Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Finishing Questions / Discussion

Posts

Finishing Questions / Discussion

#1

Finishing Questions / Discussion

Joanne Adler in Pt. Pleasant, PA

>In my quest/mission to replace all of the ugly furniture (well, in my opinion, it's ugly) in my parents' house, I made them a new table for their kitchen for this year's holiday gift. It is solid cherry, 48" round top with pedestal base. It's done, except for final sanding and finish coats. There is a knot or hole on the top and one leg that I'm going to fill with some crushed stone (malachite or lapis, I think); the turning folks were very helpful on how to do this. After I do the lapidary work and final sanding, I will probably put on a coat of Sealcoat shellac. But for the overall finishing coats, I'm still undecided. I need something durable (it IS a kitchen table), but I am not a huge fan of poly. I asked the King of Waterlox, since I'd remembered that he used that on his kitchen table, and Ellis asked me to post the questions here. The answers are probably in archived posts, but I must admit to being lazy. And I'd also like to spark a discussion about something actually woodworking related here (not that I don't appreciate and learn wonderful things from OT posts). And we have a bunch of newbies lately who may not know they can search for answers.

So--durable finish for a solid wood kitchen table? What do you like? I like clear coat finishes that let the wood look like wood. I do NOT like the plastic look of thick poly. When I do use it, I tend to use water-based and wipe it on, to try to circumvent bubbles (and water-based for easy cleanup). I know it will provide a more water-resistant coat faster that 80 million coats of Waterlox, but what about scratches? Is a wiping varnish more waterproof or durable? Is it less likely to scratch? What about something like a spar varnish? I do not have a sprayer and am not particularly interested in getting one. So, let's hear it--what clear, sturdy finishes do you use?

Thanks in advance for joining the discussion,

Joanne

Re: Finishing Questions / Discussion

#2

Ellis Walentine

Some thoughts on kitchen table finishes

Ellis Walentine

>Waterlox isn't very abrasion resistant, so I wouldn't necessarily recommend it unless your parents plan to treat it carefully and/or have a reasonable tolerance for the inevitable scratches and dulling that will occur over time. I have Waterlox on my kitchen table and it's exactly what I want -- funky, dull, utilitarian, like a workbench top. It protects the wood from grease and oil and stuff but not from abrasion. The nice thing is that you can wipe on a fresh coat anytime to rejuvenate the luster.

A few wiped coats of polyurethane might be a more serviceable finish for your parents. Seal the wood with a coat of Waterlox first if you want the warm amber color. Poly resists scratching much better than Waterlox, so it will stay more pristine. The feet of the table are also subject to constant abrasion, from shoes and mops and vacuum cleaners and such, so they might as well be finished in something bulletproof like brush-on poly. One coat of gloss followed by one coat of satin will give you a simple satin finish that will last a long time.

Poly is hard to repair if you build it too heavy. Then it becomes like a sheet of plastic. If you crush it by dropping a frying pan on it or something, it looks bad and I don't know of a good way to repair it inconspicuously. A thinner build is easier to deal with and more closely resembles a wiped-on finish, especially if you wipe it on.

Regarding glossy finishes, you can build Waterlox to any sheen you want, but it is a lot of labor to spend for the luxury of using a dust-free wipe-on finish (or the inconvenience of not having a spray booth). You need to build ten or twenty coats of 'Lox on something, with sanding between every second or third coat, to finally arrive at a high gloss finish that will reflect light evenly, but the finish is too vulnerable for working surfaces like table tops and such. You're better off spraying on a few coats of lacquer or conversion varnish. Wham, bam, rub it out, done.

You also asked me about using partially gelled finish. Waterlox is usable as long as there is enough liquid to transfer to the wood, but once it begins to gel, it becomes tackier and the gelatinous stuff fragments and becomes a mess. You have to totally wipe off the surface, which means you end up applying little or nothing for your effort. You are much better off with product that is fresh, so you can extend it over the surface and control the amount of build. This control aspect is what I've always liked about Waterlox and one other similar wiping varnish, General Seal-a-Cel.

Hope this helps.

Ellis

Re: Finishing Questions / Discussion

#3

Lee Grindinger

It's a tough decision,

Lee Grindinger

>I used to use alkyd varnishes (tung/linseed resins and oils) for nearly everything. Alkyd varnishes have a much nicer feel than the coldness and hardness of poly and up until a few years ago the alkyd varnishes met my needs. California declared war on VOC.s (unfairly) and changed the formulation of my favored varnish forcing the manufacturer to replace some solvent with oil. This changed the properties of the film so much it was no longer hard enough for table top use. This unfortunate reformulation happened to most alkyd varnishes. As a result I switched to poly for my tops. I still use alkyd for the surfaces not under the same stress top receive.

