Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

joining boards

Posts

joining boards

#1

joining boards

Tomm

>I have had a hard time trying to join the edges of boards to make a table top. I have been woodworking for a long time and I don't think I have ever experienced the trouble I am having now. A retired shop teacher told me I am being too fussy. So I am just curious about how others edge join boards. If you were to edge two four foot boards and hold them to the light before gluing, would you see any daylight between the two boards. Does it matter to have a little light or should they be tight their entire length? Thanks for your comments.

Re: joining boards

#2

Re: joining boards

Steve Schoene

>You shouldn't be able to see the light, unless you have carefully "sprung" the joint with a very small but even concavity between them.

Boards will stay together when joined together without much fussing. But they will show the glue line in many cases. If you can't see the light between them, then you aren't likely to have a visible glue line, just a discontinuity where the grain lines on one board ends and the others begin. That's how good work should be.

Re: joining boards

#3

Re: joining boards

Jesse Cloud

>I agree with Steve. Have you changed jointer knives recently, maybe they are out of kilter....

Re: joining boards

#4

Re: joining boards

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Evening Tomm,

When I examine the unglued joint line, I expect NOT to see any daylight. Not a good thing to make the daylight disappear by cranking in more clamp pressure. Rejoint one of both boards until they mate properly.

George

Re: joining boards

#5

Re: joining boards

Ken Platt (Granby, CT)

>I use the "no light" method to tell when I'm ready to glue. If I see light, I edge-joint both boards together - that way if one is a bit off 90 degrees, the other will be complementary.

I have found to my dismay that long boards can be a bear - it's so easy to end up jointing them a bit convex by putting too much pressure at the beginning of the cut as you compensate for the length of the board hanging off the jointer bed. This was my main impetus to get a bigger jointer, I kept having difficulties with long boards.

Ken

Re: joining boards

#6

Pressure to close the gap remains

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>You should see no daylight between boards. Forcing the boards together when you see daylight puts all that stress into the joint. The amount of force it takes to close the gap is going to be trying to rip the joint apart over the life of the joint or at least a very long time. You should be able to get four foot boards straight edged on a jointer as small as a 6" one if it is properly set up and your techniques is good.

Lee

Re: joining boards

#7

Re: joining boards

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>With a decent blade, the table saw can produce a glue line edge by setting it up to take just a nip.

Clint

Re: joining boards

#8

Re: joining boards

Barry Irby

>The consensus is "no daylight." I agree.

If you can explain exactly what your problem is, maybe one of us can diagnose it and help. If there are fifty ways to leave your lover, there must be at least that many ways to leave daylight in a glue joint.

Re: joining boards

#9

How to eliminate the daylight

Steve Schoene

>I must say I can't conceive of obtaining a no daylight edge joint directly off of a table saw, in part because it is a rare thing directly off of the jointer.

Here's how I was taught. After 4 squaring the boards, I move the Jointer fence near the front for the freshest of edges. The edges are then jointed with as smooth steady motion making particular effort to keep uniform pressure on the boards over the outfeed table just beyond the knives.

Then I clamp one board on edge on the bench and stack boards with light behind. This also makes checking for square edges pretty easy. Inevitably there are one or two places where there are dark places. I mark these with a pencil or chalk. Usually you find a swirl in the grain or other wood defect at that spot. Then I take the offending board, or both boards if no one board is clearly the problem, and lower the board onto the moving jointer for a few inches before and after those locations. If the size of the boards makes that unsafe I do about the same thing with a finely set hand plane. Then I make one more full length pass with the jointer at the ssame depth setting.

Re: joining boards

#10

Re: How to eliminate the daylight

Calvin in Irmo, SC

>One thing which improved my "joint-ability" when making table tops was to alternate face to fence on one board and back to fence on the next. I agree with above obervations--no daylight.

Re: joining boards

#11

Re: joining boards

Jim Dillon

>I agree regarding the "light" criteria especially on relatively short boards 4-5 feet or less. I've also had success with 12 footers using a support, but it is awkward. Another thing I do is mark the entire length of the edge with one swipe of chalk. When this chalk mark is gone, I know that the entire edge has been jointed and I am done. Works for me 8-).

Jim

Re: joining boards

#12

Bart Goldberg

Re: How to eliminate the daylight

Bart Goldberg

>I use my table saw to get a glue line edge all the time - My milling sequence is to first face joint one face, then edge joint on side. I then plane the opposite face using the planer and rip the opposite edge on the table saw. Since the jointed edge and face are on the fence and flat against the table saw respectively, the last edge easily comes out square and parallel to the other surfaces. Never had a problem. In fact, if you joint both edges, you run the risk of not having these edges parallel.

