Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

220v circuit question

Posts

220v circuit question

#1

220v circuit question

Joe Pack

>I think I know the answer, but I am not completely sure of the loads for a 220v, 20 amp circuit, how each 20 amp leg works, etc. So, I'm looking for some reassurance from the electrical experts here.

A couple of years ago I ran a 20 amp, 220v circuit (#12 wire) for a 2 1/2 hp dust collector system, with extra outlets every 4-6 feet along one wall of my shop "just in case." Last year I added a 2 hp, 220 v. bandsaw. The amp draw for the dc motor is labeled13/26. The bandsaw motor is labeled 10/20. I assume these amperages are maximums...the startup amperage. I always start the dc, then the bandsaw, and have never had any noticeable problem running both of them. I assume, though, that I am at the high end of the capacity of a 220v, 20 amp circuit.

Now I have added a 3hp, 220v table saw, labeled simply 13 amps. Thinking that I would be overloading a 20 amp, 240 v. circuit with both the dc and the table saw running at the same time, I have been planning to run an additional 220v circuit for the table saw (and for the bandsaw once it is available) so that the dc and the saws will be on different circuits when in use.

Am I heading the right way by putting in the new circuit?

Re: 220v circuit question

#2

Re: 220v circuit question

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>I am not a licensed electrician, although I've chased electrons around electively for several decades. I've also been following electrical discussions in woodworking since I've been on the internet. With all of that in mind, my opinion is worth exactly what you paid for it.

Yes, those first numbers are the draw when the motors are wired for 240V. They should be FLA (full load amp) numbers, and thus, for your bandsaw and table saw, aren't likely to be approached except for the startup inrush, which is momentary.

Your dust collector, however, sort of runs full bore the whole time. So while I wouldn't get excited about running either the bandsaw or table saw on the same circuit as the DC (note the operative word, or), and absent demanding cuts, such as resawing, I believe your startup sequence should be saw first, then DC.

Running the second circuit is a good idea, and supporting what you are thinking, I'd put the DC on it and have the bandsaw and table saw share the other, since you're unlikely to ever run them both at the same time. I do the same with my table saw and planer.

Rod

Re: 220v circuit question

#3

Re: 220v circuit question

David Wittner

>If I read your question correctly, you're asking if it's ok/advisable to add a second circuit for your dust collector. I would say yes, it's usually preferable to have a dedicated circuit. I believe that residential code requires/prefers a separate circuit for each "motor," e.g., refrigerator, ac unit, so it certainly wouldn't hurt.

I literally just finished wiring my new shop. There are dedicated circuits for the DC, and pairs of machine stations. Since it's just me and my arms are too short to use more than one machine at a time, I went this route. The inspector also had no problems with my setup.

Official Disclaimer: I'm not an electrician but have a good many years experience working with electricity.

Re: 220v circuit question

#4

Re: 220v circuit question

Barry Irby

>Joe,

The 10/20 are the amp draw of the motor. 10 @ 220 and 20 @ 110.

These may be Full Load Amps. (FLA) The amount of current the motor should pull under full load.

Motors have many ratings, some more "honest" than others.

RLA is Running Load Amps or the current it draws just running.

LRA is Locked Rotor Amps or the amount of current draws with the shaft locked. This is generally near the maximum for the motor.

There is also the startup draw. Motors draw a huge amount of current to spin the shaft from dead stop to full speed and this may be five times the Running Load Amps. That's why you can't start eh two at the same time without tripping the breaker.

Some breakers are slightly time delayed so that they will ignore the over current draw for a very brief time. (There are also Time Delay fuses for this purpose)

So, Code wise, you should have separate circuits for each motor. OTOH, if you put tow on the same circuit, it may be inconvenient in that you have to finesse the startup , but it probably is not terribly unsafe. You may get tripped breakers form time to time.

Another thing. For long term draw, you are supposed to only load the circuit to 80%. So 16 amps on a 20 amp circuit. You are running above that when your machines are loaded. One danger here is over heating the wiring. In effect the wire runs too hot over a long period of time and breaks down, becoming brittle. This is sort of unlikely with a table saw and bandsaw because the use is intermittent.

Re: 220v circuit question

#5

Re: 220v circuit question

Bill Howatt

>"This is sort of unlikely with a table saw and bandsaw because the use is intermittent."

It is extremely unlikely because table saws and larger bandsaws in the shop environment rarely run near the maximum current ratings even when they are being used.

Bill

Re: 220v circuit question

#6

Re: 220v circuit question

Jim Moore

>I agree with all that was said above. But, I would like to add one other little tidbit. It may not apply here since in the "real world" your equipment will be run intermittently, but you must also be aware of how many wires you have in a conduit. There is a maximum of wires you are allowed to put in any given size conduit. If you put over a certain number of wires, you must "derate" the ampacity rating of the wires in that conduit. I won't go into technicals here, but for easy thnking, a 3/4" conduit shoud not generally have more that three 120V circuits in it. In this case, that would mean one 220V cct. and one 120V cct. After that, you may have to derate the wire ampacity. By Code, you would have to take this into account, regardless of what the "real world" use of the circuits will be. Don't mean to confuse anyone, but this is just something to be aware of.

