>Can anyone out there give me a recommendation for staining some stair treads? I am putting in a staircase with solid beech treads. This will be a high traffic staircase with dogs and kids... I'm well versed in furniture restoration with Danish Oil, mineral spirits, sanding, 0000 steel wool etc... Is the process for finishing the treads any different than it would be for a tabletop? Are there different products out there that I should consider? Any advice would be appreciated. Thanks!
>Chris, unless you plan to place some type of protective runner on the steps, Danish oil would not be a good choice for a finish in this situation. The reason is that you need something that will seal the wood in a way only a film finish can. A danish oil finish won't build a protective film that will last in that environment. Dirt and dust will make its way into the wood and the stairs will look real bad at that point.
I'd say at the least you'll want to use a polyurethane like they use on hardwood floors. Perhaps Varathane makes something you could try but I know there are many other brand choices available too.
>The staining process would be no different, at least that's how I've approached staining wood floors and stairs, wipe it on, blend if desired, wait, & wipe off.
As the other David said, don't use Danish oil. I installed Tamarack floors in part of my house years ago (beautiful but too soft, that's another story) and was warned off of poly by "experts" because it was (and I quote) "harder than the floor and would crack." Put down an oil and wax finish that was so beautiful you just wanted to get down and hug the floor. It didn't last beyond a year or so and maintenance was also way too high. Redid the floors and laid more this summer, sealed with 5 coats of Hydrocoat poly. I would recommend this stuff to anyone and it can be tinted if so desired. You don't need to sand with 4-0 steel wool. 120 is about it, some guys stop at 100. My regime was 36-60-80-120, ran a green pad over the floor before poly and between each coat. I did 5 coats of poly because the wood soaked up so much of the stuff that 3 coats didn't give even coverage.
>Thanks for the tip! I'm glad I didn't try the Danish Oil. Do you dilute the Hydrocote poly at all with mineral spirits? Or do you just brush it at full strength and let it dry? And for tinting, what products would you recommend? I will probably have to experiment a bit... My flooring is a dark walnut stained birch and my treads are beechwood.
Do you dilute the Hydrocote poly at all with mineral spirits?
There's a link below for the Hydrocote Products page. The name should tip you off that all their finishes are water based. So, mineral spirits is not the correct thinner or solvent. I'd think you wouldn't want to thin any of the coats applied for stair treads.
And for tinting, what products would you recommend?
If it were me, I'd forget tinting and just go for staining the beech to match your floor. If you plan to use the Hydrocote polyurethane, I'd recommend using a water based dye stain for coloring the beech first. My first choice would be one of the General Finishes water based dye stain colors that would match well with your floor. Assuming you have some scrap pieces of the beech, you'll want to test your choice to be sure it is what you want first.
My flooring is a dark walnut stained birch and my treads are beechwood.
Birch and beech are similar woods that will stain well with a dye stain (General Finishes) and come out looking the same. You can find General dye stains many places but the easiest might be Woodcraft.
>I didn't even clue in that Hydrocote is water based... Duh! Fortunately I have a lot of scrap beech to test some stain combinations.
One last question- would you stain it once and then apply the Hydrocote? Or does it hurt to do a couple of rounds of stain? I guess that really depends on how well the color matches after the first round of stain. And what effect does the Hydrocote have on the final finish (as far as color?) Does it tint any further?
>Chris, your test on the scrap beech will tell the tale. If one coat of the dye stain doesn't quite get the color right, try a second. The General water based dye stain can be lightened by wiping it down with a wet cloth before it dries. You should finish your test piece with the same finish schedule you plan to use on the stairs to be absolutely sure how it's going to turn out. Don't just stain some and not apply the topcoat too. It's this testing that will tell you exactly what you need to do for a match with your floor.
>Great advice again. I think I'm almost there. Last question. The selection on water based stains isn't very good at my local shop. Hence, I bought some oil based stains to experiment with. According to the guy at the store, he claims I can use the oil based stain in conjunction with the hydrocote, so long as I wait 72 hours and ensure the oil stain is 100% dry. That seems a bit suspicious. I would hate to have to find a water based stain, as I think I've nailed my combination (I'll know for sure after the poly coat!). If it's not too much trouble, I'd like to hear your take on the oil/water combo with sufficient dry time in between.
>I know you can apply an oil based topcoat over a water based dye/stain. I do not know for sure if the reverse is true.
I also think the brand of o/b stain used could make a difference since there are some that have ingredients that partially seal the wood in addition to coloring.
This is why I suggested going with the General Finishes brand of w/b dye stain. Here's what I would do. Since I have no personal experience with applying a w/b topcoat over an o/b stain and can't give you a definite answer, and since this topic has moved so far to the bottom of the page, start a new post with an appropriate subject line and ask this question to see what the collective wisdom here says.
The one thought that comes to mind that could be a solution and others might offer as a solution is to use a barrier coat that will stick to both finishes - de-waxed shellac, aka - Zinsser SealCoat. However, it seems to me I read a caution somewhere that there was a problem using SealCoat under certain w/b polyurethanes. I can't recall now if there was any validity to this or not and for that reason can't fully endorse this suggestion. Again, post a new message and let's see what others say. If it's worth doing, it's worth doing right.
>Sorry to fall off on this one. Things are hectic around here. Don't need my 2 cents on diluting Hydrocoat other than I wouldn't. The tint that Hydrocoat sells is for folks who want the finish to "yellow" as if it were oil based. I used the tint on my first coat and then lessened the amount down to none by the fourth coat because I was trying to blend new floor with old and get it to be somewhere close in color to the floors in an adjacent room that are a different species (ash vs tamarack/larch).
I haven't used w/b stains and must admit to only using off the shelf varieties of o/b such as Minwax, Zar, etc. For the last 5 or more years I've topcoated with w/b poly. Never had a problem.
This may be for David Y, are there grain raising issues with using a w/b stain?
>David, a w/b stain can raise the grain but may not all the time, depending on the type of wood and how it's treated beforehand.
There are a couple of ways of dealing with preventing or limiting raised grain when finishing with water based finish. One is to pre-raise the grain by wiping the wood before staining with a wet rag, let it dry, and lightly sand away the fuzz with 320 paper. This usually limits but, depending on the type of wood, could prevent the amount the grain raises after applying a w/b stain or dye.
The other way is to seal the wood before applying the stain/dye. I like Zinsser SealCoat right from the can (no thinning needed). Wipe it on liberally and wipe it right back off. Let it dry, check for raised grain, sand lightly with 320 by hand, and proceed with your color. This method will prevent further grain raising by w/b stain or dye.