Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

trying to keep a miter box station level

Posts

trying to keep a miter box station level

#1

trying to keep a miter box station level

Scott in Montana

>Hello everyone,

I've built a 15' long miter box/radial arm saw station similar to the one on New Yankee Workshop.

The problem is that my shop floor rises and sinks due to the clay it's built on. An added note, this shop is almost 100 years old and when they poured the new floor they didn't break out the existing floor and even though it is almost six inches thick and has 1/2" rebar on one foot centers, it has broken along the scribed lines and the large quadrant sections move independently; up to about 1/4" depending on the season and amount of moisture. One of the seams is right in the middle of these cabinets.

Due to this movement, it is difficult to keep the work surface flat. My solution is to build a frame or table for the entire 15' to sit on and then level it as one entire unit rather than the three cabinets it is now. My thoughts have gone from a steel frame such as a large version of a table saw mobile base, to a torsion box, to a glulam. I just don't know what would be best.

The cabinets are only about 18" deep except for beneath the radial arm saw which is 27" deep. Altogether I'm guessing that, with machinery cabinets and contents, the whole thing weighs about 750 pounds. Keeping this table or plinth less than 4 1/2" thick would be nice as well.

Which would be best? What have I overlooked?

Thank you,

Scott

Re: trying to keep a miter box station level

#2

Re: trying to keep a miter box station level

Barry Irby

>I am not an Engineer, but I do have some experience with expansive clay in my work as a home inspector.

There are a number of approaches you can take.

You can install a soil watering system that will keep the soil consistently wet. The concept is that the soil shrinks when it drys out and swells when it wet. Generally, the soil has plenty of bearing capacity, it just changes volume. The watering systems keep it constantly wet and therefore at a constant volume.

The rebar you have in the slab does very little good at resisting the changes in the soil volume. If it installed at the center of the slab, the slab cracks and the rebar acts as a hinge. Until it rusts out.

If you had done it to start with, you could have installed a "floating slab". This would be a slab thick enough and strong enough to rise and fall with the changes in soil volume. This would have been a slab with top and bottom steel or either "post tensioned" or "pretensioned" steel.

None of that helps you much now. Its just background.

You could take a similar approach though. You could make a base for your unit that is strong enough to stay "flat" even if it is not level. I would think that the individual sections of your floor are remaining fairly flat even though they are hinged together. If you could position your setup on a single panel, they might work for you. Or, you could make some sort of pedestal base that would only rest on a small area of the floor and float along with it.

The problem is that the smaller the base is, the stronger the top has to be to remain flat. There are probably some opportunities to use Truss Joists, the wooden I beams that have plywood webs and either 2X3 or laminated chords. Fifteen feet is a little on the short side for them. You might be able to buy some cheap form a local dealer where they might be seen as cut offs or shorts. You can cut lots of holes in them for cords, dust collection and even drawers if you do it right.

You could also turn them into a big torsion box or stressed skin panel.

Re: trying to keep a miter box station level

#3

Re: trying to keep a miter box station level

Jay St. Peter - Southern, MD

>I'd just make a frame out of 2x4s, level it and set the whole thing on top.

Re: trying to keep a miter box station level

#4

Re: trying to keep a miter box station level

Scott in Montana

>Thanks,

I tried two 16 foot 2x4's standing upright side by side and put 60 pounds of weight distributed on both sides of the high center and they immediately deflected quite a bit. So I'm thinking that with several hundred pounds on each side they'll do the same even with maybe five or so 2x4's.

I think I may have an answer in a glulam beam that seems to be somewhat affordable ($176). A 16 feet long by 18 inches wide and 3 1/2 inches thick. According to everything I've read this could do it.

Again, thanks for your input.

Scott

Re: trying to keep a miter box station level

#5

Re: trying to keep a miter box station level

Scott in Montana

>Thanks Berry,

The floor was installed before I bought the home and garage/shop. I think they might have thought that 6" to 8" thick and heavily rebarred concrete might have served as a floating floor as it doesn't appear attached to the footings. And maybe if they had taken out the original concrete floor it might have worked. Since they didn't, the breaks in the old floor are doing their best to telegraph through this newer floor.

A new shop is in the not too distant future (5 years) but right now I'd like to get this mortgage payed off before starting a new one.

