>Don't buy into the myth that Contractors saws can't have good dust collection, and that you have to buy a Hybrid or Cabinet saw to have good results. I'm really sick and tired of hearing it. Whoever says it doesn't know what they are talking about and are very close minded. Which seems to be ALOT of people. It's rediculous.
>Please post it. I have tried several methods which all work, but not well due to the open back. Those of us who have breathing problems, I am sure, will really appreciate it. And perhaps I'd not have to spend $1100 on a hybrid saw.
>On my JET contractors, I replaced the factory dust chute on the bottom with one made of wood, but in an inverted pyramid shape. Made a bigger difference in not allowing dust to accumulate in the corners.
Next, I have a sheet of formica that is made to slide horizontally over the two motor shafts to plug up the back. It just hangs there and must be removed when the arbor is tilted.
Thirdly, I cut pieces of wood and siliconed them between the sheet metal enclosure and the webbing of the table top undersides. All this makes for a better sealed unit and the dust that blows out the bottom of the blade goes out the dust hose. Still will have dust shooting out the top when the blade, on its upward travel in the board, throws dust at me.
My experiences, being the thread originator appears unwilling to share.
>The problem I've seen with blocking the back off with a sheet of plywood or anything rigid is people eventually forget to remove it when tilting the blade. I've heard of one case so far that a guy forgot to remove it and cranked on the hand wheel so hard that he cracked the rear trunion bracket and cost him a considerable amount of money to replace. Also the stock plastic dust pan for these saws is not very effecient either, the guy with the inverted pyramid shaped dust port under the saw is on the right track. Blocking off airflow between the cast iron top and the cabinet as mentioned is also recomended. Blocking the front of the cabinet where the slot is for the blade raiseing hand wheel I have done with a piece of magnetic sign material. One mistake people make is attempting to seal the saw cabinet so tight that your dust collector can't possibly breath the way it should, you need to remember that you need to be able to get enough fresh air into the cabinet as you are sucking out. Basically I have blocked everything off but the back, but have reduced the size and blocked off the back of the blade from throwing dust out. As far as dust comeing off the top of the blade and in your face, thats a problem for all table saws and requires over the blade dust collection such as a Shark Guard.
>I have a Jet 10" contractor's. I use the stock 4" dc fixture on the bottom. Ever see the magnetic sheet stock that is used for making temporary signs that go on the side of a truck/car? Same stuff used for those little magnets you may have all over your refrigerator. You can buy this stuff about anywhere in sheets of say 24" x 18" and it cuts easily with plain old sissors. See where I'm going? Thats what covers the back of mine. And the nice thing is if I tilt the arbor it just slides along with the rig. Seals very nicely. I even have a small piece cut for the front openings. REALLY makes a difference.
>Dale, Have you improved yours further? As I recall, you posted pictures a year or so ago and it was a good looking piece of work.
I took a different approach. I went to the source. I have an ancient Rockwell/Delta contractor's saw. I removed the little "half" chute in front of the blade and replaced it with a full chute that is about 2" by 12" and drops vertically into a boot for the DC. Actually, the lower part of the cut angle to the side and has a hinge in it to allow the blade/trunnions to swing to angle the blade. So, when the blade is down, it is almost completely inside the chute. The arrangement I used put the blast gate right at the front of the saw directly below the switch for the saw and I have the remote switches on the blast gates. So, to start the saw, I open the blast gate and that turns on the DC and then I flip the switch for the saw.
I was disappointed in the amount of sawdust that escaped the chute. I finally realized that the blade was throwing it over the chute at the front. I got some brushes that are strips about six inches long with two inch bristles. I epoxied them to the under side of my table insert and they "close" the space between the table and the chute. I actually tested the improvement by cleaning under the saw and covering the floor with a piece of paper folded into a tray. I ripped the same 2X4 several times, with and without the various things I was trying. I increased the hose form a four inch to a five inch, (no improvement) and installed my brushes and that cut the escaping the dust by about three fourths.
I doubt there is anything left to gain fiddling with the under side of the saw. What I need now is an over the blade pickup. I have learned that if you have the least amount of the blade possible exposed above the cut, you get the least dust thrown off the top. I have also learned that I have closed off my chute under the saw to the point it almost restricts the air flow. Air flow is a must. An over the blade pickup could provide additional air flow to help capture any invisible fines that are the really dangerous part. My problem is that I have a small shop and just don't want a pickup hanging down over the table.
I have thought about using my Air compressor to blow a jet of air horizontally sideways through the teeth of the blade at the rear to remove the sawdust from the gullets before they can throw it up and over. Just a matter of curiosity to see if it would work, but I have enough doubt that I have not tried it.
I have reduced my contractors saw to the point it is not a major contributor to the dust. Things like routers and hand tools make more. And with a lathe in the shop, it always something of a losing battle.
