Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Does anyone have a trick for removing v-tape?

Posts

Does anyone have a trick for removing v-tape?

#1

Does anyone have a trick for removing v-tape?

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryDZmgloT+ZiYFgX

>I have about 200 running feet of veneer tape to remove tonight.

What I normally do is dampen a rag, to wipe it down and get it wet, then scrape it off with a scraper that I sharpen with a wide sharpness angle, >30�, with a slight arc along the edge, rather than straight.

I try to keep the right amount of moisture in the tape ahead of where I am working, and keep the scraper more or less perpendicular to the face. With my left thumbnail, scrape the crud off of the edge about every 6" or so. Even with pretty fast hand movement, this is going too slow.

I know in the past that I have gone straight to the stroke-sander with it, but clots of the tape does build on the belts, and since this is some incredible curly koa, I don't want to risk sanding through the face while trying to get through the tape.

While we are on the subject, I will state again that I quit using veneer tape a long time ago, and use drafting dots about every three inches instead. I could have them off by the time the water soaks into this tape, so if this is the norm for you guys, I suggest one of you give my method a try, and get back on here and give your opinion. I would like to know that if I share my tips that someone tries them every now and then. Thanks K

Re: Does anyone have a trick for removing v-tape?

#2

Not that you deserve it ;-)

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryDZmgloT+ZiYFgX

>I don't know if I basically described the way most of you do the same task, or none of you use veneers, but I kept trying things, and found a little trick that helped quite a bit.

In the first post, I was using just a sharp edge, having found that a rolled burr just loaded too fast to offer any benefit. However I decided to try a bunch of different sharpening tricks, and thought a really small bur might work better than none. It made a little difference, but what I found next was to skew the blade around to about 45� to the line of travel, and tilt the blade about 30� forward. This gave the wad of paper / glue goo a way out without just forming a lump stuck on the end to the scraper.

After getting that figured out, I tried going back to a larger bur, which was fine now.

However, I would like to say, since most of you probably still sharpen your scrapers the old way, with a square edge, then burnishing a bur to both sides, I use a different sharpening technique.

Both of my thumbs are giving me a bit of pain, so I can't bend the scrapers, so what I buy is sold in the paint store, are about 3 wide, bent about 30� about 1.5" from the handle,and have a handle, which I cut about half off. I use them with one hand, on the pull stroke.

I sharpen them about like one would a plane iron, but with a curve along the edge, rather than straight. I roll the bur against a smooth rod cut from a shock-absorber, which rolls back and forth on the bench top. I start rolling with the blade tilted about 45� toward the bevel side, and b ring it up to 90� in about 6 quick motions. With my grinding set-up, I can remove the old dull bur, and have a razor edge in one minute, and still have a edge which will shave after rolling the bur, which only takes a few more seconds.

Anyway, since none of the 116 of you who read the above had any suggestions, I thought I would share what I learned.

However I don't plan to quit using the drafting dots, they are still much faster and easier to use. Since nobody responded, I won't bother taking your time to elaborate on that.:

Re: Does anyone have a trick for removing v-tape?

#3

Re: Not that you deserve it ;-) Have a heart, Kei

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>It has been a long time since I have done any veneering. Probably because of little frustrations like having trouble getting the tape off. :)

You are now in the position of knowing more about this fine art than all of the folks who read your post. So please don't bow out and not share information with us. That is the beauty of this forum. We rely on the folks who know more than we do.

I have the drafting dots but would never have thought of using them this way. Any other cool ideas?

And I like your scraper idea, but this visually challenged person would love to see a picture, especially with the sharpening set-up. Any chance? I have used paint scrapers with the four-sided blade, but I think what you are describing is different???

Re: Does anyone have a trick for removing v-tape?

#4

Re: Ditto to Carol!

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>There's a couple of hundred folks in my woodworkers' club I know. And maybe that many more of you on the web whose names I recognize as consistent contributors.

There are perhaps a dozen I could count who consistently work with veneer, and most of those folks have been doing it for much longer than I have been trying to do what I call fine work.

What you described in both posts was useful, and I filed it away for when I get to the stacks of nice veneer I picked up on sale back three summers ago. I wish I had something to offer you. I don't, other than the same thanks that Carol had for the information you shared with us.

