Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

OT. alternative power

Posts

OT. alternative power

#1

OT. alternative power

Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon

>Good morning folks. Anyone out there power thier house and shop with wind, solar or a combination of the two. Our new property is just far enough from the power lines that going off grid may be a less expensive alternative. I'd sure like to hear from anyone with experience in this.

thanks

glc

PS. The house is suppossed to move at 11:00pm tonight, providing yesterday's snow doesn't foul-up the mover. It is a bright and sunny day here today

Re: OT. alternative power

#2

Re: OT. alternative power

John in New Mexico

>Unless you go hand powered, I think your power consumption will be too large for most alternative supplies - I haven't done the math though.

Best one I've heard of is to bury a couple of rail tank cars and make yourself a couple of air compressor windmills (got to use the large fan, agricultural windmills, low speed, high torque). No idea if it'd actually work, but sounds neat.

Re: OT. alternative power

#3

Gary - not really a consumer-oriented resource but

Howard In Toronto

>Hi Gary -

Check out www.cansia.ca .

They're Canada's main (self-appointed) solar industry trade association.

The info is oriented towards businesses but they have some useful general links for calculating viability of going/adding solar.

You won't need the social/business visibility but their info should provide some insight into the arithmetic and infrastuctural requirements.

Obviously Federal and Provincial grants and rebates won't apply!

Another great Canadian link is www.canadiantire.com .

They're hugely into selling their own branded solar gear but their info and worksheets is aimed squarelty at the consumer.

Also, Wired Magazine has a great article on turnkey consumer solar providers in the US west. There may be something in their website's archives.

HTH

Howard

Re: OT. alternative power

#4

Re: OT. alternative power

David Yoho

>I recently saw a show where Larry Hagman (of Dallas fame) had enough solar panels installed at his huge home that he had more than enough power for his own use and sold the excess to the electric company. I've seen several shows about folks using solar arrays to power their homes. Looks like something to possibly look into.

David

Re: OT. alternative power

#5

Re: OT. WoodCentral the "Font of All Knowledge"

Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon

>Well John, here in Central Oregon ya don't bury much of anything, unless you have cheap access to to drills and rock hammers. The lava rock on my new place gives me some good visual interest.

I do have a generator that is large enough to power any of my shop tools except the welder, up to two at a time. I would really rather not have to start a genset every time I went to the shop for a few minutes, but the may be my only option. The is a "developement" about 30 miles East of Bend that is all off grid and I know a couple of people the live or have lived out there, so I have more brains to pick. Since I consider WoodCentral the "Font of All Knowledge" and since I believe that denizens of WoodCentral possess more knowledge about more things than the Library of Alexandria, I asked the question here first.

Commercial power is about 1200 feet away, Overhead will cost about $25,000.00 plus clearing and easment acquisition (if I can even get the easments). I am having commercial water brought to the property (only 300 feet) but I don't think I can use the same ditch for mainline power and mainline water.

thanks

glc

Re: OT. alternative power

#6

For what it's worth

Craig in Silverdale

>Gary,

I have a cabin in the foothills of the Olympic mountains. It is off grid and is powered by solar. I only use it as a get away on weekends so I have a small power array. The system consists of a 120 watt solar cell and four golf cart batteries. I have never lacked for electricity even on the long dark weekends in the Northwest winter. Granted, it is mostly for lights and blower fan for the heater, but I don't have to worry about the batteries running down. The system you need will be much bigger of course. You may find you'll need a generator for larger power tools, but may be able to get by with solar for everything else. Good luck.

Re: OT. alternative power

#7

Re: OT. alternative power

Bill Hammond, Oregon Coast

>I envie you your new home, Today I am thinking that a small water turbines in the downspouts of our gutters would generate enough power to tun the house (grin).

When we first moved here we looked at a house up the Chetco River that was part of a group of homes off the grid. They all seemed to have a combination of solutions. Most had generators and soler and gas lighting and cooking and a change of lifestyle and and and.... While it seemed a bit of a cobbled together way of living it worked for them. The largest single source of alt power was not using it. The change in lifestyle was amazing to me, from laptop computer and cell phone to lots of canned goods rather then the fridge full of fresh food. At one point I felt like I had stepped into Little House On the Prairie.

Seems to me you should have lots of geothermal potential there, perhaps a thermal well with a steam electrical generating plant. Lets not forget hydrogen power cells I hear tell they are very efficient and people powered woodworking tools too.

Good luck with the house today, we expect lots of pictures.

