Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Fluoresent Lighting

Posts

Fluoresent Lighting

#1

Fluoresent Lighting

Larry in NW Ohio

>I have fluoresent lighting in my shop and need new bulbs I am so confused about the different types and would like some advice. The last ones I got were from Sam`s Club, something like $1 a bulb. Yes some of the cheaper ones, the # on them are GE Ecolux wattmizer F34CW-RS-WM ECO COOL WHITE. They are the bigger older T-12 bulbs. Would there be a better bulb that would be brighter. I know that there was a write up in one of the magazines in the last few years, but trying to find it, I could find the neddle in a haystack easier. Any comments would be appriciated. Larry in Ohio

Re: Fluoresent Lighting

#2

Re: Fluoresent Lighting

Rick in Colgate, Wi

>There is an article right here at WC about lighting under "shop topics", lots of good info.

Re: Fluoresent Lighting

#3

Re: Fluoresent Lighting

Jack

>Here is a tables from GE with some of tier bulbs

http://genet.gelighting.com/LightProducts/Dispatcher?REQUEST=RESULTPAGE&CHANNEL=Commercial&CATEGORY=Lamps_Linear+Fluorescent_Straight+Linear_T12&BREADCRUMB=CATG

Lumens is the brightness

color temperature is how yellow the light is (hotter is whiteer)

color rendering index is how faithfully they reproduce color ( higher is better 100 is perfect)

Re: Fluoresent Lighting

#4

I stepped up to the higher price T 12 fuorescents

Forrest Addy

>I stepped up to the premium price T 12 fuorescents from Home Depot. They weren't cheap at about $6.20 each but their color temperature(11,000 K) color rendering (92) and brightness (8700 lumens) is superb.

I now have brilliant shadow free shop light equivalent to a sunny day with a thin overcast. I never knew I had that much stuff in my shop or that it was at last findable.

Over time fluorescents dim and poop out and you wonder if therre isn't something better than what you have. Then you change them out and it's like a new day and money well spent.

But still you wonder if the flourescent light people don;t tweak their products to fail earlier so yhey can sell you more stuff. Like the auto battery people whose products almost certainly fail just after at the end of the pro-rated warrenty period. My experience over three shop lighting change outs: I replace all my 36 fluorescent tubes at the same time and 6 years later the first one fails. Six weeks after that half are pooped out. Hm, say I. I wonder... Engineered life expencancy? Fits a pretty skinny bell curve.

Anyway, if you have to color match finishes and do finicky detail work good lighting makes success easier to attain. Find one of those comparison sampler thingies where they have the different tubes lit up and compare a color swatch chart from the paint department under each sample light so you can see for yourself the effect of color temp and full spectrum rendering. 100 equals full spectrum black body radiance as from halogen filament bulb. There's a world of difference between 82 and 92 - maybe enough to make you want to spend the money.

Re: Fluoresent Lighting

#5

Re: Fluoresent Lighting

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I have various bulbs in my Florescent fixtures (around 20 dual fixtures), mostly T-8's. All of my fixtures are T8 & T12 compatible. I have several "sunlight", some that tend toward the high kelvin temp. and some lower. I also have 6 halogen 100 Watt incandescents on the ceiling. My son's employer is retrofitting their plant to fluorescents and discarding a large number of explosion proof metal halide 150 Watt fixtures, so I have a couple of those. Haven't mounted them yet - but they will replace 2 of the Halogens. Several of my fluorescents have the high CRI. However I also have some photo lights, 2 pole mounted with multiple bulbs and one hand held (picked them all up at auctions for very little). I also use a hand held style 500 Watt halogen fixture to inspect for tool marks and imperfections. In reality I am not sure how much the "Sun light" true color matters. Most if not all of the furniture will be used in rooms that are lite by artificial lighting - used to be all incandescents - now much is being replaced by "soft white" fluorescents. I know that I would not need (or probably even want) all the lighting I now have 20 or 30 years ago. As I age however (66 now), I require far more lumen's to see details, imperfections and lines.

Re: Fluoresent Lighting

#6

Re: I stepped up to the higher price T 12 fuoresce

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

>Hi Forest.

Tell us more about the 11,000K color temp bulbs.

From everything I have read, 6500K is the photographic standard for white light. Temps lower are some degree of red, and higher temps are some degree of blue. Now I am not an expert by any measure on light bulbs, it it seems to me that 11,000K would be approaching ultra violet. ???

Have you noticed getting a sun tan while working in your shop? :-)

Beats me,

Ken

Re: Fluoresent Lighting

#7

That's what is says on the box, Ken.

Forrest Addy

>That's what is says on the box, Ken. I'll go out and look laer to see if I got it right.

Re: Fluoresent Lighting

#8

Argh!! That's NOT what it says on the box.

