Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

OT Cold Shower almost

Posts

OT Cold Shower almost

#1

OT Cold Shower almost

Dustmaker Mike

>Well I have a Gas hot water heater and it is just not up to what I think it should be. So here I go trying to figure out what to do to fix it. The culpret is a ~15 year old Rheem 40 gallon NG water heater. The shower starts out Hot then very quickly turns warm and stays that way. I figured it was an anti scold value in the shower but it seems to be getting worse. So I figured I should be able to fill a tub with Hot water, but it got a few inchs into filling it and started to get cooler and cooler. I then flushed the tank by hooking up a hose to the bottom and turning off the gas. I then opened the hose to empty the tank. I did leave the cold water turned on the back fill the tank.

Now I was told there is a dip tube that should be on the cold water side. So how hard is it to replace it? Also did I flush it correctly? With Christmas almost here I really don't want to replace the tank. Any other ideas?

Re: OT Cold Shower almost

#2

Re: OT Cold Shower almost

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown, PA

>Good Afternoon Mike,

My hot water tank will need replacing in the next year or two. I am seriously considering preempting the flood by having a tankless heater installed. I understand there is a noteworthy reduction in gas use because the heater operates on demand only rather than continuously to keep a whole tank hot. Some space is saved too.

George

Re: OT Cold Shower almost

#3

Re: OT Cold Shower almost

Nat Robison

>My neighbor, a plumber, tells me that a possible culprit in a tank that doesn't put out enough heated water is that the dip tube may be broken, pulling the cold water that comes in the top of the tank, instead of the hot water at the bottom. I believe they are replaceable and are carried at most home centers.

That being said, without knowing anything about your particular tank, I think that at 15 years old, it may have lived its useful life. I'm sure people might chime in about how their water heater has gone 25 years but I think that 12-15 years is more realistic.

Re: OT Cold Shower almost

#4

Re: OT Cold Shower almost

Ron Hildreth

>Mike,

I installed a Tankless water heater a couple years ago, and we love it. Ours is an electric made by S.E.T.S. They are the pioneers of the technology, developing the first one for NASA's Space Shuttle. They carry a life time warranty that is transferable to the next owner if you sell your house. They cost a little more, but I think the warranty makes it well worth the cost. If a problem arises, just call them and they overnight it to you at no cost, not even shipping (from Florida).

I love the fact that I can stand under the shower from 6:00AM till midnight and the only thing that goes cold is my singing voice! But the wife says I was never a singer anyway!

Ron in Iowa

Re: OT Cold Shower almost

#5

Re: OT Cold Shower almost

Howard Norman

>My propane fired hot water heater is starting to do the same thing. I am on a private well with bad water so I am not surprised about the sludge building up in the bottom of the tank. I have tried to flush mine out several times but I am not sure that I accomplished anything with what I was doing which was essentially what you did. As I sit here typing this I am wondering what would happen if after you drained the tank you turned the cold water back on with the drain valve still open. Would that cause some of the trash in the bottom of the tank to get stirred up enough that some of it would flush out? I obviously don't know the answer to the question.

As far as George's thought of replacing a conventional tank with a demand hot water heater you need a good supply of gas to operate one of those things as I understand it. My neighbor installed one from the day he built his house about 12 years ago. He had to replace his this year. They are not cheap and I don't know if the gas savings pay for them in a short enough time to justify the expense or not.

Howard

Re: OT Cold Shower almost

#6

Re: OT Cold Shower almost

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>I think normally the culprit is what has been mentioned, sludge buildup in the bottom of the tank. My FIL once cleaned ours out but I am not sure how he did it; we had to replace it about a year later. A good sized new water heater I think runs around $300 or so, and they are not hard to install yourself with basic plumbing skills. If you hire a plumber to come out and fix your heater it will probably end up costing about the same and still having the same heater. Just my take on it, although there is a lot I don't know about water heaters. We recently installed a water softener which will help all of our appliances that use water last longer, plus will reduce the lime buildup on the faucets.

Re: OT Cold Shower almost

#7

Re: OT Cold Shower almost *LINK*

Ron Hildreth

>I forgot to mention that sets also makes gas powered tankless heaters, too. Here's the link to their web site, if anyone is interested:

Ron in Iowa


S.E.T.S tankless water heaters

Re: OT Cold Shower almost

#8

Re: OT Cold Shower almost

John Pappas

>Rheem was using some type of plastic for the dip tube that simply disolved in time. When the plumber removed mine, it was about 6 inches long. One of the symptoms we had was small white particles that ended up in the faucet screens. Replaced it and all is ok.

Re: OT Cold Shower almost

#9

Re: OT Cold Shower almost

Larry in NW Ohio

>Ron Do you have a web site mfor S.E.T.S. I never heard of them. Thanks Larry in Ohio

Re: OT Cold Shower almost

#10

I have seen those

Dustmaker Mike

>I was wondering what was in the water that could have caused them. I think I will need to find a dip tube. I really don't have the time nor money right now to replace it with a Tankless. I will be redoing a bathroom next year and will be puting 2 smaller units in one for upstairs and one for down. I hate waiting for hot water.

Thanks

Re: OT Cold Shower almost

#11

Re: OT Cold Shower almost

Barry Irby

>Sounds like the dip tube to me. Never replaced one personally, but I don't think it is hard. Check with a plumbing supply house.

Re: OT Cold Shower almost

#12

Re: OT Cold Shower almost

John McGaw

>My experience with gas-fired hot water tanks is that they build up a mineral sludge in them very quickly and that this material is difficult, if not impossible, to flush. Since almost all of the heating in the tank occurs in the bottom, below the sludge, they lose efficiency very quickly and never recover. Personally, I've never had a gas tank last more than 7-8 years. When replacing them it has been obvious where the culprit lay - the "empty" tank always weighed twice as much as a new one even after draining for a prolonged time. Sometimes it was all two men could do to get the old tank into the back of a pickup.

Re: OT Cold Shower almost

#13

Re: OT Cold Shower almost

Marv

>Mike,

I bet if you did some googling you might find some good info and pictures that will instruct you so you can easily understand what and how to fix it yourself.

Marv

Re: OT Cold Shower almost

#14

Re: OT Cold Shower almost *LINK*

Brian Aust - Nevada, IA

>For $20 you can get a very informative book on how to keep your water heater in tip-top shape. I would suggest if you are going to replace the dip tube, that you replace the anode rod at the same time. I have this book and highly recommend it.


heatinghelp.com

Re: OT Cold Shower almost

#15

Re: OT Cold Shower almost - - 15 yrs old ? ! ?

Pete in Holland, MI

>Replace the water heater, rather than trying to repair it. You're swiftly coming up to the end of its usefull life. It'll cost you a new tank now, OR cost you the tank, AND what ever water damage it generates as it leaks all over the basement before you discover it if you wait.

Your choice.