Finishing Questions / Discussion
Joanne Adler in Pt. Pleasant, PA
>In my quest/mission to replace all of the ugly furniture (well, in my opinion, it's ugly) in my parents' house, I made them a new table for their kitchen for this year's holiday gift. It is solid cherry, 48" round top with pedestal base. It's done, except for final sanding and finish coats. There is a knot or hole on the top and one leg that I'm going to fill with some crushed stone (malachite or lapis, I think); the turning folks were very helpful on how to do this. After I do the lapidary work and final sanding, I will probably put on a coat of Sealcoat shellac. But for the overall finishing coats, I'm still undecided. I need something durable (it IS a kitchen table), but I am not a huge fan of poly. I asked the King of Waterlox, since I'd remembered that he used that on his kitchen table, and Ellis asked me to post the questions here. The answers are probably in archived posts, but I must admit to being lazy. And I'd also like to spark a discussion about something actually woodworking related here (not that I don't appreciate and learn wonderful things from OT posts). And we have a bunch of newbies lately who may not know they can search for answers.
So--durable finish for a solid wood kitchen table? What do you like? I like clear coat finishes that let the wood look like wood. I do NOT like the plastic look of thick poly. When I do use it, I tend to use water-based and wipe it on, to try to circumvent bubbles (and water-based for easy cleanup). I know it will provide a more water-resistant coat faster that 80 million coats of Waterlox, but what about scratches? Is a wiping varnish more waterproof or durable? Is it less likely to scratch? What about something like a spar varnish? I do not have a sprayer and am not particularly interested in getting one. So, let's hear it--what clear, sturdy finishes do you use?
Thanks in advance for joining the discussion,
Joanne



