Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Design/Creativity Question?

Posts

Design/Creativity Question?

#1

Design/Creativity Question?

Barry Irby

>We have many posts here about Craft Vs. Art here. I know I am a better Craftsman than Artist/Designer. If you show me a piece of work, often I am confident I can make one like it. I feel my short coming is in coming up with original creative designs. My question is: can you train yourself to be a better designer and more creative? Is it nature or nurture? How would you start?

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#2

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

Sgian Dubh

>Start by learning how to draw. If drawing is something you're unable to do, there's your major stumbling block.

If you can't draw, then any shapes or ideas you get in your head have to stay there for you have no easy means of expressing them in a form that others can see.

I know people that can't draw, and won't learn how to for some reason. They prefer to resort to tools like SketchUp and other 'drawing' programmes. All are useful tools and can help a designer, but the problem with SketchUp, for example, is that nothing produced in the programme has any spark, individuality or life.

SketchUp drawings all just look like SketchUp renditions. I have to assess a lot of work from furniture design students, and people that enter designs for competitions. I'm pretty fed up and bored of looking at SketchUp renditions from a wide variety of students or competitiors. All the drawings are very 'samey' even if the pieces drawn are different. My reaction nowadays to SketchUp drawings is usually, "Oh yeah, here's another bloody boring SketchUp thing. Yawn. Next!"

Most of what we do as furniture makers are based on frames, boxes, or rectangular things with twiddly bits, so a good place to start is learning how to draw squares, rectangles, triangles, circles, ellipses, etc. Then add two point perspective and move on to rendering with broad nibbed markers to suggest tone, colour and intensity, light and shade, etc.

Once you've got some basic skills the next thing is observational drawing, and that develops an eye for shape and form.

There's a bunch more too on studying the history of design, proportion, anthrapometrics, ergonomics, and so on, but being able to draw, even not very well, gives you literacy in the designer's language. If you can't 'talk' in the language of the 'country' you want to be in, you can't communicate. Slainte.

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#3

Lee Grindinger

Can design be taught?

Lee Grindinger

>My answer is that it can. I liken designing furniture to writing music. You'd never expect much from a person who has just learned their Do Re Me. You wouldn't expect much of a person not familiar with and in possession of a broad woodworking repertoire.

The more you know, the more you can accomplish, the better designer you'll be. The skills set a woodworker needs to learn takes a great deal of dedication and practice, design comes later. Lousy designs are often the case when a person is unfamiliar with the material, the engineering and practice. Skills sets, as they increase, generally lead to more challenging designs and these will lead to new ideas. I taught a seminar on embellishing designs and it's not difficult to distill the process down to steps.

However, great and truly original designs are rare indeed and the Sheratons, Phyffes, Townsends and Goddards, Hortas, etc. are extremely rare individuals. However, learning to design pleasing furniture is not impossible, it simply requires familiarity with the subject. Familiarity includes ergonomics, engineering and embellishments Simple aesthetically pleasing shapes have been the topic of mathematicians for centuries and formulas like the golden mean and Fibonacci can provide acceptable, if not predictable, lines and proportions.

If you want to learn design, study the masters. You need to choose who your masters are. Teach your eyes to notice the subtleties. Set off a few proximity alarms in museums trying to peer underneath a piece or around the back.

Can design be taught? Of course it can, good design too. Can truly great design be taught? Nope, that's a magical combination of interest, drive, curiosity and the extraordinary feat of peering into a world of unseen shapes and colors.

Lee

Lee

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#4

Lee Grindinger

Hey Siggy,

Lee Grindinger

>It's good to see you.

I agree with learning to draw, freehand drawing is much freer than CAD.

I hope life is good in Scotland. Ruthie and I are now in the Caribbean, it's awfully nice.

Lee

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#5

Re: Hey Siggy,

Sgian Dubh

>I was wondering how you're getting on Lee. I've seen you post here and there.

It's pretty bloody cold over here right now. You'd love it here as respite from all those white beaches, blue seas, palm trees, and lolling about at bars sipping pina colada. Slainte.