I think for now I'm going to try a 3.5" x 18" glulam beam with heavy duty levelers underneath and set the cabinets on top of that. I'm told that torsion box design doesn't work well in such long proportions. And the glulam is about $175 which I don't consider too bad if I consider my labor savings.

Again, I sure appreciate your input.

Scott

PS The new shop will have much improved drainage installed under and around it. And it will probably be built on top of 18" of river gravel. Even with these percautions, it will have 48" footings and an engineered floating floor. It is my thought that all of the clay currently under the garage may have come from when they dug the foundation and rather than haul it off, they just smoothed it out into a yard. I'm told that clay when it becomes wet can expand to lift 50,000 pounds per square inch.

Re: trying to keep a miter box station level

#6

Re: trying to keep a miter box station level

Barry Irby

>Probably not what you want to do and not worth it, but there are companies around (here at least) that can come in and screw "helical piers" down through the floor. They can screw them down to the point the soil does not move and then weld an angle on the top of them for you to attach the bench. It would work, but it would cost over a thousand here. If you want to know more, Google A B Chance Co.

Re: trying to keep a miter box station level

#7

Re: trying to keep a miter box station level

Jay St. Peter - SoMD

>If you shim it every so often or use levelers it should keep it from deflecting.

Re: trying to keep a miter box station level

#8

Re: Ooops

Jay St. Peter - SoMD

>Oops, I see your floor moves by season. What if you reinforce a 2x4 with a piece of metal. I used to bolt angle iron to a 2x8 to make motorcycle ramps. Makes it real strong and still much cheaper than $175.

Re: trying to keep a miter box station level

#9

Re: trying to keep a miter box station level

Bob Persing

>Just in the spirit of brain-storming here....have you given thought to boring a few holes through the new + old slab and down far enough into the soil so that you could pour some small "footers" onto which you would supp ort the base of your cabinets. Ideally these footers would rise slightly above the existing floor and be somewhat isolated from the existing floor. The result would be that you have 6 or so pillars that are now independent of the existing slabs movement and hopefully down far enough to remain stable.

Just a wild thought.

BobP

Re: trying to keep a miter box station level

#10

Re: trying to keep a miter box station level

David

>Don't know if this would make sense but what about mounting the whole station on the wall? Just my 2 cents.

DGW

Re: trying to keep a miter box station level

#11

Re: trying to keep a miter box station level

Scott in Montana

>Hello Bob,

We were thinking alike until I realized that between the newer floor and the old floor, there is a bit over 12" of concrete. And the fact that I would have to core drill through the concrete and then drill down 48" to the frost line (this is an outside wall)... I got a bit scared.

Still, if this was a shop I was going to be in for years to come I think you have a good solution.

Thanks,

Scott

Re: trying to keep a miter box station level

#12

Re: Ooops

Scott in Montana

>You know, I was thinking of box steel until I shopped the price, $400! Then I asked about angle iron and it dropped it down to $140...plus lumber. Wow! I had heard how much steel prices had gone up but this was the first time I had experienced it up close and personal.

Thanks for the additional input.

Scott

Re: trying to keep a miter box station level

#13

Re: trying to keep a miter box station level

Scott in Montana

>I'm just a little afraid of that since the walls of this old garage/shop are 2x4's and I'm not sure of the force that a cantilevered radial arm saw might subject the walls to. I want a new shop, just not in the next month or two. :O)

Thanks very much for your input,

Scott

Re: trying to keep a miter box station level

#14

Re: trying to keep a miter box station level

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Scott,

Seems to me that there would be no danger of hanging the whole thing off the wall. My understanding is that you are basically hanging a series of cabinets. You would essentially be spreading the load over the whole 15'. As long as you attach directly into the studs, and as long as the studs are still sound, I don't see a problem.

If you are concerned specifically about the weight of the radial arm saw, you could add a couple of adjustable legs under the front of it to keep it level and supported. Just don't forget to check them regularly. I'm assuming here that your floor doesn't move a lot over a short time period and that you are mainly concerned with keeping things flat over time.

Gary

Re: trying to keep a miter box station level

#15

Re: trying to keep a miter box station level

Scott in Montana

>Hi Gary,

That is a problem, it does seem to move on a daily basis; up to 1/4" per day and up to an inch at times.

This is complicated by the fact that the wall also move, not as much, but I do see cracks in the drywall open and close up to a quarter inch as well.

