Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Heating Garage Workshop

Posts

Heating Garage Workshop

#1

Heating Garage Workshop

Howard

>I am going to build a 25' x 25' garage shop and was intending on one electric heater on a 220 volt line. Any idea what this would cost to run if I keep it at a constant 50 degrees? Would natural gas be a cheaper alternative? Thanks for your thoughts.

Re: Heating Garage Workshop

#2

Re: Heating Garage Workshop

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Howard,

Well I guess it depends on where you live and what electricity costs vs natural gas in your region. It is hard to tell you otherwise.

A bit more information would help give us an idea.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Heating Garage Workshop

#3

Ellis Walentine

Check this out *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

>I just put these radiant electric heaters in my shop office so Charlotte wouldn't have to wear her parka to work. They are cost-effective to buy, install and run. Around here, oil and natural or LP gas are now more expensive per BTU than electricity. Wood heat is still cheaper, but it takes a lot of work.

The thing I like about these heaters besides the cost is that there is no forced air blowing dust around, and they are not baseboards, so they don't compete for floor/wall space.

Ellis


Radiant Systems, Inc.

Re: Heating Garage Workshop

#4

A.J. Hamler

How about dust?

A.J. Hamler

>Ellis, I keep a pretty clean shop, but I still manage to have a film of fine dust settle in the shop. How are these heaters affected by that?

Also, I couldn't seem to find on the link how to size one to a specific space. Maybe I missed it?

A.J.

Re: Heating Garage Workshop

#5

Dale Lenz

Re: Also...

Dale Lenz

>would these heater be a no no when spraying lacquer? Would think so, but your input would be helpful. Been using those oil filled radiator type heater when spraying lacquer, not real impressed, but they are safe.

Re: Heating Garage Workshop

#6

Re: Check this out

Larry in NW Ohio

>Howard I finally found what I was looking for, which is some sort of panel you hang on a wall. Something called eheat @ www.eheat.com , it sounds great of course. May be worth a look. Larry in Ohio

Re: Heating Garage Workshop

#7

Re: Heating Garage Workshop *LINK*

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>My shop is roughly that size. I have a Lennox "Hot Shot" heater. It's natural gas. I took a flexible natural gas pipe from my house to the shop. It's thermostat controlled. Why I like it is that I keep it set low and then when I want to work I can heat the shop very rapidly...in a matter of less than 5 minutes. Here is a link:

Tom


Lennox Heaters

Re: Heating Garage Workshop

#8

Lee Grindinger

Radiant heat and dust

Lee Grindinger

>I used radiant heat for my workshop in Montana. Never did I have an issue with sawdust burning, I just don't think enough dust can settle on the tube to cause problems as long as you blow them off before firing them up in the fall. I had a 75,000 BTU tube so it got pretty hot compared to these smaller units, the tube itself was about 4" diameter. I'm sure mine was a larger tube than the room sized ones Ellis has posted. I'd smell the heater the first time I'd fire it in the fall just as you'd smell any heater the first time it was turned on for the season but never got concerned.

For what it's worth, radiant tube heat was the best shop heat I ever had from a comfort and economic standpoint and believe me, I've worked a FEW shops in my career.

Lee

Re: Heating Garage Workshop

#9

Lee Grindinger

Check with the manufacturer

Lee Grindinger

>Mine was a sealed system. A sealed fresh air intake supplied the combustion air, the flame was spewed into the first section of the tube, then it was vented straight outdoors. There was no open flame in the shop.

Having said that, I don't know if it's rated for flammable locations.

Lee

Re: Heating Garage Workshop

#10

Re: Check this out

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Ellis, these look like very reasonably priced units. Thanks for the link. Something to stick in my back pocket for when I button up my shop with drywall and insulation :)

Jen

Re: Heating Garage Workshop

#11

Re: Also...

Bill White

>Now I don't live in the great frozen North, but it does get cold and damp here in the Magnolia State. I started using the oil filled radiators about 5 years ago. I found that I could increase the effective radiant value by sitting the heater next to heavy cast iron/metal eqipment in the shop.

Just set the thermostat, monitor daily, add a second unit on really cold times.

Don't have to worry about open flame or air filters. Keeps the digs very comfy.

Bill

Re: Heating Garage Workshop

#12

Thanks....

Howard

>Sorry I did not mention that I live in New York 30 miles away from New York City. Some good options that I will compare. Should be going to construction in around 2 months or so. Thanks again.

Re: Heating Garage Workshop

#13

And when

Joanne Adler in Pt. Pleasant, PA

>is THAT party, Jen? ;-)

Re: Heating Garage Workshop

#14

Re: Heating Garage Workshop

Jeffrey D. ROse

>I am heating a 24'X 26' shop with radiant floor heat, 2" of insulation under the floor, using an electric water heater. I keep the temp right at 50. Last month it my bill was about $10 more with the system on then when it is off. I am in Cedar Falls, IA, and would estimate the outdoor temp to be an average of 20 degree. I also have 2x6 walls with insulation and well insulated ceiling I would not choose any other way to heat, it is so comfortable. I put on a coat and can work just fine.

Jeff in Iowa.