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#6

Alan Young

Guilty as charged...... sort of...

Alan Young

>Sgian- Programs such as Sketchup do have some definite assets. I have been using the Sketchup program for over a year now. I use it because it helps me get through the frame work of the design process quickly. I can also save many iterations and plug and play to see what I like and what I don't.

I send sketchup drawings to clients as way to say this what I propose. In the digital age I find the immediacy of this type of program to be a great asset. I can get an inquiry at 9am regarding a project idea and have a proposed sketch e-mailed off in less than an hour. The ability to quickly refine ideas through e-mails has no doubt made a lot of my projects finalize.

But as to the question of learning how to design I think understanding what has been done before is of utmost value. That includes, joinery, materials,shapes,forms and finishes. So I would not say I recommend it as a starting place for learning to design pieces. In fact I do more hand drawing now than ever before- but I am usually practicing a specific design element-like a cabriolet leg curve, or volute or spiral etc...I think this type of hand-eye execution is a necessary exercise in developing drawing and design skills.....

Just being able to say you've learned the tools in program like sketchup is not the way to learn design.

Alan

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#7

Re: Design/Creativity Question? *LINK*

charlie belden

>The same question was asked in the news group rec.woodworking recently. Here's my response.

One approach used in "lateral thinking" is to change what

they refer to as the "entry point"

Think about a table

What are the parts

legs

apron

top

maybe stretchers

possible a drawer

Consider the legs

Normally there are four, sometimes three and sometimes one

central pedestal. What it there were FIVE - or only two? What

if there were NONE? Would it then be a "shelf"? But if the

top were "table size", would it still be a "shelf"?

Consider the apron

does it have to be straight on top, on the bottom or on

either the top or the bottom?

does it have to be flat or can it be curved?

can it be pierced to the point of being almost non existent?

does it have to intersect the legs it's full width or only at

a small area, or perhaps a couple of points?

Consider the top

how thin can the top be and still be functional AND not

look odd?

does it all have to be flat? What about a step down in it,

or a raised feature?

can the ends curve up or down, or one up, one down?

do the sides have to be parallel and the ends as well?

does the thickness have to be uniform or can you go

with a taper and adjust the legs so the top surface is

horizontal?

Consider the stretchers

can they be arcs rather than straight?

do both ends have to meet the legs the same distance

from the floor?

Consider a drawer

why one instead of two or three?

do they need to be layed out symetric on the apron

or can they be asymetric? What about staggered

one up, one down, or stair stepped?

Now think about some of the joinery.

do the legs have to meet the table top at 90 degrees?

can some, or most, if not all, of the joinery be "blended"

(think Sam Maloof rocking chair joinery) so that you

can't tell where one part ends and the other begins.

What about color and shades of a color. Dark looks

"heavy", Light looks - well - light. The eye sees the

highest contrast first. So a dark leg on a table in a

light colored room will be noticed before lighter parts.

What if you play with a heartwood/sapwood piece for

a leg or two and exploit the light and dark outline?

Basically it's a break things down and examine each

part - and consider other possibilities than the "tried

and true", "traditional" assumptions of what each one

"should look like" - or how it's "supposed to work".

The world of woodturners break all "the rules" and

new ideas and techniques have been, and continue

to pop up and spread through the community. Turners

are scorching and sand blasting and grinding and

carving and painting, inlaying, bandsawing and wire

brushing pieces exploring possibilities, starting with

Why A Round Cross Section? Why Symetric

About a Single Axis? Why A Single Piece Of Wood?

"Flat Work" on the other hand is pretty static, with

a few exceptions - some of Michael Fortune's work

for example.

=================

Now about the point that being able to draw is absolutely necessary to come up with creative designs - BULL!

Most little kids can't draw worth spit - but give them some clay to play with . . .

If you can't draw you still have the ability to see -and - see what looks right or not. So - start with the basics of what you want to make - using inexpensive stuff - cardboard, MDF, 2x4 studs and scrap ply. Doesn't have even be at full size if you're pressed for stuff to work with - not wanting to waste the good stuff (that's also expensive to replace). Stick things together with duct tape, pins, brads, finishing nails, stables or glue. It's preferable to use "joinery" that can be undone and moved. Don't worry about strength at this point, you can figure that out later. Just get the height, width and length stuff - along with where things go. Then begin modifying, adaptingm fiddling. If you think something would look better than what you have at the moment - try it.