It's one of the reasons I hang out here. Smart people who share what they know. But it's a holiday weekend. Many folks, who don't have a cold, may be away, doing other stuff.

In fact, I'm due in the shop now!

Re: Does anyone have a trick for removing v-tape?

#5

Thanks Carol

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryDZmgloT+ZiYFgX

>I know this was a mundane subject, and nobody really wants to think of it as fww, but rather just one of the drudgery parts of the dance of getting to the glorious part. Namely the end. Usually it is a smaller task than it was for me this time.

I realize that most of the readers here probably are into woodworking as a hobby, and just a way to spend time, feeling productive. For the rest of us, time is money.

Don't let my gruff nature bother you, I really don't mean to come off mean, I usually assume that everyone knows that I am kidding. I am usually more critical of myself than others.

OK, The next time I am veneering where I need to use the dots, I will take some pictures.

As for the scraper sharpening / burnishing, I will be happy to take some photos, and write something showing the details, but I need more feedback than just one, and maybe someone like David Yoho or the other staff to take my photos and put it together. I have not figured out a lot of what I need to know to make and meet the photo sharing thing easy. I can shoot the photos down to the gnats eyebrow and email them, but get hung up being a computer neanderthal.

Re: Does anyone have a trick for removing v-tape?

#6

Oh man, now you're talking....

David Yoho

>Now you're talking something I know about. Take those pictures, write the text in an email (doesn't need to be an essay but it's your choice), attach the photo files to the email and send them to me. I'll take it from there and create your very own Shop Shot!

Questions? Email me and I'll help if I can.

David

Re: Does anyone have a trick for removing v-tape?

#7

Re: Does anyone have a trick for removing v-tape?

Sgian Dubh

>I'm one of the 116 that read your post and saw no particular reason to comment Keith. If the drafting dot tape technique works well then that's interesting.

I suppose that I can comment that I'd expect to see a series of circular indentations after the tape is removed, that's if the tape can be removed successfully without tearing out chunks of the grain with it. It's similar in thickness and gum type to masking tape which I have seen tried several times and causes indentation and grain tearing problems. The problem is caused by the heated hydraulic presses and heated vacuum bag presses I've used over the years for veneering. Masking tape is hopeless in my experience with traditional hide glue and hammer veneering and I'd expect drafting dots to have similar non-functionality.

However, I might one day guillotine up some scrap veneer and try using drafting dots to join the edges and whack it all down on a bit of scrap MDF board just to see if what I suspect will happen does happen. Slainte.

Re: Does anyone have a trick for removing v-tape?

#8

Re: Does anyone have a trick for removing v-tape?

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryDZmgloT+ZiYFgX

>Richard, I have read your post long enough to know that at some point you have had to use masking tape on drafting paper to know the difference when it comes time to remove it, so I will anticipate hearing your appraisal. Although it sounds like you may be using something with more pressure than I get at 28" hg. in my v-bag.

I have in a pinch used masking tape for veneers, and as you know regretted having to remove the gum from the seam. I don't have that problem with the dots, because they are made to peal.

I am not suggesting that they can be used for those warped and buckled veneers, and for larger sheets, I usually tape them up on top of another sheet of something else like scrap laminate or 1/4" mdf to flip over. Life is full of trade-offs. To improve one thing usually looses something else somewhere else.

Re: Does anyone have a trick for removing v-tape?

#9

Re: Oh man, now you're talking....

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryDZmgloT+ZiYFgX

>David, thanks for the offer. I will follow up as soon as I can. I think I mentioned that this job was already spliced by others, it is 3 ply sheets. It is some veneer left over from a corporate jet project. I have several friends who work at that trade, and this is left over form that, and it is barely enough for this project.

I am having to be extremely cautious. I have no margin for error, and can't mess up one part, so the pressure is on.

However the upper doors of this cabinet will have a herringbone pattern lay-up for the flip up doors, which will be a good project to show how easy the dots are to use, so I will try to plan to shoot that part when I get to it.

Re: Does anyone have a trick for removing v-tape?

#10

Re: Does anyone have a trick for removing v-tape?

Sgian Dubh

>It will probably be next week or the week after before I get chance to try your draft dot trick Keith. I'll get some pictures while I'm at it.

