Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Dedicated mortiser or router table?

Posts

Dedicated mortiser or router table?

#1

Dedicated mortiser or router table?

Dan Mitchell

>I'm still outfitting my shop, and I'd like to add something to cut mortises. I initially was thinking about a mortising machine, lately leaning towards the Delta, but I'm wondering if a router table (which I'd like to have anyway) might not be a more useful alternative. Although I've not used either machine, can't you nearly as quickly cut a nice, albeit round-ended mortise for most any mortising application with a router table? Or am I missing something?

Dan

Re: Dedicated mortiser or router table?

#2

Re: Dedicated mortiser or router table?

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>You can build a router table. It's a bit more difficult to build a mortising machine.

Rob

Re: Dedicated mortiser or router table?

#3

Re: Dedicated mortiser or router table?

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>Fist off for someone who hasn't cut morices I would probably recomend doing the first ones by hand. it is not a teribly dificult task and it will give you skills at trimming and fitting machine cut mortices.

That said the next would be to cut them with a plunge router rather than a router mounted in a table. it is more versitle and a bit safer than plunging the wood down on to a bit in router table.

For the serious minded a morticing machine offers the versitility of making angled mortices, a task useful in chair making.

not trying to rain on your parade I have both a router table and a morticing machine. I built my first router table 13 years ago and just purchased a morticeing machine about a year ago.

Re: Dedicated mortiser or router table?

#4

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Dedicated mortiser or router table?

Jesper, Denmark

>The mortising machine is much better for mortises than the router table. For one thing, you can directly see and measure where the mortice goes and do not need elaborate swet-ups for each mortise. Mortises on a router table are a bit time consuming to set up and the set-up only works for that mortise.

Oh....and you will want a router table anyway! I built mine - Norm style - ten years ago in about 40 hours. It was necessary to round over then edges of luovers - not possible with a bearing bit on the second side.

I do nopt use either much these days, but when needed, they are there and very useful

Re: Dedicated mortiser or router table?

#5

Re: Dedicated mortiser or router table?

Barry Irby

>I have a mortising attachment for my Delta DP and have had it for over thirty years, but only started using it a few years ago. It works well enough. (I have the Small Shop Blues and no real good place to set up a dedicated machine, but it would be nice.) It seems that every time I get the mortising attachment on the DP, I need to use the DP as a DP.

I have a router table in the wing of my TS. (Note small shop and multi use complaint above) I can use the fence for the TS with the router, but every time I do, I wish I could use it to rip something on the TS.

Having said all that, I would not use my router table for mortises on a regular bases. Too difficult to set up and see what you are doing. I have done it several times, but if the mortises get deeper than about an inch, I just don't like it at all. a little nerve wracking to lower the wood over the bit.

I saw one of the Multi????? (Senior moment) Router table David Marks seems to be found of on the WoodWorks Show in Highland Hardware. It is basically a table you clamp the work to and move the wood/table in any of the three axises. The router is clamped into the end of the machine and appears to do a good job of cutting fairly deep mortises. The Machine was approaching $2000 the last I heard, but if you need it it could be useful. David Marks uses it to do loose mortise and tenon joints.

My choice might be a dedicated Hollow Chisel mortiser, but that might be "limited" thinking. Limited by the fact that I already have the DP model and a Tenoning attachment for my TS.

Re: Dedicated mortiser or router table?

#6

Another option

David Yoho

>You'll want and need a router table for sure. That's probably a good item to put toward the top of your "to do" list. Personally, I wouldn't use one for cutting mortises.

Next, a dedicated hollow chisel mortiser is a nice tool to have but not entirely necessary, especially if you won't be cutting a large number of mortises at one time. While I have one in my shop, it doesn't see as much use as you would think.

Personally, I think one of the best ways to cut mortises, and one that doesn't require the purchase of expensive or dedicated equipment, is by hogging out the bulk of the mortise at the drill press and finishing up with good bench chisels.

I usually set up a fence on my drill press table to locate the cut. A piece of wood clamped to the table will work for this but there are fancy rigs out there that you can buy that will work too. Then I use a forstner bit as close to the size of the mortise as possible and set to the required depth by the adjustment on the drill press. After hogging out the majority of the waste, you simply use sharp chisels to clean and square up the mortise.

If you already own a drill press, all you need are chisels and forstner bits, which I would imagine most woodworkers already have in the early stages of equipping a shop.

David

Re: Dedicated mortiser or router table?