When you've got something that you like, or has possibilities if it were in a specific wood, paint the prototype enough to give you an idea of light and dark / basic look in a chosen color or colors.

Another approach is to start with a digital image of a piece that is interesting and use PhotoShop or any of its cousings to manipulate your starting image (see link)

If the word "creative" is the "I can't do THAT" part of the challenge - then think in terms of "synthesis" - combing things already being used by others in a new way. At some point, "modifying/synthesizings" becomes indistinguishable from "creative".

The more "designs" you're exposed to the more stuff you'll have to "synthesize". Sounds like you have the knowledge and skills of woodworking required to stick parts together so you're well ahead of the person with a lot of "creativity" but little if any woodworking skills and abilities. If you can get passed the "I'm not creative" thing you'll be surprised at what you come up with.

(more than you wanted to know?)

charlie b

ps

pick up a copy of "Lateral Thinking - Creativity Step By Step"

by Edward de Bono - ISBN 0-06-090325-2 $15.00 US for

much better explanations, examples and exercises


Design Options Using PhotoShop

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#8

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

Thomas S Stockton

>Barry,

I would agree with both Lee and Sgian about what they had to say. I'm not that good at drawing but what a drawing does is gets the ideas out of my head and onto paper. All my pieces usually start out as quick sketches that are relatively crude to start, I then go through them and decide which ideas I like and which I don't. I then do a cleaner sketch and then draw the piece using drafting tools even these are pretty simple as I prefer to work on details as I go along.

There are lots of different ways to design some people like mock ups and models while others can do these amazing presentation drawings that are near perfect renditions of a finished piece you need to find what works for you.

Lee's ideas of studying others work is good, look at as many different books of furniture as you can, don't worry about technique or how the piece was built but look at proportions and shapes and how they work together. Study pieces you like as well as ones you don't. I think it is much harder to figure out why a piece doesn't work then it is figure out why you like one. If you want to get better at design I would stay away from plans you can purchase or in magazines, they are a great resource for some one starting out but after you've done a few pieces you should have the skills to go at it on your own, or if you're not comfortable with that use them as a rough starting point and modify them to suit your needs or to get the overall dimensions you need.

Some good books are "drawing on the right side of the brain" and Seth Stem's "Designing Furniture", James Krenov's books are also good but not so much about design but why he works wood and are an inspiration.

The important thing is to find out what works best for you and put your time into that technique. And yes it can be taught, some people just have an easier time with it.

Tom

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#9

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

Ron Jackson

>All design has to do with the ability to see. Painting, sculpture, photography etc. A basic art class is a good place to start. Then apply the basics to your craft and the medium you choose. Altering design to work with your skills of course. Sometimes as much can be learned from observing bad design as from good. If you see something thats just not right try to figure out why.Keeping in mind all design is somewhat subjective. Hope this helps.

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#10

Re: Guilty as charged...... sort of...

Sgian Dubh

>Alan, SketchUp is a great tool, as is AutoCad, and a bunch of other tools. The ability to create libraries of shapes, textures, forms, etc, is a wonderful time saver. And the ability to share this information via email, printed drawings, JPEG's, and so on is useful too. It's also good for checking your proportions and placement of parts as well as other benefits.

But it's not a tool that lets you play around with shapes and forms quickly. When I'm working up initial ideas I often draw them so quickly (and also poorly sometimes) that the drawings overlap. Ideas are abandoned half way through, or morph into yet another idea. The pages of my sketch book at this stage are a mess of overlapping drawings, half shading, abandoned ideas half drawn, a few squiggles here, some leg forms over there, a doodle of a fish in that corner. The point is that I can fill an A3 or A2 size page with these ideas and musings in as little as ten minutes.

