Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Need Help Choosing Miter Gauge

Posts

Need Help Choosing Miter Gauge

#1

Need Help Choosing Miter Gauge

Cody Lewis

>I'm to the point now that I think I need to get a good mitre gauge for my table saw. I think the standard issue mitre gauge that came with it is holding me back a bit. Incra seems to be a popular choice, but there are a lot of options out there, and I'm not sure if there's a better value. Can anyone give me some guidance? I'm willing to pay for high quality but like most don't have an unlimited supply of $, so I want to be smart about it.

Re: Need Help Choosing Miter Gauge

#2

Re: Need Help Choosing Miter Gauge

Chuck W

>I just purchased the Incra V27 which seems to be a lot of miter gauge for the money. They make other more expensive models which look very good as well.

Re: Need Help Choosing Miter Gauge

#3

Re: Need Help Choosing Miter Gauge

Hal

>I've had my Incra 1000SE for over 3 yrs. and am pleased with it. Would not hesitate to buy it again. Good luck. Hal

Re: Need Help Choosing Miter Gauge

#4

Re: Need Help Choosing Miter Gauge

Jim Dillon

>Cody,

IIRC, I got the one from Woodhaven and then built a sliding wooden fence for it. It has been useful at times, but I have to say I use my 12 inch wide TS sled a LOT more for simple cross-cutting. But a good miter gauge is also good to have on hand. Just my 2 cents. Have a Happy New Year!

Jim

Re: Need Help Choosing Miter Gauge

#5

Opinions on JDS, Osborne and Jessem

Charles R. Smith

>Cody, I have three after-market mitre gauges, and like all three of them. I have two cabinet table saws (Delta Unisaw and General), and the mitre gauges have all been used and abused.

I started with the JDS Accu-Miter (www.jdstools.com) about 15 years ago, and it is a faithful workhorse. It was the first one I purchased, and I immediately appreciated the fact that it kept my fingers in a safer position than with the standard mitre gauges. It runs about $220.

I appreciate the beefy strength of triangulation mechanism on the Osborne EB-3 by Excalibur (www.osbornemfg.com), which I bought just after it was released some years ago. However, there has been some suggestion by others that, after its manufacturing went from Canada to Asia, it may not be as good. You would need to canvas the opinions of others on that. It runs about $110. My only other caution is that for cuts that demand 1/64" accuracy or better, I use the other mitre gauges rather than the Osborne, as it has developed just a very slight bit of play over time.

My newest, and favourite, is the JessEm Mite-R-Excel (www.jessem.com), which costs about $250. It is incredibly robust and its shot-pin accuracy is a joy to use. As a cost-control move, Jessem recently moved from Canada to the U.S., and I expect that move will help maintain its high quality of manufacturing standards. I think I like this one the best from the safety viewpoint, although all three feel safer to use than the standard mitre gauges which came with the saws.

Anyway, those are my experiences in a nutshell. But you will need to seek the opinions of those who have experience with other products. And a happy new year to you!

Charles (who still has all ten digits on his forepaws, after 20 years of woodworking, thanks to good mitre gauges)

Re: Need Help Choosing Miter Gauge

#6

Re: Need Help Choosing Miter Gauge

George@Colonel's Workshop

>Good Afternoon Cody,

I felt the V-27 was the optimum choice when I considered quality and price. I commonly use a cross cut sled on the table saw, but I needed somethingwhich would allow me to do miters accurately. The detents of the V-27 make adjustments quick and easy, repeatable and acurate. Further, there is slop adjustment to maintain the accuracy. I would like to have an adjustable fence for the V-27 miter guage, but really can do without it. I have found the V-27 has provided happiness along with good results.

George

Re: Need Help Choosing Miter Gauge

#7

Re: Need Help Choosing Miter Gauge

Patrick Schupbach

>My Woodhaven has served me well for many years. Hope this helps!! Happy New Year!!

Re: Need Help Choosing Miter Gauge

#8

Re: Need Help Choosing Miter Gauge *LINK*

knotscott

>I've got an Incra V27, an Osborne EB-3, and a Jet/Woodhaven Deluxe....all work well. The V27 is easily the most bang for the buck....it benefits from a shopmade or aftermarket fence, but is otherwise ready to go and excellent. The Woodhaven is the most rugged but is also the most cumbersome to adjust. My EB-3 works well now, but was problematic when I bought it and service was poor.