Maybe I should have said that I have reduced the "under the table" dust on MY saw to the point that there isn't very much left to gain fiddling with it.
I have a friend that used Dust Collection, Air pressure, and Vacuum in industry for his entire career for debris removal and materials handling. He looked at what I was doing and explained to me you hit the point of diminishing returns. Perhaps better minds than mine would reconfigure the situation to the point it would do somewhat better, but even then it is unlikely to be perfect. I have a 1 1/2 hp Delta DC that cost $250. If I were willing to spend three or four times as much on a cyclone perhaps it would be better, but that would mean the first $250 was able to collect about 95 to 98% of the under the table dust and the rest of the money would be spent on trying to collect the last 2 to 5%. What my friend explained is that I really don't KNOW that if I spent the money on upgrading the DC and then the ducts and then the connection to the TS it would actually collect ANY more dust. I could spend the money and make the effort and find that it was an insignificant improvement.
It would be great if the companies that made these tools would set up some sort of test lab and took a whack at it under some sort of scientific conditions. They could make various setups and rip lumber under clean room conditions and account for where the coarse dust goes and then account for the fines. This is clearly beyond my budget and apparently they don't care. Maybe some of the woodworking mags would tackle this?
It was Interesting to fiddle with my set up. Without the brushes I mentioned, I found that an amount of sawdust I could weigh on a postal scale fell into my trap I set between the feet of the saw. With the brushes in place, the amount was so small the scale did not react to it. Clearly the brushes helped the system capture about 80% of what was left. What would have been better would have been to clean the DC thoroughly and then install a clean bag. Make the rips on the test pieces and then do it again with modifications. If you had good enough scales you could weight the wood before and after the rips and the dust in the bag and then account for the losses.
I think what I need now is an over the blade pickup that has huge air flow to capture the almost invisible fines. It's fun to capture the big crap and avoid some of the shop cleaning, but in the end, that stuff is not really dangerous. Its the tiny stuff that you might inhale that will hurt you.
And, the TS is not my only tool that produces dust. I have a BS, a chop saw, a radial arm saw, jointer, planer, shaper, DP, router table in a wing on the TS, belt sander and numerous hand and power tools. I have dust collection on all the stationary tools except the DP. The dust collection on the Jointer and planer appears to be nearly perfect. Everything else produces more sawdust than the TS if you consider the amount of wood cut on each machine. IOW, cutting six inches of wood on the chop saw or RAS leaves more dust in the shop than cutting the same wood on the TS. So it appears the TS is more efficient at dust collection that the other tools. It's time for ME to quit obsessing over the TS and either do some wood working or work on the other tool's dust collection.
If your setup is the one I remember, I think it might be better than mine in several respects. Its simple to install, and requires no modifications to the saw and with excellent air flow would be as efficient.
>I think maybe the reason the saw manufactures don't care to correct the dust collection on Contractors saws is they can sell you a Hybrid or a Cabinet saw. It's not that it can't be done, they just make more money selling you a new saw.
I am truely greatful to all posters for the lively and thought provoking discussion. You all convinced me to part with my 10" Jet Contractors' Saw and buy a Jet Hybrid. I don't feel like taking extraordinary means to suck up what I think is reasonable dust residue, and the heavier motor and fine fence would make it a better saw in my shop. I wonder if the cast iron wing of my present saw will fit their hybrid?
>George. I fully agree. I have been fumadiddling around for a number of years trying, trying to collect more dust (my lungs do an excellent job of that!) from a machine never meant to send the sawdust anywhere but to the floor and surrounding air! Contractor saws are a frame with a box containing a sawblade run by a motor hanging off the back. They were and are designed to be used outdoors, not in a furniture shop.
>Unless you don't have access to 220 power in your shop you'd be better off buying the Grizzly G1023 cabinet saw for about the same price. The hybrids offer very little in upgrades for the money if you allready have a Contractors saw with a good fence. Your not really gaining much. For me there isn't enough money in woodworking to justify upgradeing nor is it neccesary, so I make do with what I have. My Contractors saw with a Unifence, link belts, and a improved dust collection has served me very well for 13 years and is still going strong. If I was running a fulltime cabinet shop things would be different, but in this economy I don't see it happening. But to each his own.
>As I mentioned above, I chose to try to completely enclosed the blade in a box That hangs straight down. It turned out that if I did that, it would hit the frame of the saw when I tilted the blade. So I put a angle in it. Still did not work, so I hinged the chute. The top of the chute is angled off to allow for the tilt. There is a cover that sits on to of the chute that closes it down to a slot about a half inch by 12" for the blade.
When the blade is vertical, the blast gate is near the right front leg. When you tilt the blade to forty five the blast gate moves to the left and hit the left leg, but the hinge allows it to swing. There is a rubber boot (piece of inner tube) around the chute that keeps it sealed while it swings.