Now of course I have to remember to do the experiment, and there's no guarantee of that, but I'll try, ha, ha. Slainte.

Re: Does anyone have a trick for removing v-tape?

#11

Just so you know,

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryDZmgloT+ZiYFgX

>I am using Alvin brand, professional draft dots, as opposed to non-professional dots ;-)

I just checked one, and they are .002" thick. Not sure what brand is offered in your part of the world.

Re: Does anyone have a trick for removing v-tape?

#12

Re: Just so you know,

Sgian Dubh

>I too have Alvin brand dots. I've been using them since I lived in the US four years ago. I seem to draw manually less and less as I gradually switch over to AutoCAD, so those are the dots I've got. I'm not sure what the UK equivalent drafting dots are in terms of brand, thickness or adhesive. Slainte.

Re: Does anyone have a trick for removing v-tape?

#13

Re: A photo-essay response.

Sgian Dubh

>A few weeks ago Keith Newton posted his technique for veneering using drafting tape or drafting dots to join the prepared veneers.

I expressed some doubts about the suitability of using drafting dots for this task guessing that they might perform much like masking tape. Masking tape has the nasty habit of adhering too well to the wood and on removal tearing out the grain. It is also quite thick and, on soft veneers, I�ve experienced it leaving a depression in the veneer that�s difficult to remove without cutting through to the ground below.

I decided to give the drafting tape technique a go on a sample board. I used a piece of 12 mm MDF as the ground and used some offcuts of crown cut black cherry Prunus Seritona and radially sliced European beech Fagus sylvatica veneers for each face.

The rest is a photo essay of the job with comments here and there and a conclusion at the end.

The following four images show the veneers cut with a guillotine and the prepared edges taped together, the cherry with drafting dots and the beech using masking tape. I used PVA glue and applied it the ground on both faces to press the veneers in one go.





The panel is slipped into the veneer press. I used a heated hydraulic press for speed, although I could have used the vacuum bag press. Hide glue and a veneer hammer don�t work well at all with masking tape as the join �cramp� and I doubt that drafting tape would perform any better. Both these methods are slower anyway and I was after speed.


The veneered panel gets high pressure heat treatment. The panel stays in the press for about 60 seconds: that�s all the time required for applying veneer with platens heated to 60�C.


The bottom platen lowers to remove the panel. Normally I slip a sheet of plastic, like a cut up black bin bag, between the platens and the panel to prevent sticking. I didn�t have one handy so slapped a bit of paper towel either side, something I wouldn�t normally do as the paper gets imprinted into the veneer�s grain.


The veneer, the ground and the tape is hot when removed from the press, so you�d think tearing off the masking tape, next, or the drafting dot tape in the image after, wouldn�t cause grain tearout. It does in both cases even though I was very careful how I peeled back the tape. I was a little surprised to see the drafting dot removal caused more damage than the masking tape. However, beech is very hard, and the cherry joined with the drafting dots is a lot softer, so perhaps the tearing out of the grain in the cherry isn�t too surprising.



Glue bleed through on the beech veneer.


Some residual adhesive left on the cherry veneer from the drafting dot.


A bit of prep work is needed, so it's off to the 100 grit abrasive paper on the stroke sander followed by some hand sanding to 150 grit. After that a bit of carelessly brushed on shellac just to seal the grain.




In these last four images you can see the general colour and the bit of torn out cherry grain shows rather badly.





Conclusions. I was right to be sceptical of the efficacy of drafting dots used as a means to join veneers prior to gluing. They do tear out the grain on removal just as masking tape does, but I suspect it depends to some extent on the wood species. Neither the masking tape nor the drafting dots imprinted themselves into the wood. The masking tape I suspect was defeated by the hardness of the beech veneer beneath it. The drafting dots are thinner, so perhaps their ability to imprint deeply is compromised.

I shan�t be switching over to using drafting dots to join veneers on a regular basis, particularly for woods that can be �stringy� such as European sycamore Acer pseudoplatanus for example or hard maple Acer sacharum. I might use it for some of the harder tighter grained woods such as ebony or possibly some of the rosewoods. Slainte.

Re: Does anyone have a trick for removing v-tape?