I'm just hoping to get five more years out of the building before building the shop I've always wanted.

Thanks,

Scott

Re: trying to keep a miter box station level

#16

Re: Ooops *LINK*

Jay St. Peter - Southern, MD

>I know the angle iron prices at Lowes have gone up significantly over the last few years. I just bought a piece for some brackets for my car not too long ago and wouldn't have thought it would be that expensive. But, I came up with some cheaper possibilities anyway.

Two more possibilities that I can think of, then I'm probably out of ideas ;). First, gang up three 2x4s (or 2x4s sandwiching ply pieces) and glue/screw/bolt them together. Might be less expensive than the gluelam. Second, make an i-beam out of plywood. I've attached a link to a blog post that shows what I'm talking about. Maybe make the i-beams less tall, but double up the inner support. Should be pretty dang strong. It'll take some doing to overlap all the parts to get 15', but should be doable without compromising the strength. One piece of construction ply should do it and would only cost around $30.


Bob Lang's i-beams

Re: trying to keep a miter box station level

#17

Re: trying to keep a miter box station level

James Watriss

>I've made a lifestyle out of being a devil's advocate, so I'm here with a gun to start shooting holes in things to help clarify things. You'll hate me for this, and possibly go ahead with your existing plan. But this is what I do.

While I'm not 100% on the actual project (I'm not a regular new yankee guy, so I don't know what you've built exactly) I think I understand the following things:

-Floor is very unstable, but the issue is involved enough that more concrete work, and major modifications, are really not in the cards.

-15 foot chop bench is a mix of cabinets and whatnot, with the bench on top. Is the radial arm attached to the unit, or is it wall mounted? Or did you go with the chop box?

-You want to keep this thing level.

-You hope the solution will last 5 years, or or as long as the current shop situation is needed.

-------------------------------------

I see the following quandaries:

-a 15 foot bench with cabinets et al is fairly long, and is typically designed for a stable flooring situation, and that's part of your problem. (I know, I'm repeating the painfully obvious)

-You want to keep it level. This is my first question: Does it HAVE to be? Can the work be done if it's not exactly level? 1/4"-1" is a lot of movement, for a floor, but across 15' of chop table, it's really not catastrophic. Can you build the station such that it's rigid enough as a standalone to put up with being moved out of level from time to time?

-Does it have to be level all the time? Or can you add something like a bottle jack into one end, and level it as you need?

-If this station is designed to rely on the stability of the floor, and your floor isn't stable, then is this design really appropriate to the situation? Or would you be better served by a torsion box table surface with a couple of smaller tables for support? If the 2xstock was flexing under the weight of the cabinets, but what you really need is a chop table, then could you put the cabinets to use somewhere else and modify the rest to suit your situation?

Sometimes the biggest mental and physical battles we face are trying to reconcile what we've got, or what we'd like to have, with the reality of the situation. If you're having to fight so hard trying to force rigid structure on a very shifty floor, would your efforts be better spent in other ways?

Instead of glue lam and angle iron and hundreds of dollars for something that will work for a while until it's racked out of position, why not break up the set for now, and go with what you have? If you have a flexible floor, don't make a solid station. Try laying a torsion box or big board across two smaller stations that you can move or shim. You're trying to make something that will support 15 feet worth of cabinets and their contents... basically, a unit that, fully loaded, could weigh over a ton... when all you really need is a flat surface that will support the wood, and the saw.

I'm going on theory here, because I'm not familiar with the particular project. But it sounds like a table on top of cabinets. And the weight of the cabinets is the issue. Could you not make a stable table that straddles the cabinets instead, and take the weight of the cabinets out of the equation, and rest them as smaller units on the bouncy floor? What parts of the station, specifically, really have to be supported?

Are you planning on moving this thing into the new shop, in which case, it might benefit from a sturdy fir 4x4 chassis with some wheels, or are you planning on getting rid of it in a few years, in which case, what's the cheapest (in terms of time and money) way to cope with it for now?

-The underlying thread in my post is that what you want isn't compatible with your situation, and that's what's really messing with you. If you can't change the fact that the floor isn't stable, is there something about the station that you can change? Sure it'll be work. But futzing and wrangling with expensive stuff that you hope will work to make this thing functional, and all of the scraps of time spent in such an endeavour is expensive too.