Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Design/Creativity Question?

Posts

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#26

Re: principles of design can be taught. .. my view

Norman (Ottawa, Ont.)

>My thoughts on this are as follows.

Woodworkers evolve in both experience and expertise. The challenges we initially faced are no longer challenges at a certain point in our woodworking career and we develop new challenges, at least this is how we grow as woodworkers.

Some woodworkers feel comfortable working from plans , others design or roll their own. I use the word challenge freely because I feel that to grow as a woodworker one needs to be challenged or face hurdles in design.

When this is applied to design and creativity, we perhaps subconsciously limit ourselves to designing or creating a piece with the skill set we have at that particular point in time. The challenge would be to design in a element that we haven't been exposed to before or have little experience with. From this, we build on our repertoire of experience and can then take the creativity and design aspect to the next level for any subsequent piece, incorporating what we have learned.

This sequence continues over the years and hopefully we arrive at a point where we have complete freedom in the creativity and design of a piece, completely unemcumbered by limitations such as limited skills.

This I feel is how a furniture maker evolves and some arrive at this point quicker than others.

An example is the implementation of curved surfaces in work. This is definitely a challenge and once overcome, opens a new (curved) design door for the woodworker, one more hurdle overcome.

So I have to say the design and creativity of a woodworker can be considered to be an evolving skill in my opinion, we have subconscious hurdles that we translate into our designs.

Norman ( an evolving woodworker)

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#27

Re: Guilty as charged...... sort of...

john lucas

>First of all I'm computer illiterate. I try but it's just so darned frustrating. Many of my ideas come when I'm not anywhere near a computer (there might be a good reason for this).

I draw very poorly but I plan on working on that this year. There isn't any reason why I can't learn to draw better. When I get a good idea I usually make a quick sketch so I don't forget. There's no telling how many good ideas have occured on my way to Lunch or at a restaurant so they often end up sketched on Napkins. I have litterally hundreds of idea sketches in my files. I hope someday to have time to work on them.

I think everyone can learn to be more creative. They simply have to work on it. You have to learn to play the guitar before you can write new music for it.

I think the best way is to work on a series of some kind. Grap some idea in the back of your mind or a pattern or texture you see in nature or on another product. Then imagine how you might apply this to a piece your making. Once you've done that try to come up with 5 more ways to use this idea. While your building those you may think of another way to use it or another idea altogether might come along.

Someone once asked John Jordan how to come up with new turning ideas and all he said was Turn, turn, turn. To create new ideas you have to practice.

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#28

Re: Big help with "Designing".....& a challenge

Barry Irby

>Bill, As an aside, I think what we can learn for the masters like Chippendale and Goddard if not only their elements of style, but their respect for the wood. And the engineering it took to make fabulous pieces of furniture out of this crazy material that would last for generations.

I said I had some experience with AutoCad. That was a stretch. I actually have AutoSketch by AutoDesk, the people that bring us AutoCad. It is the Junior or "lite" version of the program. I am not sure it is still available, but when I bought it it was in the $200-300 neighborhood, making it MUCH more affordable than AutoCad. I have not played with it in a long time. When I changed from version 2 to version 3 or whatever, they changed the interface and I lost much of what I thought I knew. And, My career changed and I no longer needed it for my work. You might check around and see if they still make it and if it will do what you want.

Also, I have a friend who is retired, but keeps his hand in with AutoCad. He recently bought the "Educational" version of it at the local community college book store. It was more than the AutoSketch but much less than the business version of AutoCad. I'm not sure if it is as complete as the business version, but it is clearly powerful enough to do what you are talking about. One (minor?) drawback is that it prints each page with a sort of frame around it that says, "Produced by an Autodesk Educational Product". That did not bother either of us enough to pay for the business version.

I recently had him draw up some table legs. My cousin took pictures of the table she wanted to copy and he converted them to a drawing of the legs. Once he got them like we wanted them, he printed them full sized. the program tiled them across several pages and we taped them together. I hung them up behind the lathe and turned away any wood that did not look like the picture.

Several years ago, I had him draw up some arches I wanted for a huge rose arbor. I laminated the bentwood arches out of redwood. What a wonderful tool. He could touch the picture of the arch at any point and tell me what the "coordinates" were so that I had nice scaled dimensions to set up the forms.

I will have to discuss this with him. It is a powerful tool and could do full sized plans, Including templates and patterns. I don't know if he knows how to convert a JPEG, but I'm sure he can learn. Funny that you bring it up, his daughter suggested we sell the plans for the rose arbor on the Internet.

