>I'm curious about the conventional wisdom regarding sharpening of bandsaw blades. Specifically I am talking about standard silicon steel blades. How many folks here sharpen their own blades? Do you feel it's worth the time and effort? Or do you use your blades until dull and purchase new ones?
I tried the sharpening bit with a minigrinder and a dremel fitting. Each time t'was a failure. The teeth were sharp all right, but the sets were not uniform and the blades wandered or would barely cut.
I now use'em 'till they're done, and put on a new one. Not worth the effort for me.
>I use'em till they start smoking, trash em, and put on a new one. I have no skill at attempting to sharpen them and I don't think a service could do it for the price of a new one. I just keep spares on hand and try to be careful with the one I'm using.
>i shde several times using dremel. works fine. i use a method shown i woodturning mag. several years ago. do not worry about wander though havent noticed that problem
>Iv'e done it with good results but the time it takes is several times longer than changing blades. it is a task I reserve for those rare momnets where I don't have a spare blade and hit a screw or the blade breakes and all I have is one of the dull blades I save because I hate to throw out good metal.
the way I sharpen the blade is with the blade on the saw and with a dremel or flexshaft if my dremel batteries are dead. I mount a cut off wheel in the grinder and hold the grinder in line with the blade and the cut off wheel perpendicular to the blade. I pivot grinder into the blade while at the same time I use my other hand to slowly advance the blade into the cutoff wheel. the cutoff wheel lightly touches the gullet and then the face of the tooth touches the side of the cutoff wheel. I then pivot the grinder out and advance to the next tooth. In practice the blade hardly stops moving.
I came up with this prosess after watching a friend sharpen his woodmizer blades on an automatic sharpening machine.
As you can surmize my prosess does nothing about adding set and we all know it is the loss of set that is one of the bigest reasons for a badsaw blade becomeing dull.
Sharpening a band saw blade is a great thing to know how to do when you are in a pinch but unless you can re set the teeth it is really only usefull for emergencies untill the saw shop opens on monday.
>I think there was a large thread on this last summer or fall on the turning forum. You might do a search on the turning archive or post a query on the turning forum asking this same questions. Good luck.
>I have begun to sharpen my 1/2" and 3/4" resaw blades using a Dremel tool with a grinding stone bit. Not like new, but I cut a lot of logs I find by the wayside and if I bought a new blade each time I dulled the blade I'd go broke. I use 105" blades on my Delta bandsaw and 3TPI blades don't take long to sharpen. The smaller size blades I just buy new.
>I sharpen those I use for thick, green wood (for woodturning). These blades have fewer teeth (3-4tpi) so sharpening doesn't take too much time. I use a dremel tool with a metal cutoff wheel and hit the faces as per instructions from Brian Hahn and Steven Russell. Brian has an article about this on AAW > how-to's > tips.
I also have sharpened other blades when they were dull and I wanted to keep working. It is tedious but not difficult.
>There have been more than one thread on this in the last year or two, so check the Turning(?) Forum or search the archives.
I have a box of ten blades I bought from the company mentioned in FWW a few years ago. They were about $10 or $12 each. I have sharpened some of then. Used the Dremel with a cut off wheel in it and hit the top of each tooth. Marked one with black ink to show where I started and turned the blade by hand. With a 3 TPI 105" blade it takes about 10 to 15 minutes. They cut fairly well, but not as well as a new blade. Especially for resawing.
What I find is that it also takes about 10 or 15 minutes to change a blade. So the time is not really a consideration. I find it slightly tedious and annoying to sharpen one. Just don't get much thrill out of the process. But I get little sense of accomplishment out of changing a blade either.
For thinner stock, a resharpened blade works fine, for resawing, not so much.
I have tried using a cylindrical stone and grinding from the gullet side. That seemed to work about as well.
I have also tried to figure out why I am saving all those dull blades. (Pack Rat). Sometimes I take off a semi dull blade to use a new one to resaw and never quite get around to putting the semi dull one back on. I guess when the box is empty, I will decide its time to sharpen again.
I like having identical blades. Much easier to change the blade if you don't have to change everything.
>I appreciate all the responses. They pretty much confirm what I have been thinking. Now that "time is money" for me I have been thinking that for the cost of the blades it generally isn't worth my time to sharpen them...maybe with some exceptions. And the points made about losing the sets is a good one too.
>course I came from a generation that was taught to fix and repair rather than spend money for what you already have. We were not a throw away culture.
I found that it takes practice to develop the skill but that in the end it became fast and easy. I never had problems with set and angle, but of course we used hand saws a lot and learned to do what was necessary. I enjoy keeping tools in good shape and really enjoy using well maintained tools.
>From a commercial perspective. There are semi automatic bandsaw grinders available but just like handsaws the labor cost exceeds the price of a new band in most sizes.
>I've never sharpened a bandsaw blade (or a handsaw blade, for that matter), but my understanding is that if I was to do so, I would file the gullet of each tooth in the bandsaw. How would that affect the set of the tooth, assuming that I didn't crank down on the tooth while filing? I'm asking because of reports that I have read where people tried to resharpen a bandsaw blade and somehow altered the set of the tooth.
>Here is a nice Youtube video showing how to quickly sharpen a bandsaw blade. If you only get one sharpening out of your blade you are money ahead unless you are making a bunch of money per hour in your shop.