why are you guys so picky about your joints?
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>Let me begin by saying that I have never had a joint fail with KD wood in 30+ years of woodworking. Once I did have a glued up bed post fail with hide glue as a result of one of the 8/4 pieces being wet and drying out and/or bad glue. Dry lumber is a critical issue in making glue joints.
I think a 0.0001 gap would be seen with back lighting. Can you imagine keeping a 4' edge straight to even 0.001" overnight, never mind for a century. There isn't going to be any more force induced on a joint if one were to pull a tiny gap together during clamping than what this joint will see in service as a result of humidity changes.
The proof is in the clamping. If whatever gap you see can be pulled together with modest camp pressure, I consider the gap irrelevant to the in-use strength of the joint.
Now I would agree that a gap so extreme that it takes full clamp pressure to pull it together is unacceptable. And I agree that after gluing there should be no glue line showing. But it sure doesn't take a light-free joint to achieve these criteria.
Vastly more important to success is dry lumber and not out-of-date glue.