#14

all masking tape not created equal

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I don't know a thing about veneering. But having worked some with 3M I do know a bit about masking tape. While most of us think of masking tape as something we buy at the stationary department of some retail store, this product is but one example of a product category known as "masking tape". Most of the products in this category are used for..... masking. As such, there are products that are more or less sticky and/or heat resistant and even thickness.

If the stuff you buy at the retail stationary store is too sticky, or thick, or whatever, get on the phone to your regional 3M supplier or equivalent, and describe the need. They will recommend a product that will better do the job and suggest sources for buying it.

But then, why aren't people using the stuff I saw at the factory laying up veneered architectural panels? It is designed for the task of joining veneer. Its tissue thin and it sands right off because the adhesive is designed to be sandable.

Re: Does anyone have a trick for removing v-tape?

#15

There's your masking tape, here's mine...

HC Sakman

>Hi Richard,

Thanks for the detailed post.

This side of the Atlantic we're fortunate enough to have "Blue" making tape made by 3M. It does not leave any rasidue on the surface.

I think in your case, the culprit is the heat! There's also another cheap masking tape, called "Painter's Buddy", though if it's left in warm places, even in direct sunlight, this tape turns into "Painter's Nightmare" when it's time to remove. I am not a chemist, but I know for a fact that heat makes most glue activate faster and stronger (perhaps "stickier" is a better description.) Probably your heated press may make this matter worse.

Long story short, that cheap "green" masking tape is just bad news. On the other hand, 3M's blue masking tape is a pleasure to remove. (I use vacuum press.)

Just my own experience.

Chico...

Re: Does anyone have a trick for removing v-tape?

#16

I read yours after I posted mine.

HC Sakman

>Hi Bill,

So, I guess you'd know what I mean by 3M's blue masking tape. ;-)

Chico...

Re: Does anyone have a trick for removing v-tape?

#17

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Which blue?

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>3M has at least two blue masking tapes that I know of. One is 14-day and the other is 60-day. The 60-day is very thin, low adhesion, and removes very cleanly for a long time. The 14-day is heavier, has more of a crepe-paper appearance (paint will often wick under it), and can be a problem after a couple weeks in the hot sun. We also regularly use the 3M green (lacquer) tape, because of its high adhesion, but that is rated at 3 days. Even after a week in the hot sun, it comes off pretty well (have to watch for slivers of it being left behind).

3-day: #2060 (different sizes have slightly different numbers)

14-day: #2090

60-day: #2080

The 60-day tape is also for delicate surfaces--it can be put on acrylic/latex paint that has dried for only 12-24 hours with only a low risk of damage.

I generally don't mess with the white masking tape.

Jason

Re: Does anyone have a trick for removing v-tape?

#18

Re: There's your masking tape, here's mine...

Thomas S Stockton

>I used both the blue stuff and 3m's painters tape. The blue stuff works much better. The painters tape works also and using a hair dryer to warm the tape as you peel it up helps to avoid large chunks coming up with it and a little naphtha cleans up any residue.

I think Chico's got a point about the hot press making the dots harder to remove and that they probably behave differently in a vacuum press. I think it shows how important it is to find out what works for you by doing these simple trials and not blindly follow whatever you see hear or read , but come to your own conclusions.

Tom

Re: Does anyone have a trick for removing v-tape?

#19

Honestly.... No idea!

HC Sakman

>No idea that there are 3 versions of strength. I'll pay attention to the model numbers you've given. Although, I did notice some being thinner than the other, (Probably I purchased them from different places at different times.) so at least 2 different kinds work the same, but thinner one is better. Thanks for the info Jason.

Chico...

Re: Does anyone have a trick for removing v-tape?

#20

Re: There's your masking tape, here's mine...

HC Sakman

>Hi Tom,

I find 3M's "Painter's Tape" too sticky. That "Painter's Buddy" is made by a different manufacturer and it's way too sticky. Probably meant for textured ceilings, floors etc.

Chico...

Re: Does anyone have a trick for removing v-tape?

#21

60 Day works best for veneering

Craig Thibodeau

>I use the 60 day blue tape for almost all my veneering in a vacuum press that gets heated to about 120F-130F and it peels off with little effort and no tearout after pressing. It doesn't stay attached to the raw veneers long after taping so I try to get my sheets in the press within and hour or so.

