>I'm looking for a good way to treat nail holes in old wood so I can reinsert the same sized nails.
I'm repairing and rebuilding a saddle that was run over with a tractor. (!!) The frame (the "tree") is made of wood (pine and y.poplar) and nails were used to hold it together as well as to hold all the leather in place. Although I will use screws in some places, for critical alignment of some components I see an advantage to reusing the same nail holes. However, the nails must be tight and must not work out over years of use, or it can cause a problem for the skin of the horse or the rider!
In the past I've applied glue to "plugs" and hammered them into nail holes.
I thought about injecting something such as a glue into each nail hole to reduce the diameter some so the nail will grip. I think epoxy would be too hard. Is there some product that will soak into the wood and swell the fibers and remain somewhat flexible but tough?
What about that stuff used to tighten chair rungs, Chair-Loc? Will that work?
>by some who have used it that it loosens after a time because the liquid that causes the swelling does not cause it to stay swelled over time. I personally wouldn't use it for anything I wanted to last. I certainly wouldn't use it on customer's chairs and furniture although I know some "professionals" who do.
>John, I have been using CA glue in any screw hole which I think needs to be fortified, and I really like the results I am getting. I am not suggesting gluing the fastener in, rather saturate the hole, then use a new fastener after the glue has made a new plug.
Although, I am not sure that you could drive a nail into the new altered hole without drilling a new pilot hole. Why not just use screws?
>When I need to re-insert screws in worn out holes, I put some glue on a toothpick or two, put it in the whole then replace the screw. I would imagine this would work for nails as well.
Gary: the story is a friend had saddles in the bucket of his tractor - his wife was driving with a bit too much spirit and one new saddle bounced out and ended up halfway under the wheel of the tractor before she got stopped. They called it the John Deere saddle. The tree and cantle ware broken in several places, the pommel broken completely in two, and the leather ripped. I decided to try to fix it, mostly for the experience to learn how saddles are constructed. It's been a real education so far - just removing all the layers of leather was a challenge.
Keith: I am using screws for in many places, especially where strength is critical. However, there are places where nails must hold leather tightly and screws would not be practical - to reuse the same leather I think the best choice here is to put nails back through the same holes in the leather. There are also a few places where it would be helpful to reuse the same nail holes to maintain critical alignment. I understand the shape of the tree is critical and any deviation may hurt the horse and make the saddle unusable.
Ellis: I'm looking for some ring shank nails of the proper size - I found some that may work if I cut a bit off the end and reshape the point. The wood is quite thin in places so the nail length is critical. The saddle used five different sizes of nails.
I'm experimenting with various glues - the flexible epoxy sounds interesting, not only to fill and strengthen nail holes but to fill some voids. The saddle maker had used some kind of plaster (looks like wall plaster to me) to fill many gaps and to shape fillets and curves under the leather. Epoxy may work better for voids and I'm thinking of trying bondo for the fillets.
I hesitate to use the sliver of wood method in the nail holes since the wood is thin, dry, and brittle and I'm afraid of splitting. I'm also trying the woodturner's trick of saturating some weaker areas with CA glue - that seems promising.
Just for fun, I've attached a picture of some of the nails I removed from this saddle, followed by pictures of the disassembled pieces.
>Maybe underlayment nails would work for you? They're little ring shanks. Where you need a filler like bondo you may want to try Abatron's structural epoxy and putty. It mixes like body filler but is meant for wood and can take some serious abuse. I've done a number of historic home restorations using this stuff when the situation called for it.
I didn't know about underlayment nails, at least by that name, but looked them up. They may do the trick in some spots (there were 5 different sizes used). I found 5 and 50lb quantities on-line - I'll look for smaller quantities. I looked the other day for ring shank nails but didn't find the right sizes.
The Abatron structural epoxy looks great. I remember reading about that once. Do you have a favorite supplier? I don't need a large quantity.
I finished all the glueups today and am assembling some of the wooden pieces with screws. A saddle repair guy stopped by today and suggested I cover the wood in fiberglass instead of the original goat skin.
>Home Depot and Lowe's sell underlayment nails in 1 lb boxes, at least around here. HD also had two different sizes at one point too.
I buy the structural epoxy directly from Abatron (see link). The only thing you have to do with either their structural epoxy or consolidant is to let is sit for 10 or 15 minutes before you apply it (it's in the directions). If you don't, it stays tacky. You can also thin the consolidant with MEK (nasty stuff) if you need it to flow better. Hope this helps.