Bill, in the rain that will soon be your snow

Re: OT. alternative power

#8

Re: OT. alternative power

Sean Troy

>If code allows underground, you may be able to find a small trenching outfit that would do it as a side job for a lot less than the overhead. I know you still have to have the power company bury the line but I think the savings would be great plus a better view. My father in law did that for a few people years ago with a big wheel trencher through solid granite for most of the run. 1-2 day job tops. best of luck, Sean

Re: OT. alternative power

#9

Re: OT. alternative power *LINK*

Robin Corell in Atascadero Ca

>There is a local builder around here who has been building green homes before there was a word to describe it. His son has started a company that builds portable solar generators. I have pesonaly seen three diferent size units all built around diferent size utility trailers and they are all top notch. Many of the parts are off the shelf and very replaceable as well as somewhat expandable. Travis recently delivered three of the large units for use on remote sites for cal Poly. I saw a 7000w unit tat was going to a client to power an off grid home and the small unit is one that his faters company uses on job sites.

If you contact him please let him know I refered you. I don't get anything but I would like him to know I support his busness all the same.

Travis also ownes a small portable bansaw mill and I had him mill some olive that was too small to do with my chainsaw.

Robin


www.mobilesolarpower.net

Re: OT. alternative power

#10

Re: OT. alternative power *LINK*

Robin Corell in Atascadero Ca

>another interesting site is otherpower.com they have some really gret info on home brew wind generators as well as some info in micro hydro electric and some limited stuf about solar. it is also a great source of interesting links.

Robin


otherpower.com

Re: OT. alternative power

#11

Re: OT. alternative power

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Gary, I have done some research on this as my youngest son is "into" solar / wind power sources etc. Oregon does have a tax credit system for alternate energy methods (Link) http://www.oregon.gov/ENERGY/RENEW/Solar/PV.shtml

There is much to think about - especially if your "off the grid". Much of the problems and expense is due to having a method of storage of the generated power that allows you to use appliances, lighting etc. when there is no sun (or wind). If you are installing systems, you would want to use as many alternate methods such as solar water heating, solar house heating etc. as possible to reduce the need for power (fans etc) - unless you are planning to heat with gas. I am assuming you will have a source of propane or NG. If natural gas is available, a generator may be the most economical method of operating your home / tools etc. when solar isn't available. Money wise, I feel sure the $25,000 you quote for running power to the house is the most economical in the long run. (not sure why you don't think you could run power lines alongside the water lines, it is done frequently). That said, I think the cost to continue to live like your "hooked to the grid" using solar or wind would be very high. The only people I have read about that are using alternate energy sources have dramatically changed their life style. They use very small (usually solid state) refrigerators, low energy lighting, no high amperage draw appliances, no outdoor lighting, no air conditioning etc. Don't know what the wind systems are costing, again storage is a real issue.

Re: OT. alternative power

#12

Re: OT. alternative power

John McGaw

>To my mind, the answer would be to have a solar + battery system for "normal" usage and a small diesel generator of the land yacht variety to enable usage of the high-drain items in the shop. This would allow you to size the solar system more rationally.

Re: OT. alternative power

#13

OT your OT

CJ McLaughlin

>If you run across a retired forest ranger named Bob Hilliard, tell him hello from Chris. I was in the Peace Corps with him down in Ecuador. He took a leave of absence from the Forest Service in Bend (John Day) to join the Corps. Last time I talked with him, he was still out there, but that was some years ago.

As an aside, I could probably give you a few tips on how the Ecuadorians handled your problem, but the lack of safe guards or any type would curl your toes.

Chris

Re: OT. alternative power

#14

Re: OT. alternative power

Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon

>Hi Bill Wells in this area are hit and miss at best. There are a couple of Known geothermal resource areas within 30 miles, both North and South, but none where I am going to be living. The variability of groundwater temprature is interesting to me. The well where I work is less than 20 miles from an actively growing bulge (well it's not growing very fast) on one of Oregon's more likely to erupt volcanoes and the water comes out of the ground at 36 degrees. We put in a bit of snowmaking a few years back and were told that if we were going to use groundwater we would need a cooling tower. The snow makers couldn't believe at 1000ft well at 36 degrees.

your rain, my snow, no move the house tonight, they don't want it slid in to the ditch. Maybe Wed.