#7

Re: Dedicated mortiser or router table?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Years ago when I was in "shop outfitting" mode, I made several router tables, a horizontal router jig, and bought a benchtop mortiser [see my comments of the JET JBM-5 in the Reviews Section].

I used the horizontal jig once; it then gathered dust until is was used for kindling.

I have cut mortices on the router table, but it can be a somewhat tedious process to get them positioned precisely, I'm never really comfortable dropping a piece of wood onto the spinning cutter, and issues arise when the mortise is larger than your available bit so that you must cut it in several passes. All that said, I have produced very nice clean mortices with the router table. But

My preferred method is to use the mortiser. It's quick and easy to set up, it's "OS" factor is practically nill, and slanted and oversize cuts are easy and repeatable.

Note here that a router bit will cut a much cleaner slot than the mortiser which is especially important if you're cutting through-motices which I often do.

Note too that, in my view, a router table plus a sled is the clear winner when it comes to cutting precise tenons to match the mortices, both straight and slanted.

Translation: Short Answer - Work both the mortiser and router table into your shop space!

mm

Re: Dedicated mortiser or router table?

#8

Re: Dedicated mortiser or router table?

Mike Schwing from Md.

>I have a router table and a hollow chisel mortiser. I don't use either for mortises! Instead, I have been using the plunge router. It is way faster for me to set up than the hollow chisel mortiser, and it produces cleaner mortises that only require the corners to be squared. I can cut them by hand, too, but the plunge router does a better job than my hands. The router table, however, is an invaluable tool for many other uses.

Re: Dedicated mortiser or router table?

#9

Re: Dedicated mortiser or router table?

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Morning Dan,

I use my router table nearly every day, and like the way it does stopped mortises. Set up is a little tedious. I run scrap first to confirm the set up. Mostly, the router table does profiles and raised panels. My Shop Fox mortising machine is a wonderful tool which I love to use. With a cross feed vise installed underneath, it is the mpdy effective way to make mortises. My Shop Fox isn't used too often. My advise is to build yourself a good router table, and perform mortises on it, with a drill press, or DP and chisels.

George

Re: Dedicated mortiser or router table?

#10

Re: Dedicated mortiser or router table?

Bill Schreiber, Litchfield, NH

>Dan,

A router table is very useful in a shop. With a router table, you can do just about anything but a mortiser can only do one thing. If you have the money for both, why not? Between the both though, the router table would be my vote. You can also build a mortiser table (FWW had a plan a few years back) that uses your router for very little $. I built one for a project I did 5 years back and it worked well.

Regards,

Bill

Re: Dedicated mortiser or router table?

#11

Re: Dedicated mortiser or router table?

Jim Dillon

>Dan,

Another option, if you have a plunge router, is to build the mortising fixture described in Bill Hylton's book Router Magic and shown below. Granted, it does not create square mortises, but I have used this fixture more times than I can remember. It is very versatile. It is shown here doing a mortise in end grain, but it works equally well (if not better) for horizontal work. There are adjustable stops to assist, but I've often taken these off when doing stopped mortises in long pieces. I've even done the mortises for Brusso hinges using this fixture and it worked great.

Regarding your question of router table or dedicated mortiser, personally I would use this homemade fixture any time for making mortises rather than a router table. I have a dedicated mortiser (Delta) but almost never use it - at least so far. As others have said, a router table - if you don't have one - is far, far more useful, just not for cutting mortises IMHO.

Another option is a slot mortiser. I think Bill's book has a plan for one of those as well, but there are many plans around for them, some quite sophisticated. From what I've read, a slot mortiser is really the cats meow for doing router cut mortises. Good luck.

Jim (Enjoying the falling snow in central MD)


img

Re: Dedicated mortiser or router table?

#12

Research router options

Bill Hylton

>Before you put a three figure dent in your bank account, stop by the library or a store with a variety of woodworking books and page through Woodworking with the Router. It has several chapters on router tables and a chapter on routing mortise-and-tenon joints.

Mortising with the router is a piece of very tasty cake, but don't do it with a table-mounted router. Use a plunge router, a good edge guide, and a homemade mortising block. The mortising block I've been using for the last 4 years or so is shown on page 281-286 of the book. Or use the plunge router with a template. Or with some other mortising jig.

With a plunge router and shop-made jigging, you can cut all sorts of mortises in all sorts of places. A bonus is that the job-specific investment is minimal. A plunge router and edge guide have all sorts of applications in woodworking. A mortiser does only mortises.