Although I generally applied 4 to 8 coats they were always sanded severely between coats so the actual film thickness upon completion was the equivalent of one or two top coats. This helped with that plastic look as did using a lower sheen rubbed out.

Poly is durable, that's it's greatest property and it's always a trade off between the natural oil look and the durability a table in use requires. It's your call. Scratches are difficult to repair in poly and deep ones require sanding and re coating the entire surface. Shallow scratches can be rubbed out with automotive polishing compounds. Scratches are a fact of life in a table that gets daily use and minor dings and scratches are unavoidable no matter what finish you use. Paste wax helps prevent scratches remarkably well.

So, on balance, I opted for the durability of poly for my work but only on table tops, I still use alkyd varnishes for everything else. Forget spar varnish for table tops, spar has more oil which makes it more flexible, a characteristic necessary outdoors where temperatures and humidities range widely. Higher oil to resin ratios make a softer but more flexible film. Higher resin to oil ratios make a harder more scratch and dent resistant film.

Lee

Re: Finishing Questions / Discussion

#4

Re: Finishing Questions / Discussion

Jesse Cloud

>I asked the same question about a year ago. The answers seemed to fall into two camps: simple oil or wipe-on that can be restored easily (and often) or a hard finish that will last a long time, but is hard to repair. Both camps have good arguments.

Personally, I am so swamped with all the maintenance chores involved in keeping a house and woodshop running that I just couldn't take on another routine maintenance chore (refresh the table top) that I went with the hard finish route. I used Behlen's Rock Hard varnish and automotive polish/wax on the top. So far, a year later, I am happy with it. It has held up well against incredible abuse. Only maintenance is an occasional spritz with water and drying with a clean cloth.

One lesson learned, though, especially with hard finishes but probably with any finish, finish the table and the breadboards separately before you attach the breadboards. The wood will move and if theres finish between the parts it will break and create a crinkly line between the parts. You can guess how I know this. ;^)

Re: Finishing Questions / Discussion

#5

Re: Finishing Questions / Discussion

loftguy

>One lesson learned, though, especially with hard finishes but probably with any finish, finish the table and the breadboards separately before you attach the breadboards. The wood will move and if theres finish between the parts it will break and create a crinkly line between the parts. You can guess how I know this. ;^)

Very good advice; BTDT, :-(.

Bob

Re: Finishing Questions / Discussion

#6

Re: Finishing Questions / Discussion

David Yoho

>Joanne, I'm in the Waterlox lovers camp. However, like others have said, it's not abrasion resistant enough for the surface of the top. This is the perfect time to use polyurethane.

I'm also big on wiping on finishes. If I were doing the tabletop, I think I'd go with two wiped-on clear gloss and one satin. Your call as to using the regular liquid poly or the gel. In gel, I like either Bartley's or Rockler's (Michael D. had a lot to do with this one).

You can go with the SealCoat as a primer/sealer coat or just use a thinned version of which ever top coat you decide on.

David

Re: Finishing Questions / Discussion

#7

One trick...

David Yoho

>If you finish any panel that includes a breadboard end and don't finish them separately, one trick that helps after the finish is on is to take a sharp razor knife and gently cut along the joint line between the panel and the breadboard end. This will break the finish at that joint and the two can move without problems afterward.

David

Re: Finishing Questions / Discussion

#8

Forget....

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>the shellac and polymerizing finishes. Solvent based alkyd lacquer is the answer.

Clint

Re: Finishing Questions / Discussion

#9

Re: One trick...

Ed Wozniak, Buffalo, NY

>David,

Do you perform your razor blade trick while the finish is still wet or do you do it after the finish has dried?

Thanks.

Ed

Re: Finishing Questions / Discussion

#10

Re: Finishing Questions / Discussion

Howard Acheson

>>> like others have said, it's not abrasion resistant enough for the surface of the top.

I'm a little confused. Which Waterlox product are you referring to? Waterlox is just a brand name of a family of finishing products. Waterlox makes both non-poly and poly finishes as well as oil/varnish products.

Their Original Gloss used to be called "Gym Floor Finish" and is frequently used as a substiture for polyurethane varnish. It stands up very well on any abused surface I have used it on. The Original Satin is also very "tough". The Waterlox Poly Varnishes are also very good.

Re: Finishing Questions / Discussion

#11

Almost The Same Here

George@Colonel's Workshop

>Good Afternoon Joanne,

Of late, practically all my furniture has been cherry, and I finished it in a fashion similar to what David discribes above. For a kitchen table in my family, its almost a no brainer that kids will use ice skates, amnd others will use it as a cutting board. Therefore: poly. I do like to put the furniture outside for a week of sunburn, and use Seal Coat. The color is very nice, and the slight amber tint makes it all the more delicious. I may use another couple coats more of wiping poly than David, but subscribe to Lee's way of keeping the build disciplined.

