Further on Stacking & Stickering
Howard
>Is it true that no matter how long wood air dries, to get it down to 6-8% MC it has to go into a kiln?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Further on Stacking & Stickering
Howard
>Is it true that no matter how long wood air dries, to get it down to 6-8% MC it has to go into a kiln?
Re: Further on Stacking & Stickering
JohnKJordan in East TN
>The final equilibrium moisture content (EMC) depends on the average relative humidity in your area. The EMC is about 14% at 75% RH. If you live in a very dry climate wood will end up much drier.
For a lower MC without kiln drying, some people bring lumber into an interior air conditioned (heated and cooled) space. This may take many months.
Note that if you dry the wood to lower than the air-dried EMC (by kiln or otherwise), the wood will have to be stored inside or somehow otherwise be protected from gaining moisture. If kiln-dried wood is left outside or even in a unconditioned covered shed or barn, it will rapidly gain moisture from the air until it is back at the air-dried EMC.
There are many sources of information for this which you might want to check. Besides the web sites and book I mentioned earlier, another good book is "Understanding Wood" by R. Bruce Hoadley. This should be required reading for all of us who work with wood!
You may want to invest in a moisture meter (quick and easy) and/or learn how to check MC with the oven drying method. The oven-drying method is a pain but far more accurate, since it checks the MC all the way through the board instead of just the depth the meter can read.
JKJ
EMC Chart *LINK*
Lee Grindinger
>I've hosted this chart for years. There are no copyright issues so feel free to download and print it everyone.
Lee
EMC Chart
also *LINK*
Dan Donaldson
>Lee also has a nice article with the same chart here in the Woodcentral articles section.
Lee's article and chart
Thanks Dan, that article
Lee Grindinger
>That article appeared in fine Woodworking several years ago. Once the contract had run it's course I gave it to WoodCentral.
Lee
Re: Further on Stacking & Stickering
Robin Corell in Atascadero Ca
>I Air dry all my wood stickered outside with minimal protection(that means I toss a sheet of OSB or tin roofing on top of each stack) I mill all my wood at 2 1/4" through and through and often end up with slabs in excess of 24" wide. Each fall I determine what wood I think I will need/want for the next 9 months and bring that wood into my shop. Some times this wood will have been air dryed outside for 6 or 8 years and some times for as little as 1 1/2 years. once the wood is in my shop it does not go back outside.
I finaly purchased a moisture meter this past summer because I knew I was going to need to use some wood that was in my mind questionable. I decided I wanted a meter with pins and ended up with a Timbercheck meter. I had fun checking all my wood to see if my long held assumptions were right. What I found surprised me. All my wood was much dryer than I expected. The wood in my shop was all between 6-7% and some walnut that I had milled about 2 months prior was at 28% (the tree had been down for a year). Currently some wood I pulled out for a silver chest checked out at 9% I had always thought my wood had more moisture than that and varied more between seasons
For refrence I am in California about 20 miles from the ocean with the coastal mountian range between the ocean and where I live. While I am blesed with very consistantly low humidity year round. We do have our cross to bear, during the spring and fall we can have nearly 50* diferance between the night time low and the day time high which causes a drastic changes in EMC.
Robin
Re: Further on Stacking & Stickering
Barry Irby
>John Jordan's answer matched up with my training and experience.
Wood equilibrates at a MC of about 1/5 the RH.
Since the RH is usually changing daylily and even hourly, the wood sort of sluggishly follows along. So, if you were to average out the RH over the last few weeks and divide it by five you would have a rough approximation of the MC. Might take longer than a few weeks, depending on the thickness of the pieces of wood, their exposure to the surround air and their MC to start with. That's why they say it takes a year per inch of thickness to air dry wood. Way too many variables to be precise, including the species of wood.
Also, there are a number of defects that can be introduced into the wood by the drying process. Checking, case hardening, etc.
And, as he mentioned, the effects of kiln drying are not completely permanent. Kiln Dried wood will acclimate to the surroundings just as air dried wood will. It would be interesting to me to know if you air dried a piece and kiln dried an Identical piece and then left them in the same shop long enough for them to reach equilibrium, would there be ANY difference in the two pieces? Assuming neither had been damaged by whichever drying process they went through, I suspect the difference would be imperceptible.
I have built essentially all the furniture I ever built out of air dried wood. If I had any that had been kiln dried, I "savored" it so long I lost the advantage of the kiln drying, if any.
I have never had a failure of any of my pieces that I could trace to air drying. I do try to pay attention to the wood movement characteristics in my construction. And often, I do a minimal amount of stock prep and then bring the pieces into the house and store them for a few months while I work on the piece or other projects. It seems to me that the wood would be better off having acclimated to the space than not.
Hysterisis in drying
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>Wood dried below equilibrium moisture content (EMC) will not quite come back to EMC according to research done at VA Tech. But the difference is not great enough that most of us would find it important.
Re: EMC Chart
Gary Evans Tallassee, TN
>Hi Lee,
I just wanted to thank you for that chart. I use it every single day at the building where I store my wood and do my woodworking. I have been monitoring conditions both upstairs and in the basement for nearly a year now.
Knowing the EMC is high enough in the basement for the thick wood I have stored to dry gradually really helps me sleep better at night.
Thanks again,
Gary
VA Tech???? I went there.......
Barry Irby
>That was a tough three weeks!
It was a disaster for the school. I took the recipe for Iced Tea with me when I graduated.