How quickly they forget
Rick Christopherson
>Well, it was just two weeks ago on this very forum that I really took it in the shorts for informing people that it was not required to replace the integral, single-pole control switch on a tool when they converted the tool to 240 volts. Some people even responded to this information as though I was being irresponsible for even suggesting such a thing. So where are all these posters today?
A 3-way switch is not integral to the piece of equipment it is controlling, and it only breaks one conductor. This means that one of the ungrounded conductors is not being opened when the switch is opened, yet nobody is questioning this today. Why not?
Just in case it is not obvious, this is tongue-in-cheek, and I do have a smile on my face.
Seriously though, tonight I did just make a cursory review through Article 404 and I cannot find any requirement for a 3-way switch to break both ungrounded conductors, even when it is not integral to the equipment. That being said, you can use a standard 3-way switch to control your 240 volt load, with one caveat.
Because this switch is controlling a motor, it is not likely that the switch contacts will be rated for motor duty. As a result, the contacts could fuse and the motor could remain powered after the switch is turned off. Being a dust collector, this is not a huge safety risk, just know that the switch may have a limited life.
Personally, I would prefer to use a motor contactor and low-voltage controls at each of the control locations. This is pretty simple. You need 3 conductors going to each control point, and they can be as small as telephone wire. All of the On buttons are connected in parallel with the contactor relay, and all of the Off buttons are connected in series with the relay coil. Any On button can start the system, and any Off button can stop the system.