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#29

Respectfully disagree

Dean Lapinel

>"Creativity can not be taught, only expressed."

I am more in the R Clough side where I think creativity can be taught. I believe yours was more a philosophical statement not meant to be taken concretely but I still disagree.

Seeing master works of any nature, arts, architecture, furniture, and allowing yourself to understand teaches creativity that then can be expressed.

Good teachers know how to break the rigid barriers that restrain the "creative" mind that exists within us all.

There are many methods but ultimately I can funnel this into two basic processes.

1 Learn how to see. Simple statement but I could speak for hours on this topic.

2. Doodle, write, create in any fashion (as in making your own paintings of the masters (interpretation) then when your brain is warmed up and receptive try a design. Try again and don't fix the last one. Try again for a maximum of about two hours.

Most artists of various fields I know have a limited time frame of expressing their creativity. Learn what yours is and recognize the end point- fatigue, frustration then stop.

Whenever I am not creating I am thinking, designing, planning, problem solving and seeing (unless I have to socialize :)).

Interestingly my best ideas come in the morning and often while showering.

I will leave "Intelligent design" to Huckabee :)

Dean

http://lapinelarts.com

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#30

Nope....I don't think so... 2 things:

HC Sakman

>1-"Many of the creative designers of "furniture" are poor engineers."

2-"An exception is Krenov."

1-The first statement is 100% wrong Bill. Creative designers may not have an engineering degree. So, they won't know the formulas and calculations, but their sense of physics are built-into their sense of design. Think about it. You can not seperate the two. Otherwise, without sense of physics, creations will break, crack, fall, be tippy, etc... etc... Of course, I am referring to "functional furniture" not useless furniture that is refused to be called "art".

2-Personally, I haven't seen any piece that Krenov made deserves the "exception" you noted in your statement. He has great sense of what looks exceptional, in other words "design" but in many of his 14"x34" cabinets, engineering was not quite essential enough that would make him "exceptional engineer in design". I am referring to the "big picture"/"design" as that's what we've been talking about, not the intricate details of his furniture.

(I am talking about a very specific issue here, I hope people understand and don't blow it out of proportion by deciding to lunch a crusade over it.;-)

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#31

Re: principles of design can be taught. .. my view

Dan Donaldson

>I can relate to at least some of this. Back in another incarnation, I played bass semi-pro in a Bluegrass band. When I first started, I had a real problem learning the songs because I had to concentrate so much on the mechanics of the bas that I could not pay sufficient attention to what I was really playing. (I played on stage the first time two weeks after the first time I had ever touched a bass) Over time, as I learned the mechanics of the instrument, the songs came easier and easier until I could pretty much step into any jam session and play along with no problem. At the end of my playing days, I went back and listened to some of the recordings that we had made and as I listened to what I played, I still wonder where it came from. There was some pretty neat stuff there, but I was not conscious of playing it, just going with the flow.

I am not at that "going with the flow" stage yet in my woodworking, still working on the mechanics, but I can already see that I can build things that I could not have a few years ago, and I am starting to notice more about what works and what does not, even if I cannot explain exactly why. I think that while I may never have the creative flair like Thomas or Andi and others, I think that I can get to where I can design something different and nice. (at least I hope so ;-))

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#32

So do I....

HC Sakman

>Hi Dean,

If creativity could be thought, we'd have no galleries, and all (ok, maybe many, if not all) the art school graduates would be famous (or whatever the adjective would be appropriate). Basically there'd be no exceptional work, as all the work would be exceptional.

Besides, just designing is not good enough. Execution can make it or break it. Even execution can be broken down to construction-finish etc... We all know what a bad finish can do to a piece with flawless joinery and overall flawless execution.

I may be making this sound confusing, my point is that even if it'd be possible to teach, it'd impossible for most to learn it so they'd be exceptional. Only a few can, because they have the talent to begin with, will be exceptional. Just like singing as I mentioned above.

You may attempt to teach it, but many won't fully absorb it. Two different things.

Chico...

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#33

Re: So do I....

Thomas S Stockton

>I think I agree with you Chico! While creativity maybe can't be taught it certainly can be brought out and nurtered by a good teacher who is willing to challange the student and let them find there own way.

Tom

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#34

Re: And me, mostly

Brian in Brighton

>While I can see teaching people how to do various things to help release the inner creative side, some people just can't get it. For my engineering company I have a tough time finding quality people because you can teach someone how to use the software, they have to be normally intelligent or better. To teach them to create something from nothing is a different ballgame and not everyone can do it. I have seen phD's who could not think their way out a paper bag. They could tell you more than you would ever want to know about the bag, but could not create a bag from nothing.

