Re: New Finishing thread
ScottS
>I am far from being a finishing expert, but I have completed a several projects using solid cherry, cherry plywood, and wipe-on polyurethane. Here's what seems to work for me:
1) I've been using an oil-based polyurethane specifically formulated for wiping. I've heard that you can make your own wiping poly by diluting 1:1 with mineral spirits. I wasn't up for any chemistry experiments, so I just grabbed a couple of cans of wiping poly from my local woodworking shop. Might have been Watco brand; I forget.
2) I sand the surfaces to 220 or 320 grit before finishing. I want the wood to feel smooth and I don't want to see any scratches when I shine a raking light across the surface to be finished.
3) The first coat I treat almost like a Danish Oil: I flood the wiping poly onto the wood, spread it around gently with a wiping pad (= old T-shirt wadded into a ball), and let it sit. The wood will often soak up the poly like a sponge at this point. As I see areas drying, I wipe on more finish. When I get tired of waiting, usually after about 5 or 10 minutes, I wipe off any excess poly.
4) I have trouble keeping my wiping pad loaded with finish when I'm working on large surfaces. For something like a cabinet or bookcase, I'll pour a thin line of finish across the middle of the piece perpendicular to the direction I plan to wipe. Of course, I'll also "charge" the pad with finish before I start wiping. I run the pad across the piece in long, slightly overlapping strokes. The finish I've poured on the piece tends to keep the pad loaded. If you pour on too much, you'll see waves of finish getting pushed out of the way of the pad. I've had no problems removing excess finish using a dry pad; just be careful not to push the excess off the side of the piece and have it running down the sides!
5) I find that the finish tends to be very thin near edges, especially the edges where you start and stop the wiping motion. If I'm finishing a large rectangular piece of wood, I'll rotate the wiping direction 90-degrees with each coat. I find that this tends to make the thickness of the finish more consistent at the edges.
6) After 2-3 coats, I'll start to think about sanding between coats. I sand by hand using 320- or 400-grit paper folded into a small square. I sand VERY lightly, ESPECIALLY near the edges of a piece! If the finish wants to gum up rather than sand smoothly, I'll wait another hour before making another attempt. My goal is to scuff the surface a bit to promote adhesion of the next coat and also to keep the surface relatively smooth from start to finish. If the surface is already pretty smooth, I don't do much sanding at all!
7) I'll apply 2-4 coats per day, waiting the manufacturer recommended time between coats. If the surface feels tacky, I wait longer. If I need to sand and the paper gums up, I wait longer. The thicker the coats, the longer you have to wait.
8) I switch from "gloss" to "satin" for the last 2-3 coats, unless I want a really glossy finish. I've also had some success with rubbing out, but it seems like you have to wait quite a while (3-4 weeks minimum) before you can do it successfully.
FYI, my experience suggests that if you use oil-based polyurethane and only oil-based polyurethane you'll probably end up with some blotching. If you don't want blotching you'll probably want to do something to seal the wood before you apply the poly.