Re: joining boards

#13

yes

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>In answer to your specific question I would expect to see some daylight over 4'. I suppose it would be possible to get a perfect 4' joint but I don't regard it as necessary. Over 4' of length, a 6" wide piece of lumber is quite flexible and it would take but a small clamp force to close a tiny gap. A gap the width of a piece of paper would not concern me.

As I joint I lay the pieces on a flat surface, like the saw table, pushing the edges together as I go. If they look tight in this configuration I then lay the pieces in clamps. If something is not perfect I see if a modest clamp force will pull things together. On a 4' piece it is common to have to fix a joint of two that I judge has too large a gap. It is easy on something as long as 4' to get a convex edge and those I like to correct.

Re: joining boards

#14

why are you guys so picky about your joints?

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Let me begin by saying that I have never had a joint fail with KD wood in 30+ years of woodworking. Once I did have a glued up bed post fail with hide glue as a result of one of the 8/4 pieces being wet and drying out and/or bad glue. Dry lumber is a critical issue in making glue joints.

I think a 0.0001 gap would be seen with back lighting. Can you imagine keeping a 4' edge straight to even 0.001" overnight, never mind for a century. There isn't going to be any more force induced on a joint if one were to pull a tiny gap together during clamping than what this joint will see in service as a result of humidity changes.

The proof is in the clamping. If whatever gap you see can be pulled together with modest camp pressure, I consider the gap irrelevant to the in-use strength of the joint.

Now I would agree that a gap so extreme that it takes full clamp pressure to pull it together is unacceptable. And I agree that after gluing there should be no glue line showing. But it sure doesn't take a light-free joint to achieve these criteria.

Vastly more important to success is dry lumber and not out-of-date glue.

Re: joining boards

#15

Gentle feed on outfeed table?

Terry Alexander

>I don't own a jointer....yet. I should be getting an unexpected big payday shortly and the long bed Jet is going to be my choice.

Anyway...not having a jointer doesn't preclude me from reading posts regarding jointing and jointing technique.

I "thought" I read on this forum sometime last year that a fellow woodworker was having jointing problems and the responder said to make sure and keep the pressure on the infeed table as the wood is passed through.

Confused (but not dazed ;-)

Terry Alexander

Re: joining boards

#16

Re: why are you guys so picky about your joints?

Jesse Cloud

>Can you clamp boards together to close a gap - yeah, probably. But personally I would rather fix the gap on the jointer. Especially if the problem is that the boards aren't square or came off the jointer at different angles. Every time I think I'm going to fix a problem with the next step instead of doing this one right, I get in trouble...

BTW, this may all be moot. We are probably talking way different tolerances. This old fart couldn't see a 0.0001 inch gap if there was a spotlight behind it. ;^)

Re: joining boards

#17

Re: why are you guys so picky about your joints?

Steve Schoene

>I'm not concerned about having glue joints fail. Glue strength is so in excess of the need that it's not an issue. The small stresses of pulling a joint together a very small amount don't bother me much either for the same reason.

What I am concerned about for fine furniture is that there are no visible glue lines of any description. I've seen enough custom furniture to know that visible lines do occur at times even on professionally made pieces. By going for the really well fitted joint to begin with I can be confident of having no glue lines. I don't really know how much exactly I could get away with. I don't think it's all that much. I'm pretty well convinced that there is a wide gap between OK joints that stay togethr, and good joints that virtually disappear.

Re: joining boards

#18

Re: Gentle feed on outfeed table?

Steve Schoene

>The outfeed table is the reference surface for jointing, and is where the downward pressure should be applied. Force over the infeed table is only to keep the board moving forward.

It does get a little more complicated in the initial stages of the cut if you are trying to remove twist, bow or crook from a board.

Re: joining boards

#19

Re: I have to agree Bill

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I am a retired Manufacturing Engineer. I know that L S Starrett does use a light source behind a super precision granite block on another super precision granite block to "true up" and prove/inspect their top of the line master squares. I believe I read that it is easy to see and error much smaller than what you quoted (.0001), I think it was actually below .00001". I have been following this thread - wondering if I was a poor woodworker since I never use a light source to check mating surfaces. When I am making a glue up for tops or panels, I lay the boards on my Bessy clamps on my assembly area. Then align them for grain match up, mark them, pull them together with hand pressure and make sure they all fit without any gaps. Then I glue up and clamp. I have never had a failure of a joint, nor have I ever seen any evidence of a glue line. When I prepare them I usually verify my joiner fence at 90 deg, then alternate the boards to remove any error. I really don't care if the glue up is parallel as I always trim after glue up. I, like you am a little anal about my glue. I purchase a gallon of TB3 and use it for a year. Then buy a new gallon and discard the old one. I do the same with my liquid hide glue. I never use hot hide glue that is over a couple days old (I mix in small batches). I am also make pretty sure of my wood is dry and stable.

Re: joining boards

#20

Re: joining boards

Roger Lance in GR, Michigan

>I would suggest that you spend some time on your jointer to make sure that your fence is at 90*, your blades are sharp, and the height of your outfeed table is at the height of your blades...then do some practicing on technique...IMHO, a big problem with the creating of a gap between edges occurs because people are placing downward force on their boards as they pass through the jointer...as stated above, it is easy to bend a 6" board with downward force and this will result in not obtaining a straight edge when the board resumes its natural shape...the trick is to let the board pass over the knives in its natural shape by placing most of your pressure against the fence not the tables...take lite cuts and test the joints to gage your fit as you work thru your boards...it takes a little time to get the feel for this but remember the idea of a jointer is to obtain flat and straight edges/faces on boards and if you are altering the shape of the board by applying some outside force, the jointer will cut that shape but the board will move back to its natural shape when that force is removed.

Re: joining boards

#21

Re: joining boards

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>I recently joined 2 5/4 boards slightly over 10" wide x 5 foot long for the top of a buffet. To make a board with 2 straight edges I always joint the concave edge first because concave is easier to make straight than a convex edge. Then I rip off the convex edge and joint the ripped edge until the saw marks are removed. Now I have a board with parallel edges that are aproximately straight. A 30" or so board is easy to make straight on a 6" jointer. A 48" board can be made pretty straight on an 8" jointer. Longer boards present different challenges. I have a 6" craftsman jointer so the boards for my top were difficult. The next step is to clamp them on edge in the face vice on your bench and pull out your #7 or #8 jointer plane. It is very easy to make a board join nicely with a jointer plane. You sharpen the iron and set the plane then put the 2 boards together and see how they fit, remove the high spots until you get a nice fit. I put a slight gap in the center of the joint that is easily pulled together with a clamp then glue it. A jointer will leave slight compressions in the wood as the board is moved across it. A sharp iron from a jointer plane will make the joint nearly invisible.

Re: joining boards

#22

agree with both responses

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Edges that are not at 90 degrees to the face can't be fixed by clamp pressure. And to say that visible glue lines are a distraction in fine furniture would be an understatement. But if modest clamp pressure pulls the joint together, the glue line will be invisible when it is clamped at proper pressure.

Re: joining boards

#23

Re: yes

Barry Irby

>I agree with Bill. The only exception would be that if your technique on the jointer leaves you with boards that are consistently narrow in the center by a fairly significant amount, so that they are sort of hour glass or bow tie shaped, the "error" will multiply and accumulate as you rack up the pieces. If you are joining two pieces that are like this it would be fine, but if you are joining 12 pieces to make a four foot wide panel, you might develop a problem. Even then, It's probably unlikely that the glue would fail.

Re: joining boards

#24

The final answer

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>It's a bugger to set up, but perfectly matched edges will follow from this procedure:

1. Prep the mating edges by running each through the table saw or over the jointer to obtain roughly matching edges.

2. Load a router with a 1/4" spiral bit.

3. Fix the two boards a little less than 1/4" apart.

4. Set up a fence to guide the router between the two boards, and route away a smich from each simultaneously.

Perfect match!

Clint

Re: joining boards

#25

Re: joining boards

Jim Dillon

>I think we are getting a little carried away with perfection here. While I stated in my original post that the "light" criteria is a laudable goal (or words to that effect), it can be very misleading - especially if the jointer fence is not 90 degrees to the jointer bed. Personally, I place shorter boards up against my table saw fence and flat on the table saw surface to judge whether or not they are OK. If I see no gap, I'm good-to-go and move on to the next board. With longer boards, I use my bench top and butt adjacent boards against one another. Any minor gap I see, I either rejoin the board, or if I am running out of wood, I live with it and clamp it up. Life is short (and getting shorter 8-().

Jim