Maybe none of the ideas on a particular page will come to anything, and I might do ten pages like this. If I get just three interesting leads from this sort of brainstorming on ten pages that's a positive result because I can start to refine those ideas into the final piece. In the end, a SketchUp drawing and an AutoCAD or hand drawn orthographic projection can be drawn up.

The problem I have with SketchUp is that so many people go straight to it and draw what they're going to build in one go and that's the end of that. They miss out the doodling phase and the getting ideas out quickly phase to refine them before they turn to the final rendition part of the job. This final rendition bit can be freehand drawing, or aided with rules, squares, bits of string and pins method, or SketchUp or some other drawing tool. The results are frequently stiff and stilted, and you can often see the 'one-shot' approach to the design job. It all just tends to get a bit samey if you know what I mean, whereas even a badly hand drawn sketch is individual. Slainte.

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#11

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>Some years ago I had the opportunity to take an Art Composition class. It dealt with positive and negative space, weight of colors and mass, proportion, and how the eye played with the design and why, but the resulting training of the eye is the foundation of all design.

Check out your local community college. An art class or two would fun and inexpensive.

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#12

Lots of great advice here Barry

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryDZmgloT+ZiYFgX

>It has always been my quest to design, and avoid overlapping another's style. I find it to be harder to do using flat surfaces, and even bends on a single plane. Once you learn techniques that allow you to get into more fully developed forms, there is more room to move.

A simple way to play with shapes is to get a couple of bricks of clay. Unlike wood, which is a subtractive shaping process, you can quickly change shapes by either taking away, or adding back.

I still am getting lots of inspiration from nature. As of late, I have gotten into macro-photography, which is bringing lots of new inspiration to my design ideas. But as someone earlier said, you must always be trying to add a new skill to your bag of tricks of craftsmanship, then finding new ways to add them into your work.

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#13

Ellis Walentine

Nice reply, Lee.

Ellis Walentine

>

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#14

Lee Grindinger

Yo, E-Man

Lee Grindinger

>Hey, while you're into these message board changes when do we get what we REALLY need?

An edit button. Any chance?

Lee

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#15

Lee Grindinger

Wow, that sounds awfully nice

Lee Grindinger

>You know, our house in Montana is still for sale. One of my greatest fears is that we accept an offer and I have to go back in the dead of winter to clear us out and close the deal. I'll need a lot of propane to keep that house warm to suit my new taste, I'm kinda hoping serious offers wait until spring.

As soon as we tire of the palms, the beaches and the weather I'll give a holler, Richard. But don't start stocking up on the ale just yet.

Lee

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#16

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

Robert R Clough - Thorncraft

>Lee (below) is absolutely correct! His allusion to music is an excellent one. I would use painting as that is my background. Copying or studying the Masters is a fine teaching device, but then, instead of copying, reproduce the painting or piece of furniture as YOU would do it. One of my instructors (in oil) had us do exactly that. Play with it, tweak it and see what the result is. What is good about that Secretary (no, not the girl)? What stands out? What leads the eye.

Get hold of a copy of Pierce's recent book on Shaker Furniture as he carefully makes several points on design.

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#17

Just "easier time" would explain? Naaah!

HC Sakman

>Hi Tom,

Let's not mix-up design with "creativity".

Creativity is a natural talent. There are people out there who are able to play 5 or more musical instruments by the age of 8~10. Some people have simply IN them. Singing is way more defined. I think.... No!; I believe one can not learn how to sing VERY WELL if the talent is not present. Have anybody ever heard that somebody who took music lessons by the age of 30 and become a star or even a wedding singer? If there are exceptions, I am sure that person(s) had the talent, but somehow undiscovered.

Of course, talent by itself will not bring out the full potential. Knowledge and experience will enhance creative talent, taking it to the next level. (Insert last paragraph of what Lee said.) In my opinion, true creativity can not be thought.

Design, on the other hand, has certain established parameters, which can be thought like any other concept. If the goal is being able to go beyond producing work from plans, this can very well be accomplished by learning and practicing. Designing "creatively"; coming up with new concepts, lines, shapes, details etc... is being able to go beyond those "established design parameters". These new, creative concepts are up to the person to come up with and can not be fully thought.