Forrest Addy

>The only thing I hate worse than screwing up is getting busted for it. Ken's right. My specs were haywire.

Here's off the box

Light output: 4650 lumens

Life: 12,000 hours

Color Rendering: Index 92

Cp;or temperature: 5000K

I don't get 12,000 hours because I turn them on and off 4 or more times a day easy and they have to start in cold weather. Fluorescents don't like that. I get more like 5000 hours.

That higher quality light is gorgeous. My buddy who is in retailing tells me those high CRI lights mean about 40% more sales than when the store is lamped with the regular cool white.

Re: Fluoresent Lighting

#9

Re: Fluoresent Lighting

John in IN

>Check out the FWW article in the Jan/Feb 2002 issue. Very informative.

Re: Fluoresent Lighting

#10

fluorescent lighting decoded

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>the secret decoding ring for this lighting is located in my Article on shop lighting in the Articles section. It will guide you in picking replacements. The variables are light output, color of light and how true to color things look under the light. Would you believe that better costs more!

Re: Fluoresent Lighting

#11

Re: Fluoresent Lighting

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Evening Larry,

The choice at HD is almost bewildering, and so is the price differential. I use eight dual 48" fixtures in my larger shop room, and these are slung below a 7 foot ceiling, covedring an area of 17 X 10 feet. Along one long wall, and beneath a 3 foot wide soffet where most of my principle stationary power tools are located , I also have 6 high hat 60 to 75 watt incandescent task lights. Its real brite. I buy only the least expensive bulbs.

George

Re: Fluoresent Lighting

#12

Re: I like T-8

Brian in Brighton

>They are more efficient and I like the brighter whites and fresh spring breeze smell. :-) My 2-bulb, 4 footer uses a 0.49 Amp/32watt electronic ballast.

Go with the T-8 as the T-12 use more energy and HATE any cold temps. My T-8's even ran below freezing. The water bottles didn't like it, but the lights ran fine. Of course, now we have heat. :-)

Brian in Brighton

Re: Fluoresent Lighting

#13

For openers,

Larry Marker

>switch to 40 Watt lamps. I have a bunch of cheap shop lights in my basement shop and have not had any problems with 40 W lamps. I bought a box of 34 W lamps and could hardly see anything. Went back to 40's, and all is well.

Larry

Re: Fluoresent Lighting

#14

Re: I like T-8

Dan Donaldson

>T8's are great, but if he has T12's now, he would have to change the ballasts to get them to work.

Re: Fluoresent Lighting

#15

Re: Argh!! That's NOT what it says on the box.

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

>Forest, thanks for checking the box. 5K temp is right in line with what I had read. I put in 5500 degree T8 bulbs and I am quite happy with them, but good old sunlight can't be beat.

As an aside, I bought a 'full spectrum' fluorescent floor lamp last year as a reading lamp, boy oh boy did it make a big difference. The print almost jumps off the page. I highly recommend that type lamp, especially for those of us over 60. :-)

Happy saw dust,

Ken

Re: Fluoresent Lighting

#16

Re: For openers,

Larry in NW Ohio

>I thought $1.00 per bulb was pretty cheap, but Hey I thought good ole Sam Walton wouldn`t screw me, would he? I`ll try different bulb`s and see what happen`s. Larry in Ohio

Re: Fluoresent Lighting

#17

Good old Sam ...

Jerry Nicholson

>Good Old Sam might not - but Good Old Sam is dead!

Jerry

Re: Fluoresent Lighting

#18

Re: Good old Sam ...

Larry in NW Ohio

>Yea I thought things changed quite a bit for the cheaper and junkyer in the last few years. Larry in Ohio

Re: Fluoresent Lighting

#19

Re: Take a look Dan

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>All of the "shop" 2 bulb 4' fixtures I have purchased from the Borg's (Menards & Lowes) are compatible with either T12 or T8 bulbs - These were the $10 - $15 lights. There are a few sold there that are T12 only but most are rated for the T8's - even though some are furnished with T12 bulbs. I purchased about 15 at one time that had T8's installed with the plastic guards for (as I remember) $14.95 ea. I did have to remove and trash the plastic guards as they turned quite yellow in about a year - I also replaced all the bulbs as they were the "soft white" and didn't give the light/color rendering I wanted.

Re: Fluoresent Lighting

#20

Re: Take a look Dan

Dan Donaldson

>Cool. The ones that I had in my shop were t-12's and when I converted them to t-8's, I had to change the ballasts and the say they wired in, but they were older fixtures. It was actually more expensive to rewire them and change the ballasts than to replace the fixtures, but I did not want to take them all down and it was less work for me to do the rewire and ballast swap.

Nice that the newer ones are compatible either way. I guess you have to be careful if you upgrade to make sure what kind of fixtures you have.