I wish I had taken pictures while I made it, but I did not. I made two or three cardboard mock ups. Then I used sheet of metal from the Borg to make the first one. That one did not work well, so I made another. This was a tedious head scratching PITA, but a interesting challenge (obsession). I used the mounting holes for the original little half a$$ dust chute and a threaded hole I found behind the blade on the trunnion.
The cost of this was minimal. About ten bucks for the metal and five for an end boot to convert it to four inch round. But the time involved was way too much. On the other hand, now that I have figured it out, I could do it again in three or four hours.
It seems to me there are three approaches you could take here. Micro and Macro and In between. The Micro approach would be what I did, trying to capture every particle just as it come off the blade. Your approach would be the In Between with the inverted hopper under the cabinet.
The macro approach would be to enclose the base of the saw and the motor all at once. Why not build a cabinet or box that would enclose the motor? You could make this part of an outfeed table, or at least the cabinet could hide under the out feed table. The enclosure could be made out of any cheap sheet goods, even cardboard or cloth. That way, EVERTHING below the table would stay in the enclosure, including the fines. Then all you would have to deal with is the stuff coming off the top of the blade, and you have that on a hybrid or cabinet saw.
>I understand that hybrids are a compromise - a median - between contractor and cabinet. (I first typed cabijet - a Freudian slip?) However, the dust collection appears considerably improved as the blade is shrouded, and in Steel City and Craftsman at least, the trunions are cabinet mounted rather than table mounted. I have Emphysema and Asthma and already have several "dust catchers" running at all times when I am in the shop. It seems to me that the two benefits mentioned above and getting a good fence (which I should purchase anyway) are worth $1,100. I do not need the extra power of a cabinet saw or cost - $2,000. I plan to add a 220 line anyway even if I stay with my present saw.
I won't get into he discussion about which saw to buy, but have you been to Bill Pentz's web site? Lots of info there on Dust Collection.
There is controversy over Ambient Air Cleaners. Clearly they take dust out of the air, but the argument is that they stir the air and keep the particles flying until they get to the filter. In the mean time they are available for you to inhale them. So the argument it is that you might be better off to let them settle out quicker.
The best argument is to capture the dust at the source and never let it get air born or out into the air that you breath.
Also, you should be wearing an effective dust mask. Probably nothing beats personal protection.
>In a review I red recently out of 8 Hybrids the Craftsman was rated as haveing the poorest dust collection and a flimsy cabinet. For $1100 you can get a Grizzly G1023 cabinet saw, delivered. Sorry, but I don't buy into the Hybrid hype. As far as the air filtration machines go, most people that have one also have a dust collector, and if theres one machine that blows the really fine dust around the dust collector would be it. A air filtration machine in my opinion is another improvement in cleaning the air. And as mentioned, in alot of woodworking tasks a good dust mask should be used until the air clears.
>Your right the cost is minimal, but it does take some time to build. The problem is most woodworkers if I introduced the idea in pictures would attempt to build it themselves or not want to pay much for one allready built. So theres really no insentive for me to give the idea away that I've spent so much time on designing. Which really is a shame, I have 2 extra dust chutes just sitting here till I decide what I want to do with them.
Anotehr Option for Contractors Saw Dust Collection
Robby Wright
>I have an old Rockwell Contractor's Saw (same as the older Delta saw). I had one of those 14" x 14" dust pickup plates, but the dust kept building up in my saw. A lot of dust spit out the back and a ton of dust was thrown off the blade. It used to hit me in the face and get in my eyes, even with eye protection. This obviously wasn't working, so I started thinking about another solution.
I bought one of those Big Mouth dust chutes from Rockler. I screwed the chute on the bottom of the saw with the straight side at the back, then connected it to an elbow and to my dust collector's duct work. It fit the bottom of my saw perfectly.
It worked like a charm. The vastly increased air flow really sucks up the dust. The dust comes right off the blade and shoots down the chute. I have a Penn State Blade Guard/Dust Pickup, but I rarely bother with it any more, although it is a great place to hang my ear muffs. Very little dust comes off the top of the blade.
It works so well that I haven't made up anything to block the back of the saw, although the magnetic sign material sounds like a good idea. I would like to extend a small dam up about 2 inches of the back of the saw. I intend to leave most of the back of the saw open to allow lots of air to flow in. Air flowing in will stop the dust from flowing out. There is very little dust that escapes this tornado. I have a 2 HP Seco collector with the Rockler felted bags and 4" ABS pipe for duct work.
The only negative I can think of is that if you drop your arbot nut, you can plan on either fishing it out of your duct work or you are going to have to fish it out of the collector. There is no way you are going to miss that chute.
Give it a shot. You will only be out $20 in parts and if you don't like it, you can use the chute for something else.