>I am thinking about buying a spindle sander, but like most people on the board I don't have too much money to spend. Rigid has a benchtop model that is both a spindle and edge sander for $199.
Does anyone have this and how do you like?
Does anyone have any other suggestions?
I'd like a floor model but its out of my price range, and I may not have enoughh room for it anyway.
Search for a recent thread about this sander (and a part failure on one).
I have had one for a long time and it works well with both the belts and spindles. (I even liked it better when our local HD had a 90% off bargain table sale on a bunch of overstocked sanding spindles a few years ago!!)
I think the first thing I'd do would be to see how readily available the sandpaper belts would be to buy from other suppliers like McFeely's, Norton, Rockler, as well as in your local area. 4" X 24" belts don't sound to be common to me, but I guess I haven't been looking for that size, either. You just don't want to buy something you'll have a hard time finding belts for, or are tied to buying them strictly from HD.
>4" X 24" sanding belts are very common. I have a 1969 Craftsman hand held belt sander and it uses that size belt. I know there other brands of sanders that use that size also.
>I already had a Delta BOSS and 12" disk sander before I got the Rigid. The BOSS was great for getting rid of bandsaw marks on curved stuff and the disk sander took care of straight flat saw marks removal - but with some trepidation. A 12" spinning disk of abrassive WILL remove skin VERY quickly.
But the Rigid does both flat and straight and flat and curved. AND, with the tilting table, does bevels. A little louder than the Delta
BOSS and disk sander, but being able to angle the table when using the spindle sander function comes in handy. AND, the Rigid has a smaller "smallest" diameter sanding tube than available on the BOSS.
Where I to do it all over, I'd skip the BOSS and the disk sander and just go with the Rigid.
I had seen that thread, but that is the only negative I've heard, in the time I've been looking. So I was wondering if I just hadn't heard about problems, or where there really not many problems.
>Good thought Ron. I did find them at Woodcraft and Rockler. I didn't look further figuring that if they are at these two they probably are other palces as well.
>It really comes down to what you intend to do with the machine. My concerns about the rigid OSS are that the table is too small and only half of it tilts. But perhaps the biggest drawback to this machine is that the largest spindle it will take is 2" diameter.
I have no doubt that there are countless satisfied rigid OSS owners around that will tell you that they never even use the 2" spindle and that means that it is the right machine for them. I rarely use anything smaller than the 4" or 3" spindles, depending on which has the grit I want. On an OSS you generally want to use the largest size spindle that will fit what you are working on. I generally use my sander for large curves such as the 41" radius rails on the silver chest I am curently working on as well as the 235" radius curve on the legs of the same chest. On curves like this a larger drum will cut faster and be easier to hold to the line with.
Years ago I knew I wanted an older State or Max floor model but could not afford one so I opted for the Powermatic bench top with the optional 3" spindle. That sander made me a lot of money before I wore it out and upgraded to what I really wanted. The bench top sanders will all give you decent results and some will perform on a par with most of the non oil bath floor models. The key is to identify what you want the machine to do and make sure the one you get will do that.
Personally I don�t care for oscillating belt sanders as I don�t find them accurate enough for my taste. I prefer a large stationary disc sander for shaping outside curves. That said the Rigid OSS is a great option for a small shop and offers a lot of bang for the buck.
I've had my Delta BOSS sander for maybe 5 years. It has been OK and very useful for some things like sanding inside curves etc. However, I had to replace a cheap plastic gear insided the sander when it stopped oscillating. Maybe I was being too agressive, but then again... . Anyway, if I were looking for one today and had the room, I would check out the Jet floor model. Unlike the Delta, it has a 1/4 inch spindle which I could really use on tight inside curves. At the time the Clayton was too expensive and still is - at least for me. I have a fixture for my 4x24 belt sander, so I don't need another horizontal sander, but I have found that a horizontal sander is very, very useful. If I didn't have that fixture, I would check out the Rigid as well. I buy my 4x24 sanding belts from Klingspor. Make sure you have a good source for the spindles if you decide on the Rigid. Hope this helps.
>If you haven't already read it, here's a review at newwoodworker.com. I got one for Christmas and I love it. I was looking at getting a belt/disk sander, but this satisfies my needs as well as being a great spindle sander. One of my three local HDs had spare spindles in stock. They all had belts.
I have that sander and agree with the impressions above that it would self destruct with production work, but its ok for the occasional hobby use. Its mostly plastic and the parts seem to fit loosely. One of the woodworking mags about a year ago had a comparison of OSS's and found them all pretty sad, but it gave the Rigid top rating for having a belt, too. I use mine for fairing curves and it does the job. Dust collection is surprisingly good.
>i have that same spindle sander It work very well No problums with it The only thing for you to do is leve the nut loose that hold's down the belt sander If not the nut will get on their so tight that you will not be able to get it off The first one i left it tight all the time Than when i went to use the spindle sander I couln't get the nut off I use all i could to get it off All the way down to the brass nut under the rubber I couldn't get it off Belive me I took it back to HD and got a new unit del
>The FWW review picked it as best buy and top pick against Griz, Jet, Delta, Clayton, etc. Dust collection can be improved with some minor work to close gaps, etc. If you need to do 8/4 stuff on a daily basis, forget it, but for guitar work and hobby duty cabinetmaking, it's fine.