Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

New Finishing thread

Posts

New Finishing thread

#1

New Finishing thread

Joanne in Point Pleasant, PA

>Well, it's probably an old thread, but I don't think anyone's asked these questions THIS week!

When we last left our heroine, she was asking those age-old questions about using Waterlox Original as a finish for a cherry kitchen table. Great discussion and answers (thanks everybody!). Out of that thread it was decided that poly would be a better finish to use for such a table. Somebody recommended (Ellis, I think) a coat of gloss followed by a coat or two of satin poly. I haven't used poly in a long time, so I could use some advice from those of you who use it regularly. Here are the questions:

1) Application method--I'm used to wiping shellac or Waterlox. I don't have fond memories of brushing poly. I know it can be wiped on. Can I wipe that on right out of the can? Do I need to thin it with mineral spirits or something? Should I try a brush or foam brush?

2) Sanding between coats--Necessary? What grit or grits? By hand or can I use a ROS? Doesn't it leave scratches?

3) Here's the additional issue--I have a spot or two where I filled a knothole with some stone (Malachite) and epoxy. Can I sand that or will it cloud over?

4) Any other tidbits or caveats your experience says would be helpful to know.

Thanks in advance for your wisdom. (yes, yes, I will post pictures when it's done.)

Re: New Finishing thread

#2

JL

Re: New Finishing thread

JL

>1) I usually thin my polyurethane with mineral spirits and then wipe it on. There are some wipe-on polyurethanes available though. I've never tried a foam applicator with poly, so I can' say anything about that. You do have do a few more coats with wiping it on than you do with a brush.

2) I usually don't sand until after I get a couple of coats on - unless I have some nibs to knock down. After I get a couple of coats on, I typically hit it lightly with 220 or higher grit by hand. I don't use a ROS. It does leave very fine scratches - but these are filled by the next layer of poly.

3) I've used polyurethane over epoxy without problems - but I was using the Loctite 5 minute 2 part stuff - YMMV.

4) Wear gloves - even if you think you don't have to :).

Re: New Finishing thread

#3

Re: New Finishing thread

Hank Knight

>Joanne,

If you use polyurethane that is not designated as a "wipe-on finish," you'll need to thin it substantially. I think the "standard" ratio is 50/50, I.E., half poly, half solvent (usually minaeral spirits). But I don't think the actual ratio is all that important. It needs to be thin enough to wipe on easily and cover completely without having to wipe over the application a second time. Many manufacturers market a product that is designated as "wipe-on polyurethane." It is thinned to a proper consistency that can be wiped on right out of the can.

My recollection is that if oyu recote within 4 hours, sanding between coats is not necessary. But once the application cures for 4 hours or more, you need to sand between coats to (a) get a good, level surface, and (b) insure good adhesion between coats.

All of this is from my memory, which isn't so great anymore. I suggest you search this forum for "wipe on poly" or any other search terms you can think of. Several of the finishing gurus have posted here about how to mix an appropriate wipe-on finish and about sanding between coats.

Hank

Re: New Finishing thread

#4

Re: New Finishing thread

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Joanne,

I agree with Hank. I use naptha for the solvent and mix 50/50 and wipe it on. I start with gloss and finish with either semi gloss or satin. I figure on putting on twice as many diluted coats. I find that it dries faster and nibs don't form as readily. I generally let the finish wait until the next day before repeating. I do level when necessary with a felt pad wrapped with 320 grit paper, lubricated by more naptha and lemon oil--(or even WD-40). Light touch and long strokes., them apply more wiping poly. Wipe clean several times with a clean paper towel dampened with more naptha. Regards to Fred. :<)

George

Re: New Finishing thread

#5

Horrific Spelling - Egads!