George

Re: Finishing Questions / Discussion

#12

Or waterborne poly floor finish...

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>with aluminum oxide additive.

Clint

Re: Finishing Questions / Discussion

#13

Re: Finishing Questions / Discussion

Ken Krawford

>Joanne,

I just finished a Jatoba kitchen table and finished it with General Finishes Water Based Precatalyzed Lacquer. It sprays like a dream and so far has withstood everything my 3 yr old granddaughter has thrown at it. I'm not sure if it can be brushed. If you're interested, contact Jeff Jewitt at Homestead Finishing.

Re: Finishing Questions / Discussion

#14

Re: Jasco brand tung oil & General HF

Robin Corell in Atascadero Ca

>My two favorite finises are jasco brand tung oil and more recently Generals HP poly. Most anyone will quickly tell you that tung oil is not rated very highly for its abrasion resistance. The key here is that tung oil is one of those murky words where by adding finish on the end it can be anything with some tung oil added to it. While jasco tung oil does not have finish added to the name I believe it is still one of the concotions that has some driers and varnish resins added to it. In the opast I have used it for two floors as well as a workbench top all with very impressive results. Its pergormance to water and solvents has been unbelievable as has its wear as a floor finish. both charicteristice that are not normally associated with tung oil. IIRC Elis has some experiance with this finis as well as had good words for it. at one time it was dificult to find, due to a factory fire and a purcahce of the comapny. I currently buy my Jasco tung oil at Orchard Supply Hardware, which is owned by Sears. I should add that Jasco has a very amber color and is great at enhancing the color on walnut and cherry but it may not be desireable with your stone inlay.

Recently I have started using Generals HF poly. it is a water based finish thet is clear and when dry sands like nitrocelulose. I bruch it on but it can also be sprayed. I startd using it after reading a review in FWW a while back and if I remember all the rating catagories its only shortcoming was for heat resistance. I'm not sure how this was determined or rated but I t was some real workd quantitative thing like heating smething up and drooping it on the finished wood and looking at the results. I have found that the finish is a bit soft for a few days and continues to develope hardness for almost a month. I have used this finish for a table and will not hesitate to use it for a kitchen table in the future where I want a crystal clear finish.

Robin

Re: Finishing Questions / Discussion

#15

Re: One trick...

David Yoho

>I did it before it was totally dry.

David

Re: Finishing Questions / Discussion

#16

Bartley vs Rockler, and the myth of 'plastic'

Michael Dresdner

>Today's trivia:

Both Bartley gel and Rockler gel are made by the same company in the same small factory. Incidentally, there is a good bit of evidence that this near sesquicentennial firm was the first to 'invent' the wipe on gel finish.

Plastic?

For years I have heard people slam polyurethane as looking plastic, then have them amazed when I showed them wood I finished in polyurethane that looks anything but. The reason is two-fold. First, most of the 'polyurethane' blamed for that plastic look is in fact either polyester or polyurea. Second, polyurethane is a catch-all -- there are five distict chemical types, and the one used on most automobiles as clear coat (definitely the plastic looking sort) is vastly different than what we use on furniture.

Most important in this discussion is what Lee and others have said -- it's not just the finish, but how it is applied that matters. You can apply lacquer thickly enough so that it, too, looks like plastic. In fact, the old plastic pickguards and bindings on acoustic guitars was for decades made from the same plastic used to make lacquer; cellulose nitrate.

Fun fact: Except for experienced luthiers, most people can not tell whether a Fender guitar is done in lacquer or polyurethane. The company has used both over the years, and both finishes are still used today for various models.

Oh, I forgot to vote. Here it is: use a wipe on polyurethane like Watco (a liquid version) or Bartley or Rockler gels, on the table top. Wipe on polyurethanes are just as durable as brushable and are easier to apply.

Re: Finishing Questions / Discussion

#17

Re: Jasco brand tung oil is....

Howard Acheson

>... a thinned wiping varnish. It's not an oil at all. It is a varnish pure and simple. Being a varnish is is more durable and tougher than an oil/varnish or a pure oil.

Re: Finishing Questions / Discussion

#18

Re: Jasco brand tung oil is....

Geary from NJ

>Almost last, but not least,my 2 cents; About 2 years ago,I finished my farmer's dining table with Fornbey's tung oil.(4coatsw/light sanding in between). With 4 daughters,and a BUNCH of grandkrunchers,this table takes a beating every day. Dents, scratches,bubble gum,coffee,soda,playdoug,Elmer's glue and occasional alcoholic beverages,all manage to adorn this table. All I ever do, is wash it w/ soap and water . Recoat when my "other half"deems it so. TUFF AS TUNG! Geary PS;doing a side board w/ tung oil top as we speak!