glc

Re: OT. alternative power

#15

Re: OT. Sean / Larry

Gary Camp, Bend Oregon

>The local code certainly allows for under ground power. I am dealing with a co-op so I will bear 100% of the cost of any line extensions (unless someone adds to the line I pay for within 5 years). Right now I am still in the planning stages. As it stands today, overhead $25,000 + I pay for right of way aquisition and clearing. Undergound $20,000 + I pay excavation, vaults and conduit. ALL undergound power has to be in conduit. 300ft of waterline extension will be $10,000. It turns out that it cheaper for me to pay for 8" mainline than to put in a 2" service and pay systems and developments fees on a former line extension. I know that I can run the service lines, power and water in the same ditch with just a 12" seperation, but my excavator thought the water company required 10ft between mainline water and mainline power. Since we have finally closed on the land, I can pay the co-op $500 for engineering fees and start getting better answers, I hope

thanks for you answers, by the way, since these questions are related to SHOP power they are only slightly OT ;-)

glc

Re: OT. alternative power

#16

Re: OT. alternative power

Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon

>Robin thanks for the websites I surely will mention your name .

glc

Re: OT. alternative power

#17

Re: OT. alternative power

Bill Hammond, Oregon Coast

>Sorry your house didn't make it in today. When I lived in Connecticut I did see where half a house slid into the ditch with part of it blocking the road. Rather than wait for a crane to lift it back on to the road they destroyed it with a loader just to clear that side of the highway. So it seems better late than mot at all. Wednesday I'll be in the south of Mexico getting burned on the beach, but I'll think of you and your house in the snow. Hope you can get some pictures of the instant house, I bet many on here would like to see the interesting landscape.

Cold water from that deep is really surprising, I have read a lot about mines where that deep and it's an oven, or was it 5000 and an oven. Anyway at least it seems that your not going to have to worry about a volcano in the near future.

bill

Re: OT. alternative power

#18

Check with the local code office

John in New Mexico

>We were able to put power and water in the same ditch, you may be able to also. Your excavator might know as well. Or the power company. Good trick to know in rocky ground - sheath your water line in the next size up pipe (assuming plastic). Sure you have to buy twice as much, but that's cheap compared to fixing it!

Ahhhh, basalt! We got lucky, we're about 50' below the limestone. Our sandstone can be dug with a heavy backhoe and some persistence, the limestone up-section from us requires blasting!

Re: OT. alternative power

#19

Re: OT. alternative power

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>Maybe twenty, twenty five years ago, my grandparents put in a wind generator on their property on the Mendocino Coast of Northern California. Windmill with batteries, they used the power for things like lights, and running heaters & such for their aviaries and sheep barns. It was running well when they passed on. Out on the coast, a mile or two from the beach, they didn't have enough sunshine to reliably grow tomatoes, even though they ran a huge garden operation.

Bend has wind, right? And plenty of sunshine? The problem, as another said, is storage for the high load use. And local generation may be the answer. The problem is that you really may want to do both. Eventually, you're going to want to be connected. The beauty of wind and solar is that the generation is cheap, once the gear is amortized. Not so with purchased power.

By the way, while the ditch is open, run a conduit with telecommunications wire and optical fiber in that ditch, leaving room for more. Being off-grid for power is one thing. Being off-net is something entirely different.

Re: OT. alternative power

#20

Re: OT. alternative power

Gary Camp, Bend Oregon

>Hi Glenn Good suggestion about fiber in the ditch however.. Even though I may complain about how big Bend has gotten, it is still a small town (maybe a tiny city). The area I moving to won't see anything like fiber for a long long time. Not enough service drops per mile. The flip side is there is more than one option for high speed wireless internet without going satelite and reasonably price I might add.

I am about 8 miles East of the center of Bend, the next town (not just a dot on the map) is 120 miles and it only has a population of about 7000. The population density goes down really fast as you go East or West for that matter.

glc

Re: OT. alternative power

#21

Re: Off Grid means lots of batteries

Peter Gregory

>I'm fairly sure it would be cheaper to pay $25k to be on the grid, than to have the kind of battery bank you need on off days. The real problem with a battery bank is the continuing maintainance and lack of breakthrough battery solutions. The science magazines are talking about startups that will be making great batteries, using new, super duper technology, within 10 years. That is a long time to wait. The thought of putting the distilled water into all those batteries was enough for me to look elsewhere.

Living in a rural area, in this age of deregulated power companies is a bummer sometimes.

Re: OT. alternative power

#22

Re: OT. alternative power

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>About fiber in the ditch: You can put your equipment that hooks to the telco out at the edge of your property, and run to where you want, essentially without distance limits, or expensive amplifier gear. Unless it's 10km to the road, ;)

We ran private networks over fiber all the time, without the need to use the massive speed available, because the fiber ignored the 'noise' around it, and needed no amplification or modification to the signal, as would normally have been the case with copper lines.

If wireless is available to you, consider that. But wireless isn't always cheap, reliable, or available. At least telco services have been.

Good luck with the project. One part of me wishes you well in the small town, on your own property. The other part of me likes getting on the freeway, and going to the office.