Re: 220v circuit question

#7

Re: 220v circuit question

Rick Christopherson

>I disagree pretty much with 90% of the previous posting. The amperage values given on the motor and listed in the original poster's message are the Full Load Amps, and they represent when the motor is operating at its maximum rating. When a motor is running at idle without a load, its running amps will be approximately 50% of the full load amps.

Locked rotor amperage is just as the name suggests, the rotor is locked and cannot turn. This is your startup current because the motor isn't turning. As the motor begins to rotate, the amperage will drop off relative to the rpm.

You do not need to derate a circuit by 80%. The circuit is capable of providing its full rating. On a multi-outlet circuit, any single device cannot exceed 80%, but the total non-continuous load can be 100%. For a dedicated circuit, the non-continuous load can be 100% of the circuit. It is continuous loads that need to be derated to 80%, and woodworking tools are not continuous loads.

As for the original poster's question, yes, your thinking is sound. For now, you will be able to operate the DC and one saw at the same time, but if you ever fully load the saw (either one), it will trip the breaker. If you are not tripping your breaker frequently, then you are fine. Adding a new circuit is my recommendation. If you are going to run a new circuit, leave the two saws on the existing multi-outlet circuit, and run a dedicated circuit for the Dust Collector. Not because the dust collector is a huge draw, but because it is the single tool that operates at the same time as other tools.

If you buy additional tools in the future, you can also put those on the same circuit as the band saw and tablesaw.

Re: 220v circuit question

#8

Re: 220v circuit question (long)

Jim Moore

>OK, here is a detailed explaination of how I see the Naational Electricl Code requires this circuit to be treated. Warning: this could be verying boring to many readers, and those in the know, are aware that the NEC overkills everthing. Non the less, here it goes.

NEC 430.6(A)(1) states that Table 430.248 must be used to determine ampacity of conductors rather than the actual ratings of a motor. Exception #3 of the same does state that we can use the full load curent marked on the nameplate if BOTH the horsepower and FLA are shown on the nameplate. Let's assume they are for this discussion.

NEC 430.22 states that a single motor conductor in a continuos duty application shall have ampacity of not less than 125% of motor's FLA as determined by 430.6(A)(1). Again, Exception #3, for our discussion, will let us use the FLA numbers on the nameplates as given by the orignal poster.

NEC 430.24 states that if more than one motor is served, the feeder ampacity must be figured by adding 125% of the largest motor FLA rating with the sum of all other motors FLA ratings as determined in NEC 430.6(A)(1).

NEC 430.22(E) discusses duty-cyle service and nameplate rating percentages and provides a table for clarification. In the table, it states that any motor application shall be considered as continuos duty unless the nature of the apparatus it drives is such that the motor will not operate continuously with load under any condition. This would be like an elevator or such.

While we would all agree the table saw would probably not operate under load continuously, the dust collector could.

So applying the above we have:

The 2 1/2 HP dust collector has a nameplate rating of 13 amps at 240V.

The band saw is rated at 10 amps at 240V.

The table saw is rated at 13 amps at 240V.

Let's look at what he has now: DC and BS on same circuit.

DC is largest motor, so take it's rating time 125% to get 16.25 amps.

BS is the samller, so take it at 100% for an additional 10 amps.

16.25 + 10 equals 26.25. This feeder should be rated greater than 26.25 amps. Probably 30 amps, not 20 amps as he curently has.

If you add the table saw, it increases the ampacity requirements by another 13 amps to get 39.25 amps. Now your pushing it, but you could use a 40 amp rated feeder to feed all three pieces of equipment.

You are not allowed to derate continuous duty motors in most cases. And we would agree that the table saw and the bandsaw would not probably ever be run at the same time, assuming a one-man shop. And realistically, we know the that in the real world, the 20 amp circuit will be fine for the DC and the BS, or even the DC and the table saw, since neither saw will run at FLA very long.

But the Code does not address real world situations. It looks only at the maximum that could happen. So if you were figuring this circuit by Code, you would need to put a feeder in that is rated over 26.25 amps for the DC and BS to run together. For the table saw and DC together, you need a feeder large enough to serve 29.25 amps.

I'm not going to tell you to change the DC and BS circuit because as long as you run them as we all typically do, you will have no problesm. The TS should be on another circuit though.

As far as derating of conductors, goes, let's leave that alone. That is getting way too complicated for this forum. Just be aware that you cannot just fill any conduit up with as many wires ae you can get into it. The Code will make you derate the ampacity rating of the conductors in a pipe once you reach a given set number of wires.

Finally, as far as connected and calculated loads are concerned, NEC Article 220 III requires feeder calculated loads shall not be be less than the sum of the loads on branch circuits supplied, after any applicable demand factors are applied. There are not demand factors for motors in the NEC that I know of. The smallest calcualted load of any motor will be 100% of its FLA.

Enough of this confusion. Put the TS on its own circuit, start the DC first before staring the BS. And you should be fine. Just not in compliance with the NEC.

Re: 220v circuit question

#9

Thanks to all.

Joe Pack

>I appreciate the advice. It's good to have experience speaking instead of "I hope this works."

I will run the second circuit as I thought, using the DC there. It is highly unlikely that I will ever run both saws on the same circuit at the same time. And the second circuit on an opposite wall will give me more flexibility in shop layout.