V27

Re: Need Help Choosing Miter Gauge

#9

Another Option Worth a Look *LINK*

David Yoho

>Cody, if it's a simple everyday miter gauge you really want, then this may be off base. That said, I have the stock miter gauge that came with my Jet cabinet saw and it does good enough for the little I use it. When I need to crosscut or miter on my tablesaw, I usually turn to my Dubby. Actually, I have two - a right and a left version and use them almost exclusively for many years now. They're more accurate than a miter gauge, can crosscut panels and most anything else, can cut very accurate miters, and the built-in stop makes repetitive cuts a breeze.

If this sounds like something that interests you, check out the Website link below to learn more about it.

David


Dubby -- Inline Industries

Re: Need Help Choosing Miter Gauge

#10

Re: Opinions on JDS, Osborne and Jessem

Ells in Boulder

>I just came across this:

http://www.woodmagazine.com/wood/slideshow/slideShow.jsp?slideid=/templatedata/wood/slideshow/data/1197301200967.xml&catref=wd1&page=10

May be a low-end option. Would like to know if anyone has one?

Ells

Re: Need Help Choosing Miter Gauge

#11

Re: Need Help Choosing Miter Gauge

David Hay @ Denver

>I have the Osborne EB-2 and generally like it. However, I noticed the other day that there is a little play in the preset stops, so when I zero the gauge to 90 degrees, I still need to check it with a square.

It has some nice features, but I'd probably be looking at other gauges if I were buying again today. In particular, I'd probably look at the sled style gauges. There's been just enough times where having the extra width capacity would have been nice (e.g. my board was just a bit wider than the distance from the saw blade to the edge of the table).

David

Re: Need Help Choosing Miter Gauge

#12

Re: Need Help Choosing Miter Gauge

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Cody for the last few years, I looked at many of the gages on the market at the Woodworking shows held in Indianapolis. This year I sprung for the Incra 3000 SE, with the little sliding table. They had a show special - picked up the whole package for about $330. It had several features I felt were quite good. The unit has no flex, even with the stop set at 48". The stop fence features allow "locking" the stop in 1/32" increments - and adjusting in between. The stop will bear on a miter you already cut as well as a square board. The angle adjustment locks every 1/2 degree. The addition of the slider really helps in maintaining position of the board being cut. Although a little pricier that most I think it is a good value.

Re: Need Help Choosing Miter Gauge

#13

a vote for JDS

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I have not used any other but I like its beefiness, and ability to set it for making multiple cut- to- length pieces that turn out exactly the same. Mine stays on the Unisaw.

Re: Need Help Choosing Miter Gauge

#14

JessEm Mite-R-Excel

M. McNamee

>I first 'upgrade' was a Rockler miter gauge and just could not get consistent 90 degree cuts. Then I bought a Incra V27 and still could not get consistent 90 degree cuts.

Finally bought the JessEm Miter-R-Excel. Out of the box, always consistent 90 degree cuts. It is heavier than the others. That is due to the rock solid quality construction.

Once again I had the learn the same lesson the hard way, you get what you pay for.

Re: Need Help Choosing Miter Gauge

#15

Re: Opinions on JDS, Osborne and Jessem

Cody Lewis

>Charles,

Thanks for the thorough explanation. You've given me some options to chew on. I appreciate the time you took.

Re: Need Help Choosing Miter Gauge

#16

Re: Another Option Worth a Look

Cody Lewis in LV

>David, very interesting. Thanks for sending. I can't tell from the pictures, though, how is it as accurate as some others? Appears that the repeatability is entirely dependent on the user's ability to return the fence to the same angle. I'm guessing it's more scientific than that....

Re: Need Help Choosing Miter Gauge

#17

Re: JessEm Mite-R-Excel

Cody Lewis in LV

>Martin, does the JessEm have the adjustments that eliminate play in the mitre slot on the tablesaw, like others in the market?

Re: Need Help Choosing Miter Gauge

#18

Get an SCMS instead

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>I limit my TS to ripping and cutting panels with a sled. My Makita 10" SCMS, and more recently a Hitachi 12" SCMS with micro adjust and laser do all the simple and compound mitering and beveling I can stand.