Typically I tape the glue face with the 14 day blue tape to hold everything tight then flip the sheet over and retape on the show face with the 60 day blue tape. Remove the glue side tape and press. All the tape gets burnished with a brass brush to help it adhere to the veneers.

Around here the 60 day blue tape is available at Home Depot and has an orange inner cardboard core. I have also used the 3" wide rolls of 60 day blue tape to tape marquetry faces together and it saves so much effort after pressing compared to gum tape. It isn't really so useful on buckled veneers though as the tape just doesn't hold well enough to make a good seam.

Hope this helps,

Craig

Re: Does anyone have a trick for removing v-tape?

#22

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Honestly.... No idea!

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>Actually, I did leave one out--we only tried it once, and I dubbed it, "The No-Stick Tape". It's purple, and I don't recall if it is made by 3M or not, but it has even less adhesion than the 60-day blue tape. BTW, the 60-day blue tape has orange on the label and the 14-day stuff has white on the label (if they're from 3M).

Jason

Re: Does anyone have a trick for removing v-tape?

#23

Re: There's your masking tape, here's mine...

Sgian Dubh

>We have different types of masking tape on this side of the pond Chico, but bearing in mind that I was primarily concentrating on how the drafting tape (dots) perform I just grabbed a bit of whatever masking tape was hanging around.

The old standby for veneering is, of course, the water activated gummed tape. This stuff too has its pluses and minuses. One disadvantage being the tendency of the veneer to buckle when water is applied to it. This is more of a problem when the veneer is strong grained and wants to go its own way. Slainte.

Re: Does anyone have a trick for removing v-tape?

#24

Re: A photo-essay response. Response------WebKitFo

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryDZmgloT+ZiYFgX

>Hello Richard. Congratulations on doing a great essay. That is some good looking equipment that you have there. With that I can see why you would pre-determine the outcome for yourself, and find that you were right.

However, I don't know how many of the other readers of this forum have a heated press, regardless of how they cut, splice, and sand their veneer glue lay-ups. I had to look at a reference conversion chart to find out how hot 60� C is = to 284� fahrenheit. I suspect that at that temperature the glue on the dots and masking tape goes fairly liquid, which would allow it to penetrate the cells of the wood more deeply than it would at a lower temperature.

Just a reminder to all, I did not suggest using masking tape, because I found that it left a lot of its gum for me on the few occasions that I felt compelled to use it to repair something just before going into the bag. Getting that much sticky gum off just wasn't worth taking a shortcut on the front end.

I didn't see where you mentioned which glue you used. I don't even recall when I started this thread asking for your or anyone's, quick tips for removing the normal veneer tape, that I use epoxy for most of my veneering. I learned and started v-bagging from an article in Wooden Boat magazine" a long time ago, and still like using that adhesive. Although, one of the things that I didn't like about the epoxy, is that it will permeate paper veneer tape. If it is left on long enough to fully cure, it virtually turns the tape into formica.

The trick is to remove the bleed-through before it reaches that level of cure, otherwise it is too easy to sand through the normal un-impregnated face before getting the tape off. This is what lead me to start using the dots.

Back to your article. You said that you carefully removed the dots, and tape. This may sound fine to a casual reader of this thread, but since you also posted your essay over in the FWW forum where I made no mention of this, but normally post. To me, this seems like I am being slapped down. So for me, I would like to hear something more specific.

For example; I used a sharp chisel to slip under the edge, then lifted straight up quickly, but the tape / dots tore in half leaving its gum behind, and tearing out fibers. Maybe there is something that you did besides cook the tape into the wood at high pressure that could have cause this results.

I would not have bothered to offer the dots suggestion if I got the same results that you obviously did.

By the way, since you obviously use standard veneer tape. How do you usually remove it. Do you just sand it off with your stroke sander, or wet and scrape? I would love to see an article of the fine art of veneer tape removal of the caliber that you just put into this one.

Nice photos too . Thanks for such a fine response.

------WebKitFormBoundaryM9XrD2Kl1RRXd+Uw

Re: Does anyone have a trick for removing v-tape?

#25

Re: Questionable source.

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>Keith,

60� C is 140� F, not 284� F as your reference said. Perhaps you need another source? ;^)

Al