Re: Dedicated mortiser or router table?
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>Years ago when I was in "shop outfitting" mode, I made several router tables, a horizontal router jig, and bought a benchtop mortiser [see my comments of the JET JBM-5 in the Reviews Section].
I used the horizontal jig once; it then gathered dust until is was used for kindling.
I have cut mortices on the router table, but it can be a somewhat tedious process to get them positioned precisely, I'm never really comfortable dropping a piece of wood onto the spinning cutter, and issues arise when the mortise is larger than your available bit so that you must cut it in several passes. All that said, I have produced very nice clean mortices with the router table. But
My preferred method is to use the mortiser. It's quick and easy to set up, it's "OS" factor is practically nill, and slanted and oversize cuts are easy and repeatable.
Note here that a router bit will cut a much cleaner slot than the mortiser which is especially important if you're cutting through-motices which I often do.
Note too that, in my view, a router table plus a sled is the clear winner when it comes to cutting precise tenons to match the mortices, both straight and slanted.
Translation: Short Answer - Work both the mortiser and router table into your shop space!
mm