>I used Messmer's UV Deck sealant on Ipe hardwood with terrible results. It was not Messmers HARDWOOD sealant because that product was not suggested nor stocked. I have used Watco Teak Oil on teak furniture and love it. Can I use it on Ipe wood for the deck here in Oregon?
>Ipe distributors recommend a "light oil" - whatever that is - as a surface treatment. Since it's so dense and oily Ipe doesn't do well with "sit on the top" type finishes. So your oil should work better.
>I replaced the floor of our back porch/veranda two years ago and finished it with a new Benjamin Moore deck finish product, a soya-alkyd and linseed oil product. Well, it took forever to dry, and by that time, the finish was full of bugs, grass clippings, animal footprints, etc. I actually stripped it off and recoated with Cabot "Australian Timber Oil" (?) finish, with similar ingredients in different proportions. That dried somewhat faster but still too slowly for my taste. It didn't weather the winter very well either, so last spring I rented a floor polisher and some abrasive disks and sanded the whole thing again. (Can you tell I wasn't too happy about this?)
This time I bought some Superdeck Exotic Hardwood Finish & Sealer, which had come recommended from somewhere. I could tell from the smell that it wasn't the same linseed oil type product. I tried it on a sample and it dried very fast and hard. I was thrilled. But then I looked at their website and it said that they had just changed the formula and were discontinuing the one I had purchased. That didn't sound good, so I called them up and talked to their chemistry gurus. Apparently the earlier version broke down too quickly, so they had reformulated using -- you guessed it --the same kind of recipe that my other two disappointments had used. I wasn't about to turn back because it was now May and deck season was about to be in full swing.
This product also took a long time to dry. It was more or less dust free in a couple days, but it didn't fully harden for months. At least it has held up pretty well in the weather.
Now, here's a theory that I can't prove: I think ipe has the same kind of anti-oxidant substances in it that rosewood has. These substances inhibit -- no prohibit -- these oxygen-curing finishes from doing their thing. Since this is outdoor use, I don't know what the answer is. I wouldn't recommend a barrier coat like shellac prior to the finish. I wouldn't recommend a lacquer-based or water-based product. And I suspect that all the recent VOC-mandated finish formulations have simply made it all but impossible to find finishes that will cure the way they used to.
Whatever the reason, my best advice is to put on one of the timber-oil style finishes if you want a nice, built-up finish coat. Use "teak oil" (there really is no such thing) or other oil varnish mixtures if you want something that goes on thin and dries fast. The trouble is that it won't build to a protective coating and it will get scuffed up pretty quickly. I'm hoping that now that I have a serviceable finish, I can build an annual coat on it without the drying problems. I'm prepared to be frustrated again.
>I had a ipe' deck installed in '95. I have tried a number of finishes on it and non have been successful. All of them have peeled off. I gave up and just let the boards weather like the boardwalk in Atlantic City.
One of the very few times in 40 years of marriage that I could not make the wife happy. Peter in south central nj
>I too used the Cabot oil on ipe, and it does take a while to cure. I wouldn't be surprised if Ellis is right about anti-oxidants in the wood, and there is the density issue as well. In any case, I had best results padding the oil on (disposable pad applicator), letting it sit for a while, then doing a pretty thorough job wiping off excess afterwards (a couple of rounds in sun-exposed areas, as the finish would bubble back out of pores when the wood heated up).
In fully exposed and/or high traffic areas, I needed to refinish once a year. Actually, I did it the first two years, then just let it weather-not as pretty, but easier on the feet in full sun, as the weathered grey doesn't heat up anywhere near as much. I refinished one more time before we sold the house.
If I were to build another ipe deck, I'd probably leave it unfinished.
>Ipe does not finish well with oil or oil based finishes. It's a very oily wood and the natural oil interferes with the drying and curing of oil based finishes. It's a wood that when finished for inside use, requires being first coated with shellac or lacquer as a barrier coat. I wouldn't recommend either in an exterior application.
Check the June and/or July issues of Consumer Reports. They have be performing long term tests of deck and exterior finishes for the past 8-10 years. Clear finishes have proven universally short lived. The more opaque, the longer the finish lasts. They have found some that last longer than others. However, given the oil issue with ipe, there may be none that will work for long.
>The folks I got my ipe from recommended a Messemer finish (don't recall which one) or Penofin. I've used the Penofin for several years now, and been reasonably satisfied. It is the one in their line which is allegedly formulated for ipe, or at least for exotic hardwoods. My main disappointment is that I need to put on a coat every year, and even so it looks faded and weathered by the end of the summer - and that's our short-ish summer in northern Connecticut. OTOH, recoating is very easy. I use a synthetic sanding pad, so that I basically wet sand a bit as I apply the stuff, which gives a fairly nice feeling surface. Only my railing is ipe, so doing this by hand is not a big deal. If I had a whole deck, I'd rent a machine with a pad.
I've heard folks who swear by Messemer's for ipe, but otherwise haven't heard of any other product much better than the Penofin.
>I agree that Cabot's is useless, too much of a film. I've used both Penofin and Sikkens with reasonable results, but both still require re-coating in 6 months or so (lots of UV up here at 6800'). In Oregon, you may get a year to 18 months out of them. The main thing is to put them on thin so you can re-coat without sanding off the old stuff. I may just learn to like it grey after I've used up the Sikkens I have on hand!
>A few years back I took a week long finishing class from Teri Masaschi. She said there was no such thing as a one-time finish for this application. So, per her recommendation, I recoat my 10' X 20' ipe deck with Penofin annually. Apply with a roller or garden sprayer, let set for five minutes or less, wipe off access. No worries.
She recommended either Penofin or Sikkens. As was mentioned, Penofin has a 99% product, or somethinmg like that, for ipe which is a higher percentage of ingredients than their other stuff.
>The annual drill of sanding and reapplying finish is already getting old. All I really want to do is to preserve the deep color of the ipe. If Penofin does it, that'll be fine with me, especially if it dries in a reasonable time period.
>I too have had problems with Cabot's Australian Timber Oil but only when I apply it as they suggest on the can. If I put it on with a lamb's wool applicator, give it a few minutes to soak in, then wipe it off, I have good results, very good on mahagony. If you follow the "directions," it will never dry in some areas.
Spoke with one of their tech reps who gave me the above method.
>....to spend $40 or whatever for a can of finish and then throw 90% of it away?
I used a lambswool mop and tried to extend each load of finish as far as possible with the mop, thereby accomplishing much the same thing. I guess I was still leaving too much finish on the surface.