Clint

Re: Need Help Choosing Miter Gauge

#19

Dumb Question - miter gauges

Cody Lewis in LV

>Thanks to all for the advice and suggestions. It has been very helpful. Here comes a dumb question, but I have to ask. I've noticed that in every photo and demo video the makers and marketers of these miter gauges all show the miter gauge in the miter slot to the left of the blade. I have always used the miter gauge on the right side of the blade. The other way seems completely backwards and unnatural to me. Am I doing it wrong, or is it just personal preference?

Re: Need Help Choosing Miter Gauge

#20

Re: Another Option Worth a Look

Earl

>I have both the Incra v27 and Dubby. I always turn to the Dubby for accuracy. Earl

Re: Need Help Choosing Miter Gauge

#21

Re: Another Option Worth a Look

David Yoho

>Appears that the repeatability is entirely dependent on the user's ability to return the fence to the same angle

Here's what I know from over 15 years of working with the Dubby - it's accuracy is dead on. I set my first one up (left side version) all those years ago, never adjusted it since, and I'm still getting perfect square cuts.

If you're talking about repeatability in cutting miters, no problem. You can cut miters two ways. One is by swinging the arm to the desired angle, which is easily set with the scale on the edge of the Dubby fixture, or you can leave the fence (arm) in the 90-degree position and tilt the blade to the desired angle. It depends on which orientation your miter cut needs to be made.

Now, for repeatability with the fence set to the desired angle -- let's say you've cut several miters and for some reason need to swing the fence back for a few normal crosscuts -- before I move the fence I take my 5-mm pencil and place a mark along the fence near the angle scale. When I need to go back to cut the exact same angle as before, I simply swing the fence back to the mark, tighten the fence in place, and cut perfect angles again.

You can call that the user's ability to return the fence to the same angle and I guess it is. And guess what? It's simple and it works!!

I'm not trying to talk you out of a miter gauge. What I am trying to tell you is sooner or later you're going to need something with more capacity than a miter gauge will handle safely and accurately. The Dubby can handle all your everyday run-of-the-mill needs and those that go beyond them. The only time mine isn't on my saw is when I'm ripping stock or sheet goods.

I don't know if anyone else here is using one but maybe you can ask to see what other owners think about it. Many guys make their own crosscut sleds. The thing is - a Dubby is more than a one trick pony.

My 5-cents!

David

Re: Need Help Choosing Miter Gauge

#22

Re: Dumb Question - miter gauges

David Yoho

>Nothing wrong with the way you're using it for crosscuts. However, my guess for why you see demos using the miter slot to the left of the blade is because probably more folks use a right-tilt saw. If I'm cutting a miter on a right-tilt saw using the miter gauge, I like to be to the left of the direction that blade is pointed.

David

Re: Need Help Choosing Miter Gauge

#23

Re: Dumb Question - miter gauges

Jim Dillon

>Cody,

Nothing wrong with how you are using your miter gauge, at least for regular 90 degree angle cross-cuts. Like David said, probably most right-handed folk are more comfortable with cutting bevels with a miter gauge mounted to the left of the blade and the blade tilted away from them, but as long as the offcut is not being trapped in any way, your method is fine.

Jim

Re: Need Help Choosing Miter Gauge

#24

Re: Need Help Choosing Miter Gauge *LINK*

Bob Lemon Sacramento Ca.

>Cody, You've gotten some great information on miter gauges. Here is my preference - the JoinTech Smart Miter. The web site has 2 demo videos showing how to set it up and use it. It's a great miter/sled.


http://www.jointech.com/smart_miter.htm

Re: Need Help Choosing Miter Gauge

#25

Kreg

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>LOML purchased a Kreg mitergauge for me for Christmas. The setup was easy and it seems solid. The only problem I've noted, and it may only be my saw, is that the srews they provide for eliminating side play don't play well with the sides of my miter slot. The machining is a series of circular rings (sort of like tooth marks) and the result is a ratcheting feeling as yo slde the miter gague across the saw. Putting some UHMW tape on the sides helped smooth things out, but there is still some bumping I can feel.

The only other concern is the pin they use for locking in the preset angles is not attached to the miter gage. If it gets dropped or lost, you would lose the precise locations. The vernier scale would help get exact set ups if that did happen.

Other than that I like the whole set up and it seems to be well made.

Lee