Hank Knight

>"oyu recote" should read "you recoat" My apologies. (Slinks away in abject humiliation)

Re: New Finishing thread

#6

Re: Recommend Arm-R-Seal

Dave Mount

>I've been really impressed with General Finishes Arm-R-Seal. It's probably no different than regular poly that's been thinned, but it gives great performance and there's no mixing to fuss around with. I used to thin my own, but I've since decided the few dollars saved is not worth it. I just use Arm-R-Seal right out of the can (jug).

Arm-R-Seal can be used as a wipe-on finish, or it can be flooded on with a foam brush if the surface is flat and level (it will run if you use a foam brush on non-horizontal surfaces). It obviously builds much faster if you can apply more substantial coats on a level surface.

For your table top, apply generous coats with a foam brush. It does not tack very fast, so you have time to lay it on and then smooth it with finishing strokes. You may get some bubbles in early coats, I think it has to do with the roughness of the surface and/or gas escaping from the wood. Regardless, don't fret over it. You can knock off the nibs with some 320 paper between coats, though it's not critical for the early coats. After 2-3 coats (and depending on whether there is an undercoat), the full surface will be saturated to where the finish is starting to build everywhere (early on it is uneven depending on the porosity of the area). At that point, put some 320 grit on your ROS and sand everything smooth. Then lay on 1 or 2 more coats, depending on how much build you want.

Arm-R-Seal levels wonderfully. My wife had some friends over a while back and a couple was admiring our cherry bar. The husband was explaining to his wife how he couldn't produce a finish like that because he didn't have spray equipment. I waited until he was alone to tell him that I didn't either (it was done as above with Arm-R-Seal) -- I didn't want to wreck his excuse for getting a spray gun.

Incidentally, I have an epoxy-filled gum pocket in that cherry bar -- no issues, just treat it as you do the rest of the surface, it comes out crystal clear.

No affiliations, just a very satisfied user.

Dave

Re: New Finishing thread

#7

Re: New Finishing thread

ScottS

>I am far from being a finishing expert, but I have completed a several projects using solid cherry, cherry plywood, and wipe-on polyurethane. Here's what seems to work for me:

1) I've been using an oil-based polyurethane specifically formulated for wiping. I've heard that you can make your own wiping poly by diluting 1:1 with mineral spirits. I wasn't up for any chemistry experiments, so I just grabbed a couple of cans of wiping poly from my local woodworking shop. Might have been Watco brand; I forget.

2) I sand the surfaces to 220 or 320 grit before finishing. I want the wood to feel smooth and I don't want to see any scratches when I shine a raking light across the surface to be finished.

3) The first coat I treat almost like a Danish Oil: I flood the wiping poly onto the wood, spread it around gently with a wiping pad (= old T-shirt wadded into a ball), and let it sit. The wood will often soak up the poly like a sponge at this point. As I see areas drying, I wipe on more finish. When I get tired of waiting, usually after about 5 or 10 minutes, I wipe off any excess poly.

4) I have trouble keeping my wiping pad loaded with finish when I'm working on large surfaces. For something like a cabinet or bookcase, I'll pour a thin line of finish across the middle of the piece perpendicular to the direction I plan to wipe. Of course, I'll also "charge" the pad with finish before I start wiping. I run the pad across the piece in long, slightly overlapping strokes. The finish I've poured on the piece tends to keep the pad loaded. If you pour on too much, you'll see waves of finish getting pushed out of the way of the pad. I've had no problems removing excess finish using a dry pad; just be careful not to push the excess off the side of the piece and have it running down the sides!

5) I find that the finish tends to be very thin near edges, especially the edges where you start and stop the wiping motion. If I'm finishing a large rectangular piece of wood, I'll rotate the wiping direction 90-degrees with each coat. I find that this tends to make the thickness of the finish more consistent at the edges.

6) After 2-3 coats, I'll start to think about sanding between coats. I sand by hand using 320- or 400-grit paper folded into a small square. I sand VERY lightly, ESPECIALLY near the edges of a piece! If the finish wants to gum up rather than sand smoothly, I'll wait another hour before making another attempt. My goal is to scuff the surface a bit to promote adhesion of the next coat and also to keep the surface relatively smooth from start to finish. If the surface is already pretty smooth, I don't do much sanding at all!