This a hard topic to write about. Any confusion here? Am I clear enough?

Chico...

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#18

Thanks everyone and......

Barry Irby

>I tend to agree with Chico. (I have admired many of your pieces here. Do I think you are creative because you are, or do you appear to be creative to me because you are drawing your designs from sources I am not familiar with?)

I grew up in a house full of American antiques. Could it be that is why I draw the styles and shapes that look vaguely familiar and are similar in some crude respect to American Antiques?

Clearly I need to study other forms and styles. I can draw to some extent. Took several years of drafting in College and have learned to use Auto Cad if only minimally. I have some familiarity with ergonomics and mathematical concepts around proportions. Would like to know more in these areas.

I need to learn to make my mistakes on paper. I tend to design on the fly and work out the details as I go. Almost everything I build, I end up saying "if I built it again I would......" When I finally work up the energy and commitment to go ahead with a project, I dash into it.

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#19

I Make All My Mistakes In Wood.

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Evening Barry,

Then my wife invites all the neighbors over and I provide the entertainment when Vesuvius erupts. She says its more fun that way. :<)

George

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#20

At last! I now know what the missing chapter.....

Art Silva

>in my Drafting Text in engineering school was. "Twiddly Bits, Squiggles & Doodles".

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#21

Re: At last! I now know what the missing chapter..

Sgian Dubh

>"Twiddly Bits, Squiggles & Doodles" are essential of course Art. How could your book omit them and claim to be complete, ha, ha. Slainte.

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#22

Designing vs Engineering

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I would define some of what you are naming "design" as engineering. And engineering can assuredly be taught through study and experience. Engineering is successfully assembling a design into something functional through knowledge of material and construction. The architect designs the bridge, the engineer figures out how to assemble it, for example.

I am less convinced that a person's innate ability to design can be anything but refined by training.

But that does not mean us design-challenged woodworkers can't build nice stuff. We gravitate to reproductions and modifications of reproductions.

Many of the creative designers of "furniture" are poor engineers. An exception is Krenov. When I set out to reproduce(approximately) one of his wall cabinets I discovered at each construction step elegant engineering solutions to assembling his airy designs. They may not look it, but I expect his pieces will be around as long as anything made of wood.

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#23

Re: Designing vs Engineering

Barry Irby

>Thanks Bill. I think you and I agree on much of this. I will have to look at Krenov's stuff more closely. I have that engineering brain and like to see things executed well and that will offer a lifetime of service or more. Good designers need to be good engineers or at least turn their designs over to good engineers. Having been in the building business, I have some experience with the clash between the two.

Its that flair for the design that I feel I lack and so admire. I need to study great designs and designers and at least steal from the best. (If you copy one design its plagiarism, but if you copy from ten of them, it research.)

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#24

principles of design can be taught.....

R. Lance in GR, Michigan

>but creativity can not be taught, only expressed.

Re: Design/Creativity Question?

#25

Big help with "Designing".....& a challenge

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Note my post above on the Autocad question. I saw a demo that is going to have as big an impact on my furniture building as my trip to College of Redwoods.

If you have an appropriate picture, it can be imported into Autocad, and I suppose other like programs, scaled and by mousing around the picture every dimension of the piece can be read from the picture. The process could take as little as 5 min on a simple piece. Curved pieces, say a skirt, can be printed 1:1, fastened to a piece of wood and cut out. With this aide I can focus on engineering and construction, something I am getting good at, and get through the "design". If I had to rely on building what I designed I would have a lot of boxy furniture.

The advantage of Autocad is that it is readily available in the industrial world so one may be able to borrow time on someone else's software. The disadvantage is that it is complex and impractical to own.

The challenge....Is there affordable, easier to use software that will do the above tasks? I asked this question once before and got many theoretical answers. It was not apparent that anyone that offered an alternate to Autocad had actually used something else to do the above tasks. Someday it would be nice to see in the Articles Section a lucid description of how to get scaled dimensions from a picture using affordable software.

Is there a business opportunity here for someone that is expert in Autocad and has a large printer?