Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Tool Life Expectency

Posts

Tool Life Expectency

#1

Tool Life Expectency

EmtFFKev

>I am trying to work on an excel spreadsheet for my tools as a project for a class i am taking. One of the inputs I'd like to have is the max life expectancy that I should be able to get out of a particular tool. Is there a way to figure this out? A website maybe with general expectancies?

Thanks a bunch,

Kevin

Re: Tool Life Expectency

#2

Re: Tool Life Expectency

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>...max life expectancy that I should be

>able to get out of a particular tool

Yikes, that that sounds incredibly difficult! A good hand tool could last for generations. A cheap cordless drill will probably not.

I think the maximum life would depend on factors such as the type, quality, use, and care of the tool, and how much rebuilding is planned.

For tools that need regular sharpening, such as a bowl gouge for a lathe, I suspect you could measure the minimum metal removed for each sharpening, and calculate the number of sharpenings before you judge the tool too short to use. For a power tool, I think you'd have to decide whether the maximum life included replacing bearings and replacing or rebuilding the motor.

I think I'd just make some guesses. One idea - when my job required extimating things, I ususally provided a range instead of a fixed number.

JKJ

Re: Tool Life Expectency

#3

Not trying to be flip, but . . .

steve mackay

>I figure if I get twice the warranty anything longer is gravy. But Mr. Jordan is right on. Good, well built tools ( and most machines for that matter ) with care and regular maintanance can out last all of us.

Re: Tool Life Expectency

#4

JL

Re: Tool Life Expectancy

JL

>Depends on the use and what care is taken of the tool.

A good quality hand tool can last for generations, even with constant use.

A good quality power hand tool can last for several years (or longer) with fair use if it is taken care of. It could also last for only a year or so with "abusive" use.

Larger quality pieces of equipment can last for years if proper care is taken.

Re: Tool Life Expectency

#5

Re: Tool Life Expectency

Robin Corell in Atascadero Ca

>My foot operated mortice machine was made sometime between 1916-1925 it is in original condition with the original electric motor which has bronze bushings rather than ball bearings. the machine has been extensively used, but was apparently well maintained as it works beautifuly.

Conversely I am on my second set of batteries for my second cordless drill.

Robin

Re: Tool Life Expectency

#6

Re: Tool Life Expectency

EmtFFKev

>Thanks for the input guys. That makes alot of sense as far as the tools go. On a second note is there a standard as far as consumables go? Router bits, drill bits, saw blades...stuff like that? Hours of operation or something like that?

Re: Tool Life Expectency

#7

That's Because *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>It's about the same price to buy a new tool with 2 batteries included as it is to just buy new batteries!!

The link is an alternative to the OEM Battery Racket. Just make sure your tool's battery cases are screwed together rather than solvent welded.

mm


Primecell

Re: Tool Life Expectency

#8

Re: Tool Life Expectency

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>On a second note is there a standard as far

>as consumables go? Router bits, drill bits,

>saw blades...stuff like that? Hours of operation

>or something like that?

I think that would largely depend on the material being cut and factors such as heat generated, related to the material and how much force is used. If the variables are constrained, say, to something like "continuous cutting slots in material xx to depth xx with brand xx spiral upcut router bits of diameter xx at xx rotational speed at xx ips", some empirical analysis might be done, but getting more general results would be a huge task.

I searched with Google and found some scientific papers describing analysis methods for such research, but saw no published results. Due to the variable nature of wood, I suspect it would be easier to find estimates for metalworking tools than woodworking tools. I once read a magazine article describing tests done with certain drill bits in wood, but if I remember, that article was primarily concerned with quality of cut.

JKJ

Re: Tool Life Expectency

#9

There might be

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>There might be.... in the industrial/prodution area of woodworking, especially where CNC machines are concerned. Perhaps in some of their trade machines, etc. But for the woodworkers like us, I've never heard of anything like this. Unless you count things like "I was just finishing up the last leg on the ABC and that's when my XYZ tool/bit gave out"

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Tool Life Expectency

#10

rebuilt = spend less get less

Robin Corell in Atascadero Ca

>if you do the math on rebuilt batteries its not as good of a deal as it appears. The cost of a new 3.5 amph panasonic battery is $85 or prime cell will rebuild my battery with 2 amph cells for $35 plus s&h. By the time you addd s&h it is more than half the cost of a new battery at my local tool supplier. But then the 2amph cells are only a bit more than half the capacity of the 3.5amph cells and will need to be charged more frequently and as we all know it is the number of charge cycles that determines how long a battery lasts. my interpretation is that with prime cell you get close to half the battery for close to half the price, not much of a savings in my book.

Robin

Re: Tool Life Expectency

#11

Re: rebuilts

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Robin,

Think you're comparing 3+ah NiMH with 2+ AH NiCads.

I have several contractor friends who use their rebuilt batteriies in the 18v and 24v classes and swear by (not at) them. They save about $15 per battery per rebuild over store-boughts which is way more than either the shipping or the sales tax. These guys use a LOT of battery tools, so I tend to take their advice.

I have not, as yet, had PrimeCell rebuilt one for me, but my trusty Ridgid 12v is getting near the time.

mm

Re: Tool Life Expectency

#12

Re: Tool Life Expectency

awh

>Hands tools can last a couple of generations, but I would guess that most portable power tools outlive their life expectancy and get replaced, not because they wear out or break, but because of new features or innovations... I can give you 3 examples because just a few days ago I pack away tools that were common and considered the norm 30 years ago but seem to pale when compared to what is available today.

1/4" chuck, single speed electric drill has been replaced by 1/2" variable speed, reversing, rechargeable drill with a torque clutch for driving screws.

1/4" collet single speed router has been replaced by a variable speed, soft start router that has interchangeable collets to accepts both 1/4" & 1/2" bits. Many routers also have built-in work lights and provisions for dust collection.

7-1/4" circular saw has been replaced with a saw that has the same size (7-1/4") blade but now has an electric brake and dust collection.



Tony Haukap

Home Page - http://www.cyberspace.org/~awh/

--

Re: Tool Life Expectency

#13

Re: Tool Life Expectency

Jesse Cloud

>General formula is warranty + 1 day ;^)

What I would suggest is to state what type of work you will be doing, e.g., cabinet shop, finish carpentry on site, framing, fine woodworking, etc. Then ask someone who has been in that business what they bought over the last few years.

Otherwise there are just too many variables, e.g. what type of material you are cutting, duty cycles, are the tools tossed into the back of a pickup and used in the rain and mud, etc. etc...

Re: Tool Life Expectency

#14

Re: Tool Life Expectency

EmtFFKev

>I see where ya'll are coming from here. I am just an average hobbyist with a small shop. The main purpose for this is to try and set aside some money based on when I think tools will be failing me, so I'm not in the dark for a little while :). From the sounds of it for the low volume use I am going to be having in my shop, this shouldn't be a problem.