I've got a benchtop hollow-chisel mortiser and very seldom use it.

A second book you ought to look at is Bill Hylton's Ultimate Guide to the Router Table, which focuses on router table operations. It will explain how to do practical work on the router table. Understanding how to use a router table is essential in designing and building one that will work for you.

Bill

Re: Dedicated mortiser or router table?

#13

Re: Dedicated mortiser or router table?

Ron in Drums PA

>I built a router table 10+ years ago thinking this was a better way to do mortises than on a drill press. It was a step up and worked well.

About 6 years ago I purchased a Jet mortiser and I feel this tool is better than a router table to make mortises.

If I had to do this again, I would start with the router table and later get a mortiser when I had the bucks.

Re: Dedicated mortiser or router table?

#14

Re: Dedicated mortiser or router table?

Thomas S Stockton

>Dan,

I would buy a good plunge router and a good router book before a mortiser. This will allow you to do a lot of different joinery. As for router tables they can be as simple as a piece of ply wood with the router bolted unerneath and a piece of wood clamped to it for a fence to the full on commercial units. I personally would start simple and figure out what works for you before spending big bucks on some of the commercialy made stuff.Can't help you on the book front but Biil Hylton and Carol Reed who post here both have books out.

Tom

Re: Dedicated mortiser or router table?

#15

Re: Dedicated mortiser or router table?

Dan Mitchell

>Thanks for all the great replies! Based on the advice, I think I'll put the mortiser on hold for awhile. I have been planning to get/build a router table anyway, and I've requested "Router magic : jigs, fixtures, and tricks to unleash your router", "Woodworking with the router : professional router techniques" and "Bill Hylton's power-tool joinery" from the local library. One reason I had been hesitating on the router table is all the possible configurations/bases/fences/lifts is a bit confusing, hopefully these books will help clear the subject up. I do have a plunge router, a Hitachi M12V.

Dan

Re: Dedicated mortiser or router table?

#16

What do you mean "or"?

Neal in San Jose

>I have a Multico mortise machine, and it converts to a small drill press. How's that for a switch? Oh, I have two router tables, one verticle and one horizontal for raising panels, etc. I prefer to cut mortises in the mortise machine, especially if I have more than one to do.

Re: Dedicated mortiser or router table?

#17

Re: Dedicated mortiser or router table?

Ray Newman

>Since you are setting up your shop, I recommend first building a good router table & customize it to your height, install a good fence, DC, feather boards, stops, etc.

In my experience, I ask myself why did I wait so long to build & outfit a router table w/ cabinet for the routers, bits, & related items.

I wouldn't worry 'bout a mortise machine until there was need for one. Then consider the cost of the machine v. exactly how many times it will be used. The consider if you could do the same thing w/ a good plunge router.

Why buy something that you may never use, or be only once very 2-3 years?...

Re: Dedicated mortiser or router table?

#18

Re: Dedicated mortiser or router table?

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>Since you mentioned it...

Mine is "Router Joinery Workshop." You might find it in your local library as it received a 'high buy' recommendation from the Library Association (or some such national organization). I forgot the name. The plaque is at home in Arizona.

There is another mortising fixture in it, complete with how-to-build plans.

In other words, you have lots of choices, and even two people here that are willing to explain what they-ve written, if need be.

And no floor real estate for a cabinet type router table? I have a small portable one in my book. Along with lots of jigs and fixtures, and plans to build them.

Re: Dedicated mortiser or router table?

#19

Re: Dedicated mortiser or router table?

Dan Mitchell

>Thanks Carol, I've added it to my request list at the library!

Dan

Re: Dedicated mortiser or router table?

#20

A 55 gal. drum of sawdust to the first person.....

Art Silva

>that can name another website messageboard that will get a reply to a router question from the "Router Lady", and the "Router Gentleman" in one thread. The clock is running.

Re: Dedicated mortiser or router table?

#21

Re: A 55 gal. drum of sawdust to the first person.

Dan Mitchell

>And how many forums of any kind where the OP can get 17 helpful replies, and not a SINGLE sarcastic response! I love this place!

Dan

Re: Dedicated mortiser or router table?

#22

Re: Yahoo Groups??

Brian in Brighton

>Ha Ha. Did you mean to send that sawdust to the first person to get it right as a reward or to the person who gets it wrong as a punishment?

Brian in Brighton.

In total agreement, WC rocks.

Re: Dedicated mortiser or router table?

#23

To the winner...Freight collect!

Art Silva

>