7) I'll apply 2-4 coats per day, waiting the manufacturer recommended time between coats. If the surface feels tacky, I wait longer. If I need to sand and the paper gums up, I wait longer. The thicker the coats, the longer you have to wait.

8) I switch from "gloss" to "satin" for the last 2-3 coats, unless I want a really glossy finish. I've also had some success with rubbing out, but it seems like you have to wait quite a while (3-4 weeks minimum) before you can do it successfully.

FYI, my experience suggests that if you use oil-based polyurethane and only oil-based polyurethane you'll probably end up with some blotching. If you don't want blotching you'll probably want to do something to seal the wood before you apply the poly.

Re: New Finishing thread

#8

Why make it .....

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>More difficult than necessary? Oil based poly is always problematic, with the concoctions, timing, sanding, rubbing, then stripping and refinishing. Nature has given us water borne poly floor finishes that are tough enough to walk on, not that you're gonna dance on the table (?), so take advantage of it. It's water white, goes on easily, dries fast for sooner recoats, builds with few coats, rubs out to whatever sheen you want, and no problem to recoat next year if necessary, but necessary is hardly ever.

Clint

Re: New Finishing thread

#10

Why make it... ugly?

ScottS

>I've been wanting to like water-based finishes for a long time. Unfortunately, at least in my hands, they always seem to come out looking dull and lifeless. No matter what I do in terms of coloring the wood, I end up with a gray or bluish tinge that seems to suck the beauty right out of the piece!

I also find WB more difficult to apply than an oil-based finish. Having to raise the grain is an extra step in the finishing process that I'd just as soon avoid. And I've yet to find a WB finish that will self-level before it dries. Which means I spend a LOT of time sanding out all of the brush marks and bubbles that are invariably left after each coat.

If anyone has any hints for solving these problems, I'm all ears!

Re: New Finishing thread

#11

Re: New Finishing thread

geary from nj

>Joanne,maybe David Marks and I are old fashion, But my farmer's table was coated, three years ago, with tung oil over Minwax mahogany and the finish is still gorgeous.(that"s three grandkids' years of play dough,soda,crayons,pastasauce,water paint.....you get the idea) I keep waiting for that distressed look to evolve,but it's just not happening. I hand wiped 6 coats of Fornby's satin, no water marks,no regrets,and I can add coats at any time....Oh yea,rubbed with a wornj out maroon scuffy pad between coats. Good luck in your new trial run.....I'm always chicken to try "new" on a piece that has a lot of time invested in it. Geary

Re: New Finishing thread

#12

Re: 1) Application method

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>When I'm trying to level a finish, I wipe on unthinned Minwax for the first 2 coats. It builds faster. After that, I sand level and apply a few coats of a 25/75 spirits/poly mixture. The last step is to rub out the finish using Wool Lube and Leberon 0000 steel wool and apply a final coat of a 50-50 mix that I wipe on and buff off after 5 minutes or so, depending on temp and humidity.

Re: New Finishing thread

#13

Re: New Finishing thread *LINK*

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

>For wiping on polyurethane, I've used a 50/50 mix of naphtha/poly with good results. You just need to apply a number of coats to get the proper build. I feel that anything applied within about 24 hours does not need to be sanded unless you need to for leveling or nubbies. Adhesion is not an issue within the 24 hour window. I still go over the piece lightly with at least 220 grit before the final application for smoothness.

I've tried Minwax wipe-on poly. While I like the convenience, I dislike the finish. It seems to take forever to get a decent build.

For what it's worth, Michael Dresdner touts his opinion that ANY poly can be wiped on right out of the can. I have yet to try that, but I want to test it sometime. See the link below.


Michael Dresdner's Wipe-it-On Advice