools that people buy and use for the job at hand and then return it for a full refund. Either broken or not, but certainly with some wear on it.

If General jointers were rare and collectible I might think about this. But they make more everyday.

If I were going to accept it even at a discount I would expect the discount to be enough to pay me for my time to set it up, change the knives and check it out.

I did see a label on my planer that said there might be some shavings in it because they test run them at the factory. But they did not nick the knives.

Re: Did dealer sell me a USED jointer?!?

#24

Thanks Barry, agree completely

Dan Mitchell

>

Re: Did dealer sell me a USED jointer?!?

#25

Re: Another Perspective on "used"

albertabob

>Dan that's the reason we will run up a tool before it leaves us.

We don't want the disappointment for the customer over something we can fix in seconds.

It used to be called "customer service".

Bob