For woodworking imagine it like this. Chippendale had a group of workers who could make his ideas into reality, could they actually conceive of these things on their own? I doubt it. There are people who take an original idea and make it better. There are people who can make an original idea from nothing. Not solving a problem which has a certain number of ideas to solve it. I mean being able to sit back and think up something brand new that the world has never seen before. That kind of creativity can not be taught.

Brian in Brighton

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#35

True Furniture Designer/Engineer.....is

HC Sakman

>...Jere Osgood. In my opinion, nobody comes even close in this aspect.

On the other hand, the visual appeal of his pieces... is a different story. Let's say: "it's an aquired taste."

I think the reason for that, his furniture is very unique... He's thinking from inside out, literally.

He thinks of the function and "unusual" inner workings of a cabinet to accomplish these functions, then the form follows that just to accomodate what his thoughts were for inside.

Mostly, you get the shock & awe when you get close to his furniture and you start moving the parts. (doors, drawers, lids etc...) He indeed builts everything in the most diffucult way, and that requires great sense of engineering.

Chico...

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#36

rebuttal

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>1. I have been visiting the Taunton Design Book Series for ideas. There is a lot of lousy engineering in there. Last IWF in Atlanta the design winner made a chair of bamboo. With good reason there was a sign not to sit in it. Rest my case. We could agree that much of the poorly engineered stuff is Art presented as "furniture", as well as there is some finely engineered art. And there is lousy engineering in some old stuff. The low boy side panel comes to mind. I took a reproduction class and someone asked Headley how to keep that panel from cracking. You can't was the reply. The joinery can only be adjusted to control where it will crack and he went on to offer suggestions.

2. I would have agreed with you on Krenov until I built a similar piece and faced the engineering decisions and saw how he approached solving them. Maybe I am easily impressed.

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#37

Thanks Barry, this has been a really enjoyable....

Art Silva

>thread,.......so far.

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#38

Not really...

HC Sakman

>Just because something in Taunton's or somebody else's design book, it doesn't mean "most desirable" by the most people. "Most" is important because everybody's taste is different. One loves violet color, other loves yellow and so on, without knowing why. Cultural heritage/accumulation and other personal interests have a great deal to do with this.

Everybody is unique in their own way, though when over 80~90 percent of a crowd agrees upon a design, that would be the exceptional design. For example 18th. century American furniture appeals very large masses. So does A&C, Art Deco but not Art Nouveau. I can't think of any other explanation/description for this.

Therefore, it's ok that you and I feel that some of the work in a "design book" are not appealing to us. The other reason is lack of decent work to find and put them in such kind of books. Naturally, I was excluding the type of work that seem unbalanced, -lack of a better word- weird and unharmonic, from the "creative and unique design" concept we were talking about. So, We're pretty much in agreement here.

Talking about "weird" I've really developped an allergy to the designs that were made just for the sake of being different. It shows through. Hey, they pour millions of dollars on some movies which may turn out to be a flop. I guess that's the risk of being "creative".

Chico...

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#39

Me Too,......

Barry Irby

>I'm still wondering if Chico (and some others here) are more creative than I am (likely), or working harder than I am (likely), or better equipped (likely), more skilled (likely), or drawing from a different pallet of designs and culture (also likely). Now that I know what to work on....

It's clear I need to put more effort into the designs. I should be observing more and better. Looking at better objects and looking better...Observing. Taking pictures, measuring, setting off those alarms. Drawing, sketching details and ideas.

Somehow, I seem to expect designs to leap fully formed from my brain. Clearly that is unrealistic. Need to make more mistakes on paper. Also need to be willing to remake pieces or make prototypes and remake them.

I also need to develop my skills and perhaps expand the tools available to me. Sort of along the lines of "If the only tool you own is a hammer, all your problems start to look like nails." But, if your only skill is hammering, it may not do you much good to own a saw. Unless you are willing to learn to use it.

Perhaps I need to get back to some of the basics. I tend to think "Every piece is a practice piece for the next piece". Maybe I just need to practice.

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#40

Ellis Walentine

That's a really tough one.

Ellis Walentine

>We would have to make very deep changes inside the scripts that run our boards. The potential for disaster would be huge and it would probably cost quite a bit, IF if can be done.

I will trot this past my gurus.

Ellis