Re: trying to keep a miter box station level
James Watriss
>I've made a lifestyle out of being a devil's advocate, so I'm here with a gun to start shooting holes in things to help clarify things. You'll hate me for this, and possibly go ahead with your existing plan. But this is what I do.
While I'm not 100% on the actual project (I'm not a regular new yankee guy, so I don't know what you've built exactly) I think I understand the following things:
-Floor is very unstable, but the issue is involved enough that more concrete work, and major modifications, are really not in the cards.
-15 foot chop bench is a mix of cabinets and whatnot, with the bench on top. Is the radial arm attached to the unit, or is it wall mounted? Or did you go with the chop box?
-You want to keep this thing level.
-You hope the solution will last 5 years, or or as long as the current shop situation is needed.
-------------------------------------
I see the following quandaries:
-a 15 foot bench with cabinets et al is fairly long, and is typically designed for a stable flooring situation, and that's part of your problem. (I know, I'm repeating the painfully obvious)
-You want to keep it level. This is my first question: Does it HAVE to be? Can the work be done if it's not exactly level? 1/4"-1" is a lot of movement, for a floor, but across 15' of chop table, it's really not catastrophic. Can you build the station such that it's rigid enough as a standalone to put up with being moved out of level from time to time?
-Does it have to be level all the time? Or can you add something like a bottle jack into one end, and level it as you need?
-If this station is designed to rely on the stability of the floor, and your floor isn't stable, then is this design really appropriate to the situation? Or would you be better served by a torsion box table surface with a couple of smaller tables for support? If the 2xstock was flexing under the weight of the cabinets, but what you really need is a chop table, then could you put the cabinets to use somewhere else and modify the rest to suit your situation?
Sometimes the biggest mental and physical battles we face are trying to reconcile what we've got, or what we'd like to have, with the reality of the situation. If you're having to fight so hard trying to force rigid structure on a very shifty floor, would your efforts be better spent in other ways?
Instead of glue lam and angle iron and hundreds of dollars for something that will work for a while until it's racked out of position, why not break up the set for now, and go with what you have? If you have a flexible floor, don't make a solid station. Try laying a torsion box or big board across two smaller stations that you can move or shim. You're trying to make something that will support 15 feet worth of cabinets and their contents... basically, a unit that, fully loaded, could weigh over a ton... when all you really need is a flat surface that will support the wood, and the saw.
I'm going on theory here, because I'm not familiar with the particular project. But it sounds like a table on top of cabinets. And the weight of the cabinets is the issue. Could you not make a stable table that straddles the cabinets instead, and take the weight of the cabinets out of the equation, and rest them as smaller units on the bouncy floor? What parts of the station, specifically, really have to be supported?
Are you planning on moving this thing into the new shop, in which case, it might benefit from a sturdy fir 4x4 chassis with some wheels, or are you planning on getting rid of it in a few years, in which case, what's the cheapest (in terms of time and money) way to cope with it for now?
-The underlying thread in my post is that what you want isn't compatible with your situation, and that's what's really messing with you. If you can't change the fact that the floor isn't stable, is there something about the station that you can change? Sure it'll be work. But futzing and wrangling with expensive stuff that you hope will work to make this thing functional, and all of the scraps of time